ANDRIYEVSKIY AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA and 229 other applications
Doc ref: 53891/16, 35633/17, 57074/17, 64064/17, 79970/17, 19340/18, 20091/18, 20092/18, 20132/18, 22878/18, ... • ECHR ID: 001-215445
Document date: December 15, 2021
- Inbound citations: 4
- •
- Cited paragraphs: 0
- •
- Outbound citations: 0
Published on 24 January 2022
FIRST SECTION
Application no. 53891/16 Vitaliy Borisovich ANDRIYEVSKIY and Others against Russia and 229 other applications (see list appended) communicated on 15 December 2021
SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE
The applications originate from the conflict between Ukraine and the Russian Federation. They concern property rights to a number of land plots located in Sevastopol and, in application no. 37175/21, in Feodosiya.
Between 2004 and 2012 the Ukrainian local authorities allocated the land plots in question to the applicants or, in some cases, their previous owners for permanent use and allowed their privatisation. In most cases the legality of allocation of the land was subject to judicial review and was eventually confirmed by final decisions of Ukrainian courts. By the time the Russian Federation asserted jurisdiction over Crimea in 2014 most applicants/previous owners had finalized the privatisation process and registered full ownership title to the land plots under Ukrainian law.
When the Russian Federation asserted its jurisdiction over Crimea in 2014 all public property that had been nominally owned by the Ukrainian state, regional and local authorities was declared to constitute the property of the Russian authorities pursuant to, in particular, “Sevastopol City Council decision of 17 March 2014 no. 7156 on the status of hero-city Sevastopol”, “Decree of the Supreme Council of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea of 17 March 2014 on independence of the Republic of Crimea” and subsequent normative instruments. The Federal Constitutional Law of the Russian Federation No. 6-FKZ of 21 March 2014 (hereinafter referred as “6-FKZ”), which formalised assertion of Russian jurisdiction over Crimea under the Russian law, provided for transitional arrangements aimed at homogenizing regulation of, among other things, property and land rights and relations in Crimea and Sevastopol with the legal regime established in the Russian Federation. These transitional arrangements were subsequently extended several times and are to be partially in force until 1 January 2023.
The “Sevastopol City Law no. 46-SZ of 25 July 2014 on particularities of legal regulation of property and land issues” and the “Law of the Republic of Crimea no. 38-ZRK of 31 July 2014 on particularities of legal regulation of property and land issues”, which were adopted as part of such arrangements for Sevastopol and Crimea accordingly, guaranteed continuity of land ownership and permanent land use rights acquired by private individuals under Ukrainian law prior to entry of the 6-FKZ into legal force, unless an individual in question belonged to a certain exceptional category or the land in question was regarded as public property under the Russian law.
The new legal regime required that all real estates in Crimea and Sevastopol (publicly and privately owned or used) and the requisite titles to them be re-registered under the Russian law in corresponding registries and cadastres. Many of the applicants have successfully re-registered their titles to the above-mentioned land plots under the Russian law. Some of them sold the land plots to third persons after re-registration. Others purchased the disputed land plots after their previous owners had their titles fully established under the Russian law.
Nevertheless, at different points in time between 2015 and 2018 the Russian authorities brought lawsuits against the applicants with a view to claiming their land plots as public property and having their titles annulled. They argued that the allocation of the disputed land plots to private persons for permanent use did not fully comply with the Ukrainian law applicable at the material time. In some cases this was because, according to the Russian authorities, the land plots should have been treated as part of forest lands, historic, cultural or park zones and, as such, they should not have been transferred from public to private hands. Since, in the opinion of the Russian authorities, the initial allocation of the land plots for permanent use by the Ukrainian authorities to private individuals was unlawful, their subsequent privatisation, ensuing registration and re-registration of ownership titles as well as any other title deeds were null and void. Hence, they argued, the applicants’ titles were to be invalidated, the land was to be requisitioned from the current proprietors or users and “returned” to the pool of public property of the Russian Federation. In most cases it was the “municipal authorities” that brought such claims against the applicants. In some, however, it was the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation (MoD RF) that lay claim to certain land plots arguing that they should be regarded as falling within the boundaries of old military compounds, which MoD RF was now entitled to fully and solely own. In addition, the Russian authorities argued that the originals of the Ukrainian authorities’ decisions, whereby the land plots were allocated to the applicants or preceding owners, were missing from the official archives. This allegedly casted doubt on the authenticity and legitimacy of the applicant’s titles to the disputed land plots.
The Russian courts granted these claims and ordered that the applicants’ land plots be “returned” from the possession or use by private parties to the Russian authorities. Even though the Russian authorities’ claims directed against those applicants who had sold the disputed land plots to third parties were dismissed by the Russian courts, the judicial proclamation of illegality of the initial transfer of land titles into private hands enabled regression claims against them. In applications nos. 35633/17, 24218/18, 7097/20 and 9959/20 the applicants were ordered to compensate financial losses to individuals, who had purchased the disputed land plots from them prior to their requisition by the Russian authorities. In the application no. 24418/18, the applicant delayed payment of such compensation. Subsequently, when on her way to mainland Ukraine in Armyansk she was stopped by the Russian border guards and informed that she was banned from exiting the “Russian territory” pending settlement of her debt.
Relying on Articles 6 and 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 thereto the applicants raise the following complaints against the Russian Federation.
They argue that annulment of their titles and requisition of the disputed land plots ordered by the Russian courts constituted de facto expropriation of their property. According to them, this measure was arbitrary, did not pursue a legitimate aim and was not provided by law.
The applicants also argue that the Russian courts in Crimea, which ordered de facto expropriation of their properties
(a) did not afford them a fair hearing,
(b) were neither independent and impartial,
(c) nor were they established by law. According to the applicants, given that the legality of the privatisation process, which eventually led to the acquisition of ownership titles by the applicants under Ukrainian law, was verified and confirmed by the final decisions of Ukrainian courts, the de facto expropriation orders, which questioned it, were not in conformity with the res judicata principle.
In application no. 24218/18 the applicant also submits that the Russian authorities’ ban on her leaving the territory of Russia resulted in an unlawful and disproportionate restriction of her right to move freely within the territory of Ukraine (between Crimea and mainland Ukraine) guaranteed by Article 2 § 1 of Protocol No. 4 to the Convention.
In 56 applications the applicants also raise complaints against Ukraine. They argue that the Ukrainian authorities have not done enough to protect their property rights in Crimea against the de facto expropriation by the Russian authorities, in breach of their positive obligations under Article 1 of Protocol 1 to the Convention.
QUESTIONS TO THE APPLICANTS AND THE RUSSIAN GOVERNMENT
1. Have the applicants complied with the admissibility criteria set out in Article 35 of the Convention?
2. Do the facts to which the applicants refer constitute a violation of Article 6 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 thereto?
3. In application no. 24218/18, has there been a restriction on the applicant’s right to liberty of movement, contrary to Article 2 of Protocol No. 4?
4. Did the applicants have at their disposal an effective domestic remedy for the above-mentioned Convention complaints, as required by Article 13 of the Convention?
QUESTION TO THE APPLICANTS AND THE UKRAINIAN GOVERNMENT
In 56 applications, where the applicants also raise complains against Ukraine (see appended list), has there been a violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention on account of the Ukrainian Government’s alleged failure to protect the applicants’ property rights?
APPENDIX
List of applications concerned:
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality
Represented by
1.
53891/16
Andriyevskiy and Others v. Russia
26/08/2016
Vitaliy Borisovich ANDRIYEVSKIY 1954 Sevastopol Russian Aleksandr Petrovich KOTLYAROV 1981 Sevastopol Russian Vyacheslav Valeryevich ASRATYAN 1970 Sevastopol Russian Yelena Viktorovna LOZA 1979 Sevastopol Russian Aleksandra Viktorovna MOSYUNDZ 1970 Sevastopol Russian Yekaterina Sergeyevna MOSYUNDZ 1979 Sevastopol Russian Zoya Stepanovna KVASOVA 1953 Sevastopol Russian Vera Maksimovna NADVODNYUK 1950 Sevastopol Russian Olga Vasilyevna TRUSOVA 1948 Sevastopol Russian Natalya Lvovna PANKRATOVA 1958 Sevastopol Russian
2.
35633/17
Sentyukova v. Russia
06/05/2017
Yelena Ivanovna SENTYUKOVA 1952 Yalta Russian
3.
57074/17
Ivanova v. Russia
25/07/2017
Nataliya Anatolyevna IVANOVA 1986 Sevastopol Russian
4.
64064/17
Kotlyarova and Others v. Russia
15/08/2017
Galina Iosifovna KOTLYAROVA 1951 Sevastopol Russian Galina Maksimovna KOLESNIKOVA 1947 Sevastopol Russian Lyubov Maksimovna BLINKOVA 1943 Sevastopol Russian Nadezhda Maksimovna KULIKOVA 1949 Sevastopol Russian
5.
79970/17
Lysenko v. Russia
11/11/2017
Anna Valentinovna LYSENKO 1975 Sevastopol Russian
6.
19340/18
Boyko v. Russia and Ukraine
27/03/2018
Lyudmyla Stepanivna BOYKO 1939 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
7.
20091/18
Malinovskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
11/04/2018
Viktor Oleksandrovych MALINOVSKYY 1953 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
8.
20092/18
Bazhenov v. Russia and Ukraine
16/04/2018
Volodymyr Valeriyovych BAZHENOV 1972 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
9.
20132/18
Ryabova v. Russia
13/04/2018
Margarita Dmitriyevna RYABOVA 1988 Sevastopol Russian
Mikhail Aleksandrovich GORSHKOV
10.
22878/18
Babiy v. Russia
02/05/2018
Vladimir Ivanovich BABIY 1962 Kharkiv Ukrainian
Svetlana Aleksandrovna GLUSHCHENKO
11.
23420/18
Livkutnaya v. Russia
14/05/2018
Natalya Nikolayevna LIVKUTNAYA 1968 Novyy Urengoy Russian
12.
24218/18
Lavrenchuk v. Russia
08/05/2018
Olena Dmytrivna LAVRENCHUK 1972 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
13.
25040/18
Vakhrameyev v. Russia and Ukraine
17/05/2018
Vadim Georgiyevich VAKHRAMEYEV 1965 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
14.
26858/18
Koloskova and Others v. Russia
19/04/2018
Zhanna Sergeyevna KOLOSKOVA 1945 Sevastopol Russian Igor Anatolyevich MANYAKIN 1965 Sevastopol Russian Aleksandr Nikolayevich TUPILENKO 1961 Sevastopol Russian Yevgeniy Vladimirovich OZHEGOV 1986 Sevastopol Russian Svetlana Ivanovna SALNAYA 1958 Sevastopol Russian Anzhelika Valentinovna KARPOVA 1968 Sevastopol Russian Petr Nikolayevich TABACHNIKOV 1960 Sevastopol Russian Oleg Vladislavovich MENSHIKOV 1974 Sevastopol Russian Liliya Fedorovna ZOLOTYKH 1958 Sevastopol Russian Sergey Mikhaylovich VOROSHILOV 1954 Sevastopol Russian Nadezhda Ivanovna MAKHNO 1949 Sevastopol Russian Nataliya Stepanovna KORNEVA 1979 Sevastopol Russian Tatyana Vladimirovna LYALINA 1953 Sevastopol Russian Andrey Anatolyevich STAKHIY 1974 Sevastopol Russian Nadezhda Vasilyevna ZALIVAN 1982 Sevastopol Russian Raisa Petrovna SMOLINA 1940 Sevastopol Russian Yevgeniya Vladimirovna ULYANOVA 1965 Sevastopol Russian Yelena Anatolyevna SOBOL 1983 Sevastopol Russian Angelina Sergeyevna STORCHAK 1977 Sevastopol Russian Andrey Nikolayevich STORCHAK 1971 Sevastopol Russian Natalya Alekseyevna SUSLOVA 1976 Sevastopol Russian Tatyana Gennadyevna BATOVSKAYA 1979 Sevastopol Russian Petr Aleksandrovich YARUN 1970 Sevastopol Russian Vladimir Valentinovich OZHEGOV 1954 Sevastopol Russian Olga Vadimovna OZHEGOVA 1959 Sevastopol Russian Dmitriy Gennadyevich MEDVEDEV 1982 Sevastopol Russian Gennadiy Dmitriyevich MEDVEDEV 1958 Sevastopol Russian Vasiliy Vasilyevich ILCHENKO 1962 Crimea Russian Natalya Nikolayevna PALEY 1953 Sevastopol Russian Zhanna Sergeyevna PLUGAR 1963 Sevastopol Russian Olga Ernestovna FESSAK 1963 Sevastopol Russian Sergey Nikolayevish PTITSIN 1977 Sevastopol Russian
15.
30408/18
Melnik v. Russia
15/06/2018
Yelena Vasilyevna MELNIK 1965 Sevastopol Russian
16.
31445/18
Vinnikova v. Russia and Ukraine
22/06/2018
Ganna Grygorivna VINNIKOVA 1992 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
17.
31446/18
Vinnikov v. Russia and Ukraine
22/06/2018
Grygoriy Dmytrovych VINNIKOV 1960 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
18.
31509/18
Kondratov v. Russia and Ukraine
27/06/2018
Stanislav Grygorovych KONDRATOV 1975 Sevastopol Russian, Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
19.
31842/18
Tkachenko v. Russia and Ukraine
27/06/2018
Tetyana Mykolayivna TKACHENKO 1962 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
20.
31856/18
Sivtsev v. Russia
26/06/2018
Vladimir Nikolayevich SIVTSEV 1974 Melitopol Ukrainian
21.
31990/18
Degtyaryov v. Russia and Ukraine
22/06/2018
Oleksandr Viktorovych DEGTYARYOV 1977 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
22.
37808/18
Antonov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/07/2018
Arkadiy Anatoliyovych ANTONOV 1966 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
23.
38847/18
Mikhulya v. Russia
01/08/2018
Anzhelika Romanovna MIKHULYA 1971 Sevastopol Russian
24.
39034/18
Gutsol and Others v. Russia
06/08/2018
Galina Nikolayevna GUTSOL 1947 Sevastopol Russian Zhanna Sergeyevna KOLOSKOVA 1945 Sevastopol Russian Vasiliy Serafimovich GORYAINOV 1957 Sevastopol Russian Vladimir Aleksandrovich FEDKOV 1980 Russian Viktor Georgiyevich SHULGA 1954 Russian Lyudmila Alfredovna SHULGA 1958 Sevastopol Russian Andrey Igorevich BELITSKIY 1987 Russian Irina Nikolayevna OLONTSEVA 1987 Sevastopol Russian Svetlana Valentinovna VYLEGZHANINA 1972 Sevastopol Russian
25.
39128/18
Nurmatov v. Russia
04/08/2018
Sergey Kholovich NURMATOV 1972 Balashikha Ukrainian
26.
40991/18
Nesmikh v. Russia and Ukraine
21/08/2018
Sergiy Mykolayovych NESMIKH 1965 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
27.
42807/18
Sklyarenko v. Russia and Ukraine
28/08/2018
Svitlana Ivanivna SKLYARENKO 1965 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
28.
44104/18
Martynovskyy v. Russia
06/09/2018
Roman Yuriyovych MARTYNOVSKYY 1965 Kyiv Ukrainian
Mykola Viktorovych KIKKAS
29.
45907/18
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
24/09/2018
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
30.
47224/18
Kosyakova v. Russia
04/10/2018
Mariya Ivanovna KOSYAKOVA 1949 Sevastopol Russian
31.
50065/18
Markov v. Russia
12/10/2018
Denis Nikolayevich MARKOV 1980 Sevastopol Russian
32.
50499/18
Konopatskiy v. Russia
23/10/2018
Oleg Borisovich KONOPATSKIY 1964 Sevastopol Russian
33.
51946/18
Naminas v. Russia
30/10/2018
Aleksandr Vladimirovich NAMINAS 1962 Sevastopol Russian
34.
52048/18
Konopatskiy v. Russia
30/10/2018
Stanislav Olegovich KONOPATSKIY 1995 Sevastopol Russian
35.
52101/18
Kosyakova v. Russia
30/10/2018
Nadezhda Valentinovna KOSYAKOVA 1978 Sevastopol Russian
36.
53003/18
Nurtynova v. Russia
01/11/2018
Zhanna Vladimirovna NURTYNOVA 1970 Sevastopol Russian
37.
53015/18
Bulgakov v. Russia
07/11/2018
Vladimir Viktorovich BULGAKOV 1960 Sevastopol Russian
38.
53374/18
Krysina v. Russia
09/10/2018
Mariya Ivanovna KRYSINA 1938 Sevastopol Russian
39.
53538/18
Krysin v. Russia
09/11/2018
Andrey Anatolyevich KRYSIN 1965 Sevastopol Russian
40.
53547/18
Ilchenko v. Russia
09/11/2018
German Vasilyevich ILCHENKO 1984 Sevastopol Russian
41.
54352/18
Ivanyuta v. Russia
14/11/2018
Olga Anatolyevna IVANYUTA 1963 Sevastopol Ukrainian
42.
54397/18
Ilchenko v. Russia
10/11/2018
Vasiliy Vasilyevich ILCHENKO 1962 Crimea Russian
43.
55116/18
Glinskaya v. Russia
14/11/2018
Anna Georgiyevna GLINSKAYA 1986 Russian
44.
55407/18
Okorokov v. Russia
13/11/2018
Nikita Aleksandrovich OKOROKOV 1995 Sevastopol Russian
45.
56405/18
Skiba v. Russia
23/11/2018
Natalya Pavlovna SKIBA 1978 Sevastopol Russian
46.
56442/18
Bulgakova v. Russia
21/11/2018
Margarita Vladimirovna BULGAKOVA 1989 Sevastopol Russian
47.
57300/18
Yemets v. Russia
29/11/2018
Vitaliy Igorevich YEMETS 1992 Kyiv Ukrainian
Natalya Stepanovna YEMETS
48.
57346/18
Mamochka v. Russia
29/11/2018
Valentina Yakovlevna MAMOCHKA 1944 Sevastopol Russian
49.
57435/18
Movchan v. Russia
01/12/2018
Aleksandr Nikolayevich MOVCHAN 1984 Sevastopol Russian
50.
57531/18
Zhorova v. Russia and Ukraine
22/11/2018
Tatyana Dmitriyevna ZHOROVA 1957 Kyiv Ukrainian
51.
57554/18
Petrosyan v. Russia
29/11/2018
Syuzanna Artashesovna PETROSYAN 1987 Sevastopol Russian
52.
57586/18
Gaydamak v. Russia and Ukraine
22/11/2018
Yelena Vladimirovna GAYDAMAK 1953 Kyiv Ukrainian
53.
57976/18
Glozhik v. Russia
29/11/2018
Vitaliy Stepanovich GLOZHIK 1971 Crimea Russian
54.
58909/18
Gargola v. Russia and Ukraine
03/12/2018
Olga Pavlovna GARGOLA 1985 Kyiv Ukrainian
55.
59438/18
Glushchenko v. Russia
11/12/2018
Galina Mikhaylovna GLUSHCHENKO 1948 Sevastopol Russian
56.
59580/18
Potapenko v. Russia
17/12/2018
Svetlana Vladimirovna POTAPENKO 1965 Zaozernoye Russian
57.
59861/18
Klimtsov v. Russia and Ukraine
04/12/2018
Vadim Aleksandrovich KLIMTSOV 1988 Kyiv Ukrainian
58.
59869/18
Lizeykina v. Russia and Ukraine
04/12/2018
Valentina Ivanovna LIZEYKINA 1955 Kyiv Ukrainian
59.
421/19
Moysa v. Russia
20/12/2018
Kirill Vasilyevich MOYSA 1977 Sevastopol Russian
60.
548/19
Mark v. Russia
25/12/2018
Roman Georgiyevich MARK 1980 Sevastopol Russian
61.
574/19
Mark v. Russia
25/12/2018
Irina Sergeyevna MARK 1986 Sevastopol Russian
62.
1328/19
Pentrinchuk v. Russia
11/12/2018
Taisiya Ivanovna PENTRINCHUK 1971 Sevastopol Russian
Vladimir Sergeyevich VOLOGDIN
63.
1601/19
Glukhova v. Russia
03/01/2019
Yelena Petrovna GLUKHOVA 1983 Sevastopol Russian
64.
1691/19
Piven v. Russia and Ukraine
13/12/2018
Maksym Yuriyovych PIVEN 1988 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
65.
1815/19
Zvonik v. Russia and Ukraine
10/12/2018
Lyubov Ivanovna ZVONIK 1957 Kyiv Ukrainian
66.
2038/19
Usenko v. Russia and Ukraine
07/12/2018
Anastasiya Yuryevna USENKO 1982 Kyiv Ukrainian
67.
2546/19
Makhneva v. Russia
24/12/2018
Galina Ivanovna MAKHNEVA 1962 Moscow Russian
Yekaterina Borisovna BELOVA
68.
3949/19
Gaydash v. Russia
12/01/2019
Nikolay Lukyanovich GAYDASH 1940 Donetsk Ukrainian
69.
4937/19
Piven v. Russia and Ukraine
28/12/2018
Lyubov Oleksandrivna PIVEN 1965 Sadove Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
70.
5036/19
Osinina v. Russia
11/01/2019
Anna Alekseyevna OSININA 1941 Stolny Russian
71.
5164/19
Olontseva v. Russia
02/01/2019
Oksana Nikolayevna OLONTSEVA 1975 Sevastopol Russian
72.
5302/19
Nesmikh v. Russia and Ukraine
28/12/2018
Oleksandr Sergiopvych NESMIKH 1992 Sevastopol Russian,Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
73.
5647/19
Kozak v. Russia
17/01/2019
Yelena Rafikovna KOZAK 1969 Chelyabinsk Russian
74.
5763/19
Nesmikh v. Russia and Ukraine
28/12/2018
Oleksiy Sergiyovych NESMIKH 1991 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
75.
5832/19
Osinin v. Russia
11/01/2019
Aleksey Leonidovich OSININ 1970 Sevastopol Russian
76.
6194/19
Galanova v. Russia
21/01/2019
Yelizaveta Vladimirovna GALANOVA 1995 Donetsk Ukrainian
77.
8108/19
Sokratova v. Russia
05/01/2019
Zinaida Akimovna SOKRATOVA 1937 Sevastopol Russian
78.
8473/19
Bulatov v. Russia
25/01/2019
Roman Karpovich BULATOV 1977 Sevastopol Russian
Aleksandr Olegovich FILONOV
79.
9198/19
Belousova v. Russia
01/02/2019
Anzhela Yevgenyevna BELOUSOVA 1965 Sevastopol Russian, Ukrainian
80.
9561/19
Khoronenko v. Russia
05/02/2019
Olga Ivanovna KHORONENKO 1949 Sevastopol Russian
81.
10279/19
Okorokov v. Russia
07/02/2019
Aleksandr Vladlenovich OKOROKOV 1958 Sevastopol Russian
82.
13503/19
Klyuyev v. Russia
26/02/2019
Vladimir Pavlovich KLYUYEV 1958 Crimea Russian
83.
14077/19
Savishchenko v. Russia
28/02/2019
Tatyana Nikolayevna SAVISHCHENKO 1951 Sevastopol Russian
84.
14504/19
Myrkin v. Russia
07/03/2019
Oleg Dmitriyevich MYRKIN 1946 Simferopol Russian
Anatoliy Andreyevich MIKESH
85.
14786/19
Rudnitskaya v. Russia
13/03/2019
Yelena Igorevna RUDNITSKAYA 1980 Sevastopol Russian
86.
15416/19
Olontsev v. Russia
13/03/2019
Aleksey Nikolayevich OLONTSEV 1971 Sevastopol Russian
87.
15877/19
Rudnitskiy v. Russia
13/03/2019
Andrey Anatolyevich RUDNITSKIY 1961 Sevastopol Russian
88.
15892/19
Savishchenko v. Russia
02/03/2019
Anna Viktorovna SAVISHCHENKO 1977 Sevastopol Russian
89.
17083/19
Savishchenko v. Russia
15/03/2019
Tatyana Nikolayevna SAVISHCHENKO 1951 Sevastopol Russian
90.
17784/19
Okorokova v. Russia
19/03/2019
Galina Viktorovna OKOROKOVA 1961 Sevastopol Russian
91.
18246/19
Kosyakov v. Russia
26/03/2019
Svyatoslav Sergeyevich KOSYAKOV 1975 Sevastopol Russian
92.
18382/19
Ustinova v. Russia
19/03/2019
Anna Igorevna USTINOVA 1980 Sevastopol Russian
93.
18473/19
Ustinov v. Russia
31/03/2019
Denis Viktorovich USTINOV 1977 Sevastopol Russian
94.
18898/19
Vitrenko v. Russia
27/03/2019
Irina Tarasovna VITRENKO 1947 Sevastopol Russian
95.
19461/19
Chubay v. Russia and Ukraine
02/04/2019
Eduard Mykolayovych CHUBAY 1973 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
96.
19649/19
Makyeyeva v. Russia
01/04/2019
Natalya Volodymyrivna MAKYEYEVA 1974 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Roman Yuryovych MARTYNOVSKYY
97.
19682/19
Krysina v. Russia
28/03/2019
Larisa Vasilyevna KRYSINA 1966 Sevastopol Russian
98.
19822/19
Makyeyeva v. Russia
01/04/2019
Natalya Volodymyrivna MAKYEYEVA 1974 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Roman Yuryovych MARTYNOVSKYY
99.
20149/19
Mardovtsev v. Russia
10/04/2019
Sergey Nikolayevich MARDOVTSEV 1988 Noyabrsk Russian
100.
20156/19
Malyarov v. Russia
29/03/2019
Adolf Isaakovich MALYAROV 1937 Sevastopol Russian
101.
20406/19
Mardovtseva and Frentsel v. Russia
04/04/2019
Galina Nikolayevna MARDOVTSEVA 1979 Noyabrsk Russian Artem Olegovich FRENTSEL 1980 Noyabrsk Russian
102.
21456/19
Zamorin v. Russia
09/04/2019
Nikolay Mikhaylovich ZAMORIN 1952 Sevastopol Russian
103.
22667/19
Sinchenko v. Russia
02/04/2019
Vyacheslav Valeryevich SINCHENKO 1969 Crimea Russian
104.
22671/19
Yemets v. Russia
15/04/2019
Natalya Stepanovna YEMETS 1972 Sevastopol Russian
105.
22895/19
Vasylenko v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2019
Volodymyr Mykolayovych VASYLENKO 1970 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
106.
22998/19
Vasylenko v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2019
Yuliya Mykolayivna VASYLENKO 1968 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
107.
23053/19
Bolshakova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2019
Galyna Georgiyivna BOLSHAKOVA 1941 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
108.
23306/19
Yemets v. Russia
15/04/2019
Igor Igorevich YEMETS 1993 Sevastopol Russian
109.
23359/19
Khazakh v. Russia
23/04/2019
Nikolay Semenovich KHAZAKH 1950 Kramatorsk Ukrainian
110.
23558/19
Brezhneva v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Olena Viktorivna BREZHNEVA 1984 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
111.
23587/19
Novak v. Russia
20/04/2019
Yevgeniya Vasilyevna NOVAK 1983 Sevastopol Russian
112.
23738/19
Burenko v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Alla Anatoliyivna BURENKO 1955 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
113.
23918/19
Burenko v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Volodymyr Mykolayovych BURENKO 1952 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
114.
23925/19
Kuznetsova v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Yevdokiya Andriyivna KUZNETSOVA 1934 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
115.
24178/19
Bolshakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Sergiy Valeriyovych BOLSHAKOV 1969 Sevastopol Russian, Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
116.
25298/19
Vasylenko v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Volodymyr Mykolayovych VASYLENKO 1970 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
117.
25457/19
Sokolova v. Russia
18/04/2019
Marina Sergeyevna SOKOLOVA 1983 Krivaya Luka Ukrainian
118.
26348/19
Savchenko v. Russia
03/05/2019
Olga Borisovna SAVCHENKO 1967 Sevastopol Russian
119.
26352/19
Prokopenko v. Russia
13/05/2019
Bogdan Vladislavovich PROKOPENKO 1981 Sevastopol Russian
120.
27314/19
Agafonov v. Russia
13/05/2019
Anatoliy Fedorovich AGAFONOV 1941 Mykolayiv Ukrainian
121.
28518/19
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
122.
28521/19
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
123.
28525/19
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
124.
28528/19
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
125.
28530/19
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
126.
28532/19
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
127.
28535/19
Bornyakov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/04/2019
Oleksandr Sergiyovych BORNYAKOV 1982 Odesa Ukrainian
Andriy Viktorovych LESHCHENKO
128.
28541/19
Budakova v. Russia
18/05/2019
Irina Viktorovna BUDAKOVA 1959 Sevastopol Russian
129.
28549/19
Gorokhovir v. Russia
16/05/2019
Sergey Davidovich GOROKHOVIR 1958 Sevastopol Russian
130.
28609/19
Rudnitskaya v. Russia
18/05/2019
Lidiya Nikolayevna RUDNITSKAYA 1939 Sevastopol Russian
131.
28616/19
Antonov v. Russia
16/05/2019
Igor Fedorovich ANTONOV 1973 Sevastopol Russian
132.
28623/19
Rudnitskiy v. Russia
18/05/2019
Anatoliy Andreyevich RUDNITSKIY 1939 Sevastopol Russian
133.
29364/19
Babkov v. Russia
17/05/2019
Aleksandr Anatolyevich BABKOV 1973 Sevastopol Russian
134.
29368/19
Shmyreva v. Russia
18/05/2019
Natalya Stepanovna SHMYREVA 1950 Sevastopol Russian
135.
30256/19
Lyubarets v. Russia
30/05/2019
Oleksandr Vasylyovych LYUBARETS 1976 Chernigiv Ukrainian
Gennadiy Mykolayovych AVRAMENKO
136.
30482/19
Shayev v. Russia
23/05/2019
Aleksandr Georgiyevich SHAYEV 1964 Crimea Russian
137.
31136/19
Kushner v. Russia
28/05/2019
Yuliya Borisovna KUSHNER 1974 Sevastopol Russian
138.
31196/19
Zhuchkov v. Russia
07/06/2019
Igor Valeryevich ZHUCHKOV 1964 Afonino Russian
Tatyana Valeryevna SEREBRYANAYA
139.
31615/19
Nester v. Russia
05/06/2019
Maksim Aleksandrovich NESTER 1972 Sevastopol Russian, Ukrainian
Aleksandr Aleksandrovich KALINCHUK
140.
33210/19
Yermolayev v. Russia
14/06/2019
Aleksandr Borisovich YERMOLAYEV 1963 Kyiv Ukrainian
141.
33827/19
Shebalin v. Russia
19/06/2019
Andrey Yuryevich SHEBALIN 1972 Cherepovets Russian
142.
35474/19
Ozhegov v. Russia
20/06/2019
Yevgeniy Vladimirovich OZHEGOV 1986 Sevastopol Russian
143.
36866/19
Prozor v. Russia and Ukraine
05/07/2019
Maksym Viktorovych PROZOR 1984 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
144.
36928/19
Brezhnev v. Russia and Ukraine
05/07/2019
Oleksandr Volodymyrovych BREZHNEV 1958 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
145.
38630/19
Polev v. Russia
17/05/2019
Sergey Nikolayevich POLEV 1967 Moscow Russian
146.
41886/19
Kuznetsov v. Russia and Ukraine
29/07/2019
Oleksiy Yevgenovych KUZNETSOV 1974 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
147.
42102/19
Kostynskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
29/07/2019
Viktor Oleksandrovych KOSTYNSKYY 1959 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
148.
42349/19
Vasylenko v. Russia and Ukraine
29/07/2019
Volodymyr Mykolayovych VASYLENKO 1970 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
149.
43425/19
Kiriyenko v. Russia
27/07/2019
Irina Gennadyevna KIRIYENKO 1966 Leskolovo Russian Gennadiy Vasilyevich KIRIYENKO 1966 Leskolovo Russian Yevgeniya Gennadyevna KIRIYENKO 1989 Leskolovo Russian
150.
43754/19
Martynovska v. Russia
09/08/2019
Galyna Viktorivna MARTYNOVSKA 1964 Kyiv Ukrainian
Mykola Viktorovych KIKKAS
151.
44696/19
Myasishchev v. Russia
12/08/2019
Oleg Nikolayevich MYASISHCHEV 1973 Sevastopol Russian
152.
44697/19
Lvov v. Russia
12/08/2019
Timur Aleksandrovich LVOV 1980 Sevastopol Russian
153.
44821/19
Zubchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
15/08/2019
Lyudmyla Oleksandrivna ZUBCHENKO 1945 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
154.
44844/19
Dengaza v. Russia
18/08/2019
Olga Yuryevna DENGAZA 1979 Sevastopol Russian
155.
44900/19
Lentyakov v. Russia
14/08/2019
Kirill Vladimirovich LENTYAKOV 1978 Sevastopol Russian
156.
44965/19
Zhestkovskiy v. Russia
12/08/2019
Aleksey Aleksandrovich ZHESTKOVSKIY 1978 Sevastopol Russian
157.
45249/19
Chubay v. Russia
16/08/2019
Olga Valeryevna CHUBAY 1975 Sevastopol Russian
158.
45380/19
Movchan v. Russia
12/08/2019
Irina Valeryevna MOVCHAN 1959 Sevastopol Russian
159.
45504/19
Dengaza v. Russia
13/08/2019
Olga Yuryevna DENGAZA 1979 Sevastopol Russian
160.
45677/19
Arestova v. Russia and Ukraine
21/08/2019
Lyudmyla Valeriyivna ARESTOVA 1979 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
161.
45937/19
Burenko v. Russia
21/08/2019
Aleksey Vladimirovich BURENKO 1987 Sevastopol Russian
162.
46496/19
Brezhnev v. Russia and Ukraine
27/08/2019
Mykyta Oleksandrovych BREZHNEV 1986 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
163.
46504/19
Sydorenko v. Russia and Ukraine
27/08/2019
Iryna Viktorivna SYDORENKO 1972 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
164.
46664/19
Zubchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
27/08/2019
Mykhaylo Pavlovych ZUBCHENKO 1972 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
165.
46675/19
Grechykhina v. Russia and Ukraine
27/08/2019
Nataliya Sergiyivna GRECHYKHINA 1951 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
166.
47138/19
Savishchenko v. Russia
20/08/2019
Roman Viktorovich SAVISHCHENKO 1970 Sevastopol Russian
167.
47241/19
Malanchuk v. Russia
19/08/2019
Raisa Ivanovna MALANCHUK 1939 Sevastopol Russian
168.
47620/19
Krysin v. Russia
23/08/2019
Andrey Anatolyevich KRYSIN 1965 Sevastopol Russian
169.
47822/19
Mikhaylyuk v. Russia
19/08/2019
Viktoriya Stanislavovna MIKHAYLYUK 1987 Sevastopol Russian
170.
48434/19
Kapustin v. Russia
04/09/2019
Aleksandr Sergeyevich KAPUSTIN 1974 Simferopol Russian
171.
48768/19
Martynovska v. Russia
07/09/2019
Anastasiya Romanivna MARTYNOVSKA 1990 Kyiv Ukrainian
Mykola Viktorovych KIKKAS
172.
49464/19
Lentyakov v. Russia
10/09/2019
Vladimir Vasilyevich LENTYAKOV 1948 Sevastopol Russian
173.
49794/19
Sinchenko v. Russia
09/09/2019
Lyudmila Yuryevna SINCHENKO 1949 Sevastopol Russian
174.
51404/19
Korniyenko v. Russia
19/09/2019
Yevgeniy Yuryevich KORNIYENKO 1959 Sevastopol Russian
175.
51433/19
Stupina v. Russia
13/09/2019
Anna Vasilyevna STUPINA 1981 Sevastopol Russian
176.
51691/19
Myasishchev v. Russia
22/09/2019
Oleg Nikolayevich MYASISHCHEV 1973 Sevastopol Russian
177.
51767/19
Polev v. Russia
19/09/2019
Sergey Nikolayevich POLEV 1967 Moscow Russian
178.
51868/19
Demchenko v. Russia
22/09/2019
Anna Yaroslavovna DEMCHENKO 1952 Simferopol Russian
Maksim Yuryevich IZHIKOV
179.
51911/19
Maslov v. Russia
19/09/2019
Vladimir Andreyevich MASLOV 1954 Sevastopol Russian
180.
52337/19
Sidorchuk v. Russia
19/09/2019
Oksana Vladimirovna SIDORCHUK 1978 Sevastopol Russian
181.
52365/19
Rodionov v. Russia
22/09/2019
German Yevgenyevich RODIONOV 1969 Sevastopol Russian
182.
53339/19
Bushuyev v. Russia
04/10/2019
Sergey Anatolyevich BUSHUYEV 1958 Balashikha Russian
Oleksandr OVCHYNNYKOV
183.
54009/19
Shevchenko v. Russia
27/09/2019
Aleksandr Sergeyevich SHEVCHENKO 1979 Crimea Russian
184.
54177/19
Korobov v. Russia
06/10/2019
Valeriy Anatolyevich KOROBOV 1969 Sevastopol Russian
185.
55138/19
Sidorenko v. Russia
08/10/2019
Sergey Nikolayevich SIDORENKO 1970 Sevastopol Russian
186.
60589/19
Yakovenko v. Russia
12/11/2019
Viktoria Valeryevna YAKOVENKO 1971 Sevastopol Russian
187.
62091/19
Gorbachev v. Russia
27/11/2019
Andrey Viktorovich GORBACHEV 1977 St Petersburg Russian Ivan Viktorovich GORBACHEV 1982 St Petersburg Russian
188.
62616/19
Degtyareva v. Russia
27/11/2019
Lyubov Sergeyevna DEGTYAREVA 1954 Sevastopol Russian
189.
62711/19
Pushkareva v. Russia
27/11/2019
Oksana Pavlovna PUSHKAREVA 1972 Sevastopol Russian,Ukrainian
190.
62803/19
Rumyantseva v. Russia
26/11/2019
Yelena Ivanovna RUMYANTSEVA 1955 Sevastopol Russian
191.
63466/19
Shulga v. Russia
26/11/2019
Svetlana Nikolayevna SHULGA 1975 Sevastopol Russian
192.
64053/19
Terentyeva v. Russia
29/11/2019
Svetlana Grigoryevna TERENTYEVA 1946 Sevastopol Russian
193.
64160/19
Sharkov v. Russia and Ukraine
30/11/2019
Ivan Mykolayovych SHARKOV 1981 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
194.
64176/19
Sharkov v. Russia and Ukraine
30/11/2019
Ivan Mykolayovych SHARKOV 1981 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
195.
64179/19
Sharkov v. Russia and Ukraine
30/11/2019
Ivan Mykolayovych SHARKOV 1981 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
196.
64395/19
Brezhnev v. Russia and Ukraine
18/11/2019
Oleksandr Volodymyrovych BREZHNEV 1958 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
197.
309/20
Monchar v. Russia
06/12/2019
Boris Arkadyevich MONCHAR 1976 Sevastopol Russian
198.
864/20
Gadyuchko v. Russia
10/12/2019
Sergey Georgiyevich GADYUCHKO 1961 Sevastopol Russian
Maksim Yuryevich IZHIKOV
199.
914/20
Matyukhina v. Russia
06/12/2019
Inna Nikolayevna MATYUKHINA 1947 Sevastopol Russian
200.
1033/20
Korobov v. Russia
10/12/2019
Oleg Anatolyevich KOROBOV 1965 Sevastopol Russian
201.
1056/20
Korobova v. Russia
10/12/2019
Zinaida Vasilyevna KOROBOVA 1940 Sevastopol Russian
202.
1063/20
Monchar v. Russia
06/12/2019
Boris Arkadyevich MONCHAR 1976 Sevastopol Russian
203.
1583/20
Korobov v. Russia
12/12/2019
Valeriy Valeriyevich KOROBOV 1991 Sevastopol Russian
204.
1636/20
Monchar v. Russia
22/12/2019
Boris Arkadyevich MONCHAR 1976 Sevastopol Russian
205.
2693/20
Kazantseva and Ryabukha v. Russia
18/12/2019
Svetlana Viktorovna KAZANTSEVA 1986 Sevastopol Russian Yuriy Nikolayevich RYABUKHA Sevastopol Russian
206.
4216/20
Meleshko v. Russia
10/12/2019
Tatyana Aleksandrovna MELESHKO 1967 Balashikha Russian
207.
5397/20
Chesakova v. Russia
09/01/2020
Olga Valeriyevna CHESAKOVA 1978 Sevastopol Russian
208.
5793/20
Derugo v. Russia
17/01/2020
Svetlana SEmenovna DERUGO 1948 Sevastopol Russian
209.
7094/20
Kisilevskaya v. Russia
27/01/2020
Mariya Andreyevna KISILEVSKAYA 1992 Tyumen Russian
210.
7097/20
Voronov v. Russia
24/01/2020
Aleksey Viktorovich VORONOV 1973 Sevastopol Russian
211.
9959/20
Fakira v. Russia
06/02/2020
Larisa Gennadyevna FAKIRA 1963 Sevastopol Russian
212.
10372/20
Rusakova v. Russia
07/02/2020
Natalya Borisovna RUSAKOVA 1969 Moscow Russian
213.
13663/20
Monchar v. Russia
06/12/2019
Boris Arkadyevich MONCHAR 1976 Sevastopol Russian
214.
14032/20
Mamchur v. Russia
29/02/2020
Aleksandr Igorevich MAMCHUR 1988 Sevastopol Russian
215.
19623/20
Popova v. Russia
13/04/2020
Irina Borisovna POPOVA 1954 Sevastopol Russian
216.
19716/20
Maryshev v. Russia
13/04/2020
Petr Grigoryevich MARYSHEV 1960 Sevastopol Russian
217.
23074/20
Pavlenko v. Russia
01/06/2020
Yevgeniy Sergeyevich PAVLENKO 1981 Sevastopol Russian,Ukrainian
218.
27099/20
Zaytsev v. Russia
03/06/2020
Sergey Aleksandrovich ZAYTSEV 1973 Sevastopol Russian
219.
29391/20
Fursenko v. Russia
14/05/2020
Nadezhda Ivanovna FURSENKO 1947 Sevastopol Russian
220.
50509/20
Mednyy v. Russia
18/10/2020
Sergey Valeryevich MEDNYY 1976 Sevastopol Russian
221.
50515/20
Mamchur v. Russia
31/10/2020
Igor Vadimovich MAMCHUR 1965 Sevastopol Russian
222.
881/21
Osadchyy v. Russia
23/12/2020
Vitaliy Vyacheslavovych OSADCHYY 1959 Sevastopol Ukrainian
Sergiy Anatoliyovych ZAYETS
223.
14715/21
Nikolin v. Russia
22/02/2021
Vladimir Arkadyevich NIKOLIN 1952 Sevastopol Russian
224.
14727/21
Yevstafyeva v. Russia
22/02/2021
Nina Ivanovna YEVSTAFYEVA 1948 Sevastopol Russian
225.
23337/21
Savishchenko v. Russia
11/01/2021
Tatyana Nikolayevna SAVISHCHENKO 1951 Sevastopol Russian
226.
37175/21
Belyakov v. Russia
06/07/2021
Aleksandr Mikhaylovich BELYAKOV 1959 Crimea Russian
Kseniya Yevgenyevna BEZRUKOVA
227.
37290/21
Shuklina v. Russia
15/07/2021
Alla Vladimirovna SHUKLINA 1957 Sevastopol Russian
228.
37294/21
Bonyar v. Russia
03/07/2021
Svetlana Mikhaylovna BONYAR 1975 Kyiv Ukrainian
229.
42276/21
Sokolenko v. Russia
10/08/2021
Nikita Aleksandrovich SOKOLENKO 1982 Kharkiv Ukrainian
230.
42297/21
Savishchenko v. Russia
08/05/2021
Tatyana Nikolayevna SAVISHCHENKO 1951 Sevastopol Russian