Lexploria

Published on 18 December 2023

SECOND SECTION

Application no. 49867/21 Emrah YILDIZ against TÃ¼rkiye and 199 other applications (see list appended) communicated on 12 December 2023

STATEMENT OF FACTS

1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.

2. The applications mainly concern the applicantsâ€™ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the â€œFetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structureâ€ ( FetullahÃ§Ä± TerÃ¶r Ã–rgÃ¼tÃ¼ / Paralel Devlet YapÄ±lanmasÄ± , hereinafter referred to as â€œthe FETÃ–/PDYâ€), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in TÃ¼rkiye on 15 July 2016.

3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia , on the applicantsâ€™ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application â€œByLockâ€, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÃ–/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÃ–/PDYâ€™s hierarchical structure.

4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, Â§Â§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).

5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya (cited above, Â§Â§ 141-193).

COMPLAINTS

6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÃ–/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 Â§ 1.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, Â§Â§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against TÃ¼rkiye.

APPENDIX

List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 Â§ 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial)

(conviction for membership of the FETÃ–/PDY based, inter alia , on the applicantsâ€™ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application â€œByLockâ€ )

No.

Application no.

Case name

Lodged on

Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality

Represented by

49867/21

YÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2021

Emrah YILDIZ 1985 Manisa Turkish

Arife YÃœKSEKDAÄž ALTUNAY

49474/19

SoÄŸucak v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/09/2019

Ercan SOÄžUCAK 1980 Istanbul Turkish

Yeliz HANOÄžLU

63600/19

YÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/11/2019

Ä°zettin YILDIZ 1988 Sivas Turkish

Okan GÃœNEL

2756/20

Parlak v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/12/2019

Ä°rfan PARLAK 1977 Bursa Turkish

Murat IÅžIK

13231/20

ApaydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/03/2020

Emine APAYDIN 1971 Gaziantep Turkish

Mehmet Fatih Ä°Ã‡ER

13734/20

TaÅŸkÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/03/2020

Adnan TAÅžKIN 1978 Antalya Turkish

Fehmi GÃœNDÃœZ

16910/20

Er v. TÃ¼rkiye

31/03/2020

Ã–zcan ER 1971 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Birsen KARADAÅž

16942/20

Kaplan v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/03/2020

Umut KAPLAN 1976 Kars Turkish

Seyfettin KAN

17632/20

DeliktaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/04/2020

Erkan DELÄ°KTAÅž 1992 Istanbul Turkish

Murat GÃœRSOY

17970/20

Åžahin v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/04/2020

Ufuk ÅžAHÄ°N 1976 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Mehmet SÄ±ddÄ±k KARAGÃ–Z

18258/20

TaÅŸtan v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/04/2020

Nursel TAÅžTAN 1976 Manisa Turkish

AsÄ±m Burak GÃœNEÅž

19827/20

Alp v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/04/2020

Atilla ALP 1993 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Ahmet Serdar GÃœNEÅž

22926/20

Eraslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/06/2020

Hasan ERASLAN 1986 KÄ±rÅŸehir Turkish

Nurullah KALKAN

26186/20

Balta v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/06/2020

Erdi BALTA 1988 Ä°zmir Turkish

MÃ¼jdat Fatih Ä°Ã‡EL

26609/20

AygÃ¼n v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/06/2020

Abdullah AYGÃœN 1967 Ã‡orum Turkish

Tahir EREN

27761/20

Åžen v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/07/2020

Veysel ÅžEN 1994 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

MÃ¼rÃ¼vet KARABAYIR AKARSU

27809/20

Zengin v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/06/2020

Kerim ZENGÄ°N 1978 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Birsen KARADAÅž

30382/20

GÃ¼ntan v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/06/2020

Ä°smail GÃœNTAN 1983 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

NeÅŸe GÃœNTAN

32874/20

Ã‡anakcÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/07/2020

ErdinÃ§ Ã‡ANAKCI 1981 Kayseri Turkish

Mutlu KARAYILAN

33274/20

Aydemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/07/2020

BÃ¼lent AYDEMÄ°R 1973 Ä°zmir Turkish

Basri GÃœNDÃœZ

36233/20

Atalay v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/08/2020

Muhammed ATALAY 1993 Konya Turkish

Mustafa Ubeyde KAYHAN

40934/20

ErÅŸen v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/09/2020

Mahmut Sami ERÅžEN 1988 Kayseri Turkish

Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAÄž

41828/20

Engin Ã–zkan v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/09/2020

Esma ENGÄ°N Ã–ZKAN 1990 Malatya Turkish

HÃ¼seyin KELEÅž

42797/20

ArduÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/09/2020

Serdal ARDUÃ‡ 1979 Ã‡orum Turkish

Tahir EREN

43197/20

YÃ¶rÃ¼k v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/09/2020

Hasan YÃ–RÃœK 1973 EskiÅŸehir Turkish

Yakup GÃ–NEN

45465/20

BaÅŸtuÄŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/10/2020

Abdullah BAÅžTUÄž 1993 Malatya Turkish

Hanifi KARTAL

46394/20

Eser v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/10/2020

SÃ¼meyye ESER 1992 Zonguldak Turkish

Okan GÃœNEL

46564/20

Saydam v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/10/2020

Ali SAYDAM 1976 Hatay Turkish

Dudu ERTUNÃ‡

47897/20

KocaaÄŸa v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/10/2020

ZÃ¼lfiye KOCAAÄžA 1980 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

48984/20

Fent v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/04/2020

Bekir FENT 1985 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Sinem GÃ–Ã‡MEZ

49044/20

Atay v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/10/2020

Mehmet ATAY 1968 UÅŸak Turkish

Fatma GÃœRMEN

52062/20

IÅŸÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/11/2020

Ä°sak IÅžIK 1980 Yozgat Turkish

Ä°rem GÃœNEÅž

52909/20

PolattaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/11/2020

Mustafa POLATTAÅž 1982 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Mehmet Fatih Ä°Ã‡ER

54162/20

SayÄ±lÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/11/2020

Ebrar Tuba SAYILI 1992 Istanbul Turkish

Mehmet Fatih Ä°Ã‡ER

55073/20

SarÄ±kaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/12/2020

Cengiz SARIKAYA 1970 Kayseri Turkish

Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAÄž

55159/20

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/11/2020

Alaettin DEMÄ°R 1972 Antalya Turkish

Ä°shak IÅžIK

30/21

KaraaÄŸaÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/12/2020

Ferda KARAAÄžAÃ‡ 1972 Ankara Turkish

Burcu HAS

210/21

Turhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/11/2020

Mehmet Akif TURHAN 1984 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

SÃ¼leyman KARTAL

239/21

Karaarslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/11/2020

Ali KARAARSLAN 1981 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

SÃ¼leyman KARTAL

900/21

AyyÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/12/2020

Elif AYYILDIZ 1972 Manisa Turkish

MÃ¼jdat Fatih Ä°Ã‡EL

1208/21

TaÅŸdelen v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/12/2020

Mustafa TAÅžDELEN 1981 Ankara Turkish

Ahmet KAVUNCUOÄžLU

5469/21

KÄ±lÄ±Ã§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/01/2021

Mustafa KILIÃ‡ 1983 Ankara Turkish

Mehmet Sena KAPU

7175/21

KurÅŸun v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/01/2021

Hakan Ã–zer KURÅžUN 1984 Sakarya Turkish

Ahmet EROL

7190/21

Ã‡akÄ±r v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/01/2021

BahadÄ±r Ã‡AKIR 1977 Istanbul Turkish

Ahmet EROL

7212/21

AkÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/01/2021

AteÅŸ AKIN 1974 DÃ¼zce Turkish

Ä°smail GÃœLER

8738/21

YÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/01/2021

Ahmet YILDIZ 1987 Mersch/

Luxembourg Turkish

Ahmet EROL

9532/21

KarabÄ±yÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/01/2021

DurmuÅŸ KARABIYIK 1969 Osmaniye Turkish

Meryem KARABIYIK

9555/21

ErdoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/01/2021

HacÄ± Harun ERDOÄžAN 1978 Erzurum Turkish

Harun IÅžIK

9803/21

Kelam v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/12/2020

Ali Arslan KELAM 1977 Istanbul Turkish

TarÄ±k Said GÃœLDÄ°BÄ°

11491/21

Menek v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/02/2021

Fatih MENEK 1978 Manisa Turkish

AsÄ±m Burak GÃœNEÅž

11864/21

Uzan v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/02/2021

Ahmet UZAN 1978 Ä°zmir Turkish

YÃ¼ksel ERSOY

13352/21

Pekuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/02/2021

Tolga PEKUZ 1984 Antalya Turkish

Ä°shak IÅžIK

13655/21

Åžahin v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/03/2021

Dursun ÅžAHÄ°N 1985 Kayseri Turkish

Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAÄž

15017/21

Ã–zkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/03/2021

Mahmut Recai Ã–ZKAYA 1968 Erzurum Turkish

Harun IÅžIK

15784/21

Ä°lhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/03/2021

Ramazan Ä°LHAN 1978 Van Turkish

Ä°smail GÃœLER

15903/21

GÃ¼rsu v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/01/2021

Emrah GÃœRSU 1988 Merkez Turkish

Abdullah GÃœRSU

15981/21

GÃ¶rgÃ¶z v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/03/2021

Alperen GÃ–RGÃ–Z 1988 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Halil KAÃ‡AMAZ

16100/21

Kaftan v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/03/2021

Mehmet Ali KAFTAN 1966 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Fatima BÃ¼ÅŸra KAFTAN

16221/21

Metin v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/03/2021

Åženol METÄ°N 1982 Samsun Turkish

Yakup GÃ–NEN

16954/21

Erbay v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/03/2021

YÃ¼cel ERBAY 1983 Eskisehir Turkish

AtÄ±l KARADUMAN

16981/21

IÅŸÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/03/2021

Numan IÅžIK 1982 Yozgat Turkish

Ahmet Serdar GÃœNEÅž

18022/21

Poyraz v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/03/2021

KazÄ±m POYRAZ 1965 Malatya Turkish

Ä°sa KARGIN

18089/21

TaÅŸtan v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/03/2021

Adem TAÅžTAN 1973 Manisa Turkish

AsÄ±m Burak GÃœNEÅž

18160/21

KalpaklÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/03/2021

MÃ¼cahit KALPAKLI 1991 DÃ¼zce Turkish

Ali KALPAKLI

18323/21

Bulut v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/03/2021

Erkan BULUT 1983 Antalya Turkish

MÃ¼nip ERMÄ°Åž

18508/21

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/03/2021

Mustafa YILMAZ 1991 Amasya Turkish

KÃ¼bra KAZANCI TOSUN

18522/21

KarcÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/03/2021

Hayrullah KARCI 1993 Osmaniye Turkish

Fatma KARCI

19168/21

ErkÄ±lÄ±nÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/04/2021

Mehmet ERKILINÃ‡ 1972 Adana Turkish

Sultan ERKILINÃ‡

19261/21

MenevÅŸe v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/04/2021

Emrah MENEVÅžE 1981 Malatya Turkish

Ä°sa KARGIN

19357/21

KaradaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/03/2021

Furkan KARADAÅž 1988 Van Turkish

Harun IÅžIK

19663/21

Kazan v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/04/2021

Ä°nan KAZAN 1984 Mersin Turkish

Nuren KAZAN

20212/21

BÃ¼rcÃ¼ v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/04/2021

Ä°smail BÃœRCÃœ 1985 Bursa Turkish

Ahmet Serdar GÃœNEÅž

22415/21

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/04/2021

Muzaffer YILMAZ 1965 Ä°zmir Turkish

Fatima BÃ¼ÅŸra KAFTAN

22946/21

Ã–zdemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2021

Erkan Ã–ZDEMÄ°R 1987 MuÄŸla Turkish

Mehmet KARAKOÃ‡

23097/21

Ã‡alhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/04/2021

Mert Ã‡ALHAN 1994 Denizli Turkish

Ä°smail KAPLAN

24015/21

Ã–zdemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/04/2021

Sabahattin Ã–ZDEMÄ°R 1971 Hatay Turkish

Dudu ERTUNÃ‡

24564/21

SÃ¼lÃ¼ v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/04/2021

HÃ¼dai SÃœLÃœ 1985 Malatya Turkish

Ä°sa KARGIN

26085/21

SÃ¶zen v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/05/2021

Yusuf SÃ–ZEN 1979 Rize Turkish

Ekrem KAYA

26103/21

Fidan v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/04/2021

Mehmet Mahsun FÄ°DAN 1994 Ä°zmir Turkish

Elif KARDEÅž

26696/21

Kutluer v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/05/2021

Ali KUTLUER 1992 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Emrah Ä°RVEN

27988/21

AltuÄŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/05/2021

Ã‡aÄŸatay ALTUÄž 1975 Turkish

Fatma KAYA

28204/21

SarÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/05/2021

Derya SARI 1991 Antalya Turkish

Muammer HAPÄ°L

28666/21

KaragÃ¶z v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/05/2021

Erdal KARAGÃ–Z 1977 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Elif KARAGÃ–Z

29668/21

OrtaÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/05/2021

Ahmet ORTAÃ‡ 1985 Hatay Turkish

Dudu ERTUNÃ‡

29678/21

Berber v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/06/2021

Mehmet BERBER 1986 Hatay Turkish

Ahmet EROL

29728/21

GÃ¶zel v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/06/2021

Hanifi GÃ–ZEL 1994 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Åžerafettin GÃœCÃœ

29775/21

Gezek v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/05/2021

Ersin GEZEK 1984 Malatya Turkish

Nesrin GEZEK

32300/21

FakÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/06/2021

Hikmet FAKI 1981 NiÄŸde Turkish

Murat Fahri ERTUL

32453/21

ArÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/06/2021

Fatih ARI 1988 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Tevfik KARTAL

32599/21

CoÅŸkun v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/06/2021

Mustafa COÅžKUN 1977 Antalya Turkish

Ä°shak IÅžIK

33042/21

YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/06/2021

Hakim YILDIRIM 1988 Turkish

AyÅŸe KAYA

35342/21

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/06/2021

Harun AYDIN 1987 Hatay Turkish

Adem KAPLAN

35446/21

Sebahattin v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/06/2021

Topal SEBAHATTÄ°N 1980 Ankara Turkish

Adem KAPLAN

35899/21

BektaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/07/2021

Yavuz BEKTAÅž 1989 Kocaeli Turkish

Hakan KAPLANKAYA

35905/21

Ã‡avuÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/07/2021

Harun Ã‡AVUÅž 1976 Hatay Turkish

Dudu ERTUNÃ‡

36083/21

AktaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/06/2021

Ã–zkan AKTAÅž 1988 Manisa Turkish

Adem KAPLAN

37049/21

TemurtaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/07/2021

Ali TEMURTAÅž 1983 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Mehmet Ali KAYA

39759/21

AkdoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/07/2021

Ferhat AKDOÄžAN 1981 EskiÅŸehir Turkish

Ahmet Serdar GÃœNEÅž

43479/21

GÃ¼ndoÄŸdu v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/08/2021

Ã–mer Faruk GÃœNDOÄžDU 1987 Antalya Turkish

AyÅŸe GÃœNDOÄžDU

43549/21

RiÅŸvanlÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/08/2021

Recep RÄ°ÅžVANLI 1990 ÅžanlÄ±urfa Turkish

Ä°brahim Halil GÃœRDAL

43979/21

KaraahmetoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/08/2021

Ä°dris KARAAHMETOÄžLU 1982 Ä°zmir Turkish

Efe KEÃ‡ELÄ°

44000/21

KarataÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/08/2021

Metin KARATAÅž 1976 Ä°zmir Turkish

Mumine KARATAÅž

45540/21

Palta v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/09/2021

Bestami PALTA 1983 Hatay Turkish

Dudu ERTUNÃ‡

46029/21

Kalkan v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/09/2021

Nevzat KALKAN 1982 Ã‡anakkale Turkish

Fatma KALKAN

48295/21

Ayar v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/09/2021

Zeynep AYAR 1980 Samsun Turkish

Fatma HACIPAÅžALIOÄžLU

48296/21

GÃ¼mÃ¼ÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/09/2021

Fatih GÃœMÃœÅž 1986 EskiÅŸehir Turkish

Fatma HACIPAÅžALIOÄžLU

48344/21

Kendirci v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/09/2021

Resul KENDÄ°RCÄ° 1978 Gaziantep Turkish

Ã‡aÄŸrÄ± Seyfettin GÃ–KDEMÄ°R

49284/21

Gezen v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/09/2021

Seher GEZEN 1988 Istanbul Turkish

Ä°lyas HARMANDALI

50009/21

Uslu v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/10/2021

Ahmet USLU 1971 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Mehmet KARAKOÃ‡

51138/21

Karaaslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/10/2021

Ahmet KARAASLAN 1983 Istanbul Turkish

Hamid KAYNARPINAR

52152/21

Eyilcim v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/10/2021

Muzaffer EYÄ°LCÄ°M 1967 Bursa Turkish

Elif KARDEÅž

52177/21

TÃ¼ysÃ¼z v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/06/2021

Suat TÃœYSÃœZ 1984 Edirne Turkish

Yakup GÃ–NEN

52501/21

Ekinci v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/10/2021

ErtaÅŸ EKÄ°NCÄ° 1987 Samsun Turkish

Ekrem KAYA

53640/21

GÃ¼l v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/10/2021

Refik GÃœL 1987 Kahramanmaras Turkish

Belma KAYRAN

54118/21

Keskin v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/10/2021

Ensar KESKÄ°N 1972 Artvin Turkish

ErsayÄ±n IÅžIK

58391/21

Yakut v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/11/2021

Muhammed FazÄ±l YAKUT 1994 Kayseri Turkish

Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAÄž

58797/21

KÄ±yak v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/11/2021

Mustafa KIYAK 1968 Bolu Turkish

Elif KARDEÅž

60040/21

GÃ¼l v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/11/2021

Cumali GÃœL 1971 Adana Turkish

Fatma GÃœL

60208/21

Okur v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/12/2021

Nihat OKUR 1980 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Mehmet SÄ±ddÄ±k KARAGÃ–Z

60282/21

TatlÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/12/2021

Mehmet TATLI 1971 Erzurum Turkish

Harun IÅžIK

2565/22

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/12/2021

Muhammed DEMÄ°R 1989 Malatya Turkish

Vedat KAPLAN

3027/22

YÃ¶rÃ¼dÃ¼ v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/01/2022

Ahmet YÃ–RÃœDÃœ 1991 Manisa Turkish

Mehmet Ali KAYA

3331/22

Saka v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/01/2022

Tacettin SAKA 1977 Bayburt Turkish

Hasan EROÄžLU

3927/22

Ä°lhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/01/2022

GÃ¼lpembe Ä°LHAN 1997 Kocaeli Turkish

AtÄ±l KARADUMAN

4294/22

ZÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/01/2022

Åžeref ZIK 1993 Samsun Turkish

Burcu HAS

4370/22

YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m Pehlivan v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/01/2022

Funda Fethiye YILDIRIM PEHLÄ°VAN 1976 Denizli Turkish

Atilla ERTEKÄ°N

5618/22

Toker v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/01/2021

Fatih TOKER 1990 EskiÅŸehir Turkish

AtÄ±l KARADUMAN

6382/22

Ä°nce v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/01/2022

Suat Ä°NCE 1983 Ã‡anakkale Turkish

Esra Ä°NCE

8978/22

Kaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/02/2022

Yusuf KAYA 1990 Manisa Turkish

TarÄ±k Said GÃœLDÄ°BÄ°

10037/22

Tutkun v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/02/2022

Ali TUTKUN 1972 Turkish

FÄ±rat KAPLAN

11431/22

Selen v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/02/2022

Ã–mer Faruk SELEN 1982 Malatya Turkish

Basri GÃœNDÃœZ

12979/22

AdÄ±yaman v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/02/2022

Yakup ADIYAMAN 1976 Istanbul Turkish

LÃ¼tfullah GÃœN

13047/22

Kaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/02/2022

Murat KAYA 1970 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

13058/22

Ã‡ubuk v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/03/2022

Ä°brahim Ã‡UBUK 1973 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

13253/22

ErdoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/03/2022

NamÄ±k ERDOÄžAN 1973 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

14201/22

Turan v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/03/2022

Mehmet TURAN 1979 Samsun Turkish

Tahir EREN

17166/22

KoÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/03/2022

Ä°brahim KOÃ‡ 1976 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Mehmet GENÄ°ÅžLER

17269/22

TuranlÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/03/2022

Sinan TURANLI 1974 Manisa Turkish

AsÄ±m Burak GÃœNEÅž

18975/22

Deniz v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/04/2022

Yakup DENÄ°Z 1992 Ä°zmir Turkish

Ä°hsan Ä°VEDÄ°

19062/22

Atabey v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/04/2022

Arif ATABEY 1986 Istanbul Turkish

TarÄ±k Said GÃœLDÄ°BÄ°

19712/22

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/04/2022

BarÄ±ÅŸ YILMAZ 1987 Sakarya Turkish

Muhammet IÅžIK

20066/22

KaÃ§a v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/04/2022

MÃ¼slim KAÃ‡A 1970 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

20681/22

DanÄ±ÅŸmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/04/2022

HÃ¼seyin DANIÅžMAZ 1976 SAMSUN Turkish

Ekrem KAYA

22188/22

KaragÃ¶l v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/04/2022

Hami KARAGÃ–L 1987 Bayburt Turkish

Harun IÅžIK

23089/22

DaÅŸtan v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/04/2022

Murat DAÅžTAN 1985 Artvin Turkish

Elif KANDÄ°LLÄ°

24900/22

Ã‡oktu v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/05/2022

Abdulhalim Ã‡OKTU 1983 Sinop Turkish

Muhammet IÅžIK

24960/22

SaÄŸlam v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/05/2022

Mustafa SAÄžLAM 1983 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Mehmet SÄ±ddÄ±k KARAGÃ–Z

25525/22

Heybet v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/04/2022

MÃ¼min HEYBET 1964 Istanbul Turkish

TarÄ±k Said GÃœLDÄ°BÄ°

27106/22

Kaplan v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/05/2022

Ahmet KAPLAN 1979 Denizli Turkish

Muhammed KAPLAN

29034/22

TopÃ§u v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/06/2022

KÃ¶ksal TOPÃ‡U 1980 Rize Turkish

Fatma Nur GÃ–KÃ‡E UYSAL

30202/22

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

31/05/2022

Ali DEMÄ°R 1972 Samsun Turkish

Tahir EREN

30463/22

Yavuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/06/2022

Halil YAVUZ 1982 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

30465/22

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/06/2022

Ã–zge DEMÄ°R 1990 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

31176/22

ErdoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/06/2022

Hakan ERDOÄžAN 1973 Antalya Turkish

Fehmi GÃœNDÃœZ

31385/22

UÄŸurlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/06/2022

Yasin UÄžURLU 1990 Manisa Turkish

Burcu HAS

32059/22

DÃ¶ÅŸer v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/06/2022

Taha Murat DÃ–ÅžER 1982 Istanbul Turkish

Elif KANDÄ°LLÄ°

32135/22

HepoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/06/2022

Erhan HEPOÄžLU 1990 Rhein Turkish

Hakan KAPLANKAYA

32508/22

Konuk v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/06/2022

BÃ¼nyamin KONUK 1983 Istanbul Turkish

Elif KANDÄ°LLÄ°

34097/22

AlÄ±cÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/06/2022

Murat ALICI 1974 Denizli Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

34564/22

Ã–zkulluk v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/06/2022

Haceli Ã–ZKULLUK 1975 Aksaray Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

35009/22

Baykara v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/07/2022

Hilal BAYKARA 1990 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Tahir EREN

35272/22

BinbaÅŸÄ±oÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/07/2022

Mehmet SÃ¼reyya BÄ°NBAÅžIOÄžLU 1973 Denizli Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

35582/22

Can v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/07/2022

ÅžÃ¼krÃ¼ CAN 1971 Istanbul Turkish

BÃ¼ÅŸra Nur KALE EKÄ°NCÄ°

36583/22

CoÅŸkun v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/06/2022

SÃ¼meyye COÅžKUN 1984 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Burcu HAS

37482/22

Ceyhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/07/2022

Hatice CEYHAN 1978 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Ä°brahim KARAÃ‡AR

37742/22

BakÄ±rcÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/07/2022

Mehmet BAKIRCI 1971 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Fatima BÃ¼ÅŸra KAFTAN

37772/22

Poyraz v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/07/2022

Mustafa POYRAZ 1971 Manisa Turkish

Ã‡aÄŸrÄ± Seyfettin GÃ–KDEMÄ°R

38410/22

Hendek v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/07/2022

Ä°sa HENDEK 1987 Amasya Turkish

Tahir EREN

38422/22

SaÄŸlam v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/07/2022

HacÄ± SAÄžLAM 1973 Ä°zmir Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

38716/22

Ekici v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/07/2022

Emin EKÄ°CÄ° 1983 Denizli Turkish

Adnan ERDOÄžAN

39114/22

Aslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/07/2022

Emine Nur ASLAN 1992 Turkish

Tahir EREN

40742/22

KaraaÄŸaÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/08/2022

Arzu KARAAÄžAÃ‡ 1974 Ankara Turkish

Burcu HAS

42233/22

Orhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/08/2022

GÃ¶nÃ¼l ORHAN 1984 Samsun Turkish

Yakup GÃ–NEN

42751/22

Akmirza v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/08/2022

Havva AKMÄ°RZA 1973 Ankara Turkish

Adem KAPLAN

42851/22

Ã–zkara v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/08/2022

Semanur Ã–ZKARA 1996 Ankara Turkish

LÃ¼tfullah GÃœN

43335/22

Karabulut v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/08/2022

Tolgay KARABULUT 1972 Ordu Turkish

Tevfik KARABULUT

43816/22

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/08/2022

MÃ¼zeyyen YILMAZ 1989 Ankara Turkish

Ãœsame Ä°NAN

43886/22

Delice v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/08/2022

Ali DELÄ°CE 1972 Istanbul Turkish

CoÅŸkun KARADENÄ°Z

43908/22

Erbil v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/09/2022

Ä°lhan ERBÄ°L 1975 Ä°zmir Turkish

Elif GÄ°RGÄ°N

44292/22

Ã–zer v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/09/2022

Abdullah Erol Ã–ZER 1971 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Hatice GÃœNDOÄžDU

44891/22

Kan v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/09/2022

Samet KAN 1986 Gaziantep Turkish

Remziye KAN

45019/22

DoÄŸru v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/09/2022

Orhan DOÄžRU 1974 Istanbul Turkish

Ziya KARA

46639/22

KÃ¶leli v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/09/2022

Osman KÃ–LELÄ° 1979 Denizli Turkish

Elif KANDÄ°LLÄ°

46925/22

Ã‡etin v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/09/2022

Yusuf TÃ¼rker Ã‡ETÄ°N 1987 Ä°zmir Turkish

GÃ¶khan KAÃ‡AR

48075/22

ErdoÄŸmuÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/09/2022

Murat ERDOÄžMUÅž 1973 Bursa Turkish

ÃœlkÃ¼ ERDOÄžMUÅž

48123/22

Dural v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/09/2022

Mesut DURAL 1980 Antalya Turkish

Ä°shak IÅžIK

49380/22

GÃ¼len v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/10/2022

AyÅŸe GÃ¼lbahar GÃœLEN 1988 Ankara Turkish

KÃ¼bra GÃœLAÃ‡TI

49831/22

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/10/2022

Ahmet AYDIN 1979 AkÃ§adaÄŸ Turkish

Ã–ncel GÃœLER

50604/22

AkkoÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/10/2022

Hikmet AKKOÃ‡ 1981 Denizli Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

52509/22

Can v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/11/2022

Hasan CAN 1972 Ankara Turkish

Burcu HAS

53895/22

Unus v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/11/2022

Ä°dris UNUS 1986 Van Turkish

Harun IÅžIK

55965/22

Ãœnsal v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/11/2022

Samet ÃœNSAL 1970 Ankara Turkish

Adem KAPLAN

56019/22

Boya v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/11/2022

Hasan BOYA 1985 Denizli Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

56635/22

DurmuÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/11/2022

HÃ¼seyin DURMUÅž 1981 Adana Turkish

Ali IÅžIK

153/23

KazanpÄ±nar v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/12/2022

Mesut KAZANPINAR 1976 Denizli Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

1059/23

Yanar v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/12/2022

Kemal YANAR 1966 Samsun Turkish

Tahir EREN

3943/23

Åžirin v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/12/2022

Salih ÅžÄ°RÄ°N 1975 Denizli Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

5048/23

Dolu v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/01/2023

Enes DOLU 1986 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Ramazan IÅžIK

5169/23

KÄ±zÄ±lateÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/12/2022

Cumhur KIZILATEÅž 1974 Antalya Turkish

SÃ¼eda KADIOÄžLU

8930/23

Demirel v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/02/2023

KÃ¼bra DEMÄ°REL 1987 Sinop Turkish

Ekrem KAYA

Menu

YILDIZ v. TÜRKİYE and 199 other applications

YILDIZ v. TÜRKİYE and 199 other applications

LEXI