Lexploria

FIRST SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 44684/22 SÃ¡ndor BÃ‰RES and Others

against Hungary

(see appended table)

The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 17 May 2023 as a Committee composed of:

Alena PolÃ¡ÄkovÃ¡ , President , Gilberto Felici, Raffaele Sabato , judges ,

and Attila TeplÃ¡n, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above application lodged on 3 September 2022,

Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the case,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

The list of applicants is set out in the appended table.

The applicants were represented by Mr V. Kodela, a lawyer practising in Budapest.

The applicantsâ€™ complaints under Article 6 Â§ 1 of the Convention concerning the excessive length of civil proceedings were communicated to the Hungarian Government (â€œthe Governmentâ€).

The Court received the friendly-settlement declaration, signed by the parties, under which the applicants agreed to waive any further claims against Hungary in respect of the facts giving rise to this application, subject to an undertaking by the Government to pay them the amount detailed in the appended table. This amount will be converted into the currency of the respondent State at the rate applicable on the date of payment, and will be payable within three months from the date of notification of the Courtâ€™s decision. In the event of failure to pay this amount within the above â€‘ mentioned three-month period, the Government undertake to pay simple interest on it, from the expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.

The payment will constitute the final resolution of the case.

THE LAW

The Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the application.

In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the case out of the list.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides to strike the application out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.

Done in English and notified in writing on 8 June 2023.

Attila TeplÃ¡n Alena PolÃ¡ÄkovÃ¡ Acting Deputy Registrar President

APPENDIX

Application raising complaints under Article 6 Â§ 1 of the Convention

(excessive length of civil proceedings)

Application no. Date of introduction

Applicantâ€™s name

Year of birth/ registration

Representativeâ€™s name and location

Date of receipt of Governmentâ€™s declaration

Date of receipt of Applicantâ€™s declaration

Amount awarded for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage and costs and expenses

per applicant/household

(in euros) [1]

44684/22

03/09/2022

(375 applicants)

SÃ¡ndor BÃ‰RES

1961

4. DIMENZIÃ“ KÃ–ZHASZNÃš ALAPÃTVÃNY

2004Rana ABDOOSH

1979Krisztina ÃDÃMNÃ‰ TURI

1968GÃ¡bor AGÃ“CS

1963LÃ¡szlÃ³nÃ© AMBRUS

1953ZoltÃ¡n ANDRÃSI

1972Istvan Gabor ANTAL

1965Karoly ANTAL

1961Szilvia BÃCSMEGI

1977MÃ³nika BAKOS

1981TibornÃ© BAKOS

1945Ferenc Bertalan BALAJTI

1956Lajos BALÃZS

1970GÃ¡bor BALOGH

1961GyulÃ¡nÃ© BALOGH

1966JÃ¡nos BALOGH

1938Roland BALOGH

1984Krisztina Zsuzsanna BALOGHNÃ‰ MEDE

1974TÃmea BALYI

1973TamÃ¡s BÃNYAI

1987TamÃ¡s BÃRÃNY

1971IstvÃ¡n AndrÃ¡snÃ© BÃRDI

1949Judit BÃRDOSNÃ‰ HARANGI

1972BÃ©la BARI

1953Orsolya BARNA

1981SÃ¡ndor MiklÃ³s BARNA

1956LÃ¡szlÃ³nÃ© BARTÃ“K

1973MihÃ¡ly BEKE

1950JÃ¡nos BENCS

1969JÃ³zsef BENCS

1957Krisztina BENE

1975ValÃ©ria Marianna BERECZ

1975Attila BÃ‰RES

1954LÃ¡szlÃ³ BÃ‰RES

1954TamÃ¡s JÃ¡nos BERNÃTH

1972AndrÃ¡s BODNÃR

1966ImrÃ©nÃ© BODNÃR

1963JÃ³zsefnÃ© BODÃ“

1961MihÃ¡ly BOLEGA

1970IstvÃ¡nnÃ© BORBÃ‰LY

1942GyÃ¶ngyi Ilona BORSOS

1955Bertold BOZÃ“K

1970IstvÃ¡nnÃ© BUDAHÃZI

1943JÃ³zsef BUDAI

1965LÃ¡szlÃ³ BUDAI

1952KÃ¡rolynÃ© BUJDOSÃ“

1955KÃ¡roly BÃšZ

1952Bernadette MÃ¡ria CSAPÃ“

1967MiklÃ³s ÃrpÃ¡d CSEGEZY

1942Zsolt CSÃ‰PÃNY

1974IstvÃ¡n CSIKÃ“S

1974Tibor JÃ¡nos CSILLAG

1956PÃ©ter CSIPE

1975EnikÅ‘ CSIZMÃR

1981JÃ¡nos CSONGRÃDI

1954Nikoletta CSONTÃ“

1987ImrÃ©nÃ© CSONTOS

1954GyulÃ¡nÃ© CSORBA

1951JenÅ‘ CUCIN

1970ÃrpÃ¡d CZAKÃ“

1959BÃ¡lint CZAKÃ“

1974BÃ©la FerencnÃ© CZÃ‰KMÃNY

1951GyÃ¶rgynÃ© CZENTYE

1950ZsoltnÃ© CZITROM

1968ErzsÃ©bet Zsuzsanna DALANICSNÃ‰ SARKADI

1969IstvÃ¡n JÃ³zsefnÃ© DANCS

1971Imre DARAI

1955LÃ¡szlÃ³ DEBRECZENI

1961EmÃlia DEME

1985DEPONA PLUSZ KFT

2008DEPONA PORT KERESKEDELMI Ã‰S SZOLGÃLTATÃ“ KFT

2011DEUTSCH Ã‰S TÃRSA VENDÃ‰GLÃTÃ“IPARI KFT

2006BalÃ¡zs GÃ¡bor DOBÃK

1973SÃ¡ndor DOMANICZKI

1959Judit Edit DOMONKOS

1961Katalin DÃ–MÃ–TÃ–RNÃ‰ CSÃSZÃR

1940SÃ¡ndornÃ© DÃ“SA

1972LÃ¡szlÃ³ DUBLINSZKI

1975DUNA HOUSE INGATLAN Ã‰RTÃ‰KBECSLÅ KFT

2009Gyula ELEK

1951LÃ¡szlÃ³ Lajos ELEK

1948Zsolt ENDRÃ‰SIK

1976BÃ©lÃ¡nÃ© ERDEI

1948SÃ¡ndornÃ© ERDEI

1945MÃ¡ria ERDÅSI

1956JÃ³zsefnÃ© FARKAS

1938Edina FARKAS-KISS

1978AndrÃ¡s FAZEKAS

1959AttilÃ¡nÃ© FECSÃ“

1974CsabÃ¡nÃ© FECZKÃ“

1963TibornÃ© FEHÃ‰R

1964LÃ¡szlÃ³ Imre FEKETE

1952Jozsef FERENCZI

1963Imre FINCZICZKI

1976Erika FODORNÃ‰ SZABÃ“

1965MiklÃ³s LajosnÃ© FÃ–LDES

1954Rudolf FÃ–LDI

1972BÃ©lÃ¡nÃ© FÃ“RIS

1942BÃ©la FORRÃS

1959JÃ¡nosnÃ© FRIEDEL

1942GÃ¡bor FRÃ“ZSI

1943JÃ¡nosnÃ© FÃœLEKI

1945Ã‰va FÃœLÃ–PNÃ‰ KOVÃCS

1970Gyula GALYAS

1959Ferenc GASPAREK

1971IstvÃ¡nnÃ© GÃ‰CZI

1964LÃ¡szlÃ³ GEREGUR

1963ZoltÃ¡n Ãkos GERGELY

1978Ottilia Anna GERHÃT

1948TamÃ¡s ErvinnÃ© GIBIZER

1970Zsuzsanna GIDÃ“FALVI

1958JÃ¡nosnÃ© GOLYÃ“SI

1946ZoltÃ¡n JÃ¡nos GÃ–RZSÃ–NY

1960IrÃ©n GUBIKNÃ‰ NYIKES

1955MihÃ¡ly Imre GYÅRI

1970KÃ¡rolynÃ© GYÃœKÃ‰R

1953HABIX KFT.

1997ImrÃ©nÃ© HAJNAL

1969FerencnÃ© HALÃSZ

1948SÃ¡ndor HARASZTI

1952Imre HEIZLER

1963JÃ³zsef HERCEG

1955BenedeknÃ© HERCZEG

1965Edit Arany HERCZEGHNÃ‰ FÃBIÃN

1949FerencnÃ© HEVESI

1970FerencnÃ© HOMOVICS

1952MihÃ¡lynÃ© HORNYÃK

1945Rita HORNYÃK-JUHÃSZ

1969SÃ¡ndor HORVÃTH

1959Betta HOVANECZ

1975IstvÃ¡n HUDÃK

1954IrÃ©n Ilona HUDÃK FERENCNÃ‰ KOSINCZKY

1940SÃ¡ndornÃ© HUSZTI

1965ZoltÃ¡nnÃ© HUSZTI

1958IGAZGYÃ–NGY ALAPFOKÃš MÅ°VÃ‰SZETI ISKOLA

2000IGAZGYÃ–NGY ALAPITVÃNY

1999SÃ¡ndor ILLÃ‰S

1974GusztÃ¡v ILLNER

1940IstvÃ¡n ILLYÃ‰S

1962INVENTAS KFT.

1991GÃ¡bor JAKAB

1958SÃ¡ndornÃ© JANIGA

1958GÃ¡bornÃ© JANKA

1956Ilona ErzsÃ©bet JARABEKNÃ‰ HUDÃK

1962PÃ©ter JÃSZKAI

1977SÃ¡ndor JÃ“NÃS

1975Tibor JÃ“ZSA

1967BÃ©la JUDIK

1952GyÃ¶rgynÃ© JUHÃSZ

1966JÃ³zsef JUHÃSZ

1958Katalin Ãgnes JUHÃSZ

1963DÃ¡vid KABAI

1989LÃ¡szlÃ³nÃ© KÃDAS

1955Ervin IstvÃ¡nnÃ© KADERJÃK

1944Ida KAJTÃRNÃ‰ VARGA

1947Lajos KAKUCSI

1940LÃ¡szlÃ³ ZoltÃ¡n KAPÃ‰RI

1951Gabriella KAPIN-LAKÃ“

1976IstvÃ¡n KÃRÃNDI

1960SÃ¡ndor KARI

1952LÃ¡szlÃ³ KÃROLYI

1964MiklÃ³snÃ© KASZA

1969ZoltÃ¡nnÃ© KAZAMÃ‰R

1950LÃ¡szlÃ³ KÃZMÃ‰R

1953Mariann KÃ‰ZSMÃRKI

1979GÃ¡bor KIS

1980AndrÃ¡snÃ© KISS

1959Ferenc KISS

1954GÃ¡bor KISS

1962GÃ¡bor KISS

1945DiÃ¡na KISS-SASS

1976JÃ¡nos KNYIHÃR

1939IstvÃ¡nnÃ© KOBA

1956EndrÃ©nÃ© KOCSIS

1959Lajos LÃ¡szlÃ³nÃ© KOCSIS

1962Zoltan KOCZIAN

1975ZoltÃ¡n TibornÃ© KONYHA

1957Piroska KOÃ“S

1950BÃ¡lint AttilÃ¡nÃ© KÃ“S

1964JÃ³zsefnÃ© DR. KOSCSÃ“

1956TÃmea KÃ“TINÃ‰ SZOKOLAI

1975Imre LÃ¡szlÃ³nÃ© KOVÃCS

1954JÃ¡nos KOVÃCS

1961JÃ³zsefnÃ© KOVÃCS

1967LÃ¡szlÃ³ ZoltÃ¡n KOVÃCS

1971Katinka IldikÃ³ KOVÃCSNÃ‰ MURA-MÃ‰SZÃROS

1961IstvÃ¡n KÃ–VESDI

1951IstvÃ¡n LajosnÃ© KRISTON

1949Zsuzsanna KRISTON-BODNÃR

1959Adrienn KRIZSOVENSZKI

1983Alexandra KULICS-BENE

1990Katalin KUTASI

1973IstvÃ¡n LACZKÃ“

1962JÃ¡nos LACZKÃ“

1947BoglÃ¡rka ErzsÃ©bet LAJSZNÃ‰ MURA-MÃ‰SZÃROS

1970IstvÃ¡n LAKATOS

1954JÃ¡nosnÃ© LAZÃNYI

1958ÃdÃ¡m LEHÃ“CZKY

1981LÃ‰TA-50 MEZÅGAZDASÃGI KFT

1999LÃ‰TAVÃ‰RTESI ARANYKALÃSZ MSZ

1990Lajos LIPPAI

1977AndrÃ¡s LOSONCZI

1987Bertalan LOVAS

1949GyulÃ¡nÃ© LOVÃSZ

1951LÃ¡szlÃ³nÃ© LUCSKAI

1966MAGYARORSZÃGI MAGISZTER ALAPÃTVÃNY

2000JÃ¡nos MAKAI

1971JÃ³zsef MARGITTAI

1957GyÃ¶rgynÃ© MARINKA

1964LajosnÃ© MÃRKUS

1975Attila ZoltÃ¡n MARTON

1959Tibor LÃ¡szlÃ³ MASSZI

1974DÃ¡niel MÃTÃ‰

1983JÃ¡nos MÃTÃ‰

1962Zsuzsanna Ã‰va MAUER

1965TivadarnÃ© MAYER

1965Ã‰va MENGYI

1980SÃ¡ndor MENGYI

1979MERKUR PAPÃR KFT.

1995ZoltÃ¡n MESTER

1980GyulÃ¡nÃ© MÃ‰ZES

1964Krisztina MILE

1968IstvÃ¡nnÃ© MOLNÃR

1955PÃ¡lnÃ© MOLNÃR

1958Csaba MORVAI

1963Hajnalka MURÃNYI

1974Tibor MUSTOS

1955Ferenc IstvÃ¡n NAGY

1962IstvÃ¡n NAGY

1967JÃ¡nos NAGY

1978JÃ³zsefnÃ© NAGY

1958KÃ¡rolynÃ© NAGY

1949KrisztiÃ¡n KÃ¡lmÃ¡n NAGY

1985Marianna NAGY

1977PÃ¡lnÃ© NAGY

1951Ã‰va NAGYNÃ‰ PAPP

1975LÃ¡szlÃ³nÃ© NEICHEL

1962ZoltÃ¡n NÃ‰METH

1961IldikÃ³ NOVÃK

1983SÃ¡ndornÃ© NYUSTI

1956AndrÃ¡s OLÃH

1952IstvÃ¡n OROSZ

1985JÃ¡nos OROSZ

1941ZoltÃ¡n BÃ©lÃ¡nÃ© OROSZ

1962Csaba OSVÃTH

1980ZoltÃ¡n JÃ³zsef PALÃSTI

1970GyulÃ¡nÃ© PALICZ

1944GÃ¡bornÃ© PÃLINKÃS

1960IstvÃ¡n PALLAG

1975ZoltÃ¡n IllÃ©s PALLOS

1955IstvÃ¡n Imre PÃPAI

1953BÃ¡lintnÃ© PAPP

1956BarnabÃ¡s PAPP

1966BÃ©lÃ¡nÃ© PARÃDI

1943JÃ³zsef PÃSZTOR

1960MiklÃ³s PEKÃR

1958Zsolt PERJÃ‰SI

1965PIXIS-2000 KFT.

2019POCSAJI MEZÅGAZDASÃGI SZÃ–VETKEZET

1990GyÃ¶rgy POGÃNY

1963Marian PÃ“KA-PALICZ

1940JÃ¡nos PREZENSZKI

1966PROMPT â€˜94 KFT

1972TamÃ¡s PUSKÃS

1963Judit PUTNOKI

1956PÃ¡l RADICS

1953MihÃ¡ly RÃKOSI

1959RichÃ¡rd RÃ‰NYAI

1980Zsolt RESCSÃNSZKI

1969JÃ¡nos IstvÃ¡n ROSTÃS

1946Zsuzsanna ROSTÃSNÃ‰ ENDRÃ‰SIK

1966Tibor SAFARCSIK

1955Zsolt SALÃNKI

1984SECURION BANKBIZTONSÃGI SZOLGÃLTATÃ“ KFT

1951Henrik SETÃ‰NY

1977SG MÃ‰RNÃ–K IRODA KFT

2012Zsolt SIKTÃR

1974GÃ¡bor SOLTÃ‰SZ

1941JÃ¡nos SOMOGYI

1945Ã‰va SOÃ“S

1955ST-RASZTER KFT

1997Arnold SZABÃ“

1977Attila SZABÃ“

1975Ã‰va SZABÃ“

1951Gyula SZABÃ“

1947IstvÃ¡n SZABÃ“

1964Zsolt SZABÃ“

1947Andrea SZALAI

1972ZoltÃ¡n ZakariÃ¡s SZALAI

1975GyÃ¶rgy SZALAY

1955ZoltÃ¡n GyÃ¶rgy SZALAY

1980Henriett SZANYINÃ‰ BAGI

1978SZATMÃR AQUA Ã‰PÃTÅIPARI KFT

2011ViktÃ³ria SZEGEDINÃ‰ GASPARICS

1953RozÃ¡lia Gizella SZELES

1949Attila SZELI

1960Tibor ZoltÃ¡n SZENYITA

1952Attila SZOKOLÃN

1980IstvÃ¡n SZOMBATI

1940GÃ¡bor SZOMOR

1973Ilona SZTOLÃR

1977Judit SZTOLÃR

1978MÃ¡rta IldikÃ³ SZÅ°CS

1970MÃ¡ria TAKÃCS

1963AndrÃ¡s Lajos TAPASZTÃ“

1966Eszter TARNÃ“CZI

1977ZoltÃ¡n TÃ‰CSI

1940GÃ¡bor TIFFENBACHER

1954TOKAJI WINE TRUST BT

1995Csaba MiklÃ³s TOKÃR

1977Albert TOLDI

1943ErnÅ‘ TÃ“TH

1972Hajnalka TÃ“TH

1974Lajos TÃ“TH

1951TamÃ¡s TÃ“TH

1985Vilmos TÃ“TH

1954Ãgnes TÃ“THNÃ‰ FEKETE

1976IldikÃ³ TÃ“THNÃ‰ VÃSÃRHELYI

1951Emil TRENYISÃN

1962IstvÃ¡n UJHÃZI

1971JÃ³zsef VADNAI

1948Zsolt VAKTOR

1984ZoltÃ¡n VALENTÃ‰NYI

1986ZoltÃ¡n VALISKÃ“

1976Ferenc VÃRADI

1953JÃ¡nos GÃ¡bor VÃRADI

1948JenÅ‘ VERÃ‰B

1972TÃ¼nde VERÃ‰BNÃ‰ BENCS

1965SÃ¡ndor VESZA

1959JÃ¡nos VIG

1957AndrÃ¡s VIGH

1945Judit VIZKELETI

1972TamÃ¡s VOLÃK

1977Erika ZAJA NORBERTNÃ‰ BENE

1977Judit Piroska ZÃMOLYI

1961PÃ¡l ZELENÃK

1957ZSÃKA COOP ZRT

2008BeÃ¡ta ZUPKÃ“

1975Household

SÃ¡ndor CSONTOS

1953Household

Imre DARÃ“CZI

1945Household

ZoltÃ¡n CSEH

1944Household

Tivadar BENCZE

1949Kodela Viktor

Budapest

14/04/2023

02/03/2023

1,300

[1] Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.

Menu

BÉRES AND OTHERS v. HUNGARY

BÉRES AND OTHERS v. HUNGARY

LEXI