Lexploria

SECOND SECTION

DECISION

Application no . 9977/08 An ı l KARADEMİR and others against Turkey and 165 other applications (see list appended)

The European Court of Human Rights ( Second Section ), sitting on 5 November 2013 as a Committee composed of:

Peer Lorenzen , President, András Sajó , Nebojša Vučinić , judges , and Seçkin Erel , Acting Deputy Section Registrar ,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

THE FACTS

A. The circumstances of the case s

The facts of the case s , as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix , may be summarised as follows.

On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil , administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them . All proce edings lasted several years.

B. Relevant domestic law

A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in M ü d ü r Turgut and o thers v. Turkey (( dec. ), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013 ).

COMPLAINTS

The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.

Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 5, 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1. These complaints are linked to the same proceedings which they complain about the excessive length .

THE LAW

I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS

The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background s .

II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION

All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides :

“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”

The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.

In that respect, the Court found in its decision M ü d ü r Turgut and o thers (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.

In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.

It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.

III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATION S OF THE CONVENTION

Relying on various A rticles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.

Having examined the applicants ’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matter s complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.

It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill ‑ founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.

For these reasons, the Court unanimously

Decides to join the applications;

Declares the applications inadmissible.

Seçkin Erel Peer Lorenzen Acting Deputy Registrar President

Appendix

No

Application No

Lodged on

Applicant

Date of birth

Place of residence

Represented by

9977/08

26/02/2008

An ı l KARADEMİR

01/01/1971

Erzin

Mehmet OCAK

01/01/1957

Hatay

Mustafa GÖRGEL

01/01/1970

Hatay

Alaaddin AYHAN

01/01/1970

Hatay

Yusuf OCAK

01/01/1969

Hatay

Vaysal ŞİMŞEK

01/01/1964

Hatay

Lütfi DÖNMEZ

01/01/1964

Hatay

Yılmaz KAYAR

01/01/1977

Hatay

Bülent KAYAR

01/01/1974

Hatay

Metin DÄ°KÄ°CÄ°OÄžLU

01/01/1963

Hatay

Ahmet DAÄžLI

01/01/1959

Hatay

Bünyamin GÖKDOĞAN

01/01/1971

Hatay

Bestami KAYA

01/01/1968

Hatay

Ali KARACA

21/12/1962

Hatay

Mehmet KELEÅž

01/01/1957

Hatay

HurÅŸit AVCI

01/01/1967

Hatay

Mustafa KAYA

01/01/1965

Hatay

Turan ÃœLGER

01/01/1962

Hatay

Mehmet CÄ°HAT

01/01/1966

Hatay

Mehmet AVCI

01/01/1970

Hatay

Cemal ARPAY

01/01/1960

Hatay

Ali ÇAPAROGLU

01/01/1967

Hatay

Murat OKUR

01/01/1972

Hatay

Ercihan KAMBUR

01/01/1960

Hatay

Abdullah AÅžIK

01/01/1968

Hatay

Halis KALI

01/01/1959

Hatay

Ömer DURMUŞ

01/01/1971

Hatay

Sedat ÇİNGİL

01/01/1972

Hatay

Hayri GÃœLMEN

01/01/1966

Hatay

Bilal USTA

01/01/1963

Hatay

Åžemsettin LEK

01/01/1959

Hatay

Metin REÇBER

01/01/1966

Hatay

Selahattin ÖZASLAN

02/04/1966

Hatay

Hasan ÅžAHÄ°N

01/01/1964

Hatay

HurÅŸit ORMAN

01/01/1973

Hatay

Osman KURT

01/01/1972

Hatay

ReÅŸit YIRTICI

01/01/1966

Hatay

Ali KÃœLTÃœR

01/01/1974

Hatay

Mehmet Şerif KOÇ

01/01/1966

Hatay

Mustafa DEMÄ°R

01/01/1970

Hatay

Bedi USLU

01/01/1967

Hatay

Kadir GÃœNAY

01/01/1975

Hatay

Cafer YEŞİL

01/01/1964

Hatay

Yahya KÜRKÇÜ

01/01/1974

Hatay

Ä°shak NAL

01/01/1969

Hatay

Erol GÖDEN

01/01/1966

Hatay

Halil ŞİMŞEK

01/01/1965

Hatay

Erdal UZGAÅž

01/01/1971

Hatay

Necmettin BERKER

01/01/1961

Hatay

Kazım TABAK

01/01/1963

Hatay

Fadıl TEKELİ

01/01/1970

Hatay

Kemal KARACA

01/01/1971

Hatay

Åžirzat GÃœLLER

01/01/1961

Hatay

Musa

KILIÇASLAN

01/01/1969

Hatay

Serdal KARTAL

01/01/1960

Hatay

Kemal UZGAÅž

01/01/1967

Hatay

Sami ORDULUOÄžLU

01/01/1967

Hatay

Hasan KIRAÇ

01/01/1967

Hatay

Osman Nuri KINALI

01/01/1967

Hatay

Hasan GAYIR

01/01/1965

Hatay

Yılgör KORKMAZ

01/01/1960

Hatay

Ä°smail BAÅžAR

17538/08

02/04/2008

Hülya ERDEM

01/03/1965

Bursa

Günsel DEDE

43225/09

03/08/2009

Mustafa GÃœRBÃœZ

16/04/1931

Ankara

Zehra GÜRBÜZ ÖNAL

48885/09

04/09/2009

Özkan GÜNDÜZ

19/07/1981

Ä°stanbul

49129/09

02/09/2009

Metin SAYGIN

05/07/1981

Ä°stanbul

Çelik HASAN

25/02/1982

Ä°stanbul

Şengül İLKAY

24/04/1984

Ä°stanbul

Nergis ÃœMÄ°T

24/10/1983

Ä°stanbul

Kazım Erkut GÜZEL

52513/09

07/09/2009

Necdet KUTOÄžLU

02/06/1963

Zonguldak

53791/09

29/05/2009

Cemil AKKAYA

05/05/1964

Ankara

Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU

58474/09

23/10/2009

Metin KONDAKÇI

04/04/1957

Ä°stanbul

İsmail Deniz GÖKKILIÇ

58871/09

23/10/2009

Nazım KULALI

12/06/1940

Ä°stanbul

Hayati ÅžAHÄ°N

26981/10

26/04/2010

Fikri ER

01/07/1977

Ankara

26982/10

26/04/2010

Fikri ER

01/07/1977

Ankara

26983/10

26/04/2010

Fikri ER

01/07/1977

Ankara

26984/10

26/04/2010

Fikri ER

01/07/1977

Ankara

64890/10

09/10/2010

Ahmet ÖZDEMİR

05/12/1946

Ankara

ÖZLER YAPI İNŞAAT SANAYİ TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ

MuÅŸ

4099/11

30/12/2010

Ä°smail NAZLIOÄžLU

03/12/1967

Edirne

40463/11

29/03/2011

Ä°sa KAYA

01/06/1938

Şanlıurfa

Nabi ÖZALP

40532/11

28/03/2011

Hakkı TALAŞLI

01/11/1974

Bitlis

Mehmet ERBÄ°L

40627/11

03/03/2011

Güner GÜNDÜZ

24/05/1952

Elazığ

Aziz DİNÇ

42177/11

05/07/2011

İLKAY BALIKÇILIK TURİZM SANAYİ TİCARET A.Ş

Diyarbakır

Zeki UÇAR

42194/11

11/01/2011

Hasan DEMÄ°REL

24/03/1943

Marmaris

Meral ÖNDERSEV

43267/11

09/06/2011

Bayram BAYAR

05/05/1972

Antalya

43444/11

09/07/2011

Samime SANAY

21/10/1940

Ä°stanbul

Mehmet Semih GEMALMAZ

43709/11

22/06/2011

Hüsamettin GÖZÜAÇIK

24/02/1975

Antalya

Ayten ÃœNAL

44640/11

27/06/2011

Mustafa YILMAZ

15/02/1939

Antalya

45859/11

24/05/2011

Yusuf ÖZER

15/12/1963

Ä°zmir

Cem ALTIPARMAK

45868/11

20/06/2011

Ekrem YAMAL

02/11/0972

Diyarbakır

Arzu PAMUKÇU YÖRDEM

46281/11

17/06/2011

Faik CEBEL

24/03/1969

Ä°zmir

Mehmet Nur TERZÄ°

46710/11

29/06/2011

Åžadi BAYRAMOÄžLU

10/07/1940

Ä°stanbul

46853/11

08/07/2011

Mehmet Nesim KAR

01/01/1976

Şırnak

Mehmet Zeki ERGÄ°N

03/02/1977

Istanbul

Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ

47482/11

02/06/2011

Necmi VAROL

01/01/1974

Şanlıurfa

Nabi ÖZALP

47574/11

20/06/2011

Basri YERKAZAN

05/01/1938

Elazığ

Feride KAVAKLI

01/07/1926

Elazığ

Sabriye ULUCAN

01/07/1929

Elazığ

Niyazi Nezir YERKAZAN

01/01/1944

Elazığ

Semedin YERKAZAN

05/03/1950

Elazığ

Halise YERKAZAN

18/03/1954

Elazığ

Hane YERKAZAN

15/03/1975

Giresun

Hasan YERKAZAN

05/03/1979

Erzurum

47735/11

02/06/2011

Cevat Ferruh KATRANCIGÄ°L

01/01/1925

Istanbul

47786/11

03/05/2011

Raziye ERTEM

16/08/1970

Ankara

Tansu BATUR

47798/11

15/06/2011

Fettah BİTİRGİÇ

03/12/1973

Kocaeli

47930/11

25/04/2011

Mehmet YILMAZ

01/01/1956

Diyarbak ı r

Mustafa Günşat AKSU

48171/11

02/07/2011

Ahmet Nuri DEMÄ°RSOY

03/07/1945

Kassel

Hakan ÃœZENLÄ°

48257/11

02/06/2011

Harun YILDIZKÜÇÜK

24/01/1962

Hatay

Maruf KAYMAZ

48284/11

20/12/2010

Seyfi KARAARSLAN

13/07/1948

Zonguldak

Ergin KAYA

48391/11

13/05/2011

Mahmut DELÄ°

09/12/1947

Antakya

Ali DAÄž

48593/11

02/05/2011

Yusuf Vehbi OCAK

23/01/1955

Şanlıurfa

Ali Rıza GERGER

01/12/1955

Şanlıurfa

Ramazan UYAR

11/11/1968

Antalya

Müslüm Cengizhan AKALIN

48597/11

09/04/2011

Radife SON

01/01/1961

Aydın

Åžebnem TOKAT

48614/11

11/04/2011

Özgür ŞAHİN

25/05/1971

Kocaeli

Kureyş BİLGİÇ

48616/11

10/01/2011

Kerim TANIR

17/04/1955

Ulm

48763/11

27/04/2011

Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU

01/02/1947

Ä°stanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

48943/11

22/03/2011

Tekin KARAKÃœLAH

22/02/1977

Aksaray

Beytullah COÅžKUN

49023/11

08/04/2011

İbrahim AYKAÇ

30/07/1959

Balıkesir

Åžerif TOPUZ

49271/11

15/05/2011

Kamuran MALGÄ°L

15/06/1937

Istanbul

Ahmet Cumhur MALGÄ°L

29/10/1963

Istanbul

Zekiye Gülnur DALKILIÇ

12/07/1967

Istanbul

Sabiha ÇAM

05/03/1938

Istanbul

Gülçin ÇAM

13/06/1968

Istanbul

Neslihan ÇAM

08/08/1974

Istanbul

Hüseyin AYDIN

49330/11

12/05/2011

Halil KUT 01/11/1943

Mardin

Hüsnü KUT

01/01/1937

Mardin

Ziver KUT

07/02/1959

Mardin

Süleyman DEMİR

06/04/1964

Mardin

Nezir KUT

14/02/1960

Mardin

Suphiye METE

01/05/1948

Ä°zmir

Müşerref KAYA

18/02/1986

Mardin

Åžerafettin KUT

25/03/1980

Mardin

Semire KARAKOYUN

01/01/1965

Adana

Mizgin AKMEÅžE

02/03/1976

Mardin

Kasım KURT

25/10/1936

Mardin

Hamdiye BAYSAL

01/01/1940

Ä°zmir

Ferhat KUT

01/03/1974

Mardin

Åžener KUT

10/07/1984

Mardin

Mehmet Salih ALÄ°OÄžLU

03/12/1949

Mardin

Fahriye ORAL

01/01/1953

Mersin

Gülistan TAŞ

01/01/1980

Mardin

Lema DENÄ°Z

01/01/1966

Mardin

Mustafa KUT

01/01/1976

MuÄŸla

Abdurrahim KUT

01/07/1966

Mardin

Azat KUT

02/12/1975

Mardin

Abdülselam KUT

01/02/1969

Mardin

Nezehat KUT

01/05/1959

Mardin

Yusuf KUT

01/01/1964

Mersin

Pale KUT

01/01/1991

Mardin

Mehmet Hatip KUT

25/08/1986

Mardin

Yazgı ÇİMEN FİDAN

49557/11

29/12/2010

Halil LÄ°MON

13/03/1938

Antalya

AyÅŸe ÅžEN

12/02/1940

Antalya

Hatice BALAMAN

08/02/1944

Antalya

Emine LÄ°MON

10/01/1947

Antalya

Levent ERCAN

50186/11

08/06/2011

Hasan ÖZÇELİK

07/08/1949

Ankara

Hakkı Oğulcan ÖZÇELİK

05/10/1990

Ankara

Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU

50620/11

23/03/2011

Åževket ERTÃœRK

12/09/1938

Kocaeli

Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN

50678/11

08/07/2011

Mehmet ÇALIŞKAN

12/11/1933

Aydın

Mustafa GÜVENÇ

16/12/1931

Aydın

Serkan CENGÄ°Z

51231/11

14/07/2011

Mehmet DEVELÄ°

01/01/1989

Van

Kerem AKDOÄžAN

51472/11

25/03/2011

Sinan YILMAZ

14/10/1984

Istanbul

Nesrin KARAGÖZ KARATEPE

51500/11

04/04/2011

Suat ÖZBAL

01/01/1965

Ä°zmir

Türkan ASLAN

51512/11

03/05/2011

Eyyüp EROL

01/01/1962

Mardin

Yılmaz FİDAN

51519/11

25/05/2011

Hüseyin SEZEN

24/07/1968

Samsun

Mesut BEDÄ°RHANOÄžLU

51527/11

11/04/2011

Mahfuz DEMÄ°R

01/02/1959

Erzurum

Celal DEMÄ°R

19/03/1952

Erzurum

Ahmet DEMÄ°R

07/06/1956

Erzurum

Ömer KURT

51528/11

11/04/2011

Mahfuz DEMÄ°R

01/02/1959

Erzurum

Celal DEMÄ°R

19/03/1952

Erzurum

Ahmet DEMÄ°R

07/06/1956

Erzurum

Ömer KURT

51529/11

11/04/2011

Mahfuz DEMÄ°R

01/02/1959

Erzurum

Celal DEMÄ°R

19/03/1952

Erzurum

Ahmet DEMÄ°R

07/06/1956

Erzurum

Ömer KURT

51530/11

11/04/2011

Mahfuz DEMÄ°R

01/02/1959

Erzurum

Celal DEMÄ°R

19/03/1952

Erzurum

Ahmet DEMÄ°R

07/06/1956

Erzurum

Ömer KURT

52417/11

27/07/2011

Köksal DENİZ

31/07/1965

Ankara

Haluk PEKÅžEN

52418/11

27/07/2011

Etem UZUNAY

15/03/1957

Istanbul

52419/11

27/07/2011

Åžeref KOCAMAN

17/06/1960

Ankara

Haluk PEKÅžEN

52745/11

13/07/2011

Mehmet SAVCI

Mardin

Zeynep HAZAR

Mardin

Zübeyde SAVCI

Mardin

Zahra DÜZGÖREN

Mardin

Selahattin HAZAR

Mardin

Mustafa HAZAR

Mardin

Meryem KORHAN

Mardin

Ä°brahim SAVCI

Mardin

Mahsun HAZAR

Mardin

Hıdır SAVCI

10/08/1969

Mardin

Fatma DÜZGÖREN

Mardin

Hatice TALAYHAN

Mardin

Fatma HAZAR

Mardin

Emine Ä°LBOÄžA

Mardin

AyÅŸe HAZAR

04/02/1964

Mardin

Ahmet HAZAR

Mardin

Ahmet SAVCI

Mardin

Abdürrezak HAZAR

01/02/1963

Mardin

Abdulvahit HAZAR

Mardin

Zeynep HAZAR

Mardin

Ä°nci Fidan AYDEMÄ°R

52791/11

07/06/2011

Fatih ÖZEL

01/01/1974

Adana

Hüseyin ÖZVEREN

53041/11

15/07/2011

Åžeyhmus AKSOY

03/03/1960

Derik

Metin AKSOY

03/03/1974

Derik

ReÅŸat AKSOY

06/07/1944

Derik

Bülent AKSOY

03/05/1974

Derik

YaÅŸar AKSOY

05/02/1970

Derik

Serdar AKSOY

20/10/1989

Derik

Filiz AKSOY

01/06/1972

Derik

Sinan AKSOY

20/01/1988

Derik

53209/11

05/07/2011

Candan KOZANLI

01/01/1965

Çanakkale

Ceyda AKKAÅž DEMÄ°RCÄ°

53231/11

29/06/2011

Hamza ÇİFTÇİ

01/01/1952

Aksaray

Beytullah COÅžKUN

53257/11

08/06/2011

Sevil ADA

23/03/1955

Ä°stanbul

Faruk ÖKSÜZ

53820/11

20/05/2011

ALTUNTAS KÖYÜ VE AŞAĞI KÖY MUHTARLIĞI

Malatya

Mehmet GÖRGEÇ

54560/11

08/07/2011

Yücel MANDACI

01/01/1940

Çanakkale

Hasan Erokay MANDACI

54786/11

19/08/2011

Hasan Turan YETÄ°M

13/02/1962

Istanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

54793/11

06/07/2011

Gökhan ARSLANTÜRK

29/09/1972

Ankara

Yılmaz İÇÖZ

54795/11

23/06/2011

Abbas BAYIR

01/03/1965

Istanbul

54796/11

20/06/2011

Ahmet ÜÇEK

20/04/1978

Istanbul

Yusuf EYCAN

54801/11

15/07/2011

Taner KANDEMÄ°R

16/09/1949

Istanbul

Ömer ÖNEREN

55497/11

17/06/2011

Osman AKTAÅž

10/04/1966

Sivas

Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ

55693/11

01/08/2011

Serhat ÅžAÅžOÄžLU

21/03/1961

Ä°zmir

Sevgi DEMÄ°RTAÅž

55879/11

30/06/2011

Mustafa NAZLIER

26/09/1969

Ä°zmir

İlkay PALA ÖGE

56164/11

12/05/2011

Metin TUNCEL

08/04/1933

Istanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

56995/11

12/07/2011

Gülten DEMİRHAN

20/10/1954

Ankara

Z. Cem DEMÄ°RHAN

57296/11

05/08/2011

Selman AYDIN

01/01/1978

Istanbul

Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ

57471/11

01/07/2011

Yusuf ÇİÇEK

11/05/1965

Viyana

Figen OPAK ÇİÇEK

57594/11

25/06/2011

Tuncay KARAKAÅž

18/03/1975

Bursa

Nigar YILMAZ

57596/11

27/06/2011

Salih BEKTAÅž

15/03/1960

Freudenstadt

58011/11

05/08/2011

Mehmet Ali ÇELİK

13/10/1977

Şanlıurfa

Ä°lyas BARAN

58568/11

08/08/2011

Vahit COÅžAR

10/05/1964

Amasya

Makbule ÖZER ARPAĞ

58936/11

11/07/2011

Ahmet EKÄ°NCÄ°

12/02/1972

Diyarbakır

58943/11

25/08/2011

Özen NURAY

17/10/1960

MuÄŸla

Selçuk KURT

59979/11

25/07/2011

Salih ASLAN

05/04/1971

Şanlıurfa

Ä°lyas BARAN

60059/11

22/07/2011

Kerim CÄ°CÄ°

21/05/1938

Bingöl

Mustafa ALPTEKÄ°N

60558/11

24/08/2011

Adnan HALÄ°S

01/01/1952

Hendek

Erol ARIKAN

01/01/1962

Gönen

Esral KARAGÖZ

30/01/1961

Istanbul

Fazıl Ahmet TAMER

11/08/1966

Istanbul

Volkan KARTAL

01/01/1977

Istanbul

Kemal TUFAN

01/01/1967

Istanbul

Erol KAPLAN

01/01/1967

Istanbul

Hikmet KALE

08/12/1970

TekirdaÄŸ

Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ

01/10/1952

Edirne

Mehmet GÖKTAŞ

01/01/1966

Tunceli

Mehmet BOZTEPE

01/01/1968

Malatya

Hacı Aziz HUN

01/01/1965

Samsun

Dinçer OTLUÇİMEN

01/01/1976

Istanbul

Yılmaz YİĞİT

01/01/1976

Istanbul

Bülent YİĞİT

01/01/1977

Istanbul

Cem ÅžAHÄ°N

01/01/1976

Istanbul

Gülizar TUNCER

60943/11

14/09/2011

Nuran ÖZDEMİR

01/10/1961

Ankara

Ömer ÜNLÜ

60986/11

07/06/2011

Memnune KARAKULAK

04/01/1961

Istanbul

61290/11

11/08/2011

Ä°mam AYDIN

01/01/1977

Istanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

62408/11

27/07/2011

İhsan KÖRPE

07/12/1986

Siirt

62442/11

24/08/2011

Özgür SAĞLAM

01/01/1981

Istanbul

Cengiz KARAKAÅž

17/04/1978

TekirdaÄŸ

Vedat ÇELİK

01/01/1981

Istanbul

Several BALLIKAYA

62655/11

20/09/2011

Atilla GÃœRDER

02/01/1947

Ankara

İlhan BİÇER

63115/11

21/09/2011

Babur Nuri KILIÇ

01/01/1960

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63129/11

21/09/2011

Yücel KÜRKLÜ

01/01/1945

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63135/11

21/09/2011

Didem ERGÄ°N

21/07/1975

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63138/11

21/09/2011

Gülgün TREN

14/06/1948

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63163/11

21/09/2011

Abdülkadir SAĞER

28/02/1958

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63167/11

21/09/2011

Nuriye ÖSER

03/02/1934

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63169/11

21/09/2011

Ayfer Ahu ÇAKIR

25/12/1954

Ankara

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63173/11

21/09/2011

SavaÅŸ Ahmet BUÄžRA

11/01/1965

Amasra

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63176/11

21/09/2011

Sevgi ILGAZ

27/12/1942

EskiÅŸehir

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63186/11

21/09/2011

Özcan EMEK

01/11/1944

Sakarya

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63190/11

29/08/2011

Bircan KAYSUN

20/12/1965

Ankara

Özcan GÜÇLÜ

24/05/1964

Ankara

Gürcan GÜÇLÜ

22/03/1970

Ankara

Nevin ÖZKAN

63191/11

21/09/2011

Timur Ahmet KILIÇ

01/01/1959

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63198/11

21/09/2011

Cengiz Mehmet KILIÇ

01/01/1957

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

63213/11

21/09/2011

Saliha Solmaz ÖĞET

06/10/1931

Istanbul

Ergin CÄ°NMEN

68064/11

26/09/2011

Bekir ARPA

10/03/1935

Diyarbakır

Fırat ÜGER

70415/11

04/10/2011

Hakkı AKBAŞ

29/06/1966

Ä°zmir

Yüksel KAVAK KILINÇ

72974/11

31/10/2011

Ahmet ÇELEBİ

01/01/1945

Istanbul

Cem ALPTEKÄ°N

74392/11

10/10/2011

Ersin ÖZŞEN

04/05/1973

Istanbul

Haluk PEKÅžEN

76763/11

23/11/2011

Süleyman SARIBOĞA

01/08/1951

Aydın

Gül SÖZEN

7527/12

29/11/2011

Nurettin BORAN

10/03/1962

Ankara

9725/12

25/01/2012

Ahmet BESER

12/05/1962

Istanbul

Ahmet Ersin BAZMANOÄžLU

17/08/1950

Istanbul

HÄ°DRO-MAK DAMPER VE HÄ°DROLÄ°K MAKÄ°NALARI SAN. TÄ°C. A.Åž.

Istanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

10037/12

23/12/2011

Yıldız İMREK

15/11/1964

Istanbul

Semir KARADAÅž

10325/12

14/12/2011

Aziz ÖZDEMİR

01/01/1957

Adana

Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU

13479/12

06/01/2012

Melek ORHAN

15/06/1949

MuÄŸla

Åžuayip ORHAN

11/11/1967

MuÄŸla

Naciye CEYLAN

13714/12

13/02/2012

Ahmet KIZIL

01/07/1941

Adıyaman

Mustafa YAVUZ

13730/12

27/01/2012

Mustafa YILMAZ

30/03/1953

Sakarya

Nadir KURTDERE

14538/12

23/02/2012

Necati ÇALIŞKAN

29/08/1959

Ä°zmir

Barış KAŞKA

14539/12

23/02/2012

Halime DALMIÅž

09/11/1964

Ä°zmir

Barış KAŞKA

14540/12

23/02/2012

Birsen ÃœLKÃœ

20/10/1969

Ä°zmir

Barış KAŞKA

15079/12

24/01/2012

Mehmet Nuri KARAKAYA

10/02/1976

Kırklareli

16379/12

03/02/2012

Mithat CABA

19/07/1954

Amasya

Kasım ER

16385/12

20/02/2012

Süleyman ERDEM

01/01/1968

Istanbul

Baran DOÄžAN

16439/12

10/02/2012

Sabit DURMUÅž

10/07/1951

Ä°skenderun

16452/12

23/02/2012

Ali Sait BULUT

09/08/1966

Istanbul

Åžefik KARAKIÅž

16532/12

22/02/2012

Fuat ÇETİNKAYA

01/01/1964

Şanlıurfa

Fatma TAVAÅž

01/01/1966

Şanlıurfa

Ayşe ÇETİNTAŞ

03/03/1981

Şanlıurfa

Abdullah ÇETİNKAYA

02/04/1985

Şanlıurfa

Hasan ÇETİNKAYA

01/04/1980

Şanlıurfa

Osman ÇETİNKAYA

01/01/1959

Şanlıurfa

Hüseyin ÇETİNKAYA

01/01/1978

Aydın

Saliha ÇETİNKAYA

01/03/1940

Şanlıurfa

Muhammet ÇETİNKAYA

10/01/1977

Şanlıurfa

Mustafa YAVUZ

16569/12

23/02/2012

Bedriye AZEMOÄžLU

22/02/1981

Şanlıurfa

Şükran YILMAZER

22/02/1974

Şanlıurfa

Hasan BALTACI

22/02/1979

Şanlıurfa

Cengiz BALTACI

22/04/1973

Şanlıurfa

Sedat BALTACI

22/02/1986

Şanlıurfa

Kadriye YILDIZ

22/02/1977

Şanlıurfa

Mustafa YAVUZ

18143/12

16/02/2012

Asiye FARAÇ

01/01/1971

Şanlıurfa

Eyüp AVCI

01/07/1949

Şanlıurfa

Ziya AVCI

01/01/1969

Şanlıurfa

BinevÅŸ Ä°NCE

02/03/1946

Şanlıurfa

Mehmet AVCI

08/05/1947

Şanlıurfa

Fatma AVCI

01/01/1945

Şanlıurfa

Emine AKMAN

04/06/1953

Şanlıurfa

Mustafa YAVUZ

19659/12

09/06/2011

Hikmet GAYIP

01/05/1965

Istanbul

19747/12

07/06/2011

Azmi GÜNGÖR

19/04/1960

Istanbul

21064/12

22/02/2012

Murtaza ANSEN

13/09/1951

Ä°zmir

Kubilay Ä°stemi ERGÃœN

26141/12

06/04/2012

Sebahattin YALÇIN

05/04/1967

EskiÅŸehir

27087/12

13/03/2012

Fikret ESMEROÄžLU

01/01/1948

Şanlıurfa

Lütfü POLAT

27348/12

30/03/2012

Tahir Nafiz ÖZKUL

01/08/1949

Denizli

27373/12

05/04/2012

Arif ÖTLEŞ

21/05/1983

Ankara

Nuran ÖZDEMİR

29252/12

02/04/2012

Bilal ÇETİNER

03/02/1974

Gümüşhane

48753/12

03/06/2012

Mehmet GÜNGÖR

01/01/1965

Şanlıurfa

Mehmet KIRBOÄžA

49490/12

04/06/2012

Sevil KARABURÇAK

10/03/1952

MuÄŸla

51150/12

14/06/2012

Filiz GÃœMELÄ°

06/06/1960

Ä°zmir

Sevim ÇAM (LAPÇİN)

04/07/1956

Ä°zmir

Günay TÜRK

15/03/1960

Ä°zmir

Turgay TÃœRK

24/09/1958

Ä°zmir

Güney DİNÇ

54588/12

18/06/2012

Hamdi GÜNGÖR

01/05/1976

Manisa

Mustafa ROLLAS

56073/12

25/06/2012

Hatice Semra BAÅžTÃœRK

03/08/1957

Ä°zmir

Havva Zülal KARATÜFEK

15/10/1955

Ä°zmir

Fatma Nihal ISPARTA

30/11/1964

Ä°zmir

Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK

56283/12

02/07/2012

Halil GEÇKİL

01/01/1961

Şanlıurfa

Ahmet GÜNGÖR

01/01/1962

Şanlıurfa

Deham GÜNGÖR

01/01/1957

Şanlıurfa

İsmail GEÇKİL

01/01/1962

Şanlıurfa

Mehmet KIRBOÄžA

56761/12

16/07/2012

Ziya KÖROĞLU

01/01/1967

Antalya

Bekir ASRÄ°

56922/12

11/06/2012

AyÅŸan DEMÄ°R

19/02/1962

Batman

Fahrettin DEMÄ°R

01/01/1978

Batman

Abdurrahim DEMÄ°R

01/10/1992

Batman

Sibetullah DEMÄ°R

01/01/1987

Batman

Alaattin DEMÄ°R

10/11/1979

Batman

Muhittin DEMÄ°R

25/09/1983

Batman

Seyhan GÃœZEL

01/01/1985

Batman

Ceyhan DEMÄ°R

01/01/1989

Batman

Naif DEMÄ°R

01/01/1960

Batman

Bayram DEMÄ°R

02/02/1962

Batman

Rıfat DEMİR

15/04/1958

Batman

Mehmet Masum ERKEN

62289/12

30/07/2012

Mustafa UÇAR

18/12/1950

Aydın

Adnan ÇUKUR

62535/12

18/11/2011

Güler SÖYLEMEZ (YILMAZ)

01/01/1982

Istanbul

Gülizar TUNCER

62612/12

11/09/2012

Osman GÖKDAL

01/01/1956

Mersin

ErdoÄŸan ATA

63107/12

11/09/2012

Fatma GÖREN

05/05/1927

Istanbul

İlhan GÖREN

01/05/1954

Istanbul

Zahide HASPOLAT

04/10/1949

Istanbul

Sedat HASPOLAT

65432/12

20/09/2012

Yavuz BÄ°LEN

01/06/1975

Istanbul

Osman SALMAN

66487/12

10/09/2012

Atilla GÃœRDER

02/01/1947

Ankara

İlhan BİÇER

66508/12

20/09/2012

Halil ÅžAHÄ°N

01/01/1968

Sincan

Cengiz KAHRAMAN

15/05/1974

Ankara

Naki DEMÄ°R

01/01/1981

Ankara

Sedat OT

01/01/1975

Ankara

YaÅŸar Ä°NCE

01/01/1972

Ankara

Deniz TEPELÄ°

01/01/1977

Ankara

Hakan KARAKUÅž

66603/12

01/09/2012

Sabri TOLUAY

05/04/1928

Bingöl

Türkan KIRMIZITAŞ

67044/12

21/09/2012

Hasan ÖZGE

10/11/1974

Aydın

Ece SOLMAZ

75633/12

21/09/2012

Bülent ÇAN

21/09/1980

Istanbul

Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ

75761/12

21/09/2012

Mehmet ReÅŸit AKAR

01/01/1975

Istanbul

Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ

77609/12

09/09/2012

Ahmet ERCÄ°YAÅž

01/01/1961

Diyarbakır

Gülcan KARTAL

32/13

09/11/2012

Yanık SATILMIŞ

08/04/1974

Zonguldak

21323/13

15/03/2013

Åžahin ÅžAMDAN

01/09/1975

Kocaeli

Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN

Menu

KARADEMİR AND OTHERS v. TURKEY

KARADEMİR AND OTHERS v. TURKEY

LEXI