Lexploria

Communicated on 28 August 2014

FIRST SECTION

Application no. 11421/13 Khamid Khatutovich KABARDOKOV and others against Russia and 33 other applications (see list appended)

STATEMENT OF FACTS

T he appli cants are 223 Russian nationals listed in Appendix 1 . They live in various towns of the Republic of Kabardino-Balkaria .

The facts of the case, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.

A. The circumstances of the case

The applicants were clean-up workers at the site of the Chernobyl nuclear plant accident. As a result they suffered from extensive exposure to radioactive emissions which later led to their d isability.

In late 2010 the applicants lodged a complaint with the Nalchik Town Court of the Republic of Kabardino-Balkaria (“the Town Court”) against the Russian Ministry of Finance seeking compensation of non ‑ pecuniary damage in the above connection.

In the period between January and April 2011 (see Appendix 2 , column no. 2) t he Town Court allowed the applicants ’ claims in part and awarded the applicants compensations between 1,200,000 - 1,600,000 Russian roubles (approximately 25,000 - 33 ,000 euros ) (see Appendix 3 ).

The judgments above have not been appealed against and became final and enforceable.

In the period between June and November 2011 the Department of the Federal Treasury Fund in the Republic of Kabardino-Balkaria (“the FTF”) on behalf of the Russian Ministry of Finance lodged an appeal with the Supreme Cou rt of the Republic of Kabardino ‑ Balkaria (“the Supreme Court of Kabardino-Balkaria”) against the final judgment s in the applicants’ favour through the Town Court (Appendix 2 , column no. 2) . They also requested that the statutory ten-day time ‑ limit for lodging such an appeal against the judgment s be restored.

In the same period (Appendix 2 , column no. 3) the Town Court refused to restore the time-limit for appealing against the main judgments , stating that the FTF provided no valid reasons for missing it. The latter decision s were not appealed against and became final.

Meantime some of the applicants received the awarded compensations while the others were waiting (see Appendix 3 ) .

In the period between July and November 2012 the FTF lodged an appeal with the Town Court against the previous refusals (Appendix 2 , column no. 3). They also requested that the ten ‑ day statutory time- limit for appealing against those decision s be restored on the ground s that their copies had not been forwarded to the FTF .

In the same period (Appendix 2 , column no. 4) the Town Court ordered that the time ‑ limit for appeal be extended on the grounds that the re was no evidence that the FTF had received refusals in due course.

In the period between July and November 2012 the applicants appealed against the latter decisions before the Supreme Court of Kabardino ‑ Balkaria on the grounds that according to the domestic law the court should forward a copy of its decision only to those parties, which were not present at the court hearings. However, according to the applicants, since the FTF’s representative participated in the proceedings, the court was not required to forward them a copy of the decision.

In the period between August and December 2012 (Appendix 2, column no. 4) the Supreme Court of Kabardino ‑ Balkaria found that the Town Court lawfully extended the time-limits for appeals but held that the grounds for the extensions were incorrect. The Supreme Court of Kabardino ‑ Balkaria in particular held that the Russian Ministry of Finance could not be said to have been duly represented in those proceedings as the transcript of a hearing did not provide the details regarding the power of attorney of Ms B., who had acted as a representative of the Russian Ministry of Finance. I n such circumstances the Town Court should have forwarded a copy of the decision to the defendant but had failed to do so. Accordingly , the Supreme Court held that the Russian Ministry of Finance had valid excuse in missing the statutory time-limit for appealing against the Town Court ’ s decision s taken between June and November 2011 (Appendix 2, column no. 3).

In the period between September 2012 and February 2013 (Appendix 2, column no. 5) the Supreme Court of Kabardino-Balkaria quashed the Town Court’s refusals (Appendix 2, column no. 3) and restored the time-limit for appealing against the main judgment s (Appendix 2 , column no. 2) . It noted, in particular , as follows :

“... As it transpires from the case materials the defendant [the Russian Ministry of Finance] was represented by Ms B. ... who participated in the first instance court hearing on examination of the case on the merits and, accordingly, was aware of the delivered judgment [Town Court’s judgment in the applicants’ favour].

Therefore submission of an appeal against that judgment [Town Court] within the time ‑ limit provided by Article 338 of the Russian Code of Civil Procedure depended on the representative’s good faith … Accordingly, failure to comply with the time ‑ limit by the defendant evidently was a consequence of improper fulfillment of the obligations by the representative , which obviously led to substantial violation of the Russian Federation’s rights in supporting its position before the court of appeal.”

In the period between September 2012 and March 2013 (Appendix 2, column no. 6) the Supreme Court of Kabardino-Balkaria quashed the Town Court ’ s main judgment and dismissed the applicants ’ claims in full. It noted that the domestic law concerning compensation for non ‑ pecuniary damage had been introduced on 31 May 1991 after the Chernobyl nuclear accident had occurred, therefore the applicants were not entitled to any compensation. The Supreme Court further ordered the applicants to return the money they had received pursuant to the Town Court’s judgment s taken between January and April 2011 (Appendix 2, column no. 2).

Three applicants, Mr Kolomiyets (applicant no. 67), Mr Lepekhin (applicant no. 78) and Mr Apanasenko (applicant no. 101) died on 30 and 26 March and 23 July 2013 respectively, after they filed their applica tions with the Court. By letter of 17 April 2014 the applicant s ’ wives informed the Court about their husbands ’ decease and expressed the intention to continue proceedings.

B. Relevant domestic law and practice

Article 112 of the Russian C ode of C ivil P rocedure (“CCP”) provides that a compe tent court may extend a time-limit for procedural actions, such as lodging an appeal, if the court finds that a party has a valid excuse for a failure to comply with that time-limit.

Article 227 of the CCP stipulates that a copy of a decision concerning termination of proceedings shall be forwarded to the parties to the proceedings if they were not present at the hearing within three days after its delivery .

Under Article 338 of the CCP , in force before 1 January 2012 , an appeal in a civil case could be lodged within ten days after the delivery of a first ‑ insta nce judgment in its final form. After 1 January 2012 the time ‑ limit for lodging an appeal has been extended to one month under Article 321 of the CCP .

Under Article 392 of the CCP a final judgment in a case may be reviewed, inter alia , on the ground that the European Court of Human Rights found a violation of the Convention on account of the domestic judicial proceedings or decisions taken in t hat case. Articles 393 ‑ 94 set out a procedure for reopening of domestic judicial proceedings in any such case.

Article 1109 § 3 of the CCP stipulates that , if a decision to grant compensations for damages to health to a person in the absence of a bad faith and miscalculations on his or her part is quashed on appeal or by way of supervisory review, the compensation itself cannot be claimed back .

COMPLAINTS

The applicants complain under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that restoration of the time-limit for an appeal resulting in quashing of the final judgment in their favour violated the principle of legal certainty. The applicants further complain under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 of the Convention that reversal of the compensations awarded by the Town Court, which had already been paid to some of the applicants, violated their right to property.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

1. Regard being had to the decisions listed in columns nos. 5 and 6 of Appendix 2, by which the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kabardino ‑ Balkaria, at requests of the Russian Ministry of Finance, restored a time-limit for appealing against decisions listed in columns nos. 3 and 2 of Appendix 2 respectively, were the guarantees of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention, and in particular the principle of legal certainty, respected (see Bezrukovy v. Russia , no. 34616/02, §§ 32-36, 10 May 2012)?

2. Have there been any other examples, not stemming from the facts as described in the present case, where a time-limit for an appeal was restored on similar grounds? The Government are invited to submit their reply with references to domestic practice, if any.

3. D id the quashing of the final judgment s in the applicants’ favour constitute an i nterference with the applicants’ right to the peaceful enjoyment of the possession in the form of the judgment debt? If so, was such interference justified in terms of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1?

Appendix 1

1. Application no. 11421/13 lodged on 22 January 2013 :

2. Application no. 15459/13 lod ged on 9 February 2013 :

3. Application no. 15473/13 lodged on 9 February 2013:

4. Application no. 1 5625/13 lodged on 9 February 2013:

5. Application no. 15651/13 lodged on 9 February 2013:

6. Application no. 18295/13 lodged on 20 February 2013:

7. Application no. 18767/13 lodged on 12 February 2013:

8. Application no. 18775/13 lodged on 22 February 2013:

9. Application no. 19142/13 lodged on 22 February 2013:

10. Application no. 19161/13 lodged on 14 February 2013:

11. Application no. 19179/13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

12. Application no. 19237/13 lodged on 12 February 2013:

13. Application no. 19259/ 13 lodged on 15 February 2013:

14. Application no. 19320/13 lodged on 9 February 2013:

15. Application no. 19398/13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

16. Application no. 19408/13 lodged on 14 February 2013:

17. Application no. 19422/13 lodged on 9 February 2013:

18. Application no. 19541/13 lodged on 17 February 2013:

19 . Application no. 19549/13 lodged on 11 February 2013:

20 . Application no. 19556/13 lodged on 11 February 2013:

21. Application no. 19687/13 lodged on 11 February 2013:

22. Application no. 19697/13 lodged on 11 February 2013:

23 . Application no. 19722/13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

24 . Application no. 22925/13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

25. Application no. 22935 /13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

26. Application no. 22953/13 lodged on 25 February 2013:

27. Application no. 23006 /13 lodged on 12 February 2013:

28. Application no. 23109/13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

29. Application no. 23135/13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

30. Application no. 23145/13 lodged on 13 February 2013:

31. Application no. 23177/13 lodged on 26 March 2013:

32. Application no. 26466/13 lodged on 11 February 2013:

33. Application no. 58066/13 lodged on 26 August 2013:

34. Application no. 60167/13 lodged on 5 September 2013 :

A PPENDIX 2

No.

Application no. / Case Title

Column no. 1

Main judgment taken on (final on)

Column no. 2

Refusal to restore time ‑ limit for appealing against the main judgment

Column no. 3

Decision to grant restoration of time-limit for appealing against refusal to restore time ‑ limit (final on)

Column no. 4

Decision to grant restoration of time-limit for appealing against the main judgment

Column no. 5

Decision to quash the main judgment

Column no. 6

1.

11421/13

KABARDOKOV and others v. Russia

12/04/11 (25/04/11)

08/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

7/09/12

2.

15459/13

AYTEKOV and others v. Russia

18/02/11 (01/03/11)

08/06/11

24/08/12

(27/09/12)

10/10/12

3.

15473/13

ANTONOV and others v. Russia

12/04/11 (22/04/11)

16/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

4.

15625/13

GUKEZHEV and others v. Russia

18/02/11 (01/03/11)

08/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

7/09/12

5.

15651/13

ARKHIPOV and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

08/06/11

24/0812

(26/09/12)

12/10/12

6.

18295/13

TAOV and others v. Russia

12/04/11 (22/04/11)

16/06/11

24/08/12

(26/09/12)

12/10/12

7.

18767/13

TANKANG and others v. Russia

11/04/11 (22/04/11)

08/06/11

24/08/12

(26/09/12)

12/10/12

8.

18775/13

TSYB and others v. Russia

24/05/11 (07/06/11)

01/11/11

24/08/12

(20/09/12)

04/10/12

9.

19142/13

BITTIROV and others v. Russia

05/04/11 (18/04/11)

07/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

10.

19161/13

TSIRKHOV and others v. Russia

11/04/11 (22/04/11)

08/06/11

24/08/12

(26/09/12)

12/10/12

11.

19179/13

VLASOV and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

08/06/11

24/08/12

(26/09/12)

12/10/12

12.

19237/13

VELICHKO and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

08/06/11

24/08/12

(27/09/12)

10/10/12

13.

19259/13

KHATSUKOV and others v. Russia

11/04/11 (21/04/11)

16/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

14.

19320/13

AFAUNOV and others v. Russia

15/02/11 (01/03/11)

09/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

15.

19398/13

BORIYEV and others v. Russia

14/02/11 (25/02/11)

09/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

7/09/12

16.

19408/13

APANASENKO and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

09/06/11

24/08/12

(26/09/12)

12/10/12

17.

19422/13

BOTTAEV and others v. Russia

12/04/11 (25/04/11)

16/06/11

24/08/12

(27/09/12)

10/10/12

18.

19541/13

GEDMISHKOV and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

09/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

19.

19549/13

GERDASOV and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

09/06/11

24/08/12

(27/09/12)

10/10/12

20.

19556/13

GOROYEV and others v. Russia

12/04/11 (25/04/11)

06/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

21.

19687/13

AYBAZOV and others v. Russia

04/04/11 (15/04/11)

08/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

22.

19697/13

BIDAK and others v. Russia

04/04/11 (15/04/11)

07/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

23.

19722/13

ALKHASOV and others v. Russia

04/04/11 (15/04/11)

09/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

24.

22925/13 ABDURAKHMONOV and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

09/06/11

24/08/12

(27/09/12)

10/10/12

25.

22935/13

ABAZOV and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

08/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

26.

22953/13

KUSHKHOV and others v. Russia

12/04/11 (25/04/11)

08/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

27.

23006/13

YERMOLOV and others v. Russia

11/04/11 (21/04/11)

08/06/11

24/08/12

(26/09/12)

12/10/12

28.

23109/13

BELUNIN and others v. Russia

16/02/11 (01/03/11)

09/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

7/09/12

29.

23135/13

KACHANOV and others v. Russia

04/04/11 (15/04/11)

09/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

30.

23145/13

GURTUYEV and others v. Russia

12/04/11 (22/04/11)

16/06/11

24/08/12

(27/09/12)

10/10/12

31.

23177/13

BEZYANOV and others v. Russia

18/02/11 (01/03/11)

08/06/11

15/11/12

(27/12/12)

27/02/13

32.

26466/13

ATABIYEV and others v. Russia

10/03/11 (22/03/11)

09/06/11

20/07/12

(22/08/12)

07/09/12

33.

58066 /13

NISHANOV v. Russia

17/01/11-(27/02/11)

06/06/11

16/11/12

(26/12/12)

28/02/13

34.

60167/13

KODZOKOV v. Russia

18/01/11 (28/02/11)

08/06/11

16/11/12

(26/12/12)

28/02/13

06/03/13

APPENDIX 3

No.

Applicants

Amount of awarded compensation

(RUB)

Compensation paid:

 - “yes”

 - “no”

Khamid Khatutovich KABARDOKOV

1,500,000



Viktor Vladimirovich BOCHARNIKOV

1,500,000



Yuriy Khadisovich GERGOV

1,500,000



Mukhadin Adamovich DOTKULOV

1,500,000



Zamir Misostovich KARDANOV

1,500,000



Gali Ezdanovich SHAOV

1,500,000



Baydulakh Magometovich AYTEKOV

1,500,000



Askerbiy Aslanovich BAYSIYEV

1,500,000



Ivan Grigoryevich ZAIKA

1,500,000



Viktor Mikhaylovich KREMENTSOV

1,500,000



Vasiliy Vasilyevich POPOVICH

1,500,000



Mikhail Mikhaylovich PANCHENKO

1,200,000



Sergey Ivanovich SOBAKAR

1,500,000



Ruslan Galiyevich UMAROV

1,500,000



Sergey Ivanovich ANTONOV

1,500,000



Assad Ogly Abassovich BABAYEV

1,500,000



Vladimir Petrovich BORIYEV

1,500,000



Khamid Khasanovich GUZIYEV

1,500,000



Viktor Vasilyevich DEYKIN

1,500,000



Urazay Musayevich KOKKEZOV

1,500,000



Ramazan Mustafayevich MOKAYEV

1,500,000



Marat Vladimirovich SRUKOV

1,500,000



Timur Khasanovich GUKEZHEV

1,500,000



Gisa Musayevich GUCHAPSHEV

1,500,000



Isuf Abuzedovich KUMYKOV

1,500,000



Mikhail Aniuarovich SARAKHOV

1,500,000



Arsen Khasanbiyevich URUSMAMBETOV

1,500,000



Seyf u Yusufovich KHAIROV

1,500,000



Muayed Khasanovich KHOKONOV

1,300,000



Ivan Timofeyevich ARKHIPOV

1,300,000



Muayed Sultanovich GEDMISHKHOV

1,300,000



Aleksey Dmitriyevich DADONOV

1,300,000



Khasen Vladimirovich ZHUZHUYEV

1,300,000



Vladimir Andreyevich KUDRITSKIY

1,300,000



Aleksandr Alekseyevich LARIN

1,300,000



Nikolay Fedorovich MENYAYLO

1,300,000



Vladimir Abramovich SHPAKOV

1,300,000



Zhora Khasanovich ERZHIBOV

1,300,000



Saladin Khautiyevich TAOV

1,600,000



Stanislav Sergeyevich ANOSOV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Aleksandrovich BORISENKO

1,300,000



Sergey Maratovich MAGOMEDOV

1,500,000



Ruslan Khadisovich MISROKOV

1,300,000



Aleksandr Nikolayevich SVIRIDENKO

1,500,000



Sultan Batyrbiyevich KHAMSHOKOV

1,500,000



Vladimir Grigoryevich TANKANAG

1,200,000



Andemirkan Muratovich KUCHMENOV

1,200,000



Karalbi Gidovich KEREFOV

1,200,000



Viktor Mikhaylovich TSYB

1,200,000



Igor Anatolyevich RYABTSEV

1,200,000



Aleksandr Ilyich KAGITIN

1,200,000



Mustafa Bekiyevich MANIYAYEV

1,200,000



Khasym Yusupovich BITTIROV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Mukharbiyevich ZRUMOV

1,300,000



Viktor Khazhmuratovich KUGOTOV

1,500,000



Auyes Khapitovich TSIRKHOV

1,200,000



Yuriy Alekseyevich NEKRASOV

1,200,000



Nikolay Ivanovich KHRUSHCHEV

1,200,000



Vasiliy Maksimovich LASHIN

1,200,000



Anatoliy Alekseyevich VARCHENKO

1,200,000



Magarram Vali Ogly NASIBOV

1,200,000



Vladimir Ivanovich PARSHAKOV

1,200,000



Viktor Nikolayevich YURCHENKO

1,200,000



Vasiliy Alekseyevich BOBROVENKO

1,200,000



Vladimir Timofeyevich SAVCHENKO

1,200,000



Nikolay Petrovich VLASOV

1,500,000



Vladimir Mikhaylovich KOLOMIYETS

1,500,000



Nikolay Ivanovich PRASOL

1,500,000



Leonid Spiridonovich PURKIN

1,500,000



Aleksandr Nikolayevich PEKAR

1,300,000



Aslanbi Adamovich TANASHEV

1,300,000



Aleksandr Mikhaylovich TOKAREV

1,300,000



Vladimir Nikolayevich VELICHKO

1,300,000



Vladimir Pavlovich ISTOMIN

1,300,000



Nikolay Nikolayevich KONONOV

1,300,000



Yevgeniy Aleksandrovich KILDISHOV

1,300,000



Leonid Talovich KAZHAROV

1,300,000



Sergey Filippovich LEPEKHIN

1,300,000



Pavel Ilyich LOGACHEV

1,300,000



Aleksandr Maksimovich LITYAYEV

1,300,000



Vasiliy Anatolyevich NIKOLAYENKO

1,300,000



Sarazhdin Talovich KHATSUKOV

1,200,000



Ruslan Leonidovich GUKEPSHOKOV

1,200,000



Murid Ayubovich BARAGUNOV

1,200,000



Sergey Ivanovich ARCHAKOV

1,200,000



Murid Borisovich BZHAUMYKHOV

1,200,000



Arsen Khabasovich KODZOKOV

1,200,000



Ashir Margeldyyevich ASHIROV

1,200,000



Albek Auyesovich AFAUNOV

1,500,000



Boris Sarzhudinovich BOKOV

1,500,000



Valeriy Emilevich GUBER

1,500,000



Viktor Semenovich KONTORIN

1,300,000



Vladimir Viktorovich LUKYANOV

1,300,000



Kazbek Safarbiyevich SHAOV

1,500,000



Vitaliy Viktorovich TSARKOV

1,300,000



Murik Blitovich BORIYEV

1,500,000



Anatoliy Adalgeriyevich KUMYKOV

1,500,000



Mukhazhid Mukhamedovich ORGANOKOV

1,500,000



Sergey Semenovich PANYAKIN

1,300,000



Boris Timofeyevich KHOKHLACHEV

1,500,000



Nikolay Konstantinovich APANASENKO

1,500,000



Oleg Valentinovich VOLODIN

1,200,000



Viktor Vladimirovich GLYBIN

1,300,000



Viktor Ivanovich KLOCHKOV

1,500,000



Viktor Petrovich LIKHTINOV

1,500,000



Amir Musarbiyevich PSHIGUSOV

1,300,000



Khasan Kilchukovich SIZHAZHEV

1,300,000



Nikolay Grigoryevich CHIKALENKO

1,500,000



Timosha Khazhpagovich SHADOV

1,300,000



Mikhail Lukmanovich BOTTAYEV

1,500,000



Bilyal Khangeriyevich KARDANOV

1,500,000



Taymoraz Khadzimussayevich MATAROV

1,500,000



Khazrit Tutovich MARGUSHEV

1,500,000



Vasiliy Alekseyevich TOKAREV

1,500,000



Shamil Khamidovich UYANAYEV

1,500,000



Ruslan Bashirovich KHATSUKOV

1,500,000



Anzor Khabilovich GEDMISHKHOV

1,300,000



Nikolay Ivanovich ZARKOV

1,300,000



Khasan Khazhimurzovich KOCHESOKOV

1,300,000



Mukhadin Aliyevich KOKOV

1,300,000



Bail Lyaliyevich NAGOYEV

1,300,000



Valeriy Yuryevich PUTEVTSOV

1,300,000



Khusen Gazaliyevich SABANCHIYEV

1,300,000



Igor Grigoryevich GREDASOV

1,300,000



Boris Ivanovich DEGTYARENKO

1,300,000



Khamid Bubovich KARDANOV

1,200,000



Yaroslav Yaroslavovich MORSIN

1,500,000



Nikolay Petrovich POTAPKIN

1,300,000



Aleksandr Dmitriyevich SEMOCHKIN

1,300,000



Viktor Gennadyevich SHVEDOV

1,300,000



Igor Aleksandrovich YURLOV

1,300,000



Magomet Tokayevich GOROYEV

1,500,000



Amir Kushbiyevich GELOYEV

1,500,000



Boris Pshimakhovich DZUGANOV

1,500,000



Nyusya Shagbanovna DOKSHUKINA

1,500,000



Vladimir Andreyevich POTKALO

1,500,000



Zalimgeri Gisovich TUROV

1,500,000



Zaur Shagirovich SHOMAKHOV

1,500,000



Artur Khatsuyevich SHOMAKHOV

1,500,000



Khusen Mazanovich AYBAZOV

1,500,000



Kharun Satyvaldyyevich GYZYYEV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Viktorovich KOSTENKO

1,500,000



Zhamal Zhapayevich KULBAYEV

1,500,000



Dmitriy Anatolyevich MININ

1,500,000



Mustafir Muradinovich OSMANOV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Nikolayevich FINOGENOV

1,500,000



Viktor Ivanovich BIDAK

1,300,000



Vladimir Aleksandrovich BUDNIKOV

1,300,000



Anatoliy Khambiyevich DOKHOV

1,500,000



Khazhmurat Yakhyayevich DZHANKULAYEV

1,500,000



Nikolay Mikhaylovich MUKOZHEV

1,500,000



Alisag Mukhamedovich TAKHUSHEV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Nikolayevich STEPANENKO

1,300,000



Vyacheslav Anibalovich TSIRKHOV

1,500,000



Mutalis Mikhaylovich ALKHASOV

1,500,000



Khyzyr Khadzhimuratovich KABARDOKOV

1,500,000



Anatoliy Talevich KONGAPSHEV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Nikolayevich PLAKHOV

1,500,000



Vasiliy Ilyich STRIZHAK

1,500,000



Akhmet Khasultanovich KHARSIYEV

1,500,000



Makhamadzhan Narbayevich KHAYNAZAROV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Aleksandrovich CHERNYSHOV

1,500,000



Nikolay Khadinovich SHIKLYASHEV

1,500,000



Sergey Sobirovich ABDURAKHMONOV

1,500,000



Ruslan Khazhislamovich GONGAPSHEV

1,300,000



Vladimir Anatolyevich DEREPOVKO

1,500,000



Valeriy Aleksandrovich KOROVIN

1,500,000



Aleksey Timofeyevich KOZLOVTSEV

1,300,000



Sergey Petrovich LAPTEV

1,300,000



Pavel Alekseyevich NIKITENKO

1,500,000



Muayed Mastafovich SURMAMETOV

1,300,000



Zaurbek Ismagilovich SHANIBOV

1,200,000



Eduard Chartiyevich ABAZOV

1,300,000



Fedya Khuseynovich ZHEMGURAZOV

1,300,000



Sergey Konstantinovich ZYKOV

1,300,000



Yevgeniy Nikolayevich LAZAREV

1,300,000



Tobi Khasanbiyevich KUSHKHOV

1,500,000



Vladimir Kurgokovich SIBILOV

1,500,000



Viktor Andreyevich KHALIN

1,500,000



Shota Aleksandrovich YERMOLOV

1,200,000



Vasiliy Ivanovich SHEVYAKOV

1,200,000



Eduard Borisovich CHIKHRADZE

1,200,000



Valentina Grigoryevna POLYAKOVA

1,200,000



Khuseyn Seyfullakhovich GEKKIYEV

1,200,000



Sergey Otarovich GOBEDZHISHVILI

1,200,000



Anatoliy Khizirovich ZHAMBIKOV

1,200,000



Mikhail Vladimirovich BELUNIN

1,500,000



Nikolay Nikolayevich MARCHENKO

1,300,000



Gennadiy Andreyevich MOISEYENKO

1,300,000



Yuriy Grigoryevich MEDVEDEV

1,500,000



Talgat Avzalovich NURMUKHAMETOV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Vladimirovich PINYAYEV

1,500,000



Petr Ivanovich SLIPENKO

1,300,000



Tayib Ayubovich TADZHIBOV

1,300,000



Ivan Semenovich KACHANOV

1,300,000



Viktor Petrovich LICHMANOV

1,300,000



Sergey Timofeyevich NIKOLAYEV

1,300,000



Yuriy Stepanovich OBUKHOV

1,300,000



Garri Mikhaylovich POGOSOV

1,300,000



Sergey Leonidovich SADOVOY

1,300,000



Sergey Viktorovich KHARITONOV

1,300,000



Valeriy Akhmatovich GURTUYEV

1,500,000



Muayed Khusenovich LIGIDOV

1,500,000



Mukhamed Anatolyevich MAREMSHAOV

1,500,000



Vasiliy Ivanovich MARTYNYUK

1,500,000



Zamir Gumarovich TUKHUZHEV

1,200,000



Khusein Abdullayevich SHAKHABOV

1,500,000



Nikolay Yakovlevich SHTELVAKH

1,500,000



Mukharbek Mukhadinovich SHOMAKHOV

1,500,000



Vyacheslav Vladimirovich BEZYANOV

1,500,000



Viktor Ivanovich GAYDAR

1,500,000



Nikolay Nikolayevich STOLYARENKO

1,500,000



Viktor Konstantinovich SANKOV

1,500,000



Muzafar Tatukovich ATABIYEV

1,500,000



Boris Aliyevich BEPPAYEV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Vladimirovich KATASONOV

1,500,000



Khachim Dinovich PSHIKHACHEV

1,500,000



Ruslan Yuryevich TUMOV

1,500,000



Aniuar Zhansitovich TAOV

1,500,000



Aleksandr Amirkhanovich SHOMAKHOV

1,500,000



Eduard Dikanovich SHOMAKHOV

1,500,000



Ruslan Marufovich NISHANOV

1,500,000



Boris Nashkhovich KODZOKOV

1,500,000



Menu

KABARDOKOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA and 33 other applications

KABARDOKOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA and 33 other applications

LEXI