FIRST SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 362/18 Zaira RUGGERI against Italy and 171 other applications (see list appended)

The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 29 August 2023 as a Committee composed of:

Péter Paczolay , President , Erik Wennerström, Raffaele Sabato , judges , and Liv Tigerstedt, Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to:

the applications against the Italian Republic lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by the applicants listed in the appended table (“the applicants”), represented by the lawyers and lodged on the various dates indicated therein;

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE

1. The applicants are all doctors or heirs of doctors who attended specialisation training courses between 1991 and 2006. They complained that the authorities had failed to provide them with appropriate remuneration, social security and welfare coverage during their professional training.

2. Under Article 6 of Legislative Decree no. 257 of 8 August 1991, transposing European Council Directive 82/76/EEC of 26 January 1982 amending Directive 75/362/EEC concerning the mutual recognition of diplomas, certificates and other evidence of formal qualifications in medicine, including measures to facilitate effective exercise of the right of establishment and freedom to provide services and Directive 75/363/EEC concerning the coordination of provisions laid down by law, regulation or administrative action in respect of activities of doctors, medical specialists had been receiving scholarships of approximately 11,000 euros (EUR) per year. This amount remained substantially unchanged until 2006.

3. On 17 August 1999 Legislative Decree no. 368 entered into force, transposing European Council Directive 93/16/EEC of 5 April 1993 to facilitate the free movement of doctors and the mutual recognition of their diplomas, certificates and other evidence of formal qualifications, which was intended to consolidate previous directives, including Directive 82/76/EEC, and to introduce a comprehensive reform of doctors’ professional training. The Legislative Decree instituted a specific work training contract and provided for social security and welfare coverage. It also established new criteria for determining the amount of remuneration for medical specialists. However, these provisions were to come into force with the making of a corresponding regulation on budget allocation. This occurred only in 2007, to take effect from the academic year 2006-2007. The applicants therefore did not benefit from the new provisions.

4. The applicants consequently brought an action against the State for the damages caused by the delayed transposition of the directives. They asked, in substance, for the recognition of the higher amount of remuneration and of social security and welfare coverage; an inflation-linked adjustment and the triennial revision. All the actions were deemed unfounded and were dismissed. Actions lodged after 27 October 2009 (or in any case after ten years from the last request for payment) were declared statute-barred.

THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT

5. Having regard to the similar facts and subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to order their joinder (Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court).

6. The applicants complained under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 that they had been deprived of their right to “appropriate remuneration” and to social security and welfare coverage as recognised by Directive 93/16/EEC.

7. References to the right to “appropriate remuneration” for medical specialists were first introduced by Directive 82/76/EEC, transposed by the Italian authorities with Decree no. 257/1991. The Decree granted, as “appropriate remuneration” for medical specialists, the sum of EUR 11,000 per year.

8. Directive 93/16/EEC reproduced the same provision and was transposed by Decree no. 368/1999, which added a regulation for social insurance and pension contributions and provided for a new “training contract”.

9. The Court reiterates that it is not competent to apply EU law or to examine alleged violations of EU rules unless and in so far as they may have infringed rights and freedoms protected by the Convention. It is primarily for the national authorities, notably the courts, to interpret and apply domestic law, if necessary in conformity with EU law, the Court’s role being confined to ascertaining whether the effects of such adjudication are compatible with the Convention ( Jeunesse v. the Netherlands [GC], no. 12738/10, § 110, 3 October 2014). Moreover, in assessing such compatibility, the Court is in principle bound by the presumption of equivalent protection to that provided by the legal system of the EU (see Avotiņš v. Latvia [GC], no. 17502/07, §§ 101-04, 23 May 2016). However, where the measure at issue has been taken in order to give effect to a directive, which is binding on the member States as regards the result to be achieved but leaves it to them to choose the means and manner of achieving it, the Court is called to determine whether the effects of national decisions in a particular case are compatible with the Convention (see Michaud v. France , no. 12323/11, § 113, ECHR 2012), as the presumption of equivalent protection does not apply in view of the margin of manoeuvre available to the national authorities (see O’Sullivan McCarthy Mussel Development Ltd v. Ireland , no. 44460/16, § 112, 7 June 2018).

10. Thus, in the present case, the Court has jurisdiction to examine whether the interference with the applicants’ right to the peaceful enjoyment of their possessions was justified. To this aim, the preliminary question to be answered by the Court is whether the applicants can claim to have had a “right or legitimate expectation” with regard to obtaining higher remuneration and social security and welfare coverage (see Dimici v. Turkey , no. 70133/16, § 75, 5 July 2022; N.M. and Others v. France , no. 66328/14, § 42, 3 February 2022; and Aliyeva and Others v. Azerbaijan , nos. 66249/16 and 6 others, §§ 103-04, 21 September 2021).

11 . As stated by the Court of Justice of the European Union (“the CJEU”), the aforementioned directives do not contain any definition either of the remuneration which is to be regarded as appropriate or of the methods by which that remuneration is to be fixed. Such definitions are in principle a matter for the Member States, which must adopt specific implementing measures in the field. Nevertheless, the CJEU stated that it is for the national court to interpret national law, so far as possible, in the light of the wording and the purpose of the directive concerned in order to achieve the result sought by the directive, in casu , to ensure that the doctors concerned devote all their professional activity to their practical and theoretical training throughout the week, or, in the case of a specialist in part-time training, a significant proportion of it (see, to that effect, judgment of 24 January 2018 in Pantuso and Others , joined cases C-616/16 and C-617/16, EU:C:2018:32, §§ 41-46, with further references; judgment of 25 February 1999 in Carbonari and Others , C-131/97, EU:C:1999:98, § 45; and judgment of 3 October 2000 in Gozza and Others , C-371/97, EU:C:2000:326, § 36).

12. In fulfilment of these powers and obligations, Legislative Decree no. 257/1991 provided for an annual scholarship. The applicants have submitted no allegations or evidence, either in the domestic courts or before the Court, to demonstrate that the amount of the scholarship was not sufficient.

13. That being so, the Court cannot accept the applicants’ argument that the increase provided for in 2007 was an admission by the Italian legislature that the smaller sum previously granted was incompatible with the directives. In fact, the increase was part of a comprehensive discretionary reform involving not only remuneration but also the medical specialists’ legal status (see, mutatis mutandis , Aldeguer Tomás v. Spain , no. 35214/09, § 89, 14 June 2016).

14. The same conclusion can be reached in respect of those applicants who, having attended specialisation training courses between 1999 and 2006, claimed to have acquired a right or at least a legitimate expectation to receive higher remuneration on the basis of Decree no. 368/1999.

15. The Court notes that the remuneration referred to by the applicants had not been established, as the relevant provisions of the Decree only introduced new criteria for determining the amount of remuneration and left it to the government to make specific regulations taking into account various requirements and the availability of funds. Indeed, the Decree made the entry into force of those provisions conditional on the adoption of governmental budgetary measures. The new provisions were not implemented until 2007. In the meantime, Article 46 § 3 of Legislative Decree no. 368/1999 had expressly provided for the continued application of Legislative Decree no. 257/1991.

16. Thus, the provisions referred to by the applicants were not in force at the time of their training. Therefore, the Court concludes that the applicants could not claim any right or legitimate expectation to receive a higher remuneration (see Kopecký v. Slovakia [GC], no. 44912/98, §§ 53-60, ECHR 2004-IX).

17. Regarding the social insurance and pension contributions provided for by the same Decree, the domestic courts clearly held that such measures were not required by the directives and that therefore their enactment, as well as the postponement of their entry into force, fell within the discretion of the legislature (see, among other authorities, the Court of Cassation’s judgments nos. 4449/2018 and 9104/2021).

18. The Court observes that according to its established case-law, rights to an old-age pension or social benefit are not included among the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Convention and the Protocols thereto (see Beeler v. Switzerland [GC], no. 78630/12, § 57, 11 October 2022; Aielli and Others v. Italy (dec.), nos. 27166/18 and 27167/18, § 22, 10 July 2018; and Da Silva Carvalho Rico v. Portugal (dec.), no. 13341/14, § 30, 1 September 2015). In the present case, since, according to the domestic courts, no security and welfare coverage for medical specialists was prescribed by the above-mentioned directives and Article 41 of Decree no. 368/1999 was not in force during the applicants’ specialisation training, the applicants cannot claim to have had a legitimate expectation amounting to a possession under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (contrast Stec and Others v. the United Kingdom (dec.) [GC], nos. 65731/01 and 65900/01, § 54, ECHR 2005 ‑ X).

19. In the light of the above, the Court concludes that these complaints are incompatible ratione materiae with the provisions of the Convention and the Protocols thereto within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 § 4.

20. The applicants argued that their right to appropriate remuneration had also been violated as a consequence of the failure to apply the increase provided for by Article 6 § 1 of Legislative Decree no. 257/1991. Pursuant to that provision, the annual scholarship payable to medical specialists was to be increased annually in line with the inflation rate and recalculated every three years by ministerial decree in accordance with the minimum salary increases established by the collective bargaining processes of the National Health Service’s medical staff.

21 . The provision was only applied in 1992, increasing the applicants’ scholarship in line with the inflation rate. After that, the annual increase was suspended until 2005 by a series of legislative provisions, as was the triennial recalculation. As pointed out by the Constitutional Court, those provisions were intended to safeguard the national budget and the fulfilment of obligations assumed in respect of the European Union in a period of harsh economic crisis (see the Constitutional Court’s judgment no. 432 of 23 December 1997).

22. The Court refers to its principles concerning “austerity measures” taken in response to financial crises and the resulting wide margin of appreciation of Contracting Parties when it comes to general measures of economic or social strategy (see, for example, Aielli and Others , cited above, § 26, and the case-law cited therein). Because of their direct knowledge of their society and its needs, the national authorities are in principle better placed than the international judge to appreciate what is in the public interest on social or economic grounds, and the Court will generally respect the legislature’s policy choice unless it is “manifestly without reasonable foundation” (see Stec and Others , cited above, § 52).

23 . The Court firstly notes that the measures challenged were taken to offset the consequences of an economic crisis: hence, the authorities had acted with the public interest in mind. In fact, the above-mentioned provisions were part of a much wider programme involving the whole public sector which affected not only the applicants but public servants more generally. Moreover, the applicants did not suffer any direct reduction of their income as they were only denied an expected increase. There is no allegation or evidence in the present applications that the measures taken left the applicants devoid of all means of subsistence, nor did they argue that they risked falling below the subsistence threshold (see Fábián v. Hungary [GC], no. 78117/13, § 82, 5 September 2017). Hence, the measures cannot be deemed disproportionate (see, mutatis mutandis , Savickas and Others v. Lithuania (dec.), no. 66365/09 and others, §§ 92-93, 15 October 2013).

24. In the light of the above, the Court concludes that this complaint is manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.

25. Having been subjected to harsher pay conditions and having been denied social security benefits which their colleagues who enrolled from the academic year 2006/2007 onwards had been granted, the applicants alleged that they had been discriminated against, in breach of Article 14 taken in conjunction with Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.

26. The Court has already stated that the use of a cut-off date is an inevitable consequence of introducing new regulations to replace previous schemes. Thus, bearing in mind the margin of appreciation afforded to States in this sphere and considering that the benefits granted to medical specialists by 2007 were part of a comprehensive reform aimed at improving the training system as well as rationalising public expenditure in this field, the cut-off date can be deemed reasonably and objectively justified (see Maggio and Others v. Italy , nos. 46286/09 and 4 others, 31 May 2011). In creating a scheme of benefits, it is sometimes necessary to use cut-off points that apply to large groups of individuals, and which may to a certain extent appear arbitrary. However, this is an inevitable consequence of introducing new systems which replace previous and outdated schemes (see Twizell v. the United Kingdom , no. 25379/02, § 24, 20 May 2008). There can be no “discrimination” contrary to the Convention in such a case. The applicants’ complaint, resulting in substance in a claim for retrospective application of the reform of 2006, must therefore be rejected as manifestly ill-founded in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4.

27. Relying on Article 6 of the Convention, the applicants complained that the Court of Cassation had unexpectedly overruled its own well ‑ established case-law on the interpretation of Article 6 of Legislative Decree no. 257/1991, which provided for the triennial recalculation of the amount of the scholarship.

28 . While it is true that, in four decisions cited by the applicants (nos. 16385/2008, 18562/2010, 12624/2015 and 12595/2017), the Court of Cassation had granted a triennial recalculation for the period between 1994 and 2002, that interpretation was overruled in 2018 (see the Court of Cassation’s judgment no. 4449/2018) and consequently abandoned (see judgments nos. 13572/2019, 8378/2020, 8506/2020, 9191/2020, 17913/2020, 17995/2020 and 9104/2021), when the Court of Cassation stated that the recalculation had previously been suspended until 2006 by a series of pre-existing statutory provisions which had been overlooked in its previous four judgments. The new interpretation was aimed at bringing the case-law into line with the existing legal framework.

29. The Court’s assessment, in cases of case-law development, has always been based on the principle that a departure from a well-established jurisprudence is not, in itself, contrary to the proper administration of justice since a failure to maintain a dynamic and evolutive approach would risk rendering it a bar to reform or improvement ( Atanasovski v. the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia , no. 36815/03, § 38, 14 January 2010).

30 . Moreover, the requirements of legal certainty and the maintenance of public confidence do not confer a right to consistency in case-law (see Unédic v. France , no. 20153/04, § 74, 18 December 2008). Case-law development is not, in itself, contrary to the proper administration of justice since a failure to maintain a dynamic and evolutive approach would risk hindering reform or improvement (see Lupeni Greek Catholic Parish and Others v. Romania [GC], no. 76943/11, § 116, 29 November 2016, and Albu and Others v. Romania , nos. 34796/09 and 63 others, § 34, 10 May 2012).

31. The Court has held that the existence of well-established case-law imposes a duty on the Supreme Court to make a more substantial statement of reasons to justify a departure from its own case-law ( Atanasovski , cited above, § 38). In the present case, the Court of Cassation emphasised that the overruling complained about was necessary in order to bring the case-law into line with pre-existing statutory provisions which had been partially overlooked in its previous decisions. The Court notes that these statutory provisions were clear in excluding the triennial recalculation for the period covering the applicants’ professional training. It also reiterates, as pointed out by the Court of Cassation, that the statutory provisions were part of a wider exercise aimed at safeguarding the national budget in a period of economic crisis.

32. From an analysis of the judgments cited by the applicants (see paragraph 28 above) it emerges that, while it is true that the Court of Cassation reversed its previous case-law concerning substantive rights, the new interpretation was immediately adopted in the judgments that followed, without any conflicting positions being taken. It follows that no persistent inconsistencies arose in the treatment of applicants’ claims but only a departure from previous case-law (see, contrary, Lupeni Greek Catholic Parish and Others , §§ 124-28).

33. Moreover, the Court also reiterates that it is not its function to deal with errors of fact or law allegedly committed by a national court unless and in so far as they may have infringed rights and freedoms protected by the Convention (see García Ruiz v. Spain [GC], no. 30544/96, § 28, ECHR 1999‑I). Likewise, it is not its function, save in the event of evident arbitrariness, to compare different decisions of national courts, even if they were given in apparently similar proceedings, as the independence of those courts must be respected (see Stanković and Trajković v. Serbia , nos. 37194/08 and 37260/08, § 40, 22 December 2015). In the present case, the Court observes that the applicants had the benefit of adversarial proceedings in which they were able to adduce evidence and freely formulate their defence and in which their arguments were properly examined by the courts. Likewise, the courts’ conclusions and their interpretation of the relevant law cannot be regarded as manifestly arbitrary or unreasonable. Accordingly, the Court finds that there has been no appearance of a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and that this complaint is manifestly ill ‑ founded.

34. The applicants, whose domestic complaints had been declared statute ‑ barred because they had been lodged after 27 October 2009, challenged these domestic decisions. They submitted that the limitation period had not been foreseeable because of the inconsistencies in the domestic case-law on the matter and that, in any case, there should have been no limitation since the relevant directive had never been correctly transposed.

35. The Court notes that, after a period of uncertainty and conflicting decisions on the applicable limitation period and its starting date, the Court of Cassation in judgment no. 10813 of 17 May 2011 set the limitation period at ten years and held that time should run from 27 October 1999, that is, the date of entry into force of section 11 of Law no. 370/1999. The Court of Cassation, referring to, among other things, the CJEU’s case-law, emphasised that from that moment on it should have been clear to the applicants that the Italian authorities would not take any further steps to implement Directive 93/16/EEC of 5 April 1993.

36. The Court reiterates that statutory limitation constitutes one of the legitimate restrictions on the right of access to a court as it serves several important purposes. By ensuring legal certainty and finality and contributing to public confidence in the courts, it constitutes one of the fundamental aspects of the rule of law (see, for example, Lupeni Greek Catholic Parish and Others , cited above, § 116).

37 . While it is true that before the Court of Cassation’s judgment there was uncertainty about the limitation period, it must be emphasised that a mere conflict of case-law is not sufficient in itself to constitute a violation of Article 6 of the Convention (see paragraph 30 above). Divergences may be tolerated when the domestic legal system is capable of remedying a conflict in its case-law, as in the present case.

38. In this connection, the Court firstly observes that the Court of Cassation took careful account of the applicants’ interests, granting them the longest limitation period, ten years, available in domestic law.

39. Furthermore, it did not hold that time should run from the first transposition of Directive 82/76/EEC into domestic law in 1991, as accepted in some previous decisions and as appeared possible in the light of the CJEU’s case-law (see judgment of the grand chamber of 24 March 2009 in Danske Slagterier , C-445/06, EU:C:2009:178, § 56). Instead, the Court of Cassation decided that time should run from the last legislative intervention aimed at reforming the system.

40. In conclusion, the Court finds that there has been no appearance of a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and that this complaint is manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) of the Convention.

41 . The Court notes that the applicants’ remaining complaints either do not meet the admissibility criteria set out in Articles 34 and 35 of the Convention or do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms enshrined in the Convention or the Protocols thereto.

42. It follows that this part of the applications must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 § 4 of the Convention.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides to join the applications;

Declares the applications inadmissible.

Done in English and notified in writing on 21 September 2023.

Liv Tigerstedt Péter Paczolay Deputy Registrar President

APPENDIX

No.

Application no.

Case name

Lodged on

Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality

Represented by

1.

362/18

Ruggeri

v. Italy

22/12/2017

Zaira RUGGERI 1976 Messina Italian

Alessia GIORGIANNI

2.

39696/18

Attanasio and Others v. Italy

14/08/2018

Silvia ATTANASIO 1978 Novara Italian Roberto BERRI 1976 Novara Italian Cristina BIAMINO 1978 Cuggiono Italian Chiara BORRACCINO 1977 Trecate Italian Francesca BRUCCULERI 1976 Rosignano Monferrato Italian Luigi Mario CASTELLO 1974 Ivrea Italian Laura COLLIMEDAGLIA 1979 Novara Italian Elisa CORNETTI 1979 Vespolate Italian Cristina DE BERNARDI 1976 Turbigo Italian Daniela DI FLURI 1975 Pregnana Milanese Italian Ignazio DIVENUTO 1972 Novara Italian Stefania ESPOSITO 1976 Domodossola Italian Sara FESTARI 1977 Marano Ticino Italian Alessia FRANCINI 1976 Biella Italian Cristina GALLI 1975 Marano Ticino Italian

Roberta GILODI 1974 Novara Italian Luca GRILLENZONI 1977 Biella Italian Jenny GUALINO 1976 Grignasco Italian Sandro GUGLIELMETTI 1976 Novara Italian Alessandro LITTERA 1979 Marano Ticino Italian Francesca LOMBARDI 1976 Acquaviva delle Fonti Italian Marta LOVISOLO 1975 Nebbiuno Italian Nicola MASIELLO 1963 Lecce Italian Francesco MURGANTE 1973 Oleggio Italian Claudia MUSCAS 1976 Galliate Italian Elisa Angela OLDANI 1977 Bareggio Italian Alessandra PAGGIORO 1977 Biella Italian Mariella PANCARI 1976 Oleggio Italian Roberta Zaira PEDRAZZOLI 1978 Oleggio Italian Massimiliano PINO 1974 Novara Italian Elis PRANDO 1975 Viverone Italian Anna Michela Antonia PUPPI 1972 Turate Italian Rachele RAPETTI 1975 Invorio Italian Monica REGGIANI 1977 Rivalta di Torino Italian Pier Paolo SAINAGHI 1977 Novara Italian Elizabeth SALVADOR 1976 Cavaglià Italian Marco SALVATORES 1975 Saint-Christophe Italian Elena SALVITI 1974 Corbetta Italian Silvia SANTOCONO 1979 Santhià Italian Katia SAVIO 1980 Alice Castello Italian Chiara SAVIOLO 1979 Torino Italian Fausto TARANTO 1977 Novara Italian Nadir TONELLO 1976 Biella Italian Cristina TONNA 1978 Borgomanero Italian Grazia Maria TOTA 1977 Milan Italian Elena VERCELLOTTI 1976 Novara Italian Davide VOLPE 1977 Salerno Italian Nicola VOLPE 1977 Salerno Italian Elisa ZAVATTARO 1974 Novara Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

3.

57679/19

Cuccu

v. Italy

29/10/2019

Annalisa CUCCU 1978 Italian

Giovanni GRANARA

4.

61251/19

Amici and Others

v. Italy

08/11/2019

Francesca AMICI 1973 Ronciglione Italian Natascia BOVENGA 1970 Rome Italian Novella BUSCEMI 1974 Rome Italian Rossella CATANIA 1967 Castrovillari Italian Renzo CIARDINI 1974 Rome Italian Riccardo CIATTI 1974 Rome Italian Maria Pia GIORNO 1977 Rome Italian Mario GRASSO 1969 Rome Italian Claudia LUCCHINI 1974 Rome Italian Susanna PETRUCCI 1973 Aosta Italian Linda QUARESIMA 1974 Terracina Italian Angela SPOSATO 1976 Rome Italian Francesca TONI 1978 Rome Italian Teresa VALERIO 1974 Rome Italian

Chiara BUSCEMI

5.

65245/19

Lucisano and Others v. Italy

10/12/2019

Alessia LUCISANO 1974 Rome Italian Federico ACCROCCA 1974 Rome Italian Andrea CELLIE 1969 Rome Italian Manuela Rita CORONA 1971 Rome Italian

Chiara BUSCEMI

6.

3663/20

Amendola and Others v. Italy

13/12/2019

Angela AMENDOLA 1969 Rome Italian Carolina ANDREONI 1978 Rome Italian Ludovica ARGNANI 1977 Rome Italian Federico AUGELLO 1974 Nettuno Italian Ursula BASILE 1977 Marino Italian Antonio BERTINO 1977 Rome Italian Alessia BIANCAFARINA 1977 Arezzo Italian Giulio BIOVI 1964 Rome Italian Alessandro BRACCIONI 1970 Rome Italian Katia BRESSAN 1973 Rome Italian Claudio CAGGIANO 1980 Rome Italian Elisabetta CALABRESE 1979 Rome Italian Cesare CALDERINI 1976 Rome Italian Alessandro CALISTRI 1977 Rome Italian Salvatore CANDIOLI 1972 Rome Italian Myriam CAPPUCCI 1975 Rome Italian Roberto CAPPUCCIO 1980 Rome Italian Claudia CARDELLA 1975 Rome Italian Martina CARNEVALINI 1976 Rome Italian Teodorico CASALE 1963 Santi Cosma e Damiano Italian Diletta CASSINI 1977 Rome Italian Carolina CAUCHI 1974 Anzio Italian Mario CAVACECE 1978 Rome Italian Chiara CAVALLOTTI 1980 Rome Italian Michela CELESTRE 1978 Velletri Italian Maria CERA 1976 Rome Italian Manuela CIARROCCA 1975 L’Aquila Italian Elena CICERONE 1972 Borgorose Italian Marika CIPROTTI 1978 Genazzano Italian Elena COCUZZI 1976 Valsinni Italian Linda COCUZZI 1978 Rome Italian Antonella COMETA 1974 Porano Italian Sonja CONDORELLI 1974 Acireale Italian Emanuela CORAZZESI 1972 Rome Italian Serena CORSETTI 1979 Rome Italian Maria Rosaria D’APRILE 1974 Rome Italian Luca DE CARLO 1978 Rome Italian Gian Paolo DE FRANCESCO 1976 Porano Italian Francesca DE MATTEO 1972 Rome Italian Antonella DE SANTIS 1974 Rome Italian Claudia DI BARTOLOMEO 1978 Rome Italian Maria Chiara DI LAURO 1975 Rome Italian Fulvio Pasquale D’OSTUNI 1972 Vidigulfo Italian Maria Agnese FABBRI 1980 Rome Italian Federico FACCENNA 1975 Rome Italian Francesca FATTORE 1976 Rome Italian Edy FEBI 1980 Rome Italian Francesca FERRI 1976 Rome Italian Erica FINOLEZZI 1976 Rome Italian Veronica FIORI 1977 Ciampino Italian Annarita FORCIONE 1978 Rome Italian Nicola FOTI 1974 Rome Italian Immacolata Tiziana FRANZESE 1975 Rome Italian Serena GARGANO 1974 Rome Italian Alessandra GASBARRONE 1974 Terracina Italian Donatello GEMMA 1974 Rome Italian Laura GIACINTI 1976 Marino Italian Antonio GIARDINA 1972 Potenza Italian Raffaella GIGLI 1976 Terni Italian Simona GIGLIO 1968 Rome Italian Francesca GIGLIOTTI 1977 Rome Italian Maria Cristina GIUSTINIANI 1974 Rome Italian Roberta GRANDE 1978 Frosinone Italian Francesco GRECO 1974 Rome Italian Franco IAFRATE 1976 Rome Italian Michela IOSUE 1974 Rome Italian Mauro LA PIETRA 1972 Rome Italian Valentina LA TORRE 1977 Paris Italian Antonella LAURITO 1975 Monteforte Italian Loredana LEJEUNE 1960 Montecompatri Italian Rosaria LICITRA 1980 Rome Italian Marco LIVERANI 1978 Lisbon Italian Errica LOMBARDOZZI 1972 Rome Italian Giuseppe LONGO 1970 Rome Italian Alessandra LUSI 1977 Rome Italian Andrea MACEO 1976 Bologna Italian Emanuela MAGNOLFI 1972 Sora Italian Maria Grazia MANCINO 1976 Riardo Italian Annarita MANIGRASSO 1971 Rome Italian Alberto MASCELLI 1963 Rome Italian Valeria MAZZARINO 1978 Loano Italian Francesco MELARAGNI 1978 Viterbo Italian Andrea MELE 1975 Rome Italian Anna MELLINI 1974 Pisa Italian Mariella MONTANO 1976 Arizzano Italian Monica MUCCIARONE 1977 Sessano del Monte Italian Michele NACLERIO 1976 Milan Italian Bich Lien NGUYEN 1978 Rome Italian Mafalda ORLANDO 1969 Rome Italian Viviana PADELLA 1966 Rome Italian Simona PADULA 1977 Formello Italian Micaela PAGLIARI 1975 Trento Italian Sara PARLANTI 1977 Rome Italian Giuseppe PASIMENI 1973 Rome Italian Virginia PASSERI 1978 Tivoli Italian Emanuela PICCIRILLI 1977 Fiumicino Italian Benedetta PIMPINELLA 1967 Santi Cosma e Damiano Italian Chiara PONTIROLI 1978 Frascati Italian Daniele PORCELLI 1977 Rome Italian Stefano PRO 1974 Frosinone Italian Emanuela PROIETTI 1978 Vimercate Italian Yuri Massimo PUCE 1977 Rome Italian Alberto REBONATO 1978 Perugia Italian Silvia REMEDIANI 1970 Macerata Italian Katia RIPAMONTI 1972 Rome Italian Antonella ROSELLI 1977 Rome Italian Stefano ROSI 1977 Rome Italian Cristina SANTORO 1974 Rome Italian Maria SANTORO 1978 Rome Italian Serena SAPUTO 1980 Palermo Italian Raffaela SCARNICCHIA 1977 Cori Italian Francesco SCICCHITANO 1979 Lamezia Terme Italian Simona SECHI 1973 Rome Italian Margherita SEMINARA 1978 Rome Italian Domenico SERGI 1979 Rome Italian Caterina SIMON 1977 Milan Italian Mauro SIMONE 1978 Rome Italian Gian Paolo SPINELLI 1975 Rome Italian Simona STELLATO 1978 San Fili Italian Manuela TARDIOLA 1972 Trento Italian Francesca TASSI 1971 Palombara Sabina Italian Federica TOMEI 1978 Supino Italian Gabriella TOMEI 1978 Supino Italian Manuela TOMMASIELLO 1976 Rome Italian Giovanni TORINO 1973 Rome Italian Chiara TOZZI 1978 Fiano Romano Italian Simona TRENNA 1976 Rome Italian Stefano VALENTE 1978 Rome Italian Veronica VALLE 1972 San Felice Circeo Italian Tiziana VAVALÀ 1980 Rome Italian Giuditta VIOLA 1978 Marino Italian Andrea VITALI 1975 Rome Italian Paolo FABIANO 1974 Rome Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

7.

5954/20

Gurgone

v. Italy

16/01/2020

Antonino GURGONE 1980 Milan Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

8.

5976/20

Alkabes

v. Italy

16/01/2020

Micol Ester ALKABES 1979 Milan Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

9.

5978/20

Bertazzi

v. Italy

16/01/2020

Laura BERTAZZI 1978 Nago Torbole Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

10.

6039/20

Baccaro and Others

v. Italy

23/01/2020

Sante Alessandro BACCARO 1974 Bisceglie Italian Cecilia BEZZI 1975 Rome Italian Sabino BONADUCE 1964 Valenzano Italian Rita CADONI 1972 Quartu Sant’Elena Italian Giovanni CALTAVUTURO 1971 Siena Italian Giuseppe CANCELLO 1976 Milan Italian Rodolfo CANGIANO 1976 Capua Italian Stefano CAPOBIANCO 1977 Ponte Italian Giuseppe CAPONETTO 1974 Catania Italian Barbara CARAU 1971 Iglesias Italian Vincenzo CAROTENUTO 1975 San Giovanni Rotondo Italian Barbara CASU 1971 Cagliari Italian Tanina CATALDO 1971 Ragusa Italian Armida Alida CIORRA 1974 Latina Italian Anna Lisa CONTI 1970 Nuoro Italian Germano CORONELLA 1973 Casal di Principe Italian Angela CURCIO 1966 Naples Italian Roberto D’ELIA 1964 Rome Italian Rosa DAMBROSIO 1964 Sannicandro di Bari Italian Antonella DE CAPRARIS 1976 Foggia Italian Gaetano DE LUCA 1965 Casole Bruzio Italian Anna DE PASQUALE 1970 Parma Italian Paolo DEMAIO 1974 Modica Italian Valeria DEVIRGILIIS 1976 Rome Italian Paola DI GIOVANNI 1975 Mazara del Vallo Italian Raffaele DI MICHELE 1974 San Giovanni Rotondo Italian Teresa DI PALMA 1976 Latina Italian Ornella BLANCA 1967 Enna Italian Olimpia DIFRUSCOLO 1973 Bari Italian Gianluigi DI STASIO 1968 Santa Maria Capua Vetere Italian Pierina ENA 1968 Olbia Italian Sabrina FARACI 1968 Licata Italian Anna Maria FERRARO 1967 Rome Italian Francesco FERRIGNO 1975 Angri Italian Laura FRANCESE 1975 Ruvo di Puglia Italian Daria FUNARO 1973 Rome Italian Serena GENNARO 1977 Parma Italian Maria GERRATANA 1974 Cuneo Italian Giorgio GIANNATTASIO 1979 Cham Italian Marina IBBA 1968 Quartu Sant’Elena Italian Urania Elisabetta LAGRASTA 1970 Cervaro Italian Stefania LANZA 1967 Guidonia Italian Simona LEDDA 1972 Settimo San Pietro Italian Paolo RAIMONDO 1976 Portici Italian Elisabetta RISTORI 1974 Rome Italian Giuseppe ROSANO 1976 Grenoble Italian Raffaele RULLO 1974 Rome Italian Samantha SANNICANDRO 1973 Bari Italian Luca SEGRETI 1977 Vecchiano Italian Tania SEVERI 1969 Fara in Sabina Italian Domenico SFORZA 1973 Bari Italian Giuseppe SGARITO 1974 Palermo Italian Francesca SILVI 1971 Genazzano Italian Emilia MONTAGNA 1977 Milan Italian Vincenzo PANASITI 1975 Rome Italian Sergio Concetto PARISI 1969 Nizza di Sicilia Italian Rosa PERROTTA 1963 Rome Italian Monica PETROSINO 1974 Fisciano Italian Giada PIETROSI 1974 Palermo Italian Raffaella PINTO 1976 Rome Italian Fabio PIZZARDI CASELLA 1975 Vittoria Italian Daniela Maria POZZI 1974 Italian Alessandro Francesco PULVIRENTI 1972 Giarre Italian Gabriella LICITRA 1974 Pisa Italian Alessandro LISTRANI 1972 Milan Italian Vincenzo LOTESORIERE 1969 Mesagne Italian Francesco LUPIDI 1976 Viterbo Italian Stanislao MANGIATORDI 1965 Terlizzi Italian Paola MARRAS 1964 Sardara Italian Nunzia MASCIALE 1900 San Giovanni Rotondo Italian Laura MELONI 1973 Sassari Italian Giuseppe MENNEA 1972 Barletta Italian Agostino MESSINA 1975 Viagrande Italian Manuela SOMMANTICO 1971 Portici Italian Angelo SPINAZZOLA 1973 Castelleone Italian Alessandra TARTAGLIONE 1972 Rocca Priora Italian Fiammetta TODI 1976 Rome Italian Vittoria VACCARI 1970 Colleferro Italian Agostino VEGA 1964 Pomezia Italian Patrizio VICINI 1975 Grottaferrata Italian Francesca ZULLINO 1968 Lecce Italian

Carlo RIENZI

11.

11405/20

Fazzio and Giobbe

v. Italy

21/02/2020

Marta FAZZIO 1974 Rome Italian Monica GIOBBE 1975 Rome Italian

Chiara BUSCEMI

12.

26819/20

Berardi

v. Italy

29/06/2020

Stefano BERARDI 1972 Campobasso Italian

Ennio CERIO

13.

30601/20

Bocci

v. Italy

14/07/2020

Chiara BOCCI 1971 Orbetello Italian

14.

33255/20

Agai and Others

v. Italy

30/07/2020

Jerin AGAI 1973 Bressanone Italian Monica MAFFEI 1963 Bologna Italian Raffaella ALBARELLO 1978 Bologna Italian Vincenzo ALLEGRI 1975 Bologna Italian Cristina AMADINI 1961 Bologna Italian Valentina AMBROSINI 1979 Bologna Italian Barbara AMORE 1973 Rimini Italian Lucia ANGELONI 1972 Bologna Italian Valentina Angela ANTONUCCI 1977 Bologna Italian Alessandro ARMARO 1981 Palermo Italian Giorgia ARNONE 1975 Bologna Italian Maria ASTORINO 1977 Grosseto Italian Filippo BABACCI 1976 Forlì Italian Chiara BAIAMONTE 1972 Ferrara Italian Barbara BENDANDI 1975 Imola Italian Alessandra BERNARDI 1974 San Giovanni in Persiceto Italian Matteo BERTINI 1976 Funo di Argelato Italian Carlotta BERZIOLI 1977 Bologna Italian Ilaria BETTOCCHI 1976 Bologna Italian Barbara BIGUCCI 1975 Riccione Italian Diego BIONDINI 1974 Modena Italian Federico BOARON 1974 Pianoro Italian Francesca BONAZZI 1975 San Lazzaro di Savena Italian Caterina BONICELLI 1978 Rimini Italian Daniela BONSANTO 1974 Treviso Italian Biancamaria BORTOLOTTI 1975 Bologna Italian Roberta BORTOLOTTI 1972 Bologna Italian Carla BRINDISI 1977 Budrio Italian Nicoletta BRUNETTI 1970 Paris Italian Sonia CALDARELLI 1977 Porto San Giorgio Italian Morena CALLI 1977 Godo di Russi Italian Olivia CAMELI 1972 Bologne Italian Cristina CAMPIDELLI 1975 Garbagnate Milanese Italian Nicola CAMURRI 1977 Porto Mantovano Italian Silvia CAPPANERA 1975 Ancona Italian Alberta CAPPELLI 1975 Bologna Italian Michela CASORIA 1973 Bologna Italian Laura CASTIGLIONI 1976 Rimini Italian Marco CAVALLO 1976 Modica Italian Agnese CECCONI 1979 Milan Italian Laura CECCONI 1972 San Lazzaro di Savena Italian Bruno CHIAPPINI 1975 Pescara Italian Alessandra CHIARINI 1976 Ravenna Italian Paolo CILIBERTI 1979 Fermo Italian Serena COLUMBO 1975 Pescara Italian Enrico Maria CONGEDO 1975 Bologna Italian Francesca COPPOLA 1973 Bologna Italian Giulia CREMANTE 1977 Bologna Italian Alessandra D’ADDIO 1980 Ravenna Italian Erika DAL CHECCO 1975 Bologna Italian Giulia DI LORETO 1976 Forlì Italian Elisa DONINI 1976 Bologna Italian Silvia FANELLO 1975 Reggio nell’Emilia Italian Claudia FAVA 1974 Cesena Italian Marta FISCALETTI 1976 Bologna Italian Tommaso FOGACCI 1974 Santarcangelo di Romagna Italian Filippo FORTUNA 1979 Fano Italian Alessandro FRANCESCHELLI 1972 Bologna Italian Francesca FUSCO 1969 Sesto Fiorentino Italian Gianluca FUSCONI 1974 Bologna Italian Andrea GALVANI 1973 Misano Adriatico Italian Guido GAMBINI 1975 Bologna Italian Silvia GARUTI 1975 Bologna Italian Filippo GAZZOTTI 1974 Bologna Italian Monia GENNARI 1972 Bologna Italian Valentina GENTILE 1973 Pianoro Italian Daniela Maria GIARDINA 1974 Bologna Italian Federica GIOMMI 1977 Fano Italian Maddalena GIOVANNINI 1978 San Pietro in Casale Italian Cinzia GIULIANELLI 1973 Sant’Arcangelo di Romagna Italian Lorenzo GOTTARELLI 1974 Ravenna Italian Laura GRECO 1978 Bologna Italian Marcello GUIDI 1974 Bologna Italian Michele LA DONNA 1966 Dozza Italian Ettore LARACCA 1978 Paris Italian Sara LAZZARI 1979 Bologna Italian Simona LINARELLO 1974 Bologna Italian Sigrid LIOTTA 1974 Imola Italian Francesca LODATO 1975 Bologna Italian Maria LONGHI 1978 Urbino Italian Myriam LUONGO 1976 Pescara Italian Giorgia MAGAGNOLI 1970 Bologna Italian Giorgio MAGNANI 1972 Cento Italian Laura MALAIGIA 1972 Cesena Italian Dario MANGANARO 1978 Bologna Italian Samanta MANONI 1976 Montegiardino Italian Eugenia MARANELLA 1977 Penna Sant’Andrea Italian Leonardo MARCHESINI REGGIANI 1976 Bologna Italian Debora MARCHIORI 1977 Casalecchio di Reno Italian Elena MARRA 1979 Lecce Italian Mabel MARTELLI 1977 Ozzano dell’Emilia Italian Maura MASTRACOLA 1977 Porto San Giorgio Italian Federica MAZZANTI 1975 Bologna Italian Francesca MENCARELLI 1976 Molinella Italian Marina MERLI 1978 Ferrara Italian Elisa MIKUS 1977 Bologna Italian Loris MIRABILE 1973 Casalecchio di Reno Italian Maria Grazia MIRARCHI 1978 Bologna Italian Barbara MONDARDINI 1978 Cesena Italian Fausta MONTESI 1978 Lanciano Italian Laura MOSCA 1975 Modena Italian Pietro Antonio MOTTA 1969 Scicli Italian Alessandro MURAGLIA 1975 Verona Italian Nicola MURIGLIO 1968 Castel San Pietro Terme Italian Andrea MUSSONI 1978 Rimini Italian Ilaria NALDI 1977 Castel San Pietro Terme Italian Cristina NANNI 1975 Bologna Italian Anastasia NERI 1969 Russi Italian Elisabetta NOBILI 1972 Bologna Italian Massimo ONORATO 1966 Chiaravalle Italian Valerio ORSINI 1977 Ascoli Piceno Italian Laura PAGLIARA 1976 Lecce Italian Maria Chiara PAJNO 1978 Rome Italian Francesca PALANDRI 1977 Bologna Italian Gaia PANTIERI 1975 Forlì Italian Cristina PAPAYANNIDIS 1980 Bologna Italian Pietro Antonio PAPILI 1978 Pianoro Italian Laura PASQUINI 1974 Bologna Italian Gabriella PELUSI 1975 Rimini Italian Barbara PERENZE 1973 Forlì Italian Giulia PERRONE 1978 Milan Italian Elisa PERSICI 1975 Bologna Italian Raffaella PIERINI 1972 Pesaro Italian Elena PRATI 1979 Cesena Italian Silvia PREDIERI 1973 Ozzano dell’Emilia Italian Chiara PRESTI 1978 Castel Maggiore Italian Francesca Rita PULVIRENTI 1974 Castelfranco Emilia Italian Sara QUERCIA 1978 San Lazzaro di Savena Italian Alessio RAIMONDI 1976 Porretta Terme Italian Matteo RENZULLI 1978 Bologna Italian Davide RICCI 1977 Bologna Italian Lorenzo RIMONDINI 1970 Bologna Italian Matteo ROMAGNOLI 1975 Bologna Italian Luca RONCI 1973 Rimini Italian Eugenio ROSSI 1979 Bologna Italian Alessandro RUSSO 1975 Bologna Italian Maria SARMA 1976 Bologna Greek Angela SCARANO 1974 Francavilla Fontana Italian Mirella SCIPIONE 1976 Copertino Italian Riccardo SELLERI 1974 Bologna Italian Enrico SEVERINI 1976 Bologna Italian Giada SIBAHI 1976 Ferrara Italian Mariantonella SIMONE 1975 Vasto Italian Francesca SPERANDI 1975 Bologna Italian Vincenzo SPIGONARDO 1975 Bologna Italian Luca SPINARDI 1979 Bologna Italian Michelangelo STANZANI MASERATI 1975 Bologna Italian Michela TABANELLI 1974 Bologna Italian Giovanni Roberto TEDESCO 1973 Girifalco Italian Benedetta TOSCANO 1977 Rimini Italian Orsola TRANI 1963 Grottaglie Italian Gilda Vittoria TREBINI 1978 Torino Italian Matteo VERSARI 1975 Rimini Italian Monica VIOLA 1973 Bologna Italian Giada VOLTA 1975 Bologna Italian Sara ZANZANI 1976 Rimini Italian Alessandra ZUCCALÀ 1975 Rimini Italian Elisabetta ZUCCHINI 1975 Ferrara Italian Maria Chiara COLONNELLI 1977 Bromley Italian Francesca D’ADDIO 1975 Seregno Italian Lorenzo GARAGNANI 1977 London Italian Francesco SANGUEDOLCE 1976 Barcelona Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

15.

33567/20

Alberghina and Others v. Italy

30/07/2020

Filippo ALBERGHINA 1979 Niscemi Italian Emanuele AMODIO 1979 Palermo Italian Filippo BONO 1977 Palermo Italian Marco BRESCIANI 1973 Castellammare del Golfo Italian Antonella CAMPISI 1973 Caccamo Italian Pietro CARADONNA 1973 Mazara del Vallo Italian Laura DAMIANI 1979 Niscemi Italian Fabrizio DAVID 1975 Palermo Italian Vito DITTA 1967 Paceco Italian Giuseppe GIGLIA 1976 Caltanissetta Italian Maria IMPASTATO 1974 Chivasso Italian Claudio LA SCOLA 1976 Rimini Italian Giovanni LEONE 1976 Padua Italian Alessandra LO CASCIO 1977 Palermo Italian Giovan Battista LO PIPARO 1979 Nicosia Italian Giuseppe LOSI 1972 Scandicci Italian Gabriele LUPICA 1959 Gela Italian Riccardo MANDRACCHIA 1979 Favara Italian Serena MERAVIGLIA 1977 Palermo Italian Maria MESSINA 1977 Mazara del Vallo Italian Clara MOSA 1976 Palermo Italian Filippo NARESE 1980 Agrigento Italian Stefano ORLANDO 1958 Misilmeri Italian Giancarlo PANCUCCI 1977 Agrigento Italian Carmen RAMONDETTA 1971 Modica Italian Giuseppa RUDISI 1966 Palermo Italian Leonardo RUSSO 1974 Agrigento Italian Paola SANFILIPPO 1976 Caltanissetta Italian Francesco SCARPA 1973 Palermo Italian Daniele SPECIALE 1953 Milan Italian Michele SPICOLA 1974 San Biagio Platani Italian Adele TAIBBI 1977 Palermo Italian Serena TROPIA 1974 Palermo Italian Lidia URSO 1976 Erice Italian Arturo VACCARI 1974 Palermo Italian Francesca VERDERAME 1976 Palermo Italian Ernesto VINCIGUERRA 1977 Palermo Italian Giuseppina ZABBARA 1976 Ribera Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

16.

34047/20

Sapienza

v. Italy

30/07/2020

Salvatore SAPIENZA 1975 Palermo Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

17.

34554/20

Martorana

v. Italy

30/07/2020

Guido MARTORANA 1973 Palermo Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

18.

34586/20

Giliberto

v. Italy

30/07/2020

Giovanni Luca GILIBERTO 1972 Borgarello Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

19.

34840/20

Pomara

v. Italy

30/07/2020

Giuseppe POMARA 1975 Lascari Italian

Giuseppe PINELLI

20.

49917/20

Amadio and Others

v. Italy

03/11/2020

Luca AMADIO 1977 Feltre Italian Cinzia ANDRIGO 1975 Camposampiero Italian Maurizio Santi ARAGONA 1975 Lunebourg Italian Francesco BARBARO 1975 Teolo Italian Mara BARBAZZA 1975 Sarmede Italian Francesca BARBON 1975 Legnaro Italian Manuela BEDA 1970 Noventa Padovana Italian Caterina BERNARDI 1973 Rosà Italian Carla BETTINI 1969 Vigodarzere Italian Giovanni BETTO 1972 Casalserugo Italian Michela BEVILACQUA 1977 Padua Italian Luca BONANNI 1975 Padua Italian Elisa BONELLO 1977 Verona Italian Valeria BORILE 1975 Noventa Vicentina Italian Emanuela BRIGO 1972 Dueville Italian Sara CALAMELLI 1975 Mestre Italian Carlo CALZAVARA 1958 Chirignago Italian Daniele CANOVA 1976 Cassola Italian Rosa CARMELLO 1973 Mogliano Veneto Italian Cristina CECCHETTO 1977 Padua Italian Stefano CHECCACCI CARBONI 1977 San Martino di Lupari Italian Francesco Antonio CIARLEGLIO 1975 Trento Italian Laura CICCARIELLO 1976 Merano Italian Alessia COMACCHIO 1973 Albignasego Italian Paola CONFORTIN 1974 Castelfranco Veneto Italian Geeta Giulia COSTA 1976 Padua Italian Andrea COSTACURTA 1976 Padua Italian Umberto CUCCHINI 1974 Bassano del Grappa Italian Mario D’AGATA 1974 Padua Italian Luca DAL MORO 1965 Padua Italian Michela DE AGOSTINI 1975 Tricesimo Italian Giovanna ERENTE 1974 Arsiero Italian Paolo FERRETTO 1974 Schio Italian Francesca FOLTRAN 1975 Pisa Italian Simonetta FRACALANZA 1972 Padua Italian Malida FRANZOI 1974 Martellago Italian Valeria FRANZOI 1975 Trento Italian Emanuele FURLAN 1976 Abano Terme Italian Cecilia GAVA 1973 Padua Italian Silvia GEMELLI 1973 Padua Italian Marta GUIZZO 1975 Montebelluna Italian Antonino Vincenzo Ivano INGRASSIA 1970 Trecastagni Italian Stefano LAI 1974 Sestu Italian Francesca LAZZAROTTO 1974 Padua Italian Dario Maria Umberto LI MURA 1966 Centuripe Italian Giuseppe LUCCISANO 1964 Trevignano Italian Francesco LUPIA 1972 Verona Italian Antonio LUPO 1975 Villafranca Padovana Italian Michela MADALOSSO 1977 Belluno Italian Francesca MANGANELLI 1975 Padua Italian Giuseppe MARGANI 1975 Mirano Italian Mee Jung MATTARELLO 1976 Vicenza Italian Payvand MEHRAVAND 1975 Vigodarzere Italian Eva MICHELIN 1975 Ferrara Italian Flavio MISTRORIGO 1973 Vicenza Italian Jgor MORETTO 1973 Albignasego Italian Antonio MURRONE 1972 Castelfranco Veneto Italian Tiziana ORO 1974 Padua Italian Duilio PAGANO 1978 Palermo Italian Margherita PALAZZI 1974 Mirano Italian Chiara PAVAN 1974 Padua Italian Paola PICCIONE 1972 Pianiga Italian Giuseppe PORTALE 1975 Pordenone Italian Anna REALDI 1975 Padua Italian Giovanna RIZZARDI 1977 Bergamo Italian Christian RIZZETTO 1975 Pieve di Soligo Italian Marco ROSSI 1973 Treviso Italian Athanasios SARATZIOTIS 1973 Larissa Greek Alessandra SCHIAVO 1966 Padua Italian Umberto SCHIAVO 1976 Piazzola sul Brenta Italian Sarah SCHIAVON 1976 Padua Italian Piero SPIRITIGLIOZZI 1970 Padua Italian Nicoletta STERZA 1962 Mirano Italian Gianluca TAMAGNO 1975 Dublin Italian Silvia TAMBUSCIO 1972 Padua Italian Diego TONELLO 1974 Castello di Godego Italian Barbara TRANI 1971 Zelarino Italian Kalongo Vicky TSHIMANGA 1964 Tirano Italian Federica VIAN 1975 Salzano Italian Vladimiro VIDA 1973 Padua Italian Paola VIOLI 1977 Verona Italian Nadia XAMIN 1965 Pieve del Grappa Italian Sandra ZAMPIERI 1963 Padua Italian Michela ZANDONÀ 1975 Padua Italian Umberto FRASCI 1954 Portogruaro Italian Mirko MENEGOLO 1976 Padua Italian Silvia ORLANDO 1976 Castelfranco Veneto Italian Silvia ORLUNGHI 1970 Rubano Italian

Gabriele DONÀ

21.

13261/21

Di Giovan

v. Italy

26/02/2021

Marco Paolo DI GIOVAN 1966 Rome Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

22.

13264/21

Orsini Federici

v. Italy

26/02/2021

Barbara ORSINI FEDERICI 1974 Perugia Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

23.

14308/21

Cereda and Others

v. Italy

25/02/2021

Emanuele CEREDA 1978 Milan Italian Luca GIACOMETTI 1972 Italian Monica LIMARDO 1978 Italian Fabiana POMPEI 1978 Italian Enrico TRICARICO 1973 Italian

Gaetano VICICONTE

24.

14636/21

Calandra and Others

v. Italy

26/02/2021

Salvatore CALANDRA 1967 Messina Italian Adele CALDARELLA 1965 Firenze Italian Francesco Tindaro CALDERONE 1968 Messina Italian Eliana CAMMARATA 1976 La Spezia Italian Tommaso CAMPAGNARO 1976 Roncoferraro Italian Nives CAMPEOL 1975 Caronno Pertusella Italian Filomena Rita CANISTRO 1962 Termoli Italian Domenico CANTE 1962 Valle di Maddaloni Italian Andrea CAPEZZUOLI 1964 Poggibonsi Italian Marcella CAPOZZI 1964 Rome Italian Angelo CARADONNA 1965 Quartucciu Italian Fabio CARAMELLI 1963 Bologna Italian Gabriella Paola Maria CARLESI 1958 Novi Ligure Italian Angela CARLETTI 1976 Colli al Metauro Italian Concetta CARLUCCI 1972 Peschiera Borromeo Italian Arianna CARMIGNANI 1973 Lucca Italian Mauro CARTA 1966 Cagliari Italian Michela CASSINOTTI 1971 Olgiate Olona Italian Ottorino CATANI 1966 Bacoli Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

25.

16605/21

Arrichetta and Others

v. Italy

16/03/2021

Giuseppina ARRICHETTA 1966 Reggio Calabria Italian Paolo Angelo BLOCCA 1956 Taranto Italian Donatella BOTTA 1965 Cairo Montenotte Italian Umberto BAGNATO 1963 Fiumara Italian Roberto Giovanni BROLLO 1968 Novi Ligure Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

26.

18836/21

Bianchini

v. Italy

31/03/2021

Gian Pietro BIANCHINI 1968 Rome Italian

Stefano SABATINO

27.

22307/21

Acler and Others

v. Italy

19/04/2021

Michele ACLER 1977 Trento Italian Antonio OLIVA 1960 Pescara Italian Franco ADDONA 1964 Busso Italian Annamaria AGOSTI 1969 Vire Italian Barbara AIRINI 1973 Macerata Italian Nicola Giuseppe ALAIMO 1972 Palermo Italian Bruno ALBIANI 1964 Agosta Italian Alessandra ALLEGRI 1959 Radda in Chianti Italian Svitlana ANDRYEYEVA 1965 Cesenatico Italian Donatella ANGELOZZI 1964 Sora Italian Riccardo ANSELMI ANGELI 1968 Tarquinia Italian Manuela ANTENUCCI 1964 Rome Italian Andrea ANTONUZZO 1969 Vecchiano Italian Daniela APRIGLIANO 1964 Frosinone Italian Alessandra ARDUINI 1963 Iglesias Italian Axel ARISTA 1963 Cesena Italian Simone BAGLIERI 1970 Pino Torinese Italian Irene BAGNASCO 1970 Moncalieri Italian Claudia BAIOCCHI 1969 Siena Italian Federica BALTARO 1967 Milan Italian Marco Guido BARBARINI 1965 Lecco Italian Lorenzo BARINA 1964 Segrate Italian Benedetta BARTOLI 1973 Rome Italian Teresa BASSANI 1965 Mazzè Italian Paolo Federico BECCARIA 1971 Milan Italian Francesca BECCARO 1965 Venice Italian Andrea BENAGIANO 1969 Rome Italian Alessia BERNARDO CIDIO 1976 Rome Italian Lucio BERTINI 1969 Rome Italian Davide BERTOCCO 1973 Moncalieri Italian Serafina BEVILACQUA 1970 Lamezia terme Italian Denise BIANCHI 1973 Sovere Italian Maria Letizia BIANCO 1971 Rome Italian Nicola BIELLO 1969 Pescara Italian Stefano BIGGI 1968 Genoa Italian Luciana BISCARI 1971 Foiano della Chiana Italian Chiara BISCOSI 1972 Rome Italian Francesco BIZZARRI 1959 L’Aquila Italian Stefano BLANZIERI 1964 Modena Italian Vincenza BLUNDA 1962 Spadafora Italian Liliana BOCCA 1971 Bordighera Italian Francesca BONVEGNA 1966 Arizzano Italian Maurizio BORZUMATI 1969 Verbania Italian Angelo BOTTONE 1957 L’Aquila Italian Daniela BRACAGLIA 1964 Frosinone Italian Francesco BRACCIONI 1973 Ancona Italian Maria Rita BRANDETTI 1968 Rome Italian Claudio BRECCIA 1970 Rome Italian Arianna BREGA 1973 Rome Italian Barbara BREGOLI 1964 Ferrara Italian Giampaolo BRICHETTO 1974 Genoa Italian Uwe Florian Manfred BRUMMER 1960 Francavilla al Mare Italian Nadia BRUNETTI 1970 Sant’Anatolia di Narco Italian Antonio BRUNO 1975 Castello-Molina di Fiemme Italian Ferdinando BRUSCHI 1969 Pasian di Prato Italian Massimo BUFFONI 1962 Conegliano Italian Massimiliano BUSTINI 1968 Rieti Italian Francesco CALLEGARI 1968 Udine Italian Josefina CAMPANELLA 1964 Rome Italian Maria Antonietta CANCELLIERI 1969 Sant’Egidio alla Vibrata Italian Pasqualina CANCIELLO 1963 Caserta Italian Andrea CANTERGIANI 1971 Fiorano Modenese Italian Silvia CAPASSO 1968 San Nicola la Strada Italian Lidia CAPELLI 1975 Rivolta d’Adda Italian Irma CAPOLUPO 1965 Rome Italian Sabrina CAPURSO 1967 Trevignano Romano Italian Salvatore CARDALI 1972 Catania Italian Michele CASALIS 1966 Campiglia Marittima Italian Loredana CASINELLI 1966 Frosinone Italian Tommaso CASINI 1967 Firenze Italian Michele CATALE 1963 Torino Italian Luigi CATALLO 1958 Castelliri Italian Nicoletta CATTANEO 1968 Ceriano Laghetto Italian Pasqualina CECERE 1965 Torino Italian Giovanna CERINA 1972 Galatina Italian Daniele CERVELLI 1978 Piediluco Italian Vito CESSA 1965 Casamassima Italian Cristina Margot CHAVES BRAIT 1965 Rome Italian Ilaria CHIESA 1975 Rome Italian Sabrina CHIFARI 1966 Palermo Italian Maria Grazia CIANCI 1962 Vercelli Italian Stefania CICUTO 1966 Pergine Italian Erri CIPPINI 1955 Botticino Italian Massimiliano CIPRIANO 1976 Rome Italian Angela CIUFFREDA 1965 Modena Italian Giulia Carla Maria CLONFERO 1972 Vicenza Italian Francesco COCCIOLO 1962 Cesena Italian Santa COGLIANDOLO 1966 Rome Italian Laura COLASUONNO 1977 Muggiò Italian Valerio Nicola COLELLA 1970 Reggio Calabria Italian Donatella COMIGNANI 1962 Rome Italian Caterina COMOLA 1972 Basiglio Italian Marcella CONVERSO 1969 Torino Italian Laura Annamaria Luisa Giuseppina COPPI 1965 Milan Italian Stefano COPPI 1969 Modena Italian Stefania CORBI 1967 Rome Italian Chiara CORIANI 1971 Reggio nell’Emilia Italian Cesaria CORLIANÒ 1974 Como Italian Paolo COSMA 1962 Tirano Italian Giorgio COSTANTIN 1964 Padua Italian Luca COVOTTA 1967 Rome Italian Massimo CRISOGIANNI 1970 Rome Italian Marta CRISTOFOLINI 1977 Milan Italian Giovanni CUCINOTTA 1947 Messina Italian Maria Teresa CUONZO 1969 Fossacesia Italian Cesare Carlo D’ALESSANDRO 1967 Rome Italian Cristina D’ANDREA 1965 Veggiano Italian Francesco D’ORIO 1962 Amaseno Italian Enrico DE CICCO 1957 Rome Italian Donatella DE FELICE 1973 Pozzuoli Italian Amalia DE LUCA 1969 Naples Italian Paola DE MARTINO 1955 Torino Italian Federica DE SANTIS 1966 Marino Italian Carmelo DEBILIO 1964 Riesi Italian Giada DEGRASSI 1972 Trieste Italian Elena DELALIO 1976 Concesio Italian Grazia DELIOS 1962 Ivrea Italian Elena DEMURTAS 1965 Cagliari Italian Luca DESPINI 1975 Milan Italian Cosimo DI BERARDINO 1973 Avezzano Italian Angela Maria DI BERNARDO 1963 Assemini Italian Francesco DI CLEMENTE 1963 Perugia Italian Francesca DI COSTANZO 1973 Nocera Inferiore Italian Flavia DI FRANCESCO 1968 Rome Italian Maria DI FULVIO 1970 Chieti Italian Luigi DI MARCO 1963 Portomaggiore Italian Gianluca DI MICCO 1967 Naples Italian Silvia DI TERLIZZI 1978 Udine Italian Domenico DI TOMMASO 1977 Torino Italian Massimo DIANA 1972 Pomezia Italian Antonella DIDONNA 1965 Rome Italian Annalisa DISTEFANO 1975 Formello Italian Maria Rosa Rosaria Rita DORIA 1971 Pisa Italian William ESPOSITO 1966 Forlì Italian Amedeo FABOZZO 1976 Torrazza Piemonte Italian Carmine FALSARONE 1961 Fiamignano Italian Massimiliano FANNI CANELLES 1965 Fogliano Redipuglia Italian Edi FEDERICONI 1965 Piombino Italian Marco FELICI 1979 Rome Italian Giovanni FERA 1964 Lamezia Terme Italian Diana FEROCI 1975 Ladispoli Italian Raffaella FERRANDO 1971 Courmayeur Italian Vittoria FERRARA 1965 Minturno Italian Susanna FERRERO 1969 Rome Italian Michela FERRO 1965 Torino Italian Cristina FINALDI 1970 Rome Italian Filippo FINIZIO 1974 Capodrise Italian Leonardo Davis Maria FINO 1973 San Severo Italian Francesco FIORENTINO 1966 Casoria Italian Antonella Angela Maria FLACHI 1968 Melito di Porto Salvo Italian Maria FOGGIA 1966 Alife Italian Domitilla FOGHETTI 1971 Fano Italian Luigi FONDRIESCHI 1968 Desenzano del Garda Italian Paolo FONTANA 1965 Modena Italian Gerardo FORTUNATO 1955 Montecorvino Rovella Italian Valentina FRESA 1968 Salerno Italian Saverio FROSINI 1967 Calenzano Italian Alessandro FUGAGNOLI 1963 Sondalo Italian Domenico FUSCO 1977 Rome Italian Luca FUSO 1972 Torino Italian Stefano GAGLIARDI 1974 Bologna Italian Concetta Maria GAGLIOTI 1968 Nicotera Italian Vincenzo GALANTE 1980 Rome Italian Francesco GALIFFA 1957 Giulianova Italian Fortunata GALLETTI 1965 Reggio Calabria Italian Roberto GALLO 1968 Cortandone Italian Lino GARAU 1970 Sassari Italian Emmanuel GASPERONI 1977 San Marino Italian Paolo GASPERONI 1974 Rome Italian Patrizia GEMELLI 1968 Ausonia Italian Nicola GERVASIO 1964 Finale Ligure Italian Giuseppe GESSA 1972 Bologna Italian Caterina GIARAMITA 1964 Riesi Italian Gabriele GIOFFRÈ 1975 Reggio Calabria Italian Paolo Antonio GIOVANNELLI 1976 Milan Italian Damiana GIOVANNETTI 1973 Rome Italian Marianna GIUDITTA 1958 Milan Italian Ernesto GIUFFREDA 1969 Foggia Italian Silvano GIURI 1973 Galatina Italian Monica GOLA 1970 Modena Italian Paolo GRANDINETTI 1966 Rome Italian Anna Maria GRECO 1968 Lecce Italian Fabrizio GRILLI 1973 Genoa Italian Lucia Maria Grazia GRIMALDI 1964 Caltanissetta Italian Francesco Andrea GUIDO 1962 Anguillara Sabazia Italian Farhad HABIBI POUR ROUDSARI 1961 Corsico Italian Carmela IACHETTA 1964 Benevento Italian Manlio IADANZA 1965 Carpi Italian Adelina IADEVAIA 1966 Dugenta Italian Filippo IAFANTI 1966 Pozzuoli Italian Saverio INVIDIATO 1962 Padua Italian Paolo IZZO 1971 Formello Italian Lara LABARDI 1980 Lariano Italian Mauro LANCIA 1966 Cesate Italian Valentina LAURIA 1973 Rome Italian Stefano LECCARDI 1971 Boves Italian Gian Mauro LIBERATORE 1965 Rome Italian Maurizio LONZI 1976 Rome Italian Stefano LUCCHINA 1974 Gordola Italian Lorella LUTI 1961 Empoli Italian Francesca MANCINI 1967 Terni Italian Tania MARIANELLI 1976 Rome Italian Marco MARIANETTI 1976 Rome Italian Moira MARTELLI 1966 Rome Italian Giuseppe MARTELLUCCI 1963 Minturno Italian Maurizio MARTINO 1962 Castellammare di Stabia Italian Stefano MAZZETTI 1961 Terni Italian Daniela Sara MELIS 1973 Centallo Italian Francesco MEROLA 1966 Minturno Italian Maria Alessia MESTORINOO 1968 Rome Italian Rosa MODESTO 1964 Formia Italian Giuseppe MOLINO 1975 Comiso Italian Maria Grazia MORETTA 1968 Castelforte Italian Maria Teresa MORMILE 1969 Frattamaggiore Italian Dario MUSONE 1974 Formia Italian Massimiliano NAPOLITANO 1965 Magliano Sabina Italian Sergio NICOLUCCI 1964 Rome Italian Giuditta PALOMBO 1964 Rome Italian Luciano PANZINI 1965 Subiaco Italian Sandra PAPALINI 1969 Rome Italian Emanuela PARADISO 1965 Pinerolo Italian Paolo Salvatore PASSANITI 1969 Milan Italian Massimo PENTA 1965 Mirabella Eclano Italian Antonella PENTASSUGLIA 1970 Ciampino Italian Alberto PERATONER 1971 Trieste Italian Donatella PEZZIMENTI 1974 Domodossola Italian Sarah PIGOLOTTI 1975 Gallarate Italian Francesco PISANTI 1971 Rome Italian Massimo POLITANO 1963 Fabriano Italian Gianpiero POLVERINO 1974 Milan Italian Barbara PUCCI 1970 Ariccia Italian Nunzio RAGNO 1965 San Ferdinando di Puglia Italian Valentina REBELLA 1973 Rome Italian Maria RIZZA 1963 Messina Italian Michele RIZZO 1962 Messina Italian Stefania ROSSI 1973 Modena Italian Anna Maria ROVEDA 1967 Stradella Italian Elisa RUBINO 1978 Chivasso Italian Biancamaria RUSSO 1964 Naples Italian Andrea SABATO 1967 Matera Italian Maria SANNINO 1968 Naples Italian Nicola SETTEFRATI 1964 Pescara Italian Cesare SIRIGNANO 1970 Naples Italian Maria Luisa SODDU 1962 Soleminis Italian Fabio Gianpaolo TANDURELLA 1971 Castelfranco Veneto Italian Nicola TARSIA 1968 Cirò Marina Italian Michela TEDESCO 1975 Rome Italian Maurizio TRIDICI 1969 Supersano Italian Giovanni TRINCHESE 1968 Cimitile Italian Antonio VALLOREO 1969 Cappelle sul Tavo Italian Alfonso VERRILLO 1968 Rome Italian Tiziana VISCUSO 1968 Pedara Italian Luigi VITTORIOSO 1969 Cardito Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

28.

23481/21

Martino

v. Italy

23/04/2021

Carmine MARTINO 1951 Salerno Italian

Giuseppe SPAGNUOLO

29.

23506/21

Petrone and Others

v. Italy

16/04/2021

Silvia PETRONE 1964 Gallarate Italian Angelo D’AMICO 1960 Sanremo Italian Elisabetta MON 1972 Trento Italian Franca MORETTI 1960 Firenze Italian Guido PALLONE 1970 Rome Italian Lorena D’ALESSANDRO 1968 L’Aquila Italian Giovanni MAVILIO 1968 Mesagne Italian Daniela CACCIAGRANO 1962 Rieti Italian Pier Paolo MAINENTI 1966 Naples Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

30.

29178/21

Calistri and Others

v. Italy

26/05/2021

Massimo CALISTRI 1973 Quarrata Italian Alessandro CALLIGARO 1975 Rome Italian Emanuele CAPUTO 1974 Castellana Grotte Italian Valentina CAPUTO 1968 Palermo Italian Antonietta CARDINALE 1962 Palermo Italian Maria Pia CARELLI 1966 L’Aquila Italian Francesco CARRATA 1964 Bari Italian Paola CASSIN 1970 San Vito al Tagliamento Italian Nicoletta CASTIGLIONE 1969 Quattordio Italian Donato CATALDO 1973 Aquilonia Italian Elena CAVALAZZI 1973 Ravenna Italian Annalisa CECILIA 1972 Bracciano Italian Mara CIGALA FULGOSI 1974 Monza Italian Marcello CILIA 1968 Messina Italian Ernesto CIMMINO 1967 Ischia Italian Stella CINI 1977 Casciana Terme Lari Italian Giacomo CIPRIANI 1962 L’Aquila Italian Irene Elisabetta CIPRIANI 1962 Rome Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

31.

40993/21

Bergonzi and Others

v. Italy

04/08/2021

Roberto BERGONZI 1972 Bergamo Italian Gloria BERTELLI 1966 Ferrara Italian Andrea BERTORELLO 1973 Pavia Italian Giuseppina BEVIGLIA 1961 Vercelli Italian Alessandra BIANCHI 1967 Sora Italian Barbara BOCCASSINI 1972 Rome Italian Lorenzo BONAPITACOLA 1966 Opera Italian Patrizia BORTOLON 1966 Sossano Italian Gemma BRIZZI 1971 La Spezia Italian Cristian BROCCHIERI 1973 Soresina Italian Manuela BRUGNI 1967 Ascoli Piceno Italian Barbara BRUNATO 1969 San Giorgio di Nogaro Italian Ferdinando BUFFONI 1959 Montignoso Italian

Andrea SACCUCCI

32.

47147/21

Annunziata and Others

v. Italy

14/09/2021

Emanuele ANNUNZIATA 1978 Sarno Italian Biagio CIAMBRIELLO 1973 Naples Italian Annunziata GERMANO 1977 Naples Italian Giuseppe RENGO 1978 Naples Italian

Andrea SACCUCCI

33.

48940/21

Agostoni and Others

v. Italy

24/09/2021

Pierfrancesco AGOSTONI 1975 Schilde Italian Leonidas AZAS 1965 Firenze Italian Placido CUZZUPÈ 1958 San Salvatore Monferrato Italian Maria Angela DI MAURO 1962 Catania Italian Ivana Maddalena FERRERO 1974 Alessandria Italian Leona FESTA 1960 San Mango sul Calore Italian Marco GABRIELLI 1965 Trieste Italian Stefano AQUILANI 1974 Rome Italian Emanuela BATTAINO 1967 Milan Italian Marco CACCIAPUOTI 1964 Savona Italian Barbara CAGLI 1976 Rome Italian Carmelo CAZZATO 1960 Tricase Italian Angelo CIOPPA 1968 Mercogliano Italian Rosario COCO 1968 Venice Italian Barbara CONTI 1971 Cossato Italian Stefania CUCCHIARELLI 1962 Copertino Italian Piercataldo D’ALEO 1967 Messina Italian Angelo DE LUCA 1963 Belpasso Italian Roberto FERRARA 1966 Bolzano Italian Monica FIORAVANTI 1971 Vedano al Lambro Italian Maria FRACASSI 1963 Messina Italian Giampaolo GASPARINI 1964 Villafranca di Verona Italian Elisabetta GIULIANI 1968 Pescara Italian Salvatore GRECO 1967 Taormina Italian

Andrea SACCUCCI

34.

48985/21

Sardelli and Others

v. Italy

24/09/2021

Luigi SARDELLI 1974 Qualiano Italian Maria Grazia SCARALE 1966 San Giovanni Rotondo Italian Intissar SLEIMAN 1963 Brescia Italian Michelangelo Mario SPANÃ’ 1976 San Giovanni Rotondo Italian Enrico Roberto SAVINI 1963 Usmate Velate Italian Emanuela SBRISCIA FIORETTI 1965 Senigallia Italian Sara SCAINI 1974 Codroipo Italian Pietro Giuliano SCALCON 1967 Pianiga Italian Marco SCARFINI 1971 Rome Italian Gabriella SCHILIRÃ’ 1971 Vittoria Italian Stefano SCICOLONE 1969 Formigine Italian Antonietta Maria SERRA 1958 Dorgali Italian Maria SERRA 1971 Milan Italian Margherita SIMEONE 1966 Follo Italian Elisabetta Giovanna SOGNI 1972 Gallarate Italian Oscar Luciano Maria SORESINI 1973 Casaleggio Novara Italian Giuseppina SPANEDDA 1973 Alghero Italian Francesca SPANÃ’ 1969 Milan Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

35.

48996/21

Riccardi and Others

v. Italy

24/09/2021

Francesca RICCARDI 1974 Pavia Italian Stefania SALAMANO 1973 Acqui Terme Italian Nicoletta SALVIOLI 1976 San Rufo Italian Martine Jeanne Elisabeth SIBILLE 1955 Terni Italian Paola Lidia Amelia SIGNORONI 1963 Milan Italian Cristiana SMORGON 1974 Rovigo Italian Roberta RINDONE 1974 Acicastello Italian Vito RIZZO 1965 Pisticci Italian Andrea ROGNONI 1975 Novara Italian Francesco ROSSI 1964 Marseille Italian Carlotta SACERDOTE 1974 Torino Italian Pierluca Nicola Massimo SALLUSTIO 1972 Bari Italian Annamaria Rosa SAPONE 1963 Manfredonia Italian Umberto SARNO RACO 1965 Perugia Italian Elisa SAROTTI 1979 San Giuliano Milanese Italian Franca Maria SATTA 1966 Sassari Italian Piera Bernarda SCALZI 1957 Aosta Italian Daniele SCAVINO 1971 Moncalieri Italian Elena SELES 1968 Roppolo Italian Giuseppe SMECCA 1961 Ragusa Italian

Andrea SACCUCCI

36.

49020/21

Palermo and Others

v. Italy

24/09/2021

Clorinda PALERMO 1949 Taormina Italian Pietro PIOVANELLI 1961 Poncarale Italian Francesca RAMAZZOTTO 1967 Bovezzo Italian Renata RISSO 1967 Santa Margherita Ligure Italian Carla TERRIN 1967 Legnago Italian Giovanna Maria TESSARI 1966 Schio Italian Maurizio PANTALENA 1964 Verona Italian Carmelo PUGLISI 1980 Castiglione Olona Italian Miriam RIGOLDI 1975 Carugate Italian Maurizio ROSSI 1959 Arezzo Italian Pierluigi RUSSO 1965 Rome Italian Roberta SALVADORI 1971 Montopoli in Val d’Arno Italian Manuela SANSONE 1976 Rome Italian Nicola UCCI 1964 San Giovanni in Persiceto Italian Fulvio VENERI 1962 Vallo della Lucania Italian Valentina VENTORINOO 1967 Alba Italian Milena VIGNALI 1967 Parma Italian

Andrea SACCUCCI

37.

12317/22

Caldiron

v. Italy

24/02/2022

Erminia CALDIRON 1966 San Giovanni Lupatoto Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

38.

12325/22

Zinelli

v. Italy

24/02/2022

Marcello ZINELLI 1969 Parma Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

39.

13642/22

Armaroli and Others

v. Italy

02/03/2022

Sara ARMAROLI 1970 Albinea Italian Gaetana Maria Ausilia BAGLIO 1968 Catania Italian Paola BALDINI 1966 Vezzano Ligure Italian Davide BARTOLI 1970 Pesaro Italian Lorena BELARDO 1977 Sant’Arpino Italian Antonio BIANCHI 1969 Rome Italian Andrea BOSCOLO 1976 Vigonovo Italian Paola BRAGA 1966 Sostegno Italian Guido Augusto BRESADOLA 1958 Buccinasco Italian Francesca BRUSCIA 1972 Cartoceto Italian Giuseppe Maria CALARCO 1966 Milan Italian Bruno CAMILLÒ 1962 San Lazzaro di Savena Italian Riccardo CAPALDI 1966 Terni Italian Elena CAPUTO 1967 Bari Italian Guido CARIGNANO 1972 Cuneo Italian Francesco Paolo CARONIA 1968 Palermo Italian Stefano CASELLATO 1971 Sovico Italian Giulia Martina CAVESTRO 1971 Segrate Italian Chiara CIACCI 1974 Asciano Italian Antonio CONTALDO 1976 Formia Italian Iacopo CONTE 1973 Cortemilia Italian Nadia COTTO 1965 Moncalieri Italian Francesca CREMASCHINI 1974 Castenedolo Italian Caterina D’ALFONSO 1969 Naples Italian Vincenzo D’AVINO 1962 Casandrino Italian Lucrezia DE VITA 1968 Rome Italian Francesco DEL SANTO 1976 Certaldo Italian Antonio DELL’UTRI 1970 Aosta Italian Sabino FALCO 1963 Trani Italian Mariacristina FALCO 1977 Pozzuoli Italian Elisabetta FARRIS 1966 Cagliari Italian Ornella GAGETTI 1963 San Giuliano Terme Italian Francesca GELLI 1976 Certaldo Italian Giuseppe GIRLANDO 1964 Sant’Agata li Battiati Italian Luigi GUARINIELLO 1960 Fisciano Italian Nicola LAZZARO 1964 Catanzaro Italian Barbara LODA 1975 Casalzuigno Italian Antonella LUCIANO 1970 Benevento Italian Giuliana LUSSU 1969 Elmas Italian Rosario MANCUSI 1969 Ischia Italian Giuseppe MANFREDI 1974 Ferrara Italian Rosa MARRAZZO 1963 Casandrino Italian Isabella MASANEO 1969 Torino Italian Maria Letizia MOROLDO 1970 Mortegliano Italian Barbara MULLINERIS 1971 Maranello Italian Enrico MURGIA 1965 Cagliari Italian Gabriele NASTA 1976 Palermo Italian Silvia OLDANI 1974 Inveruno Italian Francesca PALAMARA 1975 Rome Italian Ettore PANASCIA 1967 San Gregorio di Catania Italian Mizar PARAGONA 1975 Rome Italian Gianluca PARAVIZZINI 1963 Catania Italian Francesca PATUZZO 1973 Genoa Italian Francesco PERELDA 1968 Padua Italian Davide PERZOLLA 1970 Fontanetto Po Italian Ilaria PESCI 1972 Parma Italian Francesco PETTERUTI 1966 Caserta Italian Tullio PICCONI 1965 Rome Italian Michele PIRELLI 1963 Colleferro Italian Lorella POLLASTRINI 1965 Anzio Italian Paola PONTICELLI 1976 Naples Italian Valentina PULCINELLI 1978 Rome Italian Flavio PULCINI 1974 Rome Italian Alessandro QUAGLIO 1967 Vigonza Italian Annarita RENZI 1956 Rome Italian Pietro SANPAOLO 1974 Francavilla al Mare Italian Annemilia SANTUCCI 1959 San Donato Milanese Italian Francesca Liberata SPADAFORA 1966 Crosia Italian Carolina STRIGAZZI 1967 Milan Italian Massimo TARDIO 1960 Manfredonia Italian Valentina TRETOLA 1965 Rome Italian Matteo TRETTI CLEMENTONI 1968 Paderno Dugnano Italian Patrizia UBOLDI 1969 Lugano Italian Annalisa VANGONE 1971 Montesilvano Italian Giulia VERRENGIA 1964 Cassino Italian Roberta VETRO 1975 Palermo Italian Luisa Stefania ZANGHÌ 1971 San Gregorio di Catania Italian Elisa ZIPOLI 1967 Firenze Italian Sandro ZONTA 1974 San Martino Siccomario Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

40.

20563/22

Abbati and Others

v. Italy

07/04/2022

Elisabetta ABBATI 1970 Parma Italian Giuseppe ACCARDI 1968 Bari Italian Paola ACQUAROLA 1972 Vasto Italian Giuseppe AIELLO 1979 Carini Italian Pietro ALBENZIO 1969 Rome Italian Katia ALFÒ 1973 Nyon Italian Tommaso ALOISIO 1978 Milan Italian Alessandra AMADI 1965 Recanati Italian Giovanni ARATARI 1966 Avezzano Italian Gazi ASSADI 1958 Palermo Italian Chiara BALDESSARI 1975 Segrate Italian Daniela BALDOLI 1979 Paderno Dugnano Italian Alessandra BARASSI 1975 Travacò Siccomario Italian Enrico BARBANTI 1966 Poggio a Caiano Italian Raffaele BARBARA 1963 Rome Italian Francesco BARDICCHIA 1970 Grossetto Italian Daniela BARILE 1973 Meda Italian Elisa BARTOLUCCI 1975 Rimini Italian Cristiana BELLAN 1968 Montespertoli Italian Maria Teresa BENAZZI 1951 Trieste Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

41.

23707/22

Charkh Zarrin

v. Italy

04/05/2022

Mansour CHARKH ZARRIN 1959 Capriolo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

42.

23834/22

Cannatelli

v. Italy

28/04/2022

Annamaria CANNATELLI 1969 Messina Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

43.

23837/22

Scavina

v. Italy

04/05/2022

Paola SCAVINA 1965 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

44.

23884/22

Andreoli

v. Italy

28/04/2022

Isabella ANDREOLI 1962 Fidenza Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

45.

23897/22

Cantelli

v. Italy

28/04/2022

Giorgio CANTELLI 1957 Ferrara Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

46.

24173/22

Iamoni

v. Italy

04/05/2022

Gianmaria IAMONI 1965 Morimondo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

47.

24811/22

Cava

v. Italy

04/05/2022

Mario CAVA 1953 Rende Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

48.

26142/22

Fiori

v. Italy

10/05/2022

Rossana FIORI 1972 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

49.

26145/22

Condorelli

v. Italy

10/05/2022

Emma CONDORELLI 1974 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

50.

26667/22

Sella

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Alberto SELLA 1977 Varese Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

51.

26676/22

Popovic

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Aleksandra POPOVIC 1971 Leno Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

52.

26679/22

Marzocchi

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Nadia MARZOCCHI 1967 Bologna Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

53.

26686/22

Renna

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Donatella RENNA 1967 Conversano Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

54.

26689/22

Milesi

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Manuela MILESI 1969 Cagliari Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

55.

26695/22

Morelli

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Federico MORELLI 1968 Formello Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

56.

26703/22

Molinaroli

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Elena MOLINAROLI 1966 Piacenza Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

57.

26709/22

Panascia

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Giada PANASCIA 1971 Catania Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

58.

26746/22

Usai

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Rosa Linda USAI 1961 Cagliari Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

59.

26756/22

Santulli

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Adriano SANTULLI 1974 Trieste Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

60.

26761/22

Muliere

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Alessandra MULIERE 1969 Cepagatti Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

61.

27078/22

Romagnoli

v. Italy

25/05/2022

Silvia ROMAGNOLI 1952 Novara Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

62.

27081/22

Francesconi

v. Italy

25/05/2022

Duilio FRANCESCONI 1959 Viareggio Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

63.

27090/22

Gualco

v. Italy

25/05/2022

Carlo GUALCO 1955 Macerata Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

64.

27094/22

Lui

v. Italy

25/05/2022

Alessandra LUI 1963 Ronchi dei Legionari Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

65.

27104/22

Luccarelli

v. Italy

25/05/2022

Ermelinda LUCCARELLI 1955 Aci Castello Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

66.

27122/22

Marconi

v. Italy

25/05/2022

Daniele MARCONI 1965 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

67.

27165/22

Abate and Others

v. Italy

16/05/2022

Massimo ABATE 1970 Augusta Italian Anna Carla AUFIERO 1967 Avellino Italian Claudia ANDRETTA 1975 Naples Italian Carmine Michele ANSALONE 1972 Vanzaghello Italian Raffaele ARGIRÒ 1967 Gioiosa Ionica Italian Maria Michela ARIANO 1968 Rocca di Papa Italian Stefano BALDO 1973 Toirano Italian Raffaella BARONE 1970 Rome Italian Luca BENAZZATO 1975 Lonigo Italian Emanuela BUONCRISTIANI 1971 Perugia Italian Antonella CAMPANILE 1966 Bologna Italian Angelita CANZI 1966 Bologna Italian Laura CARDELLINI 1963 Rimini Italian Andrea CASADEI 1969 Cesena Italian Adriana Elisabetta Rosa CAU 1962 Ravenna Italian Rita CAU 1966 Selargius Italian Santina CIULLO 1968 Capurso Italian Giovanni COPPOLA 1970 Rome Italian Gianpiero COTUGNO 1969 Cava de’ Tirreni Italian Nicola D’ERI 1957 Bari Italian Nicola DE SIMONE 1962 Rome Italian Maria Paola ESPOSITO 1958 Cagliari Italian Saverio FALCO 1961 Capurso Italian Cristiana FALOCI 1968 Rome Italian Alessandro FEBO 1973 Rome Italian Alessandra GARAGNANI 1966 Bologna Italian Cinzia GATTO 1961 Preganziol Italian Roberta GIACHETTI 1965 Capannori Italian Roberto GORTAN 1971 Trieste Italian Vincenzo INSEGNANTE 1960 Angri Italian Gianluca LANFRANCO 1968 Torino Italian Giuseppe LATORRE 1966 Bari Italian Pasquale MADARO 1954 Rome Italian Maria MAJORANA 1967 Mercogliano Italian Claudio MALARA 1967 Pasian di Prato Italian Clotilde MANFUSO 1964 Angri Italian Mario MANGRELLA 1965 Sesto San Giovanni Italian Brigeetha Antony MANJALY 1950 Dicomano Indian Thomas John MANNOORANPARAMPIL 1960 Rome Indian Ivan MELONI 1973 Nuoro Italian Vittorio NITRO 1973 Lesmo Italian Maria NORPOTH 1963 Volterra German Gianluca OCCELLI 1968 Suzzara Italian Massimiliano OLIVA 1970 Milan South African Marco ORRÙ 1970 Selargius Italian Gennaro PADUANO 1968 Torre del Greco Italian Elisa PAGLIARA 1977 Rome Italian Stefano PARO 1964 Venice Italian Maria Brigida PASQUARIELLO 1970 Castel Venere Italian Manuela PIAZZA 1972 Villanterio Italian Andrea PIEDIMONTE 1975 San Paolo Italian Francesca PISU 1963 Cagliari Italian Carlo PIZZONI 1968 Viterbo Italian Alessandro PODDA 1959 Cagliari Italian Sabrina POLIDORO 1974 Aci Castello Italian Domenico ROMEO 1969 Bologna Italian Antonia RUSSOMANDO 1978 Formigine Italian Fabrizio SABA 1969 Quartu Sant’Elena Italian Alessandra SARTI 1973 Negrar di Valpolicella Italian Pietro SCAJOLA 1969 Sanremo Italian Anna Rosa SCARAMELLI 1966 Bologna Italian Isidoro SCIRÈ RISICHELLA 1963 Scordia Italian Anna TARABINI 1970 Ferrara Italian Ester TAVERNITI 1970 Reggio Calabria Italian Alfieri VELLUCCI 1973 Santi Cosma e Damiano Italian Paolo VIAZZI 1967 Genoa Italian Silvia VISCONTI 1975 Rome Italian

Carlo RIENZI

68.

27490/22

Boeris Clemen and Others

v. Italy

04/05/2022

Francesca BOERIS CLEMEN 1972 Rome Italian Stefania BONCINELLI 1972 Milan Italian Stefano CAMPOREALE 1967 Molfetta Italian Isabella CANTORI 1963 Osimo Italian Brigida CARDUCCI 1964 Rome Italian Danilo CARLONI 1965 Foligno Italian Cinzia CARUSO 1965 Cavalese Italian Margherita CASANOVA 1972 Bari Italian Stefano Maria CASIRAGHI 1958 Milan Italian Claudia CASTELLINO 1967 Cuneo Italian Annalisa CAVALLO 1977 Empoli Italian Maria CENCI 1967 Rome Italian Luigi CIANCIO 1963 Policoro Italian Maria Domenica CIPRIANI 1971 Rome Italian Ciro CLEMENTE 1966 Elmas Italian Laura COCCHI 1967 Genoa Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

69.

27559/22

Abbona and Others

v. Italy

18/05/2022

Giancarlo ABBONA 1964 Torino Italian Francesco ABENAVOLI 1956 Reggio Calabria Italian Valentina ACCATTATIS CHALONS D’ORANGES 1973 Naples Italian Roberta ALBERIO 1972 Lodi Italian Andrea ALBERTIN 1965 Correzzana Italian Diego ANGIOLILLI 1978 Bergamo Italian Paola ARTIOLI 1972 Novara Italian Alberto Maurizio BACCELLI 1961 Viareggio Italian Sandra BACILIERI 1967 Salzano Italian Sandra BADOLATI 1965 Arcola Italian Luca BALDASSARRE 1973 Giurdignano Italian Vittoria BALDI 1965 Forte dei Marmi Italian Carlo BALLOI 1962 Loceri Italian Alberto BALZANI 1969 Rome Italian Rita BARALDI 1977 Ferrara Italian Michela BARAUSSE 1969 Capiago Intimiano Italian Tanja BARESIC 1966 Vicenza Italian Enza BARONE 1967 Naples Italian Francesca BARONI 1979 Castelnovo Ne’ Monti Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

70.

27561/22

Italiano and Others

v. Italy

20/05/2022

Giovanni ITALIANO 1962 Dragoni Italian Theodoros KOTSONIS 1965 Trento Italian Rosa Maria LACERENZA 1964 Rome Italian Gianluigi LALLI 1973 Gragnano Italian Mario LENTINI 1972 Valverde Italian Giuseppe LO BUE 1964 Misilmeri Italian Michele LOSCO 1978 Firenze Italian Giancarlo Carmelo LUCA 1969 Bronte Italian Stefano LUMINARI 1971 Modena Italian Claudia MACCHETTA 1976 Torino Italian Silvia MADAFFERI 1973 Rome Italian Francesca MADIA 1974 Rome Italian Maria Desirée

MAESTRINI 1964 Urbino Italian Marco MANCA 1959 Cagliari Italian Antje MANGILI 1975 Mozzo Italian Carmen MANTA 1976 Cascina Italian Luigi Antonio MARAFIOTI 1968 Cosenza Italian Mirka MARANGONI 1972 Montecchio di Valle Foglia Italian Paola MARCHETTI 1964 Parma Italian Milvia MARCHIORI 1962 Padua Italian Daniele MARSILLI 1964 Dozza Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

71.

28804/22

Di Marco and Zannolli

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Tiziana DI MARCO 1958 Chieti Italian Raffaella ZANNOLLI 1958 Pescara Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

72.

28825/22

Turchi

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Andrea TURCHI 1959 Ardea Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

73.

28828/22

Ruggiero

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Maria Teresa RUGGIERO 1967 Policoro Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

74.

28829/22

Manzo

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Gianluca MANZO 1970 Cava de’ Tirreni Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

75.

28831/22

Rossi

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Rosalinda ROSSI 1975 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

76.

28833/22

Lugini

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Antonio LUGINI 1973 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

77.

28835/22

Pasolini

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Giuseppe PASOLINI 1965 Sanzeno Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

78.

28838/22

Rossi

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Fabio Giovanni ROSSI 1973 Milan Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

79.

28842/22

Palazzolo

v. Italy

01/06/2022

Vincenzo PALAZZOLO 1972 Palermo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

80.

29041/22

Faraldi

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Leandro FARALDI 1952 Riva Ligure Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

81.

29047/22

Teti

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Rita TETI 1964 Vibo Valentia Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

82.

29058/22

Prussiani

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Alberto PRUSSIANI 1965 Brusaporto Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

83.

29064/22

Accardo

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Giovanna ACCARDO 1960 Palermo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

84.

29065/22

Bulfaro

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Donato BULFARO 1965 Sant’Arcangelo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

85.

29420/22

La Storia and Others

v. Italy

06/06/2022

Catello LA STORIA 1974 Naples Italian Cristina PADOVAN 1977 Egna Italian Martina LANTHALER 1971 Marlengo Italian Mauro Ivan LANZANI 1970 Brembio Italian Corina LEPADATU 1967 Milan Italian Luigi Mario LOMBARDO 1966 Viagrande Italian Maria Rita LUPATTELLI 1962 Rome Italian Elena MAGGIONI 1975 Monza Italian Roberto MAGNATO 1964 Merano Italian Fabiana MAGRINI PASQUINELLI 1968 Senigallia Italian Olimpia MAIORANO 1964 Cellamare Italian Cinzia MALATESTA 1966 Lucca Italian Veronica MALFATTI 1976 Padua Italian Raniero MALIZIA 1977 Manoppello Italian Pasquale MANSUETO 1966 Palermo Italian Antonia MARAGNO 1971 Albignasego Italian Ignazio Mario MARCOCCIO 1973 Brescia Italian Matteo Ezio MARGIOTTA 1975 Pratola Peligna Italian Federica MARINO 1976 Avigliana Italian Luciana MARINO 1958 Livorno Italian Emanuele MASSEROLI 1975 Monza Italian Maria Efisia MELONI 1962 Olbia Italian Antonella MEMMO 1971 Cernusco sul Naviglio Italian Elisa MICHIELETTO 1974 Scorzè Italian Marco MIRANI 1973 Voghera Italian Francesco MORGESE 1971 Massafra Italian Adriana NARDO 1967 Carlino Italian Raffaele NARDONE 1965 Merano Italian Christian NEGUT 1968 Guastalla Italian Giuseppe ORRÙ 1965 Cherasco Italian Davide PAPPALARDO 1967 Brindisi Italian Annamaria PARENTE 1963 Amorosi Italian Roberto PARRI 1960 Republic of San Marino Italian Alessandro PARRINO 1961 Palermo Italian Antonino PELLEGRINO 1963 Patti Italian Luca PERRERO 1971 Alessandria Italian Giovanni Salvatore PICONE 1956 Messina Italian Riccardo PIEROTELLO 1958 Capannori Italian Massimo PONTILLO 1963 Pozzuoli Italian Matilde PONTILLO 1963 Amorosi Italian Laura POZZANI 1978 Caprino Veronese Italian Arianna PRECISI O PROCISSI 1961 Cascina Italian Marta PUTZU 1976 Brescia Italian Stefania Maria Alessandra RADICE 1966 Paderno Dugnano Italian Piera REGHENZI 1962 Brescia Italian Elena RIGOLI 1973 Desenzano del Garda Italian Rosangela Maria ROMANO 1969 Potenza Italian Fabio ROSSI 1963 Anzio Italian Giulio ROVANI 1972 Pujant Italian Carmela RUCCIA 1967 Bari Italian Veronica RUSSOLILLO 1977 Portici Italian Francesco SAGONE 1977 Caltagirone Italian Matteo SALGARELLO 1969 Legnano Italian Valeria SANSONE 1976 Rome Italian Cinzia SANTAROSSA 1965 Abano Terme Italian Rita SCARAFILE 1963 Bari Italian Faustina Barbara SCAVELLI 1968 Catanzaro Italian Letizia SICHINI 1964 Jesi Italian Stefano SPOSINI 1964 Pisa Italian Daniela STACCA 1964 Sassari Italian Paolo STIVAL 1961 Briosco Italian Francesco STRINATI 1967 Terni Italian Alessandro SVETTINI 1970 Agrigento Italian Andrea TOMISELLI 1966 Siena Italian Valeria Elvira Rosa TONTODONATI 1966 San Donato Milanese Italian Silvia TRAMARIN 1978 Padua Italian Tiziana TRAPASSO 1963 L’Aquila Italian Giada TREVISANI 1975 Rome Italian Filippo Augusto TRINEI 1968 Bastia Umbra Italian Emiliano TURNU 1960 Elmas Italian Antonino TUTTOLOMONDO 1970 Palermo Italian Vittoria Maria VINCI 1967 Massafra Italian Andrea VINCIGUERRA 1974 Casier Italian Andrea ZANICHELLI 1972 Milan Italian Antonio ZANOBINI 1972 Firenze Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

86.

29551/22

Biasinutto

v. Italy

06/06/2022

Cristina BIASINUTTO 1965 Albignasego Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

87.

29561/22

Ucciero

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Giuseppe UCCIERO 1965 Catanzaro Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

88.

29589/22

Orsi

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Massimo ORSI 1968 Monguzzo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

89.

29594/22

Esposito

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Gabriella ESPOSITO 1968 Lissone Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

90.

29611/22

Brusati

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Carlo BRUSATI 1966 Genoa Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

91.

29612/22

Lapomarda

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Vincenzo LAPOMARDA 1961 Vieste Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

92.

29638/22

Favilli

v. Italy

31/05/2022

Francesca FAVILLI 1963 Calci Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

93.

29752/22

Perfetti

v. Italy

07/06/2022

Giovanni PERFETTI 1960 Massa Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

94.

29898/22

Pietrobattista

v. Italy

07/06/2022

Antonio PIETROBATTISTA 1951 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

95.

31179/22

Iacino

v. Italy

25/05/2022

Antonino IACINO 1959 Bologne Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

96.

31903/22

Miraglia Faciano

v. Italy

13/06/2022

Rosario MIRAGLIA FACIANO 1955 Palermo Italian

Sonia SPALLITTA

97.

31906/22

Magliano

v. Italy

13/06/2022

Antonella MAGLIANO 1973 San Giovanni a Piro Italian

Danilo BUONGIORNO

98.

31914/22

Lanari

v. Italy

16/06/2022

Luigi LANARI 1973 Falconara Marittima Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

99.

31928/22

Chioni

v. Italy

16/06/2022

Laura CHIONI 1970 Parma Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

100.

32907/22

Ventura

v. Italy

14/06/2022

Giorgio VENTURA 1965 Belvedere Marittimo Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

101.

35435/22

Segreto and Others

v. Italy

06/07/2022

Serenella SEGRETO 1956 Rome Italian Alessandro SICILIANI 1973 Bologna Italian Carlo Alberto SILVESTRI 1971 Sassocorvaro Italian Anna SILVESTRO 1965 Castellabate Italian Licia Maria STRANO 1966 Gravina di Catania Italian Marika TUTINO 1972 Palermo Italian Fulvio VERGARI 1964 Rome Italian Valeria VIASSOLO 1978 Padua Italian Giorgio ZAVARISE 1966 Negrar Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

102.

36178/22

Burani and Others

v. Italy

15/06/2022

Paola BURANI 1969 Perugia Italian Sergio SCALISE PANTUSO 1976 Perugia Italian Vincenzo DE ROSE 1971 Perugia Italian Fabrizio PUGLIESE 1974 Foligno Italian Luca PUGLIESE 1976 Crotone Italian Graziella PAGLIARO 1976 Vibo Valentia Italian Giovanna BAGNASCO 1978 Altavilla Milicia Italian Antonino SAMMARTANO 1971 Santa Flavia Italian Ilenia FOLLETTI 1973 Monteleone di Orvieto Italian Valentina CICIONI 1972 Perugia Italian Chiara MOCHI 1972 Rome Italian Francesco GRASSELLI 1973 Terni Italian Danilo DI GIORGI 1973 Rome Italian

Giuseppe CAPUTO

103.

36297/22

Galbo and Others

v. Italy

14/07/2022

Loreto GALBO 1958 Palermo Italian Alessandra GALETTI 1966 Modena Italian Pasquale GALLINA 1959 Signa Italian Guido GALLO 1959 Torino Italian Giovanni GANGEMI 1964 Avola Italian Alberto GASPARINI 1958 Milan Italian Ludovica GASTALDO 1963 Milan Italian Alessandro GAVEGLIA 1956 Latina Italian Antonella GHEZZI 1962 Carate Brianza Italian Anna Maria GIAMMANCO 1962 Bagheria Italian Renato GIARETTA 1956 Vicenza Italian Maria Luce GIOVINE 1963 Eboli Italian Lucia GIUDICEANDREA 1961 Rome Italian Francesco GIULIANO 1955 Giardinello Italian Elena GRANDE 1955 Sersale Italian Floriano GRANZIERA 1951 Spresiano Italian Michela GRAZIA 1962 Pianoro Italian Emilia GRAZIANO 1956 Boscotrecase Italian Giacomo GRILLO 1962 Afragola Italian Maria GRILLO 1964 Pescara Italian Giacomo GROCCIA 1957 Abano Terme Italian Romano GUERRA 1956 Monfalcone Italian Eleonora GUERRINI 1955 Mazzano Italian Grazia GUIDDO 1962 Valleggia Italian Dante GUIDETTI 1956 Monzambano Italian Manuela GUZZI 1964 Carugate Italian Emanuele Giuseppe GUZZI SUSINI 1959 Torino Italian Salvatore IANNELLI 1959 Lamezia Terme Italian Franco IONNA 1955 Naples Italian Benedetto IURATO 1956 Nichelino Italian Maria Rosa Felicia IZZO 1956 Caserta Italian Dionyssios KATSAROS 1958 Moncalieri Italian Salvatore LA MAGNA 1961 Santa Caterina Villarmosa Italian Eugenia Rosaria Lucia LASORELLA 1957 Potenza Italian Angela LAZZARO 1961 Trecastagni Italian Gennaro LEONE 1959 San Nicola la Strada Italian Patrizia LESSI 1958 Milan Italian Roberto Giuseppe LICCI 1959 Lecce Italian Marina LIDDEO 1957 Cartura Italian Marcello LINO 1955 Peschiera del Garda Italian Carmela LO RE 1965 Messina Italian Giuseppe LODI 1955 Modena Italian Alessandra LONGARETTI 1961 Agrate Brianza Italian Beatrice Ida Rosa LOSI 1963 Milan Italian Giuseppe MAGARELLI 1958 Lavello Italian Angela MAGAZÙ 1960 Messina Italian Sandro MAINARDI 1959 Torino Italian Maria Luisa MALVESTITI 1953 Desio Italian Franco MANCA 1960 Savona Italian Pietro MANCINI 1956 Catanzaro Italian Lauretta MANENTI 1955 Rapolano Terme Italian Annamaria MANGANO 1955 Messina Italian Marina MANGIAGALLI 1963 Milan Italian Salvatore MANGRAVITI 1949 Genoa Italian Maria Elisabetta MANNELLO 1958 Taranto Italian Adelaide MANZO 1957 Serino Italian Daniela MARANGONI 1957 Ravenna Italian Paolo MARCHESANO 1956 San Sebastiano al Vesuvio Italian Fabio MARCONI 1956 Vicenza Italian Sergio MARIANI 1960 Rome Italian Valeria MARINELLI 1959 Pescara Italian Giampaolo MAROLLA 1957 Milan Italian Luca MAROZIO 1960 Nichelino Italian Aurelio MARTINI 1949 Torino Italian Giorgio MARTINO 1963 Lecce Italian Patrizia MASCARELLO 1965 Trofarello Italian Stefano MASIERO 1964 Abano Terme Italian Giuseppe MASNATA 1958 Cagliari Italian Luciana MATZEU 1954 Genoa Italian Marina MAURIELLO 1955 Penne Italian Bombina MAZZA 1957 Rossano Italian Franco MAZZA 1959 Viterbo Italian Giancarlo MAZZARELLA 1960 Caserta Italian Antonio MAZZEI 1957 Marano di Napoli Italian Luigina MECOZZI 1954 Monte Porzio Catone Italian Luigi MESURACA 1955 Catania Italian Maria MIGLIARESI CAPUTI 1957 San Giovanni in Fiore Italian Maria Luisa MILONE 1949 Volpiano Italian Vincenzo Maria MONDA 1964 Ferrara Italian Luca MONDAZZI 1960 Cabiate Italian Domenico MONETTI 1959 Rome Italian Alessandro MONOPOLI 1953 Rome Italian Anna Maria MORABITO 1958 Reggio Calabria Italian Letterio MORABITO 1958 San Filippo del Mela Italian Franco MOSCATELLI 1955 Mentana Italian Vincenzo MUSTACA 1959 Casignana Italian Maria Grazia NIBALI 1962 Castelnovo Ne’ Monti Italian Carmelo NIUTTA 1952 Caulonia Marina Italian Chiara NOSENGO 1957 Torino Italian Nicolò OBISO 1956 Calatafimi-Segesta Italian Rosanna ODORIZZI 1961 Lona-Lases Italian Paola Maria Concetta ORLANDI 1959 Milan Italian Ottavia PACCAGNINI 1961 Desio Italian Massimo PACILLI 1957 Rome Italian Massimo PADOAN 1957 Chioggia Italian Paolo PADULA 1959 Genoa Italian Pasquale PALADINI 1955 Surbo Italian Raffaele PALAIA 1958 Naples Italian Vittorio PALMARA 1964 Messina Italian Tiziana PALMAS 1960 Cagliari Italian Patrizia PALMIERI 1955 Milan Italian Pietro PALÙ 1957 Parma Italian Fabrizio PANE 1959 Palermo Italian Sandro PANESE 1958 Venice Italian Paolo PANTALEO 1965 Bari Italian Giuseppe PARENTELA 1958 Catanzaro Italian Claudio PARISI 1957 Bassano del Grappa Italian Anna PARLATORE 1956 Bettola Italian Alessandra PARMEGGIANI 1956 Traversetolo Italian Paolo PASSAMONTI 1955 San Donato Milanese Italian Francesco PEDONE 1960 Maglie Italian Andrea PELIZZARI 1953 Capriolo Italian Giovanni PELIZZARI 1958 Brescia Italian Franco Enzo PELLIZZERI 1949 Messina Italian Patrizia PENAZZO 1963 Savona Italian Anna Maria PENNESE 1960 Segni Italian Pasqualina PENSATI 1965 Afragola Italian Giorgio PERETTI 1958 Brescia Italian Paola PERRINI 1960 Genoa Italian Virginia PERROTTA 1953 Olbia Italian Antonio PERRUCCI 1951 Ravenna Italian Teresa PESI 1957 Modena Italian Michele PIAZZA 1961 Catania Italian Ottavio PINNA 1958 Selargius Italian Danila PISANI 1963 Cornedo Vicentino Italian Roberto PISTILLI 1958 Rome Italian Andrea PIZZOLITTO 1960 Portogruaro Italian Claudio PLAZZOTTA 1960 Torino Italian Ottaviana PODESTÀ 1955 Arcola Italian Elena POLI 1961 Rivoli Italian Fausto PRETE 1959 Galatina Italian Francesco Rocco PUGLIESE 1949 Roseto Capo Spulico Italian Anna PUZZO 1961 Genoa Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

104.

36954/22

Abraha Woldekidan and Others

v. Italy

22/07/2022

Losief ABRAHA WOLDEKIDAN 1967 Foligno Italian Elisabetta CAMPANA 1969 Rome Italian Petronela NITA 1960 Ancona Romanian Francesca ALFONSI 1962 Avezzano Italian Serenella ALIMENTI 1971 Rome Italian Claudio ALTOBELLI 1969 Rome Italian Stelio ALVINO 1964 Magione Italian Paola ANDREANI 1960 Paris Italian Luca ANGELELLI 1960 Santa Maria Nuova Italian Rossella ANNESE 1970 Rome Italian Paola ARCURI 1965 Rome Italian Luca ARDUINI 1966 Cuneo Italian Luca BALDASSARRI HOGER VON HOGERSTHAL 1968 Rome Italian Erica BASSETTI 1969 Rome Italian Maria Elena BAVIERA 1968 Rome Italian Maria Ludovica BENDONI PENTIMALLI 1961 Rome Italian Francesco BOCCACCINI 1965 Rome Italian Rosaria BONGARZONE 1967 Ancona Italian Paola BONGINELLI 1968 Rome Italian Giuliana BORSETTI 1971 Rome Italian Paolo BRANCALEONI 1963 Piobbico Italian Pantaleo CALÒ 1963 Ancona Italian Claudio CARILLO 1965 Rome Italian Walter CASAGRANDE 1970 Senigallia Italian Gianfranco CASCIELLO 1963 Nettuno Italian Camilla CASI 1967 Poggibonsi Italian Giovanni CECCARINI 1971 Livorno Italian Manuela CERQUETI 1966 Tolentino Italian Paola CHELAZZI 1962 Ancona Italian Marina CHERUBINI 1962 Capena Italian Melania CHIANESE 1973 Rome Italian Raffaele CHIARELLI 1969 Rome Italian Nunzia Antonella CHIECHI 1969 Rome Italian Francesca CIANO 1970 Rome Italian Maria CLAPS 1960 Rome Italian Mattia CLEMENTI 1968 Gubbio Italian Elena COSTI 1969 Rieti Italian Alfonso D ANNA 1968 Rome Italian Antonio D’AGOSTINI 1963 Amaseno Indian Donato D’ALESIO 1966 Tagliacozzo Indian Ezio DE ANGELIS 1965 Rome Italian Elvira DE GENNARO 1967 Rome Italian Marco DE NICOLÒ 1967 Rome German Angelo DE SANCTIS 1956 Ancona Italian Claudio DE SANTIS 1966 Frascati South African Monica DEL SOLE 1969 Viterbo Italian Giampiero DEL VECCHIO 1960 Campobasso Italian Sabrina DELMONACO 1964 Latina Italian Cecilia DI BIAGIO 1968 Rome Italian Malfisa DI CARLO 1964 Crecchio Italian Assunta DI COCCO 1963 Ortona Italian Anna Maria DI FABIO 1964 L’Aquila Italian Gabriella DI GIROLAMO 1967 Rome Italian Vito Nicola DI LECCE 1965 Matera Italian Donatella DI MASTROMATTEO 1955 Rome Italian Laura DIANA 1969 Velletri Italian Francesco DITURI 1965 Rome Italian Giuliano FALASCO 1968 Rome Italian Gabriele FALCONI 1972 Rome Italian Roberto FERRANTI 1963 Terni Italian Maria Gabriella FERRIANO 1965 Tivoli Italian Valeria FIASCHETTI 1970 Ciampino Italian Federica FICOLA 1965 Deruta Italian Claudio FIORANI 1964 Fiuminata Italian Franco Michelino FIORE 1967 Rome Italian Stefania Giovanna Paola FOSI 1970 Rome Italian Emanuela FRATICELLI 1961 Altidona Italian Gabriele GABRIELLI 1960 Ancona Italian Maria Alessandra GARDINI 1966 Rome Italian Maria Carmen GARGANESE 1966 Rome Italian Roberto GIAMMATTEI 1968 Rome Italian Marilena GIOVAGNETTI 1966 Macerata Italian Massimo GIULIANI 1965 Nereto Italian Carmen GRASSI 1964 Rome Italian Beatrice GRAZIANI 1965 Ancona Italian Romano GRAZIANI 1970 Gubbio Italian Paolo IACOVELLI 1963 Tivoli Italian Vincenzo IANNONE 1968 San Giovanni Val d’Arno Italian Pasquale Francesco Antonio LATO 1966 Rome Italian Federica LAVAGNA 1966 Terni Italian Silvio LIGUORI 1970 Rome Italian Carla LUPI 1964 Perugia Italian Francesco LUZI 1964 Falconara Marittima Italian Franca MANGIAGLI 1964 Rome Italian Lamberto MANZOLI 1971 Pescara Italian Eleonora MARCHI 1963 Borgo Maggiore Italian Luisa Marina MARIANI 1972 Fiano Romano Italian Maria Grazia MARINANGELI 1963 L’Aquila Italian Massimo MASSACCESI 1965 Osimo Italian Alessandra MONTOZZI 1964 Ancona Italian Cinzia Teresa MORETTI 1966 Tagliacozzo Italian Anna MOSCILLO 1971 Civitanova Marche Italian Maria Teresa MUNGO 1951 Rome Italian Carmela MUTINI 1968 Chieti Italian Cristiano NARDI 1969 Lanuvio Italian Stefania NONNO 1966 Perugia Italian Federico PAOLETTI 1965 Perugia Italian Patrizia PAOLINI 1969 Republic of San Marino American Renzo PARADISI 1967 Passignano sul Trasimeno Italian Enzo PARIS 1969 Avezzano Italian Fabio PASSAFIUME 1963 Rome Italian Danilo Francesco Giuseppe PATTI 1972 Rome Italian Luca PECORA 1964 Montelupone Italian Marco PELLEGRINOTTI 1966 Rome Italian Alessandra Maria PESENTI 1969 Rome Italian Carlo Maria PETRANGELI 1965 Rome Italian Paola PINCARDINI 1969 Monte Argentario Italian Margherita PIPPI 1965 Bevagna Italian Tommaso PIVA 1972 Ancona Italian Alfredo POMPILI 1965 Picenze di Barisciano Italian Stefano POTALIVO 1968 Rome Italian Mauro RAMUNDI 1965 Rome Italian Filippo RIZZELLO 1961 Rome Italian Vito RIZZO 1961 Rome Italian Pantaleo ROMANELLI 1969 Pozzilli Italian Valentina RUSCITTO 1966 Perugia Italian Emidio SANTORI 1965 San Benedetto del Tronto Italian Luca Onofrio SCAPPATURA 1964 Potenza Italian Maria Ilaria SCARDIGLI 1972 Rome Italian Monica SGOLASTRA 1971 Porto Potenza Picena Italian Patrizia SICILIANO 1968 Potenza Italian Igor SIROVICH 1966 Rome Italian Laura SPERDUTI 1955 Rome Italian Mariaiolanda SPITALERI 1971 Rome Italian Gian Maria Francesco STELLATO 1970 Genazzano Italian Gino TERREZZA 1961 Ficulle French Nicola TRAVAGLINI 1967 Castemedolo Italian Andrea VECCHI 1971 Ancona Italian Gabriella ZACCARDO 1966 Potenza Italian

Carlo RIENZI

105.

37173/22

Amadori and Others

v. Italy

28/07/2022

Fabrizio AMADORI 1971 Sassari Italian Giovanbattista MONTANO 1966 Cagliari Italian Salvatore APREA 1959 Massa Lubrense Italian Pierangela CARBONI 1970 Sassari Italian Alessandro CARIA 1972 Monastir Italian Rosanna CARTA 1968 Nuoro German Edoardo CARULLO 1964 Portici Italian Antonello CASU 1964 Sassari Italian Maria Caterina CHERCHI 1962 Ossi Italian Paolo CONCA 1971 Naples Italian Giuseppa CONGIU 1965 Mamoiada Italian Salvatore CONTE 1961 Casavatore Italian Antonio COPPOLA 1965 Castellammare di Stabia Italian Massimiliano COPPOLA 1970 Olbia Italian Pasquale CUOPPOLO 1973 Gesualdo Italian Giovanni Bruno CUSANO 1967 Selargius Italian Mauro DATI 1966 Agropoli Italian Anna Giulia Elena DE ANSERIS 1964 Serino Italian Stefano DEL GIACCO 1968 Cagliari Italian Paola Gemma DEPLANO 1957 Cagliari Italian Debora DI MAGGIO 1970 Naples Italian Linda FERRARO 1966 Naples Italian Raffaela FIGUS 1963 Iglesias Italian Giovanni FLORIO 1964 Pontecagnano Faiano Italian Antonio FRONGIA 1967 Iglesias Italian Emiliano Omar GALLO 1972 Sassari Italian Maurizio IACCARINO 1965 Naples Italian Maria Francesca MACCIONI 1957 Cagliari Italian Pasquale MADONNA 1968 Ercolano Italian Annalisa MANELLI 1960 Iglesias Italian Noemi Elisabetta MANZONI 1972 Sassari Italian Carmela MARSICANO 1965 Caserta Italian Alessandro MATTANA 1970 Oristano Italian Frieda MERCONE 1967 Maddaloni Italian Ines MICCIO 1963 Nola Italian Fabrizio MORACE 1965 Naples Italian Cesar Alfonso MOSCARIELLO 1962 Montella Venezuelan Tiziana MUDADU 1967 Buggerru Italian Carlo MULAS 1971 Cagliari Italian Mirella MUSCAS 1963 Villamar Italian Giuseppe OLLA 1959 Sinnai Italian Silvia ORRÙ 1962 Cagliari Italian Maria Germana Antonia ORRÙ 1965 Cagliari Italian Anna PAGANO 1965 Scafati Italian Maria Viviana PANI 1962 Villamar Italian Maria Teresa PELLECCHIA 1970 Avellino Italian Giovanni PIACQUADIO SALA 1971 Casagiove Italian Andrea PIBIRI 1966 Domusnovas Italian Francesco PINTUS 1971 Sassari Italian Antonello PIPPIA 1966 Porto Torres Italian Danilo PIRAS 1964 Capoterra Italian Maria Teresa PIREDDA 1966 Macomer Italian Adolfo PISANU 1966 Dolianova Italian Giovanni Maria PISANU 1964 Sindia Italian Annalisa PORCELLA 1970 Cagliari Italian Alessio PROST 1969 Sassari Italian Giampietro PUTZU 1969 Iglesias Italian Mariella PUTZULU 1970 Macomer Italian Luca RAINERI 1968 Naples Italian Paolo RICCHI 1968 Naples Italian Felice ROMANO 1965 Brusciano Italian Anna Stefania RUVINETTI 1961 Nuoro Italian Anna Maria SALE 1969 Sassari Swiss Lucia SANNA 1971 Sassari Italian Tonino SATTA 1968 Sassari Italian Pierfranco SCANU 1969 Sassari Italian Piero Luigi SCANU 1959 Cagliari Italian Maria Grazia SERRA 1965 Oristano Italian Ana Rosa SIAS 1964 Cagliari Italian Lucia SORIENTE 1966 Salerno Italian Sabrina SORO 1968 Cagliari Italian Marco SPAGNOLETTI 1965 Naples Italian Patrizia TIDONA 1964 Capua Swiss Nadia Lucia TOLA 1973 Sassari Italian Renato TRAPANESE 1950 Naples Italian Pasquale TRIMIGLIOZZI 1965 Giugliano in Campania Italian Marcello TUOSTO 1965 Macerata Campania Italian Marco VINCI 1966 Genoni Italian Antonio VOLPE 1961 Laurito Italian

Carlo RIENZI

106.

37367/22

Orlando

v. Italy

22/07/2022

Giuseppe ORLANDO 1970 Rome Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

107.

37370/22

Vagliasindi and Others

v. Italy

22/07/2022

Alessio VAGLIASINDI 1967 Ravenna Italian Luigi VALOROSO 1973 Livorno Italian Simonetta VENTURI 1966 Genoa Italian Ruggero VERCELLI 1975 Milan Italian Eva VEROPALUMBO 1973 Grosseto Italian Loredana Rosaria VILLARI 1966 Catania Italian Salvatore VISCONTI 1963 Bagheria Italian Claudia VOLTOLINA 1973 Verona Italian Debora Concettina ZAMPINO 1969 Rome Italian Maddalena ZANARDELLI 1979 Alserio Italian Antonella Maria ZANETTI 1967 Rome Italian Giuseppe ZIRUOLO 1961 Rome Italian Ermanno ZITELLI 1967 Borgomanero Italian Alessia ZONCADA 1974 Cremona Italian Alessandra ZORZAN 1967 Savigliano Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

108.

37845/22

Neira and Others

v. Italy

22/07/2022

Dario NEIRA 1963 Torino Italian Maria Giustina NEVA 1964 Alanno Italian Alessandra NISI 1964 Guidonia Montecelio Italian Marcella NORMANNO 1957 Padua Italian Carlo OLIVIERI 1970 Novara Italian Pierina ONORATO 1964 Chieti Italian Giuseppina OTTAVIANO 1977 Porcia Italian Giuseppina PABA 1956 San Martino in Rio Italian Mariella PACE 1965 Orbassano Italian Michele PALLERI 1974 Città di Castello Italian Giuseppe PALMERI 1964 Gela Italian Alfonso PALUMBO 1963 Grotte Italian Pantaleone PAPARATTO 1964 Limbadi Italian Lucia PAVAN 1967 Selvazzano Dentro Italian Leonardo COCCIA 1996 Rome Italian Michele COCCIA 1999 Rome Italian Sebastiano PAZZAGLIA 1968 Rome Italian Simona PEDRETTI 1971 Modena Italian Tatiana PERCO 1976 Buccinasco Italian Giovanni Piero PERNICONE 1962 Catania Italian Vincenzo PERRELLA 1970 Giugliano in Campania Italian Fara PETRUZZIELLO 1974 Naples Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

109.

37868/22

Fazzini and Others

v. Italy

22/07/2022

Stefano FAZZINI 1977 Rome Italian Linda FÈ 1966 Acquapendente Italian Cinzia FEDERICI 1973 Cariati Italian Laura FERRARI 1967 Magenta Italian Teresa FIANDACA 1964 Palermo Italian Domenica FICHERA 1960 Acireale Italian Stefano FIGINI 1972 Lomazzo Italian Maria Grazia FILONI 1959 Galatina Italian Rossella FIORDALISI 1978 Montegiordano Italian Alessandro FIORINDI 1972 Brescia Italian Adele FORNELLI 1969 Bologna Italian Giuseppe FOTIA 1972 Rovigo Italian Maria Immacolata FRANCO 1964 Termoli Italian Arturo FRATTONI 1965 Pasturana Italian Marinella FULGHERI 1961 Gavi Italian Paola FULGONI 1967 Piacenza Italian Francesco GABBRIELLI 1965 Rome Italian Alessandra GAIARDO 1974 Padua Italian Antonio GALLUCCI 1967 Neston Italian Antonino GALUFFO 1974 Legnago Italian Maura GAMBERINI 1974 Gravedona ed Uniti Italian Paola GANDINI 1962 Vigevano Italian Elisabetta GARETTI 1966 Modena Italian Annarita GARGIULO 1973 Anacapri Italian Laura GARIBOTTO 1968 Sanremo Italian Ernesto GASTALDO 1968 Ponzano Veneto Italian Erik GEIGER 1973 Rome Italian Alessandro GENTILE 1971 Carlentini Italian Carlo GENTILE 1968 Brescia Italian Alessandra GENTILI 1965 Forlì Italian Giovanna GERARDI 1957 Campobasso Italian Monica GEREMIA 1970 Martellago Italian Mariateresa GESUALDI 1965 Bitritto Italian Tullio GHI 1973 Bologna Italian Gian Luca GHIRARDI 1963 Parma Italian Vittorina GHIRARDO 1973 Vigonza Italian Valeria GIANNÒ 1969 Borgo San Lorenzo Italian Maria Teresa GIANNONE 1978 Catania Italian Paolo GIANSANTE 1964 Barcellona Italian Nadia GIARBINI 1969 Torri del Benaco Italian Francesca GIOVANNANGELI 1978 Rome Italian Silvana GIPPONE 1975 Novara Italian Eliana GIUFFRÈ 1977 Ravenna Italian Alessandra GOVONI 1968 Brisighella Italian Guido GOVONI 1963 Bologna Italian Marzia GRANDIS 1968 Campodoro Italian Massimiliano GRASSO 1974 Genoa Italian Francesco GRIPPALDI 1965 Aci Sant Antonio Italian Maria Tiziana GUADAGNO 1970 Santa Maria a Vico Italian Silvia GUGLIELMI 1979 Rome Italian Christian GURIOLI 1976 Ravenna Italian Danila IAVASILE 1969 Benevento Italian Marina Elisa IELASI 1961 Torino Italian Antonina ILARDO 1968 Lecco Italian Maria Cristina INSERRA 1979 Catania Italian Massimo Osvaldo JAUS 1965 Rome Italian Stefania LA FERRERA 1975 Gagliano Castelferrato Italian Massimo Renato Antonio LA RUSSA 1978 Chieri Italian Ivan LANATI 1965 Alassio Italian Maria LANZA 1963 Pisa Italian Fabrizio LAVRA 1972 Cagliari Italian Giovanni Batista LO FASO 1970 Caltanissetta Italian Umberto LOCUNTO 1974 Matera Italian Angela LOIODICE 1968 Corato Italian Licia LUGLI 1975 Carpi Italian Massimo LUPI 1965 Rome Italian Loredana MACALUSO 1973 Trieste Italian Rosa Maria MACCARRONE 1966 Como Italian Silvia MAGNI MANZONI 1971 Blessagno Italian Maria Luisa MANCINI 1965 Perugia Italian Rosa MANCUSO 1959 Palermo Italian Daniele Fabrizio MANELLI 1959 Noceto Italian Roberto MANFREDI 1964 Casorzo Italian Chiara MANIERO 1975 Paris Italian Antonio MANTOVANI 1975 Como Italian Lorenza MARCONI 1975 Massa Italian Blanka MARGALIC 1954 Rijeka-Fiume Italian Maurizio MARIANI 1965 Massa Italian Sabina MARIN 1969 Rome Italian Anna Chiara MARINI 1962 Pistoia Italian Claudia MARINI 1974 Arona Italian Leonardo MARINI 1964 Viareggio Italian Giovanni MARISCALCO 1976 Leicester Italian Lorella MARSELLI 1960 Pisa Italian Francesco MARTELLI 1975 Empoli Italian Salvatore MARTINI 1976 San Nicola la Strada Italian Elisabetta MARTON 1972 Treviso Italian Simonetta MASÈ 1967 Concesio Italian Cinzia MASINI 1966 Rome Italian Luca MASSARO 1965 Santa Margherita d’Adige Italian Concettina MASTROCINQUE 1961 Pisa Italian Marta MATTAVELLI 1978 Brugherio Italian Alessandro MATTIAZZO 1974 Torino Italian Emilio Luigi MAZZA 1973 Milan Italian Maria Teresa MELISI 1975 Agropoli Italian Marco MENCHINI 1969 Loro Ciuffenna Italian Paola MERGONI 1963 Trieste Italian Maria Vittoria MEUCCI 1959 San Polo dei Cavalieri Italian Emanuela MICELI 1973 Pavia Italian Luigi MINELLI 1967 Brescia Italian Sebastiano MININNI 1976 Brindisi Italian Claudia MINOTTO 1966 Mira Italian Daniela MINUTOLA 1973 Trieste Italian Mir Hasan MIR DJAHANBAKHSH LANGROODI 1950 Milan Italian Eleonora MOLLICA 1973 Pordenone Italian Giuliana Germana MOMBELLI 1970 Segrate Italian Efisia MONNI 1973 Pisa Italian Carmen MORANDI 1964 Cislago Italian Diego MORRI 1973 Trieste Italian Lara MORUCCI 1971 Cascina Italian Greta MOSCHINI 1975 Toscolano-Maderno Italian Vincenzo MULÈ 1957 Messina Italian Flaviana MURRU 1958 Parma Italian Giovanni MUSETTI 1965 Cesena Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

110.

37934/22

Cocci Grifoni and Di Marzio

v. Italy

22/07/2022

Silvia COCCI GRIFONI 1967 Folignano Italian Fabio DI MARZIO 1969 Folignano Italian

Carlo RIENZI

111.

38107/22

Urbani

v. Italy

22/07/2022

Moira URBANI 1967 Terni Italian

Marta PETROCCHI

112.

38797/22

Ali Ahmad and Others

v. Italy

29/07/2022

Anwar ALI AHMAD 1951 Castel d’Azzano Italian Maria Dolores CANTARERO VALLEJO 1960 Madrid Italian Marco CESCHI 1959 Peschiera del Garda Italian Vincenzo CREANZA 1954 Bari Italian Maria Rosaria D’AURIA 1957 Terracina Italian Walter DE MATTEIS 1957 Rome Italian Silvana GALDERISI 1954 Naples Italian Maria Antonietta LINZALATA 1957 Venosa Italian Francesca LOPEZ 1953 Adelfia Italian Bruno MORANTE 1955 Piazza Armerina Italian Vincenzo NEGRO 1949 Capodrise Italian Paolo PACCOI 1952 Rome Italian Sebastiano RIZZA 1957 Oderzo Italian Rossana ROSSO 1960 Torino Italian Filomena RUGGIERO 1954 Rome Italian Anna SANNINO 1955 Carate Urio Italian Gavina SOLINAS 1961 Sassari Italian Maria Nunziata VARVARA 1959 Gravina in Puglia Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

113.

38874/22

Fiorentino and Others

v. Italy

29/07/2022

Alessandro FIORENTINO 1974 Rome Italian Elisa GALLERANI 1973 Gallarate Italian Maria Assunta GALLO 1966 Querceta Italian Valentina GATTO 1968 Torino Italian Annalia GIALLOMBARDO 1964 Poggibonsi Italian Teresa GIOVANNIELLO 1973 Rome Italian Laura ILARDI 1972 Milan Italian Elisabetta LIVERANI 1969 Rome Italian Patrizia Maria MACI 1967 San Giovanni la Punta Italian Giorgio MARCHETTI 1968 Camerino Italian Gennaro MARINO 1960 Genoa Italian Alberto MAZZI 1964 Pomponesco Italian Massimiliano MIGLIORI 1968 Viareggio Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

114.

45054/22

Ferrantelli and Others

v. Italy

09/09/2022

Gaspare FERRANTELLI 1957 Alcamo Italian Cinzia GRANITO 1966 Agropoli Italian Raffaella LUSARDI 1973 Avigliana Italian Gabriella MARRA 1968 Monterotondo Italian Alessandro MENI 1969 Meda Italian Luisa MENOLASCINA 1977 Castegnero Italian Domenico PASTORE 1964 Bari Italian Donatella PEROTTI 1966 Guardamiglio Italian Francesco PIERRI 1966 Manduria Italian Giovanna PULCINELLI 1972 Tortoreto Italian Antonella ROSSI 1975 Rome Italian Carlo URAN 1967 Naples Italian Elena VACCARO 1963 Pianiga Italian Marta ZAROCCOLO 1977 Monteviale Italian Gianluigi ZAZA 1974 Bari Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

115.

46120/22

Allegrezza and Others

v. Italy

16/09/2022

Franco ALLEGREZZA 1969 Senigallia Swiss Emanuele ALZATI 1968 Legnano Italian Roberto AMATI 1968 Pistoia Italian Ignazio AMMATUNA 1973 Pozzallo Italian Sabrina ANTICOLI 1967 Rome Italian Sara BALZANO 1971 Villafranca Padovana Italian Angela BARBAN 1975 Ferrara Italian Emanuela BARBERIO 1974 Torino Italian Marianna BARROCU 1978 Sassari Italian Patrizia BO 1964 Torino Italian Tonino BONOMO 1961 Zanica Spanish Gaetano BRINDICCI 1975 Bari Italian Ivania CARRARA 1967 Pietra Ligure Italian Sara CASALIS 1975 Bra Italian Laura CASTELLANA 1968 Milan Italian Rosario CHIANESE 1966 Sassari Italian Laura CODELLO 1969 Castelfranco Veneto Italian Massimo CONTI 1966 Paullo Libyan Antonella CORALLO 1961 Catania Italian Concetta CORALLO 1965 Catania Italian Maria Giovanna COZZANI 1966 La Spezia Italian Giuseppa DEL CASTILLO 1954 Palermo Italian Debora DI FRANCESCO 1968 L’Aquila Italian Tiziana FAPORE 1961 Cascina Italian Angela Luigia FELE 1965 Sassari Italian Valeria FENZI 1969 Bussolengo Italian Stefano FINUCCI 1963 Rome Italian Patrizia FOLETTO 1965 Aosta Italian Giulia FRANCHI 1965 Sanremo Italian Giuseppe GATTI 1970 Trieste Italian Flavio Andrea GOVONI 1964 Rome Italian Walter Omar INOJOSA 1969 Vicenza Venezuelan Riccardo IVALDI 1962 Sassari Italian Mirko LOMBARDI 1972 Como Italian Laura LORENZINI 1973 Bologna Italian Antonella LORETTU 1970 Sassari Italian Alessandro LUCCHESE 1974 Messina Indian Antonella MAFFÈ 1969 Boves Indian Antonio MARCHEGIANI 1963 Pescara Italian Maristella MARCHETTI 1959 San Giuliano Terme Italian Monica MEUCCI 1962 Aosta German Emilia MIGLIANO 1965 Rome Italian Giulio MISITANO 1963 Vigevano South African Francesco MONEA 1957 Taurianova Italian Michela MORETTO 1972 Cairo Montenotte Italian Luigia MOSTACCIO 1969 Sorbolo Italian Anna Morgana NOCITA 1964 Livorno Italian Anna PALMISANO 1968 Mascalucia Italian Silvia PARESCHI 1978 San Giorgio di Piano Italian Maria Paola PIRAS 1976 Brescia Italian Laura PONTE 1965 Genoa Italian Alessandra POZZATO 1968 Aosta Italian Antonino PREVITI 1971 Torino Italian Silvia PROVERA 1972 Bussolengo Italian Lisa REALI 1972 Pistoia Italian Marco RIGHETTI 1966 Cambiago Italian Gaetano RIMEDIO 1965 Rome Italian Marcello SABA 1973 Cagliari Italian Micaela SILVESTRI 1972 Domodossola German Maria Elena SOLARINO 1973 Bari Italian Francesco SOPRANI 1972 Ravenna Italian Salvatore SPARVIERO 1964 Bitonto Italian Paola TORTI 1967 Charvensod Italian Andrea TURATO 1970 Vigonza Italian Massimo ZAMPERINI 1970 Verona Italian Simona ZERBI 1969 Cambiago Italian Germano ZURA 1967 Spoltore Italian Domenico BENEDETTO 1961 Switzerland Italian

Carlo RIENZI

116.

46228/22

Allegrezza and Others

v. Italy

16/09/2022

Franco ALLEGREZZA 1969 Senigallia Swiss Emanuele ALZATI 1968 Legnano Italian Roberto AMATI 1968 Pistoia Italian Ignazio AMMATUNA 1973 Pozzallo Italian Sabrina ANTICOLI 1967 Rome Italian Sara BALZANO 1971 Villafranca Padovana Italian Angela BARBAN 1975 Ferrara Italian Emanuela BARBERIO 1974 Torino Italian Marianna BARROCU 1978 Sassari Italian Patrizia BO 1964 Torino Italian Tonino BONOMO 1961 Zanica Spanish Gaetano BRINDICCI 1975 Bari Italian Laura Maria CARABELLI 1967 Milan Italian Ivania CARRARA 1967 Pietra Ligure Italian Sara CASALIS 1975 Bra Italian Laura CASTELLANA 1968 Milan Italian Rosario CHIANESE 1966 Sassari Italian Laura CODELLO 1969 Castelfranco Veneto Italian Massimo CONTI 1966 Paullo Libyan Antonella CORALLO 1961 Catania Italian Concetta CORALLO 1965 Catania Italian Maria Giovanna COZZANI 1966 La Spezia Italian Giuseppa DEL CASTILLO 1954 Palermo Italian Debora DI FRANCESCO 1968 L’Aquila Italian Tiziana FAPORE 1961 Cascina Italian Angela Luigia FELE 1965 Sassari Italian Valeria FENZI 1969 Bussolengo Italian Stefano FINUCCI 1963 Rome Italian Patrizia FOLETTO 1965 Aosta Italian Giulia FRANCHI 1965 Sanremo Italian Giuseppe GATTI 1970 Trieste Italian Flavio Andrea GOVONI 1964 Rome Italian Walter Omar INOJOSA 1969 Vicenza Venezuelan Riccardo IVALDI 1962 Sassari Italian Mirko LOMBARDI 1972 Como Italian Laura LORENZINI 1973 Bologna Italian Antonella LORETTU 1970 Sassari Italian Alessandro LUCCHESE 1974 Messina Indian Antonella MAFFÈ 1969 Boves Indian Antonio MARCHEGIANI 1963 Pescara Italian Maristella MARCHETTI 1959 San Giuliano Terme Italian Monica MEUCCI 1962 Aosta German Emilia MIGLIANO 1965 Rome Italian Giulio MISITANO 1963 Vigevano South African Francesco MONEA 1957 Taurianova Italian Michela MORETTO 1972 Cairo Montenotte Italian Luigia MOSTACCIO 1969 Sorbolo Italian Anna Morgana NOCITA 1964 Livorno Italian Anna PALMISANO 1968 Mascalucia Italian Silvia PARESCHI 1978 San Giorgio di Piano Italian Maria Paola PIRAS 1976 Brescia Italian Laura PONTE 1965 Genoa Italian Alessandra POZZATO 1968 Aosta Italian Antonino PREVITI 1971 Torino Italian Silvia PROVERA 1972 Bussolengo Italian Marco RIGHETTI 1966 Cambiago Italian Gaetano RIMEDIO 1965 Rome Italian Marcello SABA 1973 Cagliari Italian Micaela SILVESTRI 1972 Domodossola German Maria Elena SOLARINO 1973 Bari Italian Francesco SOPRANI 1972 Ravenna Italian Salvatore SPARVIERO 1964 Bitonto Italian Paola TORTI 1967 Charvensod Italian Andrea TURATO 1970 Vigonza Italian Massimo ZAMPERINI 1970 Verona Italian Simona ZERBI 1969 Cambiago Italian Germano ZURA 1967 Spoltore Italian Domenico BENEDETTO 1961 Switzerland Italian

Carlo RIENZI

117.

48119/22

Amigoni and Others

v. Italy

27/09/2022

Angela AMIGONI 1966 Padua Italian Angelo ANDREINI 1975 Seriate Italian Loredana ARDUIN 1975 Lendinara Italian Demetrio BALDO 1964 Treviso Italian Monia BIANCHI 1971 Rodigo Italian Laura BORTESI 1974 Verona Italian Carlo BORTOLOTTI 1959 Verona Italian Sergio CANESTRINI 1975 London Italian Filippo CARDILLO 1969 Boltiere Italian Andrea CARRARO 1963 Noale Italian Irene CIMINO 1961 Padua Italian Giovanna COLANGELI 1962 Vigodarzere Italian Kathy FIOR 1973 Piazzola sul Brenta Italian Anna FORNASIERO 1970 Verona Italian Chiara GHIZZI 1966 San Pietro in Cariano Italian Giorgia GIORA 1974 Mira Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

118.

49554/22

Maresca

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Giovanni MARESCA 1969 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

119.

49561/22

Resta

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Mariachiara RESTA 1978 Bari Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

120.

49568/22

Albani

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Emma ALBANI 1972 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

121.

49572/22

D’Ostilio

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Annamaria D’OSTILIO 1967 Giulianova Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

122.

49576/22

Fortunato

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Maria Donata FORTUNATO 1964 Casamassima Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

123.

49583/22

Ferri

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Michele FERRI 1974 Monte Sant’Angelo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

124.

49671/22

Caleno

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Mariapaola CALENO 1969 Monte Argentario Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

125.

49692/22

Messinese

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Simona MESSINESE 1974 Grosseto Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

126.

49695/22

Grapeggia

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Melania GRAPEGGIA 1970 Pozzonovo Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

127.

49700/22

Foggi

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Paolo FOGGI 1969 Rome Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

128.

49707/22

Sangapur

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Rajshree SANGAPUR 1964 Montebello Vicentino Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

129.

49715/22

Pinna

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Francesca PINNA 1973 Cagliari Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

130.

49732/22

Sani

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Lucia SANI 1962 Firenze Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

131.

49738/22

Doneddu

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Ilaria DONEDDU 1966 Puegnago del Garda Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

132.

49741/22

Bresciani

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Marco Torkel BRESCIANI 1963 Milan Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

133.

49744/22

Poggi

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Luisa Maria Adele POGGI 1962 Motta Visconti Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

134.

49749/22

Cevolani

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Annamaria CEVOLANI 1959 Pieve di Cento Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

135.

49755/22

Cannarile

v. Italy

14/10/2022

Daniela Cecilia CANNARILE 1977 San Lazzaro di Savena Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

136.

51060/22

Bettonagli

v. Italy

25/10/2022

Monica BETTONAGLI 1974 Brescia Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

137.

51071/22

Chiuri

v. Italy

25/10/2022

Vincenzo Emanuele CHIURI 1974 Tricase Italian

Guido ANASTASIO PUGLIESE

138.

52064/22

Osti and Others

v. Italy

26/10/2022

Riccardo OSTI 1970 Stradella Italian Francesco PADOVANO SORRENTINO 1964 Cava de’ Tirreni Italian Antonio PALMIERI 1978 Reggio nell’Emilia Italian Maria Grazia PANCALDI 1972 Parma Italian Paola PANE 1966 Aci Catena Italian Massimiliano PANELLA 1969 Asigliano Vercellese Italian Danila PAPPALARDO 1972 Volterra Italian Roberto Carlo PARODI 1967 Santo Stefano al Mare Italian Federica PASE 1970 Zugliano Italian Paolo PATTONERI 1974 Parma Italian Sergio PAULI 1969 Morazzone Italian Silvia Paola PEDERCINI 1975 Bellinzago Lombardo Italian Ambra PELICELLI 1974 Colorno Italian Rosaria Donatella PELUSO 1961 Acireale Italian Rossella PERNA 1972 San Gregorio Magno Italian Sara PETRONI 1966 Rome Italian Caterina PEZZANO 1972 Patti Italian Stefano PIGELLA 1968 Bourgoin-Jallieu Italian Giovanni PINNA 1972 Assemini Italian Bruno PINTO 1965 Taranto Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

139.

56745/22

Bertolo and Others

v. Italy

01/12/2022

Corrado BERTOLO 1955 Venice Italian Antonio Salvatore Rosario BOCHICCHIO 1963 Rionero in Vulture Italian Vincenzo Maria BORRELLO 1962 Pisa Italian Michele CACCO 1963 Stra Italian Livia CALORIO 1965 Torino Italian Giovanna CALZÀ 1966 Stra Italian Benedetta CANOVARI 1974 Pesaro Italian Cristina CANTONI 1964 Castel Ritaldi Italian Rosa CARNUCCIO 1960 Spinea Italian Rossella CAU 1963 Selargius Italian Donatella CESCA 1964 Remanzacco Italian Federica CIANI 1966 Poggibonsi Italian Nicola CILLONI 1965 Bologna Italian Monica D’ADAMO 1967 Teramo Italian Alvina Shireen DIN 1958 Padua Italian Fabrizio DONZELLI 1964 Aprilia Italian Giovanna Franca FANELLI 1966 Milan Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

140.

4756/23

Novo and Others

v. Italy

16/01/2023

Monique NOVO 1971 Verbania Italian Francesco OLIVA 1973 Grottaferrata Italian Gabriele ORETTI 1961 Salsomaggiore Terme Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

141.

4858/23

Arnaboldi and Others

v. Italy

03/01/2023

Piera Maria ARNABOLDI 1965 Monza Italian Leonarda BALDUCCI 1963 Montesilvano Italian Gabriella Lucia Marinella CAVALERI 1967 Como Italian Francesca D’AURIA 1976 Treviglio Italian Marcello DI PASQUALE 1967 San Giuliano Milanese Italian Fabio FACCHINI 1971 Bologna Italian Teresa DI NATALE 1976 Bagheria Italian Giacomo GARGANO 2001 Bagheria Italian Marta GARGANO 2003 Bagheria Italian Diana GHEORGHE 1969 Siracusa Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

142.

6228/23

Panepuccia and Others

v. Italy

27/01/2023

Lea PANEPUCCIA 1964 Genazzano Italian Alessandro PAPI 1962 Piombino Italian Luigi PAPI 1964 Livorno Italian Mariacristina PARRAVANO 1976 Rome Italian Angela PATANELLA 1968 Torino Italian Germano PATRONE 1967 Ceriale Italian Roberto Ivo PATUZZO 1965 Milan Italian Roberto PERNA 1966 Avezzano Italian Barbara PERTICARÀ 1971 Bologna Italian Angela Chantal PETRILLI 1974 Rome Italian Maria Gaia PIACENTINI 1976 Milan Italian Rosaria PIATTI 1960 Noale Italian Marco PICANO 1972 Gallarate Italian Federico PICCARDO 1960 Genoa Italian

Marco TORTORELLA

143.

7473/23

Verzola and Others

v. Italy

03/02/2023

Adriano VERZOLA 1968 Castelnovo Bariano Italian Gianpaolo VIDILI 1974 Sassari Italian Luisa VISCARDI 1964 Avellino Italian Michele VITTURI 1965 Venice Italian Antonio VOZA 1972 Milan Italian Renzo ZAFFARANO 1966 Genoa Italian Giuliano ZEBELLIN 1953 Milan Italian Matteo ZIMATORE 1971 Milan Italian Giovannino ZOFREA 1968 Terni Italian

Marco TORTORELLA