PARTLY DISSENTING OPINION OF MR. N. BRATZA

                       JOINED BY MR. G.B. REFFI

      I fully share the conclusion and reasoning of the majority of the

Commission that there has been a violation of Article 2 of the

Convention in the present case by reason of the lack of any effective

investigation into the circumstances of the death of Abdulmenaf Kaya.

      Since the absence of any adequate and effective investigation

into the death similarly underlies the applicant's complaints under

Articles 6 and 13 of the Convention, I have not found it necessary to

examine separately the complaint under either Article.