Lexploria

Published on 18 December 2023

SECOND SECTION

Application no. 32039/21 Hesna GÃ¼lÅŸah SUBAÅžI against TÃ¼rkiye and 199 other applications (see list appended) communicated on 12 December 2023

STATEMENT OF FACTS

1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.

2. The applications mainly concern the applicantsâ€™ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the â€œFetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structureâ€ ( FetullahÃ§Ä± TerÃ¶r Ã–rgÃ¼tÃ¼ / Paralel Devlet YapÄ±lanmasÄ± , hereinafter referred to as â€œthe FETÃ–/PDYâ€), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in TÃ¼rkiye on 15 July 2016.

3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia , on the applicantsâ€™ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application â€œByLockâ€, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÃ–/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÃ–/PDYâ€™s hierarchical structure.

4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, Â§Â§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).

5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya (cited above, Â§Â§ 141-193).

COMPLAINTS

6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÃ–/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 Â§ 1.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, Â§Â§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against TÃ¼rkiye.

APPENDIX

List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 Â§ 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial)

(conviction for membership of the FETÃ–/PDY based, inter alia , on the applicantsâ€™ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application â€œByLockâ€ )

No.

Application no.

Case name

Lodged on

Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality

Represented by

32039/21

SubaÅŸÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/06/2021

Hesna GÃ¼lÅŸah SUBAÅžI 1987 Istanbul Turkish

Ã–mer SUBAÅžI

51731/19

Ã–zdemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/09/2019

Ali Ã–ZDEMÄ°R 1962 Kayseri Turkish

61481/19

Takyan v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/11/2019

Mustafa TAKYAN 1992 NiÄŸde Turkish

2153/20

Ã–ztÃ¼rk v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/12/2019

SÃ¼leyman Ã–ZTÃœRK 1973 Adana Turkish

3532/20

Kaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/12/2019

Basri KAYA 1964 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

9528/20

Bedur v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/12/2019

Serhan BEDUR 1986 Burdur Turkish

10706/20

Cenik v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/02/2020

HÃ¼seyin CENÄ°K 1993 Giresun Turkish

13692/20

YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/03/2020

Faruk YILDIRIM 1984 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

15518/20

Karaca v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/02/2020

Ä°brahim KARACA 1976 Ã‡orum Turkish

15663/20

GÃ¼l v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/03/2020

Abdullah GÃœL 1985 Trabzon Turkish

16540/20

SaÄŸÄ±roÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/03/2020

Åžaban SAÄžIROÄžLU 1973 Kayseri Turkish

16595/20

ÃœzÃ¼mcÃ¼ v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/03/2020

HÃ¼seyin ÃœZÃœMCÃœ 1984 AydÄ±n Turkish

16597/20

GÃ¼rÃ¼ltÃ¼ v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/03/2020

Selim GÃœRÃœLTÃœ 1992 Gaziantep Turkish

16976/20

Akar v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/03/2020

CoÅŸkun AKAR 1983 Adana Turkish

Selim YILMAZ

17375/20

Ã‡etin v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/04/2020

Ã–zer Ã‡ETÄ°N 1981 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

17973/20

YiÄŸit v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/04/2020

Åžener YÄ°ÄžÄ°T 1987 Ä°zmir Turkish

Umut YILMAZ

18477/20

Tolu v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/04/2020

YÄ±lmaz TOLU 1984 Gaziantep Turkish

Ã–mer YÃœZGEÃ‡

20869/20

Adiyeke v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/05/2020

Ãœmran ADÄ°YEKE 1992 Siirt Turkish

Mehmet SATICI

21204/20

AtÄ±cÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/05/2020

Nuh Ekrem ATICI 1983 Kastamonu Turkish

Ä°nan UZUN

25691/20

Ä°nan v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/06/2020

Ä°brahim Ä°NAN 1986 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Sevim YILDIZ Ä°NAN

25710/20

TaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/06/2020

Mustafa TAÅž Ä°zmir Turkish

Hasan Ali TAN

25720/20

DoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/06/2020

Ã‡ETÄ°N DOÄžAN 1975 Kayseri Turkish

Hasan Ali TAN

27262/20

Akdemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/06/2020

Halil AKDEMÄ°R 1977 Ä°zmir Turkish

Abdi YAÅžAR

29910/20

TikiÃ§oÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/06/2020

BetÃ¼l TÄ°KÄ°Ã‡OÄžLU 1983 Gebze Turkish

Emin TELLÄ°OÄžLU

30664/20

GÃ¶khasan v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/07/2020

Ãœmit GÃ–KHASAN 1974 Istanbul Turkish

Naim UZUN

36517/20

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/08/2020

Mikail YILMAZ 1988 Kocaeli Turkish

Rukiye YILMAZ

38911/20

Arman v. TÃ¼rkiye

31/08/2020

Abdi ARMAN 1983 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Hamd ZONTUR

39920/20

Akay v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/09/2020

Hayrettin AKAY 1964 Ã‡anakkale Turkish

Eslem Feyza YAPRAK

40758/20

EfeakdoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/08/2020

Mehmet Ali EFEAKDOÄžAN 1992 Turkish

Necati TAÅž

43451/20

SÃ¶yler v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/09/2020

Murat Cem SÃ–YLER 1974 Ä°stanbul Turkish

Eslem Feyza YAPRAK

43607/20

GÃ¼leÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/09/2020

RÄ±dvan GÃœLEÃ‡ 1989 AÄŸrÄ± Turkish

Celal ZUNGULDAK

44516/20

AltÄ±ntaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/10/2020

Emin ALTINTAÅž 1993 Denizli Turkish

Hatice TELLÄ°

45774/20

TaÅŸdemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/09/2020

HÃ¼seyin TAÅžDEMÄ°R 1984 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

BÃ¼ÅŸra TAÅžDEMÄ°R

45972/20

Ãœyer v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/09/2020

Mesut ÃœYER 1986 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Yasemin ÃœYER

47660/20

Obudan v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/10/2020

Melike OBUDAN 1990 Osmaniye Turkish

SÃ¼leyman HÃ¼seyin YILMAZ

49203/20

Tuna v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/09/2020

Mustafa TUNA 1972 Osmaniye Turkish

AslÄ± TEKÅžAHÄ°N

49539/20

EroÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/10/2020

Ali EROÄžLU 1977 Manisa Turkish

Veli TOPUZ

50072/20

Uzun v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/11/2020

Hasan UZUN 1977 Kastamonu Turkish

ZÃ¼mrÃ¼t ÅžAHÄ°N

50111/20

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/10/2020

Ferhat DEMÄ°R 1978 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

51220/20

Bulut v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/10/2020

Ã–mer BULUT 1986 Erzurum Turkish

Muhammed YILDIRIM

52069/20

Can v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/11/2020

Ramazan CAN 1974 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

52462/20

DaÄŸdaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/11/2020

Åževket DAÄžDAÅž 1961 Konya Turkish

ZÃ¼mrÃ¼t ÅžAHÄ°N

53148/20

Kahya v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/11/2020

Veysel KAHYA 1970 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Bilal ÅžAÅžMAZ

53923/20

AyÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/11/2020

Eren AYIK 1974 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

AslÄ± TEKÅžAHÄ°N

54338/20

Ã–zcimbit v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/12/2020

Ã–mer Ã–ZCÄ°MBÄ°T 1985 Kirikkale Turkish

Tunahan SANDALLI

54647/20

YÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/11/2020

Ramazan YILDIZ 1981 MuÄŸla Turkish

Ä°brahim Halil TANGÃ–R

55016/20

Toka v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/11/2020

ErdinÃ§ TOKA 1971 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Zeynep TOKA

55098/20

AÅŸkÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/11/2020

Mehmet AÅžKIN 1986 Malatya Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

55103/20

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/11/2020

Ã–mer DEMÄ°R 1975 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

3808/21

Kuzucu v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/12/2020

TarÄ±k KUZUCU 1984 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Meryem YAÅžAR KARAYAZGAN

6919/21

Uysal v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/01/2021

Osman UYSAL 1970 Manisa Turkish

Cemil Ãœneys UYSAL

7433/21

Karaca v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/01/2021

Ä°lyas KARACA 1978 ÅžanlÄ±urfa Turkish

Sakip YAÅžAR

9442/21

Aktik v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/01/2021

Cem AKTÄ°K 1974 GÃ¼mÃ¼ÅŸhane Turkish

BÃ¼lent YÃœMÄ°N

9674/21

Erbay v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/01/2021

Mehmet ERBAY 1986 Manisa Turkish

Arife YÃœKSEKDAÄž ALTUNAY

10504/21

YalÄ±m v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/02/2021

Murat YALIM 1973 Kayseri Turkish

Sueda YILMAZ

10553/21

Ergin v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/02/2021

Ä°sa ERGÄ°N 1986 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

15304/21

Uzun v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/03/2021

Selahattin UZUN 1986 Malatya Turkish

Ä°brahim Halil UZUN

17369/21

SarÄ±gÃ¼l v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/03/2021

Adem SARIGÃœL 1974 Erzincan Turkish

BÃ¼lent YÃœMÄ°N

17410/21

Aktepe v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/03/2021

Mustafa AKTEPE 1993 Erzurum Turkish

Celal ZUNGULDAK

18214/21

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/03/2021

Ebubekir YILMAZ 1986 AydÄ±n Turkish

Buket YILMAZ

19729/21

YILDIRIM v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/04/2021

Ä°brahim HakkÄ± YILDIRIM 1987 Antalya Turkish

Hanife YILDIRIM

21183/21

Karaca v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/04/2021

PÄ±nar AyÅŸe KARACA 1994 Erzurum Turkish

Muhammed YILDIRIM

22495/21

YurttaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/04/2021

Abdulkerim YURTTAÅž 1975 Erzincan Turkish

BÃ¼lent YÃœMÄ°N

24961/21

Aktosun v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/04/2021

Murat Can AKTOSUN 1991 Bursa Turkish

Mustafa SAÄžSÃ–Z

26066/21

Ä°lhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/05/2021

Mustafa Ä°LHAN 1985 Manisa Turkish

GÃ¼lsÃ¼m YÄ°ÄžÄ°T Ã–Z

27318/21

Yener v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/04/2021

Osman Nuri YENER 1992 Ardahan Turkish

27355/21

Ã–zbay v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/05/2021

Fatih Ã–ZBAY 1975 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Meliha GÃ¼lsÃ¼m ÅžAHÄ°N SOYTÃœRK

27614/21

Sert v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/05/2021

Metin SERT 1986 Mersin Turkish

27763/21

TÃ¼zÃ¼n v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/05/2021

MevlÃ¼t TÃœZÃœN 1988 Balikesir Turkish

28475/21

Yavuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/05/2021

Mehmet YAVUZ 1976 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

28535/21

Avci v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/05/2021

Sami AVCÄ° 1986 Turkish

Naim UZUN

28611/21

ErdoÄŸmuÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/05/2021

HÃ¼seyin ERDOÄžMUÅž 1975 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

28696/21

Ã‡etinkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/06/2021

Emrah Ã‡ETÄ°NKAYA 1992 Istanbul Turkish

28718/21

YaÄŸmahan v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/05/2021

Ä°dris YAÄžMAHAN 1992 Baman Turkish

28777/21

KÄ±rmacÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/05/2021

Emre KIRMACI 1986 Erzurum Turkish

28876/21

DayÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/05/2021

Mehmet DAYIK 1970 Isparta Turkish

29026/21

YÄ±lmaztÃ¼rk v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/05/2021

Hakan YILMAZTÃœRK 1976 Manisa Turkish

29278/21

ErdoÄŸdu v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/06/2021

Ahmet ERDOÄžDU 1982 EskiÅŸehir Turkish

Ersoy YÃœKSEL

29436/21

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/05/2021

Cihangir AYDIN 1986 Adana Turkish

29498/21

Åžeker v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/05/2021

Kemal ÅžEKER 1974 Rize Turkish

29511/21

Ä°sanÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/05/2021

Ahmet Turan Ä°SANÃ‡ 1976 Sivas Turkish

BÃ¼lent YÃœMÄ°N

29911/21

Tecirli v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/05/2021

Necip TECÄ°RLÄ° 1977 Kahramanmaras Turkish

30369/21

Åžirin v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/05/2021

Serdar ÅžÄ°RÄ°N 1984 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Figen YILDIZ

30383/21

ErdoÄŸdu v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/06/2021

Nazire ERDOÄžDU 1986 Ä°zmir Turkish

Ersoy YÃœKSEL

30392/21

YalÃ§Ä±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/05/2021

Mustafa Onur YALÃ‡IN 1980 Kocaeli Turkish

30393/21

Ece v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/05/2021

Mustafa ECE 1990 Isparta Turkish

30465/21

Kesmeci v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/05/2021

Veli KESMECÄ° 1989 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

30575/21

YazÄ±cÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/05/2021

Selamet YAZICI 1971 Konya Turkish

30658/21

KoÃ§er v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/06/2021

Metin KOÃ‡ER 1977 Tokat Turkish

31101/21

Kenan v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/05/2021

Osman KENAN 1977 Trabzon Turkish

Nagihan KENAN

33209/21

YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/06/2021

Mehmet YILDIRIM 1975 NiÄŸde Turkish

Okan YILDIRIM

34752/21

Turgut v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/06/2021

Recep TURGUT 1974 KÄ±rÄ±kkale Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

35375/21

Gonca v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/06/2021

Ä°brahim GONCA 1988 Istanbul Turkish

Muhammed YILDIRIM

35757/21

VehapoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/07/2021

Halil Ä°brahim VEHAPOÄžLU 1988 Samsun Turkish

Ä°nan UZUN

36092/21

Tozlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/06/2021

Mustafa Ali TOZLU 1975 Manisa Turkish

Arife YÃœKSEKDAÄž ALTUNAY

36727/21

AÃ§Ä±kel v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/07/2021

Hakan AÃ‡IKEL 1977 Ankara Turkish

Demet YÃœREKLÄ°

KAYAALP

38770/21

DaÄŸdelen v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/07/2021

Mehmet DAÄžDELEN 1974 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Hamdi YAKUT

39275/21

KeleÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/07/2021

Hulusi KELEÅž 1986 Mersin Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

40447/21

YeÅŸil v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/08/2021

Pakize YEÅžÄ°L 1974 Antalya Turkish

NurgÃ¼l YAYMAN YILMAZ

40725/21

Ã‡etin v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/08/2021

Ä°brahim Ã‡ETÄ°N 1991 Manisa Turkish

Arife YÃœKSEKDAÄž ALTUNAY

41176/21

YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/07/2021

Faruk YILDIRIM 1987 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Fikri YILDIRIM

42569/21

UranlÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/08/2021

Onur URANLI 1984 Samsun Turkish

Muhammed YILDIRIM

45888/21

YILMAZ v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/09/2021

Fettah YILMAZ 1986 Manisa Turkish

Arife YÃœKSEKDAÄž ALTUNAY

46544/21

KoÃ§doÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/09/2021

DoÄŸukan KOÃ‡DOÄžAN 1990 Istanbul Turkish

Ã–mer YILDIRIM

47394/21

GÃ¼ven v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/09/2021

UÄŸur Muharrem GÃœVEN 1986 Bilecek Turkish

Nurullah YILDIRIM

47490/21

Åžahin v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/09/2021

Yusuf ÅžAHÄ°N 1975 Istanbul Turkish

Huzeyfe YILDIZ

48379/21

Ã‡alÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/09/2021

NazÄ±m Ã‡ALIK 1982 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Yavuz YILDIZ

48442/21

Ã–z v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/09/2021

Cihan Ã–Z 1984 Gaziantep Turkish

Ã–mer YÃœZGEÃ‡

49442/21

YanÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/09/2021

Onur YANIK 1991 Izmir Turkish

SÃ¼leyman ÅžAHÄ°N

50149/21

Erciyes v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/10/2021

Halil ERCÄ°YES 1988 Erzurum Turkish

Muhammed YILDIRIM

51087/21

BozkuÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/10/2021

Salih BOZKUÅž 1977 Manisa Turkish

Arife YÃœKSEKDAÄž ALTUNAY

51870/21

TaÅŸkÄ±r v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/10/2021

Ali TAÅžKIR 1982 Hatay Turkish

GÃ¼lsÃ¼m Sena YAR

52270/21

Uzun v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/10/2021

Ali UZUN 1995 Antalya Turkish

Åžahbanu ÅžAHÄ°N

52285/21

Kaygusuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/10/2021

Mustafa KAYGUSUZ 1974 Sivas Turkish

Naim UZUN

53022/21

KÃ¶klÃ¼ v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/10/2021

Soner KÃ–KLÃœ 1977 Giresun Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

53183/21

ErbaÄŸcÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/10/2021

Selim ERBAÄžCI 1981 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

53321/21

Kaynak v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/10/2021

Ä°lter KAYNAK 1971 KÄ±rÄ±kkale Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

56965/21

Tekten v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/11/2021

Alper TEKTEN 1982 Istanbul Turkish

Naim UZUN

59413/21

KaragÃ¶z v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/12/2021

Burak KARAGÃ–Z 1992 Bursa Turkish

Mustafa YELBEY

59515/21

Erciyas v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/11/2021

Furkan Enes ERCÄ°YAS 1985 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Figen ÅžAHÄ°N

59577/21

Selek v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/11/2021

GÃ¼l SELEK 1984 Ä°zmir Turkish

Abdi YAÅžAR

694/22

Uzunaslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/12/2021

Ahmet UZUNASLAN 1970 Gaziantep Turkish

Havva UZUNASLAN DEMÄ°R

3424/22

NalÃ§acÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/01/2022

Orhan NALÃ‡ACI 1985 Ã‡orum Turkish

Mustafa YELBEY

4323/22

Ã‡elik v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/01/2022

Kamil Ã‡ELÄ°K 1969 Kocaeli Turkish

Ä°brahÄ±m Halil YILDIZ

6591/22

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/01/2022

Esra AYDIN 1987 Kayseri Turkish

Safiye YILMAZ

6791/22

KÄ±zÄ±lgÃ¼l v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/01/2022

Bekir KIZILGÃœL 1978 Ankara Turkish

GÃ¼lhis YÃ–RÃœK

6926/22

Kalyoncu v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/12/2021

Kudret KALYONCU 1976 Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

7164/22

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/12/2021

Halil Ä°brahim YILMAZ 1975 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

8786/22

Bayram v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/02/2022

Åžerif Ahmet BAYRAM 1966 Samsun Turkish

NilgÃ¼n ÅžAHÄ°N POYRAZ

9327/22

DÃ¼zyol v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/01/2022

Veysel DÃœZYOL 1991 Ä°zmir Turkish

Abdi YAÅžAR

9878/22

ErgÃ¼n v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/02/2022

Abdurrahman ERGÃœN 1974 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

10609/22

YÃ¼ce v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/02/2022

Cengiz YÃœCE 1984 Adana Turkish

Selhan SAÄžIRER

11967/22

Aksoy v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/02/2022

Murat AKSOY 1971 Samsun Turkish

NilgÃ¼n ÅžAHÄ°N POYRAZ

14065/22

GÃ¼l v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/03/2022

Beytullah GÃœL 1988 Manisa Turkish

TuÄŸÃ§e Fatma YILDIZ

16578/22

KaraÃ§il v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/03/2022

Naciye Hilal KARAÃ‡Ä°L 1979 Ã‡orum Turkish

Ãœmit YaÅŸar YILMAZ

16665/22

Aksoy v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/03/2022

Hamdi AKSOY 1971 Denizli Turkish

Muhammed Berat YOLCU

16691/22

AvcÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/03/2022

Zeliha AVCI 1992 Manisa Turkish

EyyÃ¼p SAÄžIR

16895/22

Karol v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/03/2022

Ramazan KAROL 1983 Manisa Turkish

BetÃ¼l Nur YÃœKSEL

17839/22

TiraÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/04/2022

Murat TÄ°RAÅž 1965 Ä°zmir Turkish

Abdullah Erkam TAMER

17960/22

Ã‡iÃ§ek v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/03/2022

MÃ¼slÃ¼m Ã‡Ä°Ã‡EK 1975 Istanbul Turkish

Hacer ÅžAHÄ°N

18081/22

Erdem v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/04/2022

Ahmet Turan ERDEM 1987 Sivas Turkish

Åžeyma YÃœRÃœK

19749/22

TÃ¼rkoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/04/2022

ÅžÃ¼kran TÃœRKOÄžLU 1983 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Mustafa YELBEY

20157/22

YILMAZ v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/04/2022

Ahmet YILMAZ 1990 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Nurullah YILDIRIM

20694/22

Akkoca v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/04/2022

Veysel AKKOCA 1971 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Åžeyho SAYA

21581/22

Ayan v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/04/2022

Ã–zer AYAN 1978 Trabzon Turkish

Yavuz YILDIZ

21627/22

BozatlÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/04/2022

CoÅŸkun BOZATLI 1985 Manisa Turkish

Mustafa YELBEY

21796/22

Ergat v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/04/2022

Maksut ERGAT 1974 Ä°zmir Turkish

EyyÃ¼p SAÄžIR

22146/22

KÃ¶ksal v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/04/2022

Serhat KÃ–KSAL 1996 Ankara Turkish

Adnan ZEYBEK

25130/22

SavaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/05/2022

Esma SAVAÅž 1986 Gaziantep Turkish

Meryem YAÅžAR KARAYAZGAN

25870/22

KoÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2022

YaÅŸar KOÃ‡ 1974 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

25883/22

Karaman v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2022

Mustafa KARAMAN 1975 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

25889/22

ErdoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2022

Aysun ERDOÄžAN 1978 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

26334/22

Yavuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2022

Zeynep YAVUZ 1989 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

26341/22

Ã–zcan v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2022

Naci Ã–ZCAN 1974 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

28791/22

Turan v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/05/2022

Gizem TURAN 1993 Bursa Turkish

Mustafa YELBEY

29639/22

Temel v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/05/2022

Muhammed Zeki TEMEL 1978 Hessen Turkish

Fatih TOPAL

32242/22

GenÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/06/2022

Nuri GENÃ‡ 1986 Bursa Turkish

Mustafa YELBEY

32304/22

YeÅŸil v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/06/2022

Zehra YEÅžÄ°L 1991 AydÄ±n Turkish

Meliha GÃ¼lsÃ¼m ÅžAHÄ°N SOYTÃœRK

35440/22

Vural v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/07/2022

Mehmet Erdem VURAL 1991 Istanbul Turkish

Hamza Senih VURAL

37525/22

TÃ¼rk v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/07/2022

Murat TÃœRK 1985 KÄ±rÄ±kkale Turkish

NurgÃ¼l YAYMAN YILMAZ

39518/22

KoÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/07/2022

Ali KOÃ‡ 1979 Bursa Turkish

Tufan YILMAZ

39562/22

Arslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/08/2022

Enes ARSLAN 1988 Ã‡anakkale Turkish

Nurullah YILDIRIM

40675/22

Bulut v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/07/2022

Cafer BULUT 1972 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Fatma YILMAZ

41605/22

Obuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/08/2022

Yunus Emre OBUZ 1992 Ã‡anakkale Turkish

Murat YILMAZ

41889/22

TanrÄ±kulu v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/08/2022

Saim TANRIKULU 1974 Istanbul Turkish

Dilara YILMAZ

41948/22

Bora v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/08/2022

Ahmet BORA 1979 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Mustafa YELBEY

41989/22

TokgÃ¶z v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/08/2022

Hasan TOKGÃ–Z Istanbul Turkish

Muhammet Ä°mran YAVUZ

42436/22

Ercan v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/08/2022

Ali ERCAN 1986 Turkish

Samet YILMAZ

42547/22

BoÅŸcu v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/08/2022

MÃ¼berra BOÅžCU 1986 Ä°stanbul Turkish

Naim UZUN

43026/22

YalÃ§Ä±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/08/2022

Mustafa YALÃ‡IN 1970 Ã‡anakkale Turkish

Raziye YALÃ‡IN

43181/22

Ãœlger v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/08/2022

Fatih ÃœLGER 1984 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Fatma YILMAZ

43777/22

Karaca v. TÃ¼rkiye

31/08/2022

Kemal KARACA 1974 Artvin Turkish

Safiye YILMAZ

44611/22

Kilar v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/09/2022

SelÃ§uk KÄ°LAR 1990 Ä°zmir Turkish

EyyÃ¼p SAÄžIR

45912/22

Ã‡etin v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/09/2022

SÃ¼leyman Ã‡ETÄ°N 1988 Bilecik Turkish

Nurullah YILDIRIM

46043/22

KÃ¼Ã§Ã¼kyÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/09/2022

Ali KÃœÃ‡ÃœKYILDIZ 1971 Tokat Turkish

Hasan YILMAZ

46483/22

Altay v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/09/2022

Ali ALTAY 1979 Bilecik Turkish

Nurullah YILDIRIM

47038/22

SarÄ±aydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/09/2022

Ekrem SARIAYDIN 1992 Istanbul Turkish

Cemal ÅžAHÄ°N

48042/22

BeÅŸbaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/09/2022

Mustafa BEÅžBAÅž 1973 Erzincan Turkish

BÃ¼lent YÃœMÄ°N

48239/22

Uzun v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/10/2022

Davut UZUN 1992 Istanbul Turkish

Figen UZUN

48802/22

TanyaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/10/2022

Levent TANYAÅž 1975 Turkish

Adem UZAK

49106/22

YaÄŸÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/10/2022

Reha YAÄžIZ 1986 Ankara Turkish

Ali YILDIZ

50314/22

Ä°nci v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/10/2022

Ä°brahim Ä°NCÄ° 1973 Istanbul Turkish

Elmas YUNUS

50437/22

GÃ¼ndÃ¼z v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/10/2022

Fatih GÃœNDÃœZ 1988 AÄŸrÄ± Turkish

Hilal TuÄŸÃ§e ÅžAHÄ°N

51110/22

Ã–zmen v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/10/2022

MÃ¼nevver Ã–ZMEN 1979 Antalya Turkish

Zaliha VARLI

51398/22

Turgut v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/10/2022

Yunus TURGUT 1989 Istanbul Turkish

NurgÃ¼l YAYMAN YILMAZ

52003/22

Atik v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/11/2022

YILMAZ ATÄ°K 1981 Ä°zmit Turkish

Ä°brahim Halil UZUN

52302/22

Aslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/11/2022

Alaattin ASLAN 1983 Antalya Turkish

Zaliha VARLI

52528/22

Artun v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/10/2022

Ramazan ARTUN 1973 Kocaeli Turkish

Murat YILMAZ

53421/22

Derinkuyu v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/11/2022

Mustafa DERÄ°NKUYU 1986 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Fatma YILMAZ

54356/22

Altan v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/11/2022

Akif ALTAN 1974 Bilecik Turkish

Nurullah YILDIRIM

54955/22

VelioÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/11/2022

Selahattin VELÄ°OÄžLU 1993 Trabzon Turkish

Abdullah VELÄ°OÄžLU

54958/22

AkyazÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/11/2022

SÃ¼meyye AKYAZI 1985 Turkish

Naim UZUN

54961/22

Turan v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/11/2022

HÃ¼seyin AlptuÄŸ TURAN 1982 Trabzon Turkish

55403/22

Caymaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/11/2022

Mehmet Orbay CAYMAZ 1987 Turkish

EyyÃ¼p SAÄžIR

57500/22

Vural v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/12/2022

Murat VURAL 1978 Kayseri Turkish

Selim YILMAZ

195/23

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/12/2022

Ã–mÃ¼r Zehra YILMAZ 1987 Malatya Turkish

Ä°rfan YILMAZ

289/23

Uluhatun v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/12/2022

Yunus ULUHATUN 1992 Bursa Turkish

Figen UZUN

2452/23

GÃ¼neÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/12/2022

Ahmet YaÅŸar GÃœNEÅž 1977 Bilecik Turkish

Nurullah YILDIRIM

4518/23

Kara v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/01/2023

Abdulkadir KARA 1970 Malatya Turkish

Ali YÃœCEL

8453/23

DanÄ±ÅŸmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/02/2023

Ramazan DANIÅžMAZ 1972 Samsun Turkish

Ä°nan UZUN

Menu

SUBAŞI v. TÜRKİYE and 199 other applications

SUBAŞI v. TÜRKİYE and 199 other applications

LEXI