Lexploria

Published on 18 December 2023

SECOND SECTION

Application no. 31954/21 Nuri BERBER against TÃ¼rkiye and 199 other applications (see list appended) communicated on 12 December 2023

STATEMENT OF FACTS

1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.

2. The applications mainly concern the applicantsâ€™ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the â€œFetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structureâ€ ( FetullahÃ§Ä± TerÃ¶r Ã–rgÃ¼tÃ¼ / Paralel Devlet YapÄ±lanmasÄ± , hereinafter referred to as â€œthe FETÃ–/PDYâ€), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in TÃ¼rkiye on 15 July 2016.

3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia , on the applicantsâ€™ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application â€œByLockâ€, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÃ–/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÃ–/PDYâ€™s hierarchical structure.

4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, Â§Â§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).

5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya (cited above, Â§Â§ 141-193).

COMPLAINTS

6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÃ–/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 Â§ 1.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, Â§Â§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in YÃ¼ksel YalÃ§Ä±nkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against TÃ¼rkiye.

APPENDIX

List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 Â§ 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial)

(conviction for membership of the FETÃ–/PDY based, inter alia , on the applicantsâ€™ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application â€œByLockâ€ )

No.

Application no.

Case name

Lodged on

Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality

Represented by

31954/21

Berber v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/06/2021

Nuri BERBER 1984 UÅŸak Turkish

MÃ¼leyke Ã‡EVÄ°K

53509/19

Turan v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/09/2019

Mustafa TURAN 1984 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Adnan DEMÄ°R

60688/19

KadÄ±oÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/11/2019

Ä°smail KADIOÄžLU 1979 Giresun Turkish

Elif CÄ°VELEKOÄžLU

911/20

KaradaÄŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/12/2019

Ahmet KARADAÄž 1975 Edirne Turkish

AyÅŸegÃ¼l BEDELCÄ° KARADAÄž

1595/20

Demirhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/12/2019

Metin DEMÄ°RHAN 1976 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

MÃ¼nise DEMÄ°RHAN

8383/20

KarabaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/02/2020

Muhittin KARABAÅž 1982 AdÄ±yaman Turkish

Murat CENGÄ°Z

14901/20

KayasaroÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/03/2020

Ãœmit KAYASAROÄžLU 1987 Ankara Turkish

Neda BUYRUKÃ‡U

15189/20

GÃ¼venÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/03/2020

Onur GÃœVENÃ‡ 1995 Tokat Turkish

Nuriye Beyza BÄ°LGEN GÃœÃ‡

19842/20

AldÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/05/2020

Bahtiyar ALDI 1983 AydÄ±n Turkish

HakkÄ± Ã‡ELÄ°K

21508/20

BulmuÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/03/2020

HacÄ± Mehmet BULMUÅž 1975 Kayseri Turkish

Ã–mer DELÄ°GEZER

21832/20

Ã–zen v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/05/2020

Ä°brahim Ã–ZEN 1983 AÄŸrÄ± Turkish

Timur DEMÄ°R

22218/20

Tetik v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/05/2020

Åžinasi Sedat TETÄ°K 1976 Ankara Turkish

Burak Ã‡OLAK

23433/20

BÃ¼yÃ¼kÃ§akÄ±r v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/05/2020

Mustafa BÃœYÃœKÃ‡AKIR 1962 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Fatih BÃœYÃœKÃ‡AKIR

23934/20

Berk v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/06/2020

HacÄ± Hakan BERK 1968 Malatya Turkish

Tuna BERK

25553/20

TaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/06/2020

Seyfi Ali TAÅž 1978 NiÄŸde Turkish

Yasin Ã‡ALIM

25577/20

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/06/2020

Sait YILMAZ 1981 Kocaeli Turkish

Cahit Ã‡Ä°FTÃ‡Ä°

28067/20

Demirci v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/06/2020

Ä°brahim DEMÄ°RCÄ° 1980 KÄ±rÅŸehir Turkish

Rukiye COÅžGUN

30528/20

Benli v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/06/2020

Esat Faruk BENLÄ° 1970 Konya Turkish

HÃ¼lya BENLÄ°

32506/20

TopaloÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/07/2020

Mahmut TOPALOÄžLU 1979 Kocaeli Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

32701/20

Yulcu v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/07/2020

Cesim YULCU 1991 Patnos Turkish

M. Sani BÄ°NGÃ–LBALLI

34065/20

Durak v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/08/2020

Turan DURAK 1986 KahramamaraÅŸ Turkish

Murat CENGÄ°Z

35839/20

Ã‡in v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/07/2020

Murat Ã‡Ä°N 1979 Burdur Turkish

AyÅŸe Ã‡Ä°N

36249/20

Toprak v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/08/2020

Recep TOPRAK 1975 MuÄŸla Turkish

Sinan DAÄž

38114/20

Akkavak v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/08/2020

Hasan HÃ¼seyin AKKAVAK 1986 Erzincan Turkish

Sezai DEMÄ°RBÄ°LEK

41163/20

Kalkan v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/09/2020

Ä°smail KALKAN 1958 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

RÄ±dvan Ã‡AKIR

41238/20

Mercan v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/07/2020

Bayram Ali MERCAN 1988 Adana Turkish

SelÃ§uk Ã‡IÄžÅžAR

41355/20

Karabacak v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/08/2020

Ali Osman KARABACAK 1981 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Nuriye Beyza BÄ°LGEN GÃœÃ‡

42342/20

Ã‡etinbaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/09/2020

Ã–mer Ã‡ETÄ°NBAÅž 1992 Denizli Turkish

Hanifi BAYRI

42766/20

CinbaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/09/2020

Emel CÄ°NBAÅž 1965 Isparta Turkish

HÃ¼meyra Refia CÄ°NBAÅž

43101/20

GÃ¶kce v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/09/2020

Hasan GÃ–KCE 1973 Ä°zmir Turkish

Halil Ã‡ETÄ°N

43140/20

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/08/2020

Enes DEMÄ°R 1992 Ä°zmir Turkish

Metin DEMÄ°R

43516/20

Bayram v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/09/2020

Hamza BAYRAM 1985 ÅžanlÄ±urfa Turkish

Aysel BAYRAM

47233/20

Erdem v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/10/2020

Bayram ERDEM 1971 Malatya Turkish

Nalan ERDEM

49577/20

Kesgin v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/10/2020

Ä°zzet KESGÄ°N 1968 Manisa Turkish

Adem BEDÄ°R

49581/20

Medeni v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/10/2020

ErdoÄŸan MEDENÄ° 1986 Ã‡anakkale Turkish

Adnan ERDOÄžAN

51525/20

TerkeÅŸli v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/11/2020

Ramazan TERKEÅžLÄ° 1973 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

51919/20

Ä°nci v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/11/2020

Muhammed Fethullah Ä°NCÄ° 1997 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Nuriye Beyza BÄ°LGEN GÃœÃ‡

52188/20

AkdoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/11/2020

Mehmet Emin AKDOÄžAN 1981 AÄŸrÄ± Turkish

Arzu BEYAZIT

54375/20

Minareci v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/11/2020

Yusuf MÄ°NARECÄ° 1967 UÅŸak Turkish

Ahmet Emre CEYLAN

54385/20

Yavuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/11/2020

Safa YAVUZ 1973 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

55132/20

SÃ¶ylemez v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/11/2020

Ahmet SÃ–YLEMEZ 1972 Karaman Turkish

Cihat Ã‡ITIR

1126/21

DiÅŸÃ§i v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/12/2020

Ä°brahim DÄ°ÅžÃ‡Ä° 1960 UÅŸak Turkish

Yasemin MÃ¼ÅŸerref BOZKURT

2979/21

Cengiz v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/01/2021

Ferhat CENGÄ°Z 1977 Sinop Turkish

TuÄŸba CENGÄ°Z

3274/21

Evirgen v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/01/2021

Mehmet Ã‡etin EVÄ°RGEN 1986 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

RÄ±dvan Ã‡AKIR

3727/21

Demirci v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/12/2020

EyÃ¼p DEMÄ°RCÄ° 1977 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Ahmet Ã‡OBANOÄžLU

4660/21

Arslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/01/2021

Mehmet ARSLAN 1971 Malatya Turkish

Ä°zettin DEMÄ°R

4675/21

Kara v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/01/2021

Ali KARA 1988 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Ä°zettin DEMÄ°R

5181/21

KalaycÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/01/2021

Mustafa KALAYCI 1983 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

RÄ±dvan Ã‡AKIR

5204/21

YÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/01/2021

Volkan YILDIZ 1991 Turkish

DoÄŸan BEKÄ°ROÄžLU

6663/21

Ã‡eÃ§en v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/01/2021

Hamdi Ã‡EÃ‡EN 1970 NiÄŸde Turkish

Adem Ã‡EÃ‡EN

6681/21

Ã–rkÃ¼t v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/01/2021

HÃ¼seyin Ã–RKÃœT 1973 Manisa Turkish

Rukiye COÅžGUN

6978/21

Ã‡Ä±nar v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/01/2021

GÃ¶khan Ã‡INAR 1990 AydÄ±n Turkish

Ali Ã‡INAR

7782/21

KesmenoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/01/2021

Mustafa KESMENOÄžLU 1987 Kilis Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

8682/21

BiÃ§er v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/01/2021

Muammer BÄ°Ã‡ER 1975 Ä°zmir Turkish

CiÄŸdem BÄ°Ã‡ER

8735/21

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/01/2021

Ali RÄ±za YILMAZ 1973 Kocaeli Turkish

Cahit Ã‡Ä°FTÃ‡Ä°

8750/21

Ã–ztÃ¼rk v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/02/2021

Fatih Ã–ZTÃœRK 1983 Yozgat Turkish

Fatih Nadi DOÄžAN

9770/21

BÄ±Ã§akcÄ±gil v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/02/2021

SÃ¼meyye Saadet BIÃ‡AKCIGÄ°L 1994 Sivas Turkish

Mualla ERCAN

10453/21

Fidan v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/02/2021

Åžaban FÄ°DAN 1993 Van Turkish

Ramazan DUMAN

11080/21

Arslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/02/2021

Bekir ARSLAN 1987 Osmaniye Turkish

Hanifi BAYRI

11615/21

ÅžanlÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/02/2021

HÃ¼snÃ¼ ÅžANLI 1983 Istanbul Turkish

Sadrettin DEMÄ°REL

12088/21

Duysak v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/12/2020

RaÅŸit DUYSAK 1962 Manisa Turkish

Hatice DUYSAK

12121/21

ÅžerifoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/02/2021

Yusuf ÅžERÄ°FOÄžLU 1977 Kayseri Turkish

GÃ¶kmen DÃ–NER

13753/21

Tekin v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/02/2021

Fatih TEKÄ°N 1987 Van Turkish

Ä°dris ERÃ‡ETÄ°N

14028/21

YalÃ§Ä±nkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/02/2021

Ã‡elebi Batuhan YALÃ‡INKAYA 1985 Giresun Turkish

Elif CÄ°VELEKOÄžLU

14506/21

Eraslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/03/2021

ZÃ¼lfÃ¼ ERASLAN 1985 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Hesna ERASLAN

14970/21

DaÄŸhan v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/01/2021

RÄ±za DAÄžHAN 1989 Van Turkish

Ä°dris ERÃ‡ETÄ°N

16355/21

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/03/2021

Mustafa AYDIN 1971 Ä°zmir Turkish

Adnan ERDOÄžAN

16380/21

Aksu v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/03/2021

Ä°brahim AKSU 1979 Samsun Turkish

Ahmet Ã‡AVUÅž

16416/21

UÄŸurlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/03/2021

Burak UÄžURLU 1985 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Hacer Perihan DEMÄ°REL

16624/21

Timur v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/03/2021

Orhan TÄ°MUR 1984 Adana Turkish

Ä°zzettin Ã‡Ä°Ã‡EK

17609/21

AkkaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/03/2021

Musa Fatih AKKAÅž 1989 Aksaray Turkish

Fatih DÃ–NMEZ

18258/21

KuluÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

18/03/2021

YÄ±lmaz KULUÃ‡ 1979 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Sinan DAÄž

18617/21

Ã‡iftÃ§i v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/03/2021

Mesut Ã‡Ä°FTÃ‡Ä° 1987 Aksaray Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

18967/21

Ã‡elik v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/04/2021

Ekrem Ã‡ELÄ°K 1991 ÅžÄ±rnak Turkish

Gizay DULKADÄ°R

19173/21

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/04/2021

Muhammet DEMÄ°R 1985 Konya Turkish

Mustafa DEMÄ°RCAN

19326/21

Åžireli v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/04/2021

Mehmet Cihad ÅžÄ°RELÄ° 1974 Adana Turkish

BÃ¼ÅŸra DÄ°NÃ‡ER

20847/21

Ekici v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/04/2021

Nihat EKÄ°CÄ° 1973 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

20928/21

AteÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/04/2021

Mehmet Sait ATEÅž 1982 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

21686/21

Akbulut v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/04/2021

Yunus Emre AKBULUT 1993 Samsun Turkish

Nur EfÅŸan Ã‡Ä°L

21973/21

AygÃ¶ren v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/04/2021

Burak Åžahin AYGÃ–REN 1985 Istanbul Turkish

Abdullah DOÄžAN

22387/21

Karabacak v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/04/2021

Nabi KARABACAK 1963 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

22430/21

Ã‡albÄ±yÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/04/2021

Halil Ä°brahim Ã‡ALBIYIK 1988 Ã‡orum Turkish

RÃ¼meysa DENÄ°Z

22520/21

SarÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2021

Leyla SARI 1983 Erzurum Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

22649/21

SarÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

22/04/2021

Siracettin SARI 1982 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

23862/21

Ã‡evik v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/04/2021

Muhammed Said Ã‡EVÄ°K 1993 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

24500/21

Ã‡evik v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/05/2021

Ayten Ã‡EVÄ°K 1978 Istanbul Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

24537/21

ArpacÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/04/2021

Necmi ARPACI 1974 Ordu Turkish

ÅžÃ¼kran ER ÅžAHÄ°N

24622/21

BaloÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/05/2021

Remziye BALOÄžLU 1978 Ä°zmit Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

25488/21

Benli v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/04/2021

Hasan BENLÄ° 1973 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

25774/21

AltÄ±kat v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/05/2021

Ebubekir ALTIKAT Ankara Turkish

Hanifi BAYRI

26049/21

KocaaÄŸa v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/05/2021

HÃ¼seyin KOCAAÄžA 1980 Antalya Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

28215/21

Ã–zdemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/05/2021

Mahmut Ã–ZDEMÄ°R 1986 Ankara Turkish

Burhan DEMÄ°RCÄ°

29632/21

Bilal v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/05/2021

Ä°smail BÄ°LAL 1983 Manisa Turkish

Ã–znur BÄ°LAL

29991/21

Åžahin v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/06/2021

Ferdi ÅžAHÄ°N 1988 Istanbul Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

30097/21

Ceylan v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/06/2021

Mehmet CEYLAN 1975 ÅžanlÄ±urfa Turkish

GÃ¼lten CEYLAN

30645/21

Miran v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/05/2021

Celal MÄ°RAN 1986 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

30656/21

KÄ±rÄ±cÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/06/2021

Kevser KIRICI 1991 Kilis Turkish

Harun Ã‡OKGÃœNGÃ–R

31597/21

GenÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/06/2021

Serkan GENÃ‡ 1977 Manisa Turkish

OÄŸuzhan DAÅžDEMÄ°R

31738/21

Emer v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/06/2021

Sezer EMER 1986 Istanbul Turkish

GÃ¶kÃ§en DEMÄ°RHAN ALPAÄžUT

33536/21

BilgiÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/06/2021

HÃ¼seyin BÄ°LGÄ°Ã‡ 1974 Isparta Turkish

Serpil BÄ°LGÄ°Ã‡

34125/21

ErgÃ¼neÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/05/2021

RÃ¼ÅŸtÃ¼ Harun ERGÃœNEÅž 1977 Ä°zmir Turkish

Zeynep CANBELDEK YURTÃ‡Ä°Ã‡EK

36716/21

Akdeniz v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/07/2021

Mahmut AKDENÄ°Z 1978 Osmaniye Turkish

CoÅŸkun Ã‡aÄŸlar DURAN

37009/21

KoÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

14/07/2021

Ãœmit KOÃ‡ 1971 Manisa Turkish

Remzi DEMÄ°RKOL

37400/21

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/07/2021

Sabri YILMAZ 1974 Erzurum Turkish

Merve DOÄžAN

37989/21

GÃ¶kÃ§en v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/07/2021

SÃ¼meyra GÃ–KÃ‡EN 1993 Ä°zmir Turkish

Veysel Ã‡ELÄ°K

40398/21

Dural v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/08/2021

Ali DURAL 1979 Konya Turkish

Sefanur BOZGÃ–Z

40821/21

Bayraktar v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/08/2021

Hasan BAYRAKTAR 1987 Denizli Turkish

Fatma Nur BAYRAKTAR

42462/21

GÃ¶nen v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/08/2021

Yusuf GÃ–NEN 1989 Kayseri Turkish

Ã–mer DELÄ°GEZER

42606/21

BiÃ§er v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/08/2021

Yakup BÄ°Ã‡ER 1987 Antalya Turkish

Muhammet DEMÄ°REL

43799/21

Deli v. TÃ¼rkiye

31/08/2021

Adem DELÄ° 1985 Istanbul Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

44064/21

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/08/2021

Ä°brahim AYDIN 1975 Kocaeli Turkish

Cahit Ã‡Ä°FTÃ‡Ä°

50027/21

GÃ¼neÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/10/2021

Mustafa GÃœNEÅž 1977 Isparta Turkish

TarÄ±k Ã‡AÄžLAYAN

50178/21

SÃ¼mer v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/10/2021

Adem SÃœMER 1986 Ankara Turkish

Gizay DULKADÄ°R

50649/21

Kurak v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/09/2021

NurevÅŸan KURAK 1994 Malatya Turkish

GÃ¼lsÃ¼m EKÄ°NCÄ°

51706/21

Yavuz v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/10/2021

Bayram YAVUZ 1981 Bursa Turkish

Mehmet CEBECÄ°

51800/21

Demiralay v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/10/2021

Mehmet DEMÄ°RALAY 1980 Isparta Turkish

Atilla ELMA

52155/21

Aksu v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/10/2021

SÃ¼leyman AKSU 1978 Kayseri Turkish

Lalenur Ã‡ELÄ°K

52393/21

KÄ±zÄ±l v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/10/2021

Ercan KIZIL 1978 Ankara Turkish

Naciye Refia Ã‡OKER

53906/21

AlgÃ¼l v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/11/2021

Cengiz ALGÃœL 1985 BingÃ¶l Turkish

Faruk BEDLEK

54681/21

YÄ±ldÄ±z v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/11/2021

Engin YILDIZ 1983 Istanbul Turkish

Yunus ELMAS

55305/21

PilavlÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/11/2021

DerviÅŸ PÄ°LAVLI 1980 Ankara Turkish

ZÃ¼lfinaz DURSUN

55340/21

ÅžimÅŸek v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/11/2021

Mehmet ÅžÄ°MÅžEK 1979 Istanbul Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

55742/21

Kandemir v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/11/2021

Hakan KANDEMÄ°R 1985 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Muhammed Sabit CAN

57061/21

KaÃ§ire v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/11/2021

Ä°lhan KAÃ‡Ä°RE 1970 DiyarbakÄ±r Turkish

Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAÅžÄ°N

58116/21

KÄ±lÄ±Ã§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/11/2021

Faruk KILIÃ‡ 1971 Ankara Turkish

Regaip DEMÄ°R

58160/21

DinÃ§el v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/11/2021

Muhammed DÄ°NÃ‡EL 1977 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Ã–zlem DÄ°NÃ‡EL

58284/21

YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/11/2021

Ä°lhami YILDIRIM 1972 Istanbul Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

59184/21

Bilgehan v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/11/2021

Recep BÄ°LGEHAN 1964 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Furkan BURHAN

59423/21

Ã–zden v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/11/2021

Faruk Ã–ZDEN 1981 Ankara Turkish

Fatih DÃ–NMEZ

59821/21

Ã–mercikoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/11/2021

Muhammed Sinan Ã–MERCÄ°KOÄžLU 1979 Ordu Turkish

ErÅŸan CANSEVEN

60946/21

Acar v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/12/2021

Ramazan ACAR 1975 Afyonkarahisar Turkish

Abdullah DOÄžAN

1259/22

TanrÄ±Ã¶ver v. TÃ¼rkiye

17/12/2021

Recep TANRIÃ–VER 1990 Istanbul Turkish

KazÄ±m DEMÄ°R

1473/22

DanÄ±ÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/12/2021

Esin DANIÅž 1972 Antalya Turkish

SÃ¼meyra Ã‡ELÄ°K AKINCI

4355/22

Erdem v. TÃ¼rkiye

07/01/2022

Ä°dris ERDEM 1984 Manisa Turkish

BengÃ¼l BERBER

6394/22

Bilgin v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/01/2022

Mehmet Mustafa BÄ°LGÄ°N 1971 Mersin Turkish

Ali Asaf BÄ°LGÄ°N

7028/22

Demirci v. TÃ¼rkiye

30/12/2021

Recep DEMÄ°RCÄ° 1990 Kocaeli Turkish

Burhan DEMÄ°RCÄ°

8199/22

YÄ±lmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

27/01/2022

Ä°rfan YILMAZ 1979 Istanbul Turkish

Ahmet DALDABAN

8630/22

Moran v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/02/2022

Rukiye MORAN 1978 Kayseri Turkish

Burak Ã‡AÄž

8937/22

Demirci v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/02/2022

HakkÄ± DEMÄ°RCÄ° 1971 KarabÃ¼k Turkish

Nihal DEMÄ°RCÄ°

9677/22

Pir v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/02/2022

Recep PÄ°R 1975 Gaziantep Turkish

Zahide BOZKUÅž

11031/22

DaÄŸlarbaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

11/02/2022

Ersin DAÄžLARBAÅž 1969 MuÄŸla Turkish

Nezahat DAÄžLARBAÅž

14126/22

Dikici v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/03/2022

Burhan DÄ°KÄ°CÄ° 1974 Bursa Turkish

Ahmet Can DEMÄ°RCÄ°

14286/22

Akbulut v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/03/2022

Murat AKBULUT 1978 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Muhammed Ã‡APRAK

14790/22

Akcan v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/03/2022

Ä°dris AKCAN 1981 Istanbul Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡AVDAR

14918/22

Ã‡alÄ±ÅŸkan v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/03/2022

Serdar Ã‡ALIÅžKAN 1987 Istanbul Turkish

Burak Ã‡AÄž

15403/22

Baysal v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/03/2022

Ali Ä°hsan BAYSAL 1965 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

YeÅŸim BAYSAL

16607/22

Ãœrek v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/03/2022

Ramazan ÃœREK 1986 Antalya Turkish

Muhammet DEMÄ°REL

16929/22

Akaslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/03/2022

Yasin AKASLAN 1978 KÄ±rÅŸehir Turkish

Muhammet UÄŸur DEMÄ°RKAN

17609/22

Can v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/03/2022

BahadÄ±r CAN 1975 EskiÅŸehir Turkish

Olcay DÃœNDAR

18161/22

Levent v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/04/2022

Ahmet LEVENT 1986 NiÄŸde Turkish

Ersan CANSEVER

18247/22

Ãœveyik v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/03/2022

Zekeriya ÃœVEYÄ°K 1976 NiÄŸde Turkish

Adem Ã‡EÃ‡EN

18861/22

Ã–zkÃ¶klÃ¼ v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/04/2022

Ramazan Ã–ZKÃ–KLÃœ 1980 Kocaeli Turkish

Yasin DANGIR

18897/22

Tezcan v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/04/2022

Ali TEZCAN 1980 Istanbul Turkish

SÃ¼veyda BAYTAK

19850/22

BakÄ±rcÄ± v. TÃ¼rkiye

06/04/2022

Ä°zzet BAKIRCI 1987 Malatya Turkish

Yusuf EKÄ°NCÄ°

20060/22

MadanoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/04/2022

Mehmet MADANOÄžLU 1958 Istanbul Turkish

Salim DÄ°NÃ‡

20943/22

BaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/04/2022

YalÃ§Ä±n BAÅž 1979 Turkish

Ã–zgÃ¼n DÄ°NÃ‡

22536/22

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/04/2022

Mehmet DEMÄ°R 1970 Malatya Turkish

Enes DEMÄ°R

22787/22

Kocaman v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/05/2022

Ã–mer Faruk KOCAMAN 1981 Mersin Turkish

Burhan DEMÄ°RCÄ°

22808/22

Tepe v. TÃ¼rkiye

21/04/2022

Halil TEPE 1984 NevÅŸehir Turkish

Ebru EKÄ°CÄ°

24236/22

AtaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

25/04/2022

Åženel ATAÅž 1985 Kocaeli Turkish

Cahit Ã‡Ä°FTÃ‡Ä°

24877/22

TÃ¶re v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/04/2022

Rahmi TÃ–RE 1976 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Mustafa Selami EKÄ°CÄ°

24940/22

Ãœnal v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/05/2022

Ramazan ÃœNAL 1973 Samsun Turkish

Zeliha DERVÄ°ÅžOÄžLU

25882/22

AytaÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/04/2022

Kaya Mehmet AYTAÅž 1971 Samsun Turkish

Zeliha DERVÄ°ÅžOÄžLU

26862/22

YalÃ§Ä±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

20/05/2022

Rahmetullah YALÃ‡IN 1975 Antalya Turkish

Muhammet DEMÄ°REL

27983/22

GÃ¼ngÃ¶r v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/05/2022

Ferhat GÃœNGÃ–R 1983 Adana Turkish

BÃ¼ÅŸra DÄ°NÃ‡ER

34981/22

Kaynar v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/06/2022

Salih KAYNAR 1974 NevÅŸehir Turkish

Ebru EKÄ°CÄ°

37255/22

Tosuner v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/06/2022

Ebru TOSUNER 1988 Kayseri Turkish

Ã–mer DELÄ°GEZER

37272/22

Ã‡avga v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/06/2022

Semiha Ã‡AVGA 1989 Samsun Turkish

Zeliha DERVÄ°ÅžOÄžLU

40375/22

Tekin v. TÃ¼rkiye

02/08/2022

Muharrem TEKÄ°N 1974 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Refik CaÄŸlar DÄ°LBER

40942/22

AlÄ±ÅŸ v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/07/2022

Ahmet ALIÅž 1977 Samsun Turkish

Zeliha DERVÄ°ÅžOÄžLU

42500/22

Korkmaz v. TÃ¼rkiye

15/08/2022

Adem KORKMAZ 1976 Ordu Turkish

AyÅŸe DURMUÅž

42766/22

AkgÃ¼n v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/08/2022

Murat AKGÃœN 1981 Antalya Turkish

Muhammet DEMÄ°REL

42917/22

DoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

12/08/2022

Melek DOÄžAN 1977 Mersin Turkish

ErÅŸan CANSEVEN

43844/22

Demir v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/08/2022

Engin DEMÄ°R 1975 Konya Turkish

Kevser DEMÄ°R

43980/22

SÃ¶ylemez v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/08/2022

Mahmut SÃ–YLEMEZ 1974 ÅžanlÄ±urfa Turkish

Hacer Perihan DEMÄ°REL

44822/22

AfÅŸar v. TÃ¼rkiye

13/09/2022

Erkan AFÅžAR 1975 Kayseri Turkish

Merve DOÄžAN

45459/22

Maral v. TÃ¼rkiye

09/09/2022

Reyhan MARAL 1993 Istanbul Turkish

AyÅŸe DURMUÅž

46566/22

DangÄ±r v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/09/2022

Yasin DANGIR 1992 Istanbul Turkish

Kadir DANGIR

48187/22

IÅŸÄ±k v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/09/2022

Kenan IÅžIK 1973 Hatay Turkish

Tamer DEMÄ°RCÄ°

48658/22

Ã‡atkaya v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/10/2022

Remzi Ã‡ATKAYA 1985 Kars Turkish

Erol Ã‡ATKAYA

48831/22

Arslan v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/10/2022

Yasemin ARSLAN 1989 Antalya Turkish

Muhammet DEMÄ°REL

49482/22

Åženel v. TÃ¼rkiye

04/10/2022

Niyazi ÅžENEL 1975 Aksaray Turkish

AyÅŸe DURMUÅž

50213/22

Huylu v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/10/2022

Gazi HUYLU 1965 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Merve DOÄžAN

50309/22

GÃ¼rpÄ±nar v. TÃ¼rkiye

19/10/2022

Yakup GÃœRPINAR 1983 Edirne Turkish

Burhan DEMÄ°RCÄ°

51725/22

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

24/10/2022

TarÄ±k AYDIN 1980 ElazÄ±ÄŸ Turkish

Ä°zettin DEMÄ°R

52080/22

KÃ¶ksalan v. TÃ¼rkiye

05/11/2022

Salih KÃ–KSALAN 1980 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Melih DÄ°NÃ‡

52265/22

DÃ¶nmez v. TÃ¼rkiye

26/10/2022

Dilek DÃ–NMEZ 1974 Ä°zmir Turkish

Zeynep BetÃ¼l DÃ–NMEZ

53134/22

Akcan v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/11/2022

Soner AKCAN 1985 KahramanmaraÅŸ Turkish

Mehmet Ã‡ARMAN

53416/22

YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m v. TÃ¼rkiye

01/11/2022

BÃ¼nyamin YILDIRIM 1981 Ankara Turkish

Fatih DÃ–NMEZ

53506/22

DoÄŸan v. TÃ¼rkiye

31/10/2022

Åžerafettin DOÄžAN 1983 Istanbul Turkish

AbdÃ¼lmenaf DOÄžAN

54816/22

YÃ¼zden v. TÃ¼rkiye

16/11/2022

Yusuf YÃœZDEN 1982 Bursa Turkish

Adem DÃœZGÃœN

55079/22

AydÄ±n v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/11/2022

Serdar AYDIN 1982 KÃ¼tahya Turkish

Ahmet Can DEMÄ°RCÄ°

55527/22

Dede v. TÃ¼rkiye

23/11/2022

Burak DEDE 1992 BalÄ±kesir Turkish

Melih DÄ°NÃ‡

57616/22

KoÃ§ v. TÃ¼rkiye

28/11/2022

Mahmut KOÃ‡ 1985 Samsun Turkish

Zeliha DERVÄ°ÅžOÄžLU

2683/23

Ã‡olakoÄŸlu v. TÃ¼rkiye

03/01/2023

Serkan Ã‡OLAKOÄžLU 1992 Kayseri Turkish

Muhammet UÄŸur DEMÄ°RKAN

3200/23

GÃ¼der v. TÃ¼rkiye

29/12/2022

Ä°cri GÃœDER 1974 Sakarya Turkish

Bekir DÃ–NMEZ

12625/23

Uslu v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/02/2023

Hasan USLU 1976 Ankara Turkish

Burhan DEMÄ°RCÄ°

12891/23

GÃ¶kÃ§e v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/03/2023

Cem GÃ–KÃ‡E 1987 Turkish

Gizay DULKADÄ°R

12979/23

GÃ¼rler v. TÃ¼rkiye

08/03/2023

Selami GÃœRLER 1979 KÄ±rÄ±kkale Turkish

ErÅŸan CANSEVEN

21046/23

Gedikci v. TÃ¼rkiye

10/05/2023

SÃ¼leyman GEDÄ°KCÄ° 1976 Konya Turkish

Burhan DEMÄ°RCÄ°

Menu

BERBER v. TÜRKİYE and 199 other applications

BERBER v. TÜRKİYE and 199 other applications

LEXI