Lexploria

Resolution CM/ ResDH (2017)426 Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights 103 cases against Poland

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 7 December 2017 at the 1302 nd meeting of the Ministers ’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),

Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established concerning the excessive length of civil and criminal proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy in this respect (violations of Articles 6 and 13), as well as the lengthy pre-trial detention of certain applicants (violations of Article 5 § 3);

Recalling the respondent State ’ s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:

- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum ; and

- of general measures preventing similar violations;

Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;

Having examined the action plan provided by the government indicating the individual measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court (see document DH-DD(2017)1102 );

Considering that the question of the individual measures has been resolved as the domestic judicial proceedings have come to an end and/or the authorities have adopted measures to accelerate the pending proceedings and that the applicants whose pre-trial detention was criticised by the Court are no longer detained on this ground;

Having noted that the measures adopted to prevent excessively lengthy pre-trial detentions have been examined by the Committee in the Trzaska group of cases and in the Matczak case (see Final Resolutions CM/ ResDH (2014)268 and CM/ ResDH (2017)163 );

Recalling that the question of the general measures required to respond to the shortcomings established by the Court in the present judgments continues to be examined in the context of the Bąk , Majewski , Rutkowski and Załuska cases and that the closure of these judgments is without prejudice in any way to the Committee ’ s assessment of the general measures necessary to ensure the expeditiousness of civil and criminal proceedings and the effectiveness of the domestic remedy,

DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases and

DECIDES to close the examination thereof.

Appendix – List of cases

Cases concerning the excessive length of criminal proceedings ( Bak group)

Application

Case

Judgment of

Final on

28836/04

ABRAMCZYK

12/06/2007

12/09/2007

8174/02

AMURCHANIAN

19/06/2007

19/09/2007

40807/07

ANDRULEWICZ No. 2

20/10/2009

20/01/2010

3360/09

ANTCZAK

09/11/2010

20920/09

BAŃCZYK AND SZTUKA

13/11/2012

7589/12

BRAJER

13/01/2015

7147/06

BROŻYNA

02/02/2010

28/06/2010

32287/09

CHYŻYŃSKI

24/07/2012

24/10/2012

39489/08

DEEG

21/09/2010

36262/08

FLIEGER

22/06/2010

22/09/2010

15915/07

GĘŚLA

12/01/2010

12/04/2010

29130/10

GIL

20/12/2011

32440/08

GUT

18/01/2011

07/02/2012

18/01/2011

07/02/2012

17602/07

JELITTO

21/04/2009

21/07/2009

18500/10

JUREWICZ (V)

05/07/2011

45668/06

KASZA

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

44537/05

KLIMKIEWICZ

28/04/2009

21/12/2010

28/07/2009

21/03/2011

33734/06

KOWALSKI WOJCIECH

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

35615/03

KRZYCH AND GURBIERZ

13/02/2007

09/07/2007

9635/12

KUROWSKI

13/01/2015

46887/06

LESZEK PAWLAK

16/12/2008

16/03/2009

15154/03

MALIKOWSKI

16/10/2007

16/01/2008

7626/12

MASŁOWSKI

13/01/2015

30279/07

MATOŃ

09/06/2009

09/09/2009

13732/03

OSIŃSKI

16/10/2007

16/01/2008

28237/10

PAWLAK

13/01/2015

40219/08

POTONIEC

01/12/2009

01/03/2010

34653/08

RAFAŁ ORZECHOWSKI

27/07/2010

51219/09

RUPRECHT

22/01/2013

30072/04

STEFAN KOZŁOWSKI

22/04/2008

22/07/2008

7708/12

TOMCZYK

13/01/2015

20315/04

WIERZBA

13/11/2008

13/02/2009

4382/10

WINEROWICZ

21/06/2011

29345/09

WRONA

10/03/2015

473/07

WROŃSKI

23/06/2009

23/09/2009

9382/05

ŻELASKO

04/03/2008

04/06/2008

Cases concerning the excessive length of civil proceedings ( Majewski group )

Application

Case

Judgment of

Final on

30523/07

ADAMCZUK

17/07/2008

04/10/2010

18036/03

CICHLA

10/10/2006

10/01/2007

40748/09

CICHOCKI

30/11/2010

28/02/2011

18026/03

CZAUS

22/01/2008

22/04/2008

20334/04

FLOREK

20/05/2008

29/09/2008

23789/04

GNATOWSKA

07/10/2008

07/01/2009

32327/10

GOŁAWSKI AND PISAREK

27/05/2014

5943/07

GORDON-KRAJCER

07/07/2009

07/10/2009

41663/04

GÓRKIEWICZ

13/01/2009

05/05/2009

05/06/2009

05/05/2009

3206/09

GRZONA

24/06/2014

40988/09

HOSZOWSKI

27/05/2014

6433/09

IWANKIEWICZ

07/12/2010

8934/05

JAGIEŁŁO NO. 2

02/12/2008

06/04/2009

29360/06

JERZAK

07/10/2008

07/01/2009

8518/08

KANIEWSKA

18/05/2010

18/08/2010

49788/06

KRZYSTOF KANIEWSKI

30/09/2008

30/12/2008

3429/03

KARPOW

26/02/2008

01/12/2008

1564/02

KĘDRA

10/10/2006

10/01/2007

13933/04

KĘSICCY

16/06/2009

06/11/2009

39836/09

KLIK

07/12/2010

Application

Case

Judgment of

Final on

17731/03

HENRYK KOZŁOWSKI

09/06/2009

09/09/2009

47611/07

JANUSZ LESZEK KOZLOWSKI

08/06/2010

22/11/2010

46601/06

ROMUALD KOZŁOWSKI

20/01/2009

20/04/2009

31193/04

KRYSTINA MISIAK AND JEAN MISIAK

09/11/2010

11/04/2011

45097/05

ARKADIUSZ KUBIK

13/01/2009

13/04/2009

3464/06

KUCHARCZYK

08/12/2009

08/03/2010

2311/04

KUCZKOWSKA

22/07/2008

22/10/2008

50424/99

KUSIAK

21/09/2004

21/12/2004

4560/04

KWIATHOWSKI

17/10/2006

17/01/2007

24203/05

KYZIOŁ

12/02/2008

07/07/2008

28140/05

ŁAKOMIAK

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

31748/06

LUDWIECZAK

16/12/2008

16/03/2009

29539/07

MAGOCH

02/02/2010

02/05/2010

35556/05

MAKUSZEWSKI

13/01/2009

05/06/2009

17904/04

DOROTA AND ZBIGNIEW NOWAK

24/03/2009

14/09/2009

38426/03

LIDIA NOWAK

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

4064/03

OPAŁKO

15/01/2008

15/04/2008

7975/07

PALIGA

12/01/2010

12/04/2010

46074/07

PASTUSZENIA

21/09/2010

35431/05

PIASKOWSKI AND OTHERS

01/07/2008

01/10/2008

20127/08

POLKOWSKA

24/11/2009

24/02/2010

4551/10

POSTEK

11/10/2011

822/05

POZNAŃSKA

16/12/2008

16/03/2009

42778/07

PRZYBYŁA

07/07/2009

07/10/2009

49490/08

PRZYBYLSKA-CONROY

18/05/2010

18/08/2010

2311/10

PURPIAN SP. Z O.O.

18/12/2012

42205/08

REJZMUND

06/07/2010

06/10/2010

35382/06

SADURA

01/07/2008

01/10/2008

33582/08

SEWERYN

15/06/2010

15/09/2010

19616/08

SIKORSKA

28/06/2011

28/11/2011

40063/06

ŚLIWIŃSKI

05/01/2010

05/04/2010

23128/03

SOBCZYŃSKI

27/11/2007

27/02/2008

7743/06

SOKOŁOWSKA

13/01/2009

13/04/2009

20166/07

SUCHECKI No. 1

16/07/2009

16/10/2009

13545/03

SWAT

18/12/2007

18/03/2008

21695/05

TUR

23/10/2007

23/01/2008

28309/06+

WALTOÅš AND PAWLICZ

07/07/2009

07/10/2009

7258/12

WASIAK

14/06/2016

73192/01

WAWRZYNOWICZ

17/07/2007

17/10/2007

56026/00

WENDE AND KUKÓWKA

10/05/2007

24/09/2007

35840/05

ROMAN WILCZYŃSKI

17/07/2008

01/12/2008

42401/08

WIÅšNIEWSKA

20/04/2010

20/07/2010

18414/03

WOLNICKA

10/03/2009

10/06/2009

72161/01

WYSZCZELSKI

29/11/2005

28/02/2006

19817/04

ZAJÄ„C

29/07/2008

29/10/2008

49927/06

ZAKRZEWSKA

16/12/2008

16/03/2009

41701/07

ZAŁUSKA

13/01/2009

13/04/2009

Menu

CASE OF ABRAMCZYK AGAINST POLAND AND 102 OTHER CASES

CASE OF ABRAMCZYK AGAINST POLAND AND 102 OTHER CASES

LEXI