SUREK and OZDEMIR v. TURKEYPARTLY DISSENTING OPINION OF MR E. A. ALKEMA

Doc ref: • ECHR ID:

Document date: January 13, 1998

Doc ref: • ECHR ID:

Document date: January 13, 1998

Cited paragraphs only

PARTLY DISSENTING OPINION OF MR E. A. ALKEMA

I have voted against the majority's conclusion that

Article 6 para. 1 has been violated in the present case.

The majority is of the opinion that the independence and

impartiality of a State Security Court are not warranted.

In my dissenting opinion in the Report of 20 May 1997 in the case

of Çiraklar v. Turkey, Application No. 19601/92, I have set out the

reasons why the majority's opinion is abstract and in need of further

foundation in fact and law in order to be justified.