Search
document

Document text Analytics

CASE OF SAMPANI AND OTHERS v. GREECE - [English Translation] by European Roma Rights Centre "ERRC"CONCURRING OPINION OF JUDGE KOVLER

Doc ref: • ECHR ID:

Document date: December 11, 2012

Inbound citations: 0
•
Cited paragraphs: 0
•
Outbound citations: 0

CASE OF SAMPANI AND OTHERS v. GREECE - [English Translation] by European Roma Rights Centre "ERRC"CONCURRING OPINION OF JUDGE KOVLER

Doc ref: • ECHR ID:

Document date: December 11, 2012

Cited paragraphs only

CONCURRING OPINION OF JUDGE KOVLER

I take note of the Court’s decision to award a relatively modest sum of EUR 1,000 to each of the applicant families for non-pecuniary damage. I find this approach objective and rational, given the Court’s emphasis on the general measures needed to integrate Roma children into the national education system. This approach contrasts with that of the Court adopted in the previous cases: EUR 4,000 to each of the applicants in D.H. and others v. the Czech Republic [GC], NO. 57325/00, ECHR 2007-IV; EUR 4,500 to each applicant in Oršuš and others v. Croatia [GC], no. 15766/03, ECHR 2010; EUR 6,000 to each in Sampanis and others v. Greece, no. 32526/05, 5 June 2008; and EUR 6,000 to each applicant (children aged six at the time and parents combined) in the recent judgment Catan and others v. Republic of Moldova and Russia [GC], nos. 43370/04, 8252/05 and 18454/06. It is never too late to do well.

ANNEX

(The term “Ako” is used by the applicants to refer to children whose first name is not registered)

First family (4 children and 2 parents)

1) Ioanna SAMPANI, born on 1 January 1994

2) Paraskevi SAMPANI, born on 15 April 1995

3) Ioannis SAMPANIS, born on 10 August 1996

4) Christos SAMPANIS, born on 18 August 1999

5) Spyridon SAMPANIS, born on 31 August 1972

6) Vasiliki MORATI, born on 20 January 1976

Second family (4 children and 2 guardians)

7) Aglaïa SAMPANI, born on 9 November 1994

8) Zografo SAMPANI, born on 29 March 1996

9) Andreas SAMPANIS, born on 29 March 1996

10) Georgia SAMPANI, born on 29 March 1996

11) Athanasios SAMPANIS, born on 20 March 1942

12) Maria KARAGOUNI, born on 15 April 1948

Third family ( 3 children and 2 parents)

13) Ioanna VELIOU, born on 30 March 1994

14) Kyprianos VELIOS, born on 22 March 1995

15) Christina VELIOU, born on 15 April 2000

16) Nikolaos VELIOS, born on 1 March 1966

17) Maria KARAHALIOU, born on 15 March 1970

Fourth family (4 children and 1 parent)

18) Chrysovalanto KARAHALIOU, born on 24 December 1995

19) Paraskevi-Aikaterini KARAHALIOU, born on 6 June 1998

20) “Ako” KARAHALIOS, born on 27 August 1999

21) “Ako” KARAHALIOS, born on 16 November 2000

22) Vasiliki KOURAKI, born on 29 November 1976

Fifth family (5 children and 1 parent)

23) Panayotis LIAKOPOULOS, born on 16 May 1995

24) Georgios LIAKOPOULOS, born on 2 February 1997

25) “Ako” LIAKOPOULOU, born on 30 March 1998

26) Gerasimos LIAKOPOULOS, born on 4 May 2000

27) “Ako” LIAKOPOULOU, born on 10 August 2002

28) Eleni LIAKOPOULOU, born on 26 March 1977

Sixth family (1 child and 2 parents)

29) Kyriakos SAMPANIS, born on 30 April 1996

30) Sotirios SAMPANIS, born on 1 January 1970

31) Aikaterini KARAHALIOU, born on 25 June 1970

Seventh family (1 child and 1 parent)

32) “Ako” PASIOS, born on 22 March 2004

33) Maria-Patra PASIOU, born on 29 September 1985

Eighth family (3 children and 1 parent)

34) Georgios KARAGOUNIS, born on 26 October 1994

35) Nikolaos KARAGOUNIS, born on 23 June 1999

36) Tsabika KARAGOUNI, born on 9 June 2002

37) Vasilios KARAGOUNIS, born on 13 May 1975

Ninth family (1 child and 1 parent)

38) Panayota PASIOU, born on 27 February 2002

39) Sofia PASIOU, born on 21 August 1981

Tenth family (4 children and 1 parent)

40) Ioanna BANDI, born on 28 May 1995

41) “Ako” BANDI, born on 10 July 1996

42) “Ako” BANDI, born on 5 December 1997

43) Ilias BANDIS, born on 23 July 1999

44) Magdalini LAZOU, born on 9 December 1979

Eleventh family (6 children et 1 parent)

45) Evangelia PASIOU, born on 2 January 1995

46) Vasiliki PASIOU, born on 13 December 1995

47) Mariana PASIOU, born on 20 September 1996

48) “Ako” PASIOU, born on 23 July 1997

49) “Ako” PASIOS, born on 26 August 2000

50) “Ako” PASIOS, born on 16 January 2003

51) Maria SIAMPANI, born on 14 May 1980

Twelfth family (2 children and 1 parent)

52) Ioannis SAMPANIS, born on 27 June 1999

53) “Ako” SAMPANIS, born on 19 July 2001

54) Christina LIATIFI, born on 15 December 1983

Thirteenth family (5 children and 1 parent)

55) Anastasia SIAMPANI, born on 2 August 1999

56) Vasiliki SIAMPANI, born on 10 March 1992

57) “Ako” SIAMPANI, born on 5 July 1994

58) “Ako” SIAMPANI, born on 5 July 1994

59) “Ako” SIAMPANI, born on 23 January 1997

60) Eleftheria KAMPERI, born on 1 May 1976

Fourteenth family (4 children and 1 parent)

61) “Ako” DALIPIS, born on 18 August 1998

62) “Ako” DALIPI, born on 23 January 2000

63) “Ako” DALIPIS, born on 20 April 2002

64) “Ako” DALIPI, born on 14 October 2003

65) Polyxeni DALIPI, born on 29 April 1985

Fifteenth family (3 children and 1 parent)

66) Anastasios TRIANTAFILIDIS, born on 6 June 1997

67) Maria TRIANTAFILIDI, born on 12 July 2000

68) Ioanna TRIANTAFILIDOU, born on 27 August 2002

69) Davidoula TRIANTAFILIDOU, born on 28 June 1979

Sixteenth family (6 children and 1 parent)

70) “Ako” TSAKIRI, born on 1 April 1995

71) “Ako” TSAKIRI, born on 1 April 1995

72) “Ako” TSAKIRIS, born on 12 August 1996

73) “Ako” TSAKIRI, born on 7 July 1997

74) “Ako” TSAKIRI, born on 15 October 1998

75) “Ako” TSAKIRI, born on 11 February 2003

76) Panayotis TSAKIRIS, born on 15 March 1976

Seventeenth family ( 1 child and 1 parent)

77) “Ako” RAMOS, born on 26 September 1998

78) Margarita PASIOU, born on 22 July 1973

Eighteenth family (1 child and 1 parent)

79) Eleni SIAMPANI, born on 1 August 2003

80) Aikaterini SIAMPANI, born on 21 December 1984

Nineteenth family (2 children and 1 parent)

81) “Ako” LAZOU, born on 7 July 2000

82) “Ako” LAZOS, born on 21 August 2003

83) Paraskevi BANDI, born on 9 February 1983

Twentieth family (2 children and 1 parent)

84) “Ako” PASIOU, born on 25 April 1995

85) Irini Chrysovalandi PASIOU, born on 3 March 2004

86) Antonia BANDI, born on 10 March 1978

Twenty-first family (3 children and 1 parent)

87) “Ako” KARAHALIOS, born on 17 August 1995

88) “Ako” KARAHALIOU, born on 9 November 1998

89) “Ako” KARAHALIOU, born on 28 September 2003

90) Irini KARAHALIOU, born on 24 November 1979

Twenty-second family (3 children and 1 parent)

91) Kyriaki KARAHALIOU, born on 16 April 1998

92) Aikaterini KARAHALIOU, born on 7 March 2000

93) Vaïa KARAHALIOU, born on 10 April 2002

94) Georgios KARAHALIOS, born on 10 October 1978

Twenty-third family ( 2 children and 1 parent)

95) Vasilios SAMPANIS, born on 16 July 2001

96) “Ako” SAMPANI, born on 13 June 2002

97) Kalliopi SAMPANI, born on 6 June 1984

Twenty-fourth family (3 children and 1 parent)

98) Maria SIAMPANI, born on 27 August 1995

99) “Ako” SIAMPANI, born on 28 May 1998

100) Yannoula SIAMPANI, born on 1 March 2003

101) Angeliki SIAMPANI, born on 7 January 1974

Twenty-fifth family (4 children and 1 parent)

102) Nikolaos MOURATIS, born on 12 March 1995

103) Eleni MOURATI, born on 28 February 1996

104) Anastasia MOURATI, born on 12 January 1997

105) “Ako” MOURATI, born on 14 January 1998

106) Ioanna SIAMPANI, born on 27 October 1979

Twenty-sixth family (1 child and 1 parent)

107) “Ako” KARAHALIOU, born on 19 February 1999

108) Zoe KARAHALIOU, born on 22 October 1969

Twenty-seventh family (2 children and 1 parent)

109) “Ako” TSAKIRIS, born on 27 March 1997

110) “Ako” TSAKIRIS, born on 25 January 2002

111) Christos TSAKIRIS, born on 14 September 1967

Twenty-eighth family (1 child and 1 parent)

112) “Ako” KAMPERI, born on 1 August 2003

113) Chrysovalandi KAMPERI, born on 11 March 1981

Twenty-ninth family (2 children and 1 parent)

114) Ioanna SIAMPANI, born on 29 December 1999

115) “Ako” SIAMPANI, born on 12 January 2004

116) Zoe SIAMPANI, born on 20 June 1981

Thirtieth family (3 children and 1 parent)

117) “Ako” SAÏNI, born on 5 December 1994

118) “Ako” SAÏNI, born on 5 December 1994

119) Ioannis SAÏNIS, born on 25 December 1995

120) Yannoula SAÏNI, born on 30 December 1977

Thirty-first family (1 child and 1 parent)

121) Maria-Eleni SIAMPANI, born on 12 December 2002

122) Vasiliki SIAMPANI, born on 30 March 1984

Thirty-second family (1 child and 1 parent)

123) Eleni SAMPANI, born on 6 December 2003

124) Christina SAÏNI, born on 3 May 1987

Thirty-third family (2 children and 1 parent)

125) Ioanna CHRISTAKI, born on 21 April 1995

126) Thomas CHRISTAKIS, born on 22 May 1997

127) Ioannis CHRISTAKIS, born on 20 June 1974

Thirty-fourth family (3 children and 1 parent)

128) Maria TSAKIRI, born on 3 April 1994

129) Ioannis TSAKIRIS, born on 16 October 1996

130) “Ako” TSAKIRI, born on 14 July 2001

131) Dimitroula TSAKIRI, born on 15 September 1976

Thirty-fifth family (1 child and 1 parent)

132) Evangelia SIAMPANI, born on 1 February 2003

133) Zoe SIAMPANI, born on 18 February 1982

Thirty-sixth family (2 children and 1 parent)

134) Panayotis TAFILIS, born on 31 July 1994

135) Paraskevas TAFILIS, born on 14 September 1996

136) Irini TAFILI, born on 8 August 1973

Thirty-seventh family (1 child and 1 parent)

137) Antonios GARAGOUNIS, born on 3 September 1994

138) Konstantia SALI, born on 10 November 1967

Thirty-eighth family (1 child and 1 parent)

139) “Ako” SAMPANIS, born on 27 April 1994

140) Vaïa TSAKIRI, born on 10 March 1956

LEXI

Lexploria AI Legal Assistant