KARADEMİR AND OTHERS v. TURKEY
Doc ref: 9977/08, 17538/08, 43225/09, 48885/09, 49129/09, 52513/09, 53791/09, 58474/09, 58871/09, 26981/10, 2... • ECHR ID: 001-139045
Document date: November 5, 2013
- Inbound citations: 7
- •
- Cited paragraphs: 0
- •
- Outbound citations: 1
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no . 9977/08 An ı l KARADEMİR and others against Turkey and 165 other applications (see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights ( Second Section ), sitting on 5 November 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Peer Lorenzen , President, András Sajó , Nebojša Vučinić , judges , and Seçkin Erel , Acting Deputy Section Registrar ,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the case s
The facts of the case s , as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix , may be summarised as follows.
On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil , administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them . All proce edings lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in M ü d ü r Turgut and o thers v. Turkey (( dec. ), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013 ).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 5, 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1. These complaints are linked to the same proceedings which they complain about the excessive length .
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background s .
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION
All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides :
“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”
The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
In that respect, the Court found in its decision M ü d ü r Turgut and o thers (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.
In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATION S OF THE CONVENTION
Relying on various A rticles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.
Having examined the applicants ’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matter s complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill ‑ founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Seçkin Erel Peer Lorenzen Acting Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
No
Application No
Lodged on
Applicant
Date of birth
Place of residence
Represented by
9977/08
26/02/2008
An ı l KARADEMİR
01/01/1971
Erzin
Mehmet OCAK
01/01/1957
Hatay
Mustafa GÖRGEL
01/01/1970
Hatay
Alaaddin AYHAN
01/01/1970
Hatay
Yusuf OCAK
01/01/1969
Hatay
Vaysal ŞİMŞEK
01/01/1964
Hatay
Lütfi DÖNMEZ
01/01/1964
Hatay
Yılmaz KAYAR
01/01/1977
Hatay
Bülent KAYAR
01/01/1974
Hatay
Metin DÄ°KÄ°CÄ°OÄžLU
01/01/1963
Hatay
Ahmet DAÄžLI
01/01/1959
Hatay
Bünyamin GÖKDOĞAN
01/01/1971
Hatay
Bestami KAYA
01/01/1968
Hatay
Ali KARACA
21/12/1962
Hatay
Mehmet KELEÅž
01/01/1957
Hatay
HurÅŸit AVCI
01/01/1967
Hatay
Mustafa KAYA
01/01/1965
Hatay
Turan ÃœLGER
01/01/1962
Hatay
Mehmet CÄ°HAT
01/01/1966
Hatay
Mehmet AVCI
01/01/1970
Hatay
Cemal ARPAY
01/01/1960
Hatay
Ali ÇAPAROGLU
01/01/1967
Hatay
Murat OKUR
01/01/1972
Hatay
Ercihan KAMBUR
01/01/1960
Hatay
Abdullah AÅžIK
01/01/1968
Hatay
Halis KALI
01/01/1959
Hatay
Ömer DURMUŞ
01/01/1971
Hatay
Sedat ÇİNGİL
01/01/1972
Hatay
Hayri GÃœLMEN
01/01/1966
Hatay
Bilal USTA
01/01/1963
Hatay
Åžemsettin LEK
01/01/1959
Hatay
Metin REÇBER
01/01/1966
Hatay
Selahattin ÖZASLAN
02/04/1966
Hatay
Hasan ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1964
Hatay
HurÅŸit ORMAN
01/01/1973
Hatay
Osman KURT
01/01/1972
Hatay
ReÅŸit YIRTICI
01/01/1966
Hatay
Ali KÃœLTÃœR
01/01/1974
Hatay
Mehmet Şerif KOÇ
01/01/1966
Hatay
Mustafa DEMÄ°R
01/01/1970
Hatay
Bedi USLU
01/01/1967
Hatay
Kadir GÃœNAY
01/01/1975
Hatay
Cafer YEŞİL
01/01/1964
Hatay
Yahya KÜRKÇÜ
01/01/1974
Hatay
Ä°shak NAL
01/01/1969
Hatay
Erol GÖDEN
01/01/1966
Hatay
Halil ŞİMŞEK
01/01/1965
Hatay
Erdal UZGAÅž
01/01/1971
Hatay
Necmettin BERKER
01/01/1961
Hatay
Kazım TABAK
01/01/1963
Hatay
Fadıl TEKELİ
01/01/1970
Hatay
Kemal KARACA
01/01/1971
Hatay
Åžirzat GÃœLLER
01/01/1961
Hatay
Musa
KILIÇASLAN
01/01/1969
Hatay
Serdal KARTAL
01/01/1960
Hatay
Kemal UZGAÅž
01/01/1967
Hatay
Sami ORDULUOÄžLU
01/01/1967
Hatay
Hasan KIRAÇ
01/01/1967
Hatay
Osman Nuri KINALI
01/01/1967
Hatay
Hasan GAYIR
01/01/1965
Hatay
Yılgör KORKMAZ
01/01/1960
Hatay
Ä°smail BAÅžAR
17538/08
02/04/2008
Hülya ERDEM
01/03/1965
Bursa
Günsel DEDE
43225/09
03/08/2009
Mustafa GÃœRBÃœZ
16/04/1931
Ankara
Zehra GÜRBÜZ ÖNAL
48885/09
04/09/2009
Özkan GÜNDÜZ
19/07/1981
Ä°stanbul
49129/09
02/09/2009
Metin SAYGIN
05/07/1981
Ä°stanbul
Çelik HASAN
25/02/1982
Ä°stanbul
Şengül İLKAY
24/04/1984
Ä°stanbul
Nergis ÃœMÄ°T
24/10/1983
Ä°stanbul
Kazım Erkut GÜZEL
52513/09
07/09/2009
Necdet KUTOÄžLU
02/06/1963
Zonguldak
53791/09
29/05/2009
Cemil AKKAYA
05/05/1964
Ankara
Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU
58474/09
23/10/2009
Metin KONDAKÇI
04/04/1957
Ä°stanbul
İsmail Deniz GÖKKILIÇ
58871/09
23/10/2009
Nazım KULALI
12/06/1940
Ä°stanbul
Hayati ÅžAHÄ°N
26981/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
26982/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
26983/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
26984/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
64890/10
09/10/2010
Ahmet ÖZDEMİR
05/12/1946
Ankara
ÖZLER YAPI İNŞAAT SANAYİ TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ
MuÅŸ
4099/11
30/12/2010
Ä°smail NAZLIOÄžLU
03/12/1967
Edirne
40463/11
29/03/2011
Ä°sa KAYA
01/06/1938
Şanlıurfa
Nabi ÖZALP
40532/11
28/03/2011
Hakkı TALAŞLI
01/11/1974
Bitlis
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
40627/11
03/03/2011
Güner GÜNDÜZ
24/05/1952
Elazığ
Aziz DİNÇ
42177/11
05/07/2011
İLKAY BALIKÇILIK TURİZM SANAYİ TİCARET A.Ş
Diyarbakır
Zeki UÇAR
42194/11
11/01/2011
Hasan DEMÄ°REL
24/03/1943
Marmaris
Meral ÖNDERSEV
43267/11
09/06/2011
Bayram BAYAR
05/05/1972
Antalya
43444/11
09/07/2011
Samime SANAY
21/10/1940
Ä°stanbul
Mehmet Semih GEMALMAZ
43709/11
22/06/2011
Hüsamettin GÖZÜAÇIK
24/02/1975
Antalya
Ayten ÃœNAL
44640/11
27/06/2011
Mustafa YILMAZ
15/02/1939
Antalya
45859/11
24/05/2011
Yusuf ÖZER
15/12/1963
Ä°zmir
Cem ALTIPARMAK
45868/11
20/06/2011
Ekrem YAMAL
02/11/0972
Diyarbakır
Arzu PAMUKÇU YÖRDEM
46281/11
17/06/2011
Faik CEBEL
24/03/1969
Ä°zmir
Mehmet Nur TERZÄ°
46710/11
29/06/2011
Åžadi BAYRAMOÄžLU
10/07/1940
Ä°stanbul
46853/11
08/07/2011
Mehmet Nesim KAR
01/01/1976
Şırnak
Mehmet Zeki ERGÄ°N
03/02/1977
Istanbul
Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ
47482/11
02/06/2011
Necmi VAROL
01/01/1974
Şanlıurfa
Nabi ÖZALP
47574/11
20/06/2011
Basri YERKAZAN
05/01/1938
Elazığ
Feride KAVAKLI
01/07/1926
Elazığ
Sabriye ULUCAN
01/07/1929
Elazığ
Niyazi Nezir YERKAZAN
01/01/1944
Elazığ
Semedin YERKAZAN
05/03/1950
Elazığ
Halise YERKAZAN
18/03/1954
Elazığ
Hane YERKAZAN
15/03/1975
Giresun
Hasan YERKAZAN
05/03/1979
Erzurum
47735/11
02/06/2011
Cevat Ferruh KATRANCIGÄ°L
01/01/1925
Istanbul
47786/11
03/05/2011
Raziye ERTEM
16/08/1970
Ankara
Tansu BATUR
47798/11
15/06/2011
Fettah BİTİRGİÇ
03/12/1973
Kocaeli
47930/11
25/04/2011
Mehmet YILMAZ
01/01/1956
Diyarbak ı r
Mustafa Günşat AKSU
48171/11
02/07/2011
Ahmet Nuri DEMÄ°RSOY
03/07/1945
Kassel
Hakan ÃœZENLÄ°
48257/11
02/06/2011
Harun YILDIZKÜÇÜK
24/01/1962
Hatay
Maruf KAYMAZ
48284/11
20/12/2010
Seyfi KARAARSLAN
13/07/1948
Zonguldak
Ergin KAYA
48391/11
13/05/2011
Mahmut DELÄ°
09/12/1947
Antakya
Ali DAÄž
48593/11
02/05/2011
Yusuf Vehbi OCAK
23/01/1955
Şanlıurfa
Ali Rıza GERGER
01/12/1955
Şanlıurfa
Ramazan UYAR
11/11/1968
Antalya
Müslüm Cengizhan AKALIN
48597/11
09/04/2011
Radife SON
01/01/1961
Aydın
Åžebnem TOKAT
48614/11
11/04/2011
Özgür ŞAHİN
25/05/1971
Kocaeli
Kureyş BİLGİÇ
48616/11
10/01/2011
Kerim TANIR
17/04/1955
Ulm
48763/11
27/04/2011
Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU
01/02/1947
Ä°stanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
48943/11
22/03/2011
Tekin KARAKÃœLAH
22/02/1977
Aksaray
Beytullah COÅžKUN
49023/11
08/04/2011
İbrahim AYKAÇ
30/07/1959
Balıkesir
Åžerif TOPUZ
49271/11
15/05/2011
Kamuran MALGÄ°L
15/06/1937
Istanbul
Ahmet Cumhur MALGÄ°L
29/10/1963
Istanbul
Zekiye Gülnur DALKILIÇ
12/07/1967
Istanbul
Sabiha ÇAM
05/03/1938
Istanbul
Gülçin ÇAM
13/06/1968
Istanbul
Neslihan ÇAM
08/08/1974
Istanbul
Hüseyin AYDIN
49330/11
12/05/2011
Halil KUT 01/11/1943
Mardin
Hüsnü KUT
01/01/1937
Mardin
Ziver KUT
07/02/1959
Mardin
Süleyman DEMİR
06/04/1964
Mardin
Nezir KUT
14/02/1960
Mardin
Suphiye METE
01/05/1948
Ä°zmir
Müşerref KAYA
18/02/1986
Mardin
Åžerafettin KUT
25/03/1980
Mardin
Semire KARAKOYUN
01/01/1965
Adana
Mizgin AKMEÅžE
02/03/1976
Mardin
Kasım KURT
25/10/1936
Mardin
Hamdiye BAYSAL
01/01/1940
Ä°zmir
Ferhat KUT
01/03/1974
Mardin
Åžener KUT
10/07/1984
Mardin
Mehmet Salih ALÄ°OÄžLU
03/12/1949
Mardin
Fahriye ORAL
01/01/1953
Mersin
Gülistan TAŞ
01/01/1980
Mardin
Lema DENÄ°Z
01/01/1966
Mardin
Mustafa KUT
01/01/1976
MuÄŸla
Abdurrahim KUT
01/07/1966
Mardin
Azat KUT
02/12/1975
Mardin
Abdülselam KUT
01/02/1969
Mardin
Nezehat KUT
01/05/1959
Mardin
Yusuf KUT
01/01/1964
Mersin
Pale KUT
01/01/1991
Mardin
Mehmet Hatip KUT
25/08/1986
Mardin
Yazgı ÇİMEN FİDAN
49557/11
29/12/2010
Halil LÄ°MON
13/03/1938
Antalya
AyÅŸe ÅžEN
12/02/1940
Antalya
Hatice BALAMAN
08/02/1944
Antalya
Emine LÄ°MON
10/01/1947
Antalya
Levent ERCAN
50186/11
08/06/2011
Hasan ÖZÇELİK
07/08/1949
Ankara
Hakkı Oğulcan ÖZÇELİK
05/10/1990
Ankara
Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU
50620/11
23/03/2011
Åževket ERTÃœRK
12/09/1938
Kocaeli
Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN
50678/11
08/07/2011
Mehmet ÇALIŞKAN
12/11/1933
Aydın
Mustafa GÜVENÇ
16/12/1931
Aydın
Serkan CENGÄ°Z
51231/11
14/07/2011
Mehmet DEVELÄ°
01/01/1989
Van
Kerem AKDOÄžAN
51472/11
25/03/2011
Sinan YILMAZ
14/10/1984
Istanbul
Nesrin KARAGÖZ KARATEPE
51500/11
04/04/2011
Suat ÖZBAL
01/01/1965
Ä°zmir
Türkan ASLAN
51512/11
03/05/2011
Eyyüp EROL
01/01/1962
Mardin
Yılmaz FİDAN
51519/11
25/05/2011
Hüseyin SEZEN
24/07/1968
Samsun
Mesut BEDÄ°RHANOÄžLU
51527/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMÄ°R
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMÄ°R
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMÄ°R
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
51528/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMÄ°R
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMÄ°R
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMÄ°R
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
51529/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMÄ°R
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMÄ°R
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMÄ°R
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
51530/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMÄ°R
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMÄ°R
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMÄ°R
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
52417/11
27/07/2011
Köksal DENİZ
31/07/1965
Ankara
Haluk PEKÅžEN
52418/11
27/07/2011
Etem UZUNAY
15/03/1957
Istanbul
52419/11
27/07/2011
Åžeref KOCAMAN
17/06/1960
Ankara
Haluk PEKÅžEN
52745/11
13/07/2011
Mehmet SAVCI
Mardin
Zeynep HAZAR
Mardin
Zübeyde SAVCI
Mardin
Zahra DÜZGÖREN
Mardin
Selahattin HAZAR
Mardin
Mustafa HAZAR
Mardin
Meryem KORHAN
Mardin
Ä°brahim SAVCI
Mardin
Mahsun HAZAR
Mardin
Hıdır SAVCI
10/08/1969
Mardin
Fatma DÜZGÖREN
Mardin
Hatice TALAYHAN
Mardin
Fatma HAZAR
Mardin
Emine Ä°LBOÄžA
Mardin
AyÅŸe HAZAR
04/02/1964
Mardin
Ahmet HAZAR
Mardin
Ahmet SAVCI
Mardin
Abdürrezak HAZAR
01/02/1963
Mardin
Abdulvahit HAZAR
Mardin
Zeynep HAZAR
Mardin
Ä°nci Fidan AYDEMÄ°R
52791/11
07/06/2011
Fatih ÖZEL
01/01/1974
Adana
Hüseyin ÖZVEREN
53041/11
15/07/2011
Åžeyhmus AKSOY
03/03/1960
Derik
Metin AKSOY
03/03/1974
Derik
ReÅŸat AKSOY
06/07/1944
Derik
Bülent AKSOY
03/05/1974
Derik
YaÅŸar AKSOY
05/02/1970
Derik
Serdar AKSOY
20/10/1989
Derik
Filiz AKSOY
01/06/1972
Derik
Sinan AKSOY
20/01/1988
Derik
53209/11
05/07/2011
Candan KOZANLI
01/01/1965
Çanakkale
Ceyda AKKAÅž DEMÄ°RCÄ°
53231/11
29/06/2011
Hamza ÇİFTÇİ
01/01/1952
Aksaray
Beytullah COÅžKUN
53257/11
08/06/2011
Sevil ADA
23/03/1955
Ä°stanbul
Faruk ÖKSÜZ
53820/11
20/05/2011
ALTUNTAS KÖYÜ VE AŞAĞI KÖY MUHTARLIĞI
Malatya
Mehmet GÖRGEÇ
54560/11
08/07/2011
Yücel MANDACI
01/01/1940
Çanakkale
Hasan Erokay MANDACI
54786/11
19/08/2011
Hasan Turan YETÄ°M
13/02/1962
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
54793/11
06/07/2011
Gökhan ARSLANTÜRK
29/09/1972
Ankara
Yılmaz İÇÖZ
54795/11
23/06/2011
Abbas BAYIR
01/03/1965
Istanbul
54796/11
20/06/2011
Ahmet ÜÇEK
20/04/1978
Istanbul
Yusuf EYCAN
54801/11
15/07/2011
Taner KANDEMÄ°R
16/09/1949
Istanbul
Ömer ÖNEREN
55497/11
17/06/2011
Osman AKTAÅž
10/04/1966
Sivas
Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ
55693/11
01/08/2011
Serhat ÅžAÅžOÄžLU
21/03/1961
Ä°zmir
Sevgi DEMÄ°RTAÅž
55879/11
30/06/2011
Mustafa NAZLIER
26/09/1969
Ä°zmir
İlkay PALA ÖGE
56164/11
12/05/2011
Metin TUNCEL
08/04/1933
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
56995/11
12/07/2011
Gülten DEMİRHAN
20/10/1954
Ankara
Z. Cem DEMÄ°RHAN
57296/11
05/08/2011
Selman AYDIN
01/01/1978
Istanbul
Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ
57471/11
01/07/2011
Yusuf ÇİÇEK
11/05/1965
Viyana
Figen OPAK ÇİÇEK
57594/11
25/06/2011
Tuncay KARAKAÅž
18/03/1975
Bursa
Nigar YILMAZ
57596/11
27/06/2011
Salih BEKTAÅž
15/03/1960
Freudenstadt
58011/11
05/08/2011
Mehmet Ali ÇELİK
13/10/1977
Şanlıurfa
Ä°lyas BARAN
58568/11
08/08/2011
Vahit COÅžAR
10/05/1964
Amasya
Makbule ÖZER ARPAĞ
58936/11
11/07/2011
Ahmet EKÄ°NCÄ°
12/02/1972
Diyarbakır
58943/11
25/08/2011
Özen NURAY
17/10/1960
MuÄŸla
Selçuk KURT
59979/11
25/07/2011
Salih ASLAN
05/04/1971
Şanlıurfa
Ä°lyas BARAN
60059/11
22/07/2011
Kerim CÄ°CÄ°
21/05/1938
Bingöl
Mustafa ALPTEKÄ°N
60558/11
24/08/2011
Adnan HALÄ°S
01/01/1952
Hendek
Erol ARIKAN
01/01/1962
Gönen
Esral KARAGÖZ
30/01/1961
Istanbul
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
11/08/1966
Istanbul
Volkan KARTAL
01/01/1977
Istanbul
Kemal TUFAN
01/01/1967
Istanbul
Erol KAPLAN
01/01/1967
Istanbul
Hikmet KALE
08/12/1970
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Mehmet GÖKTAŞ
01/01/1966
Tunceli
Mehmet BOZTEPE
01/01/1968
Malatya
Hacı Aziz HUN
01/01/1965
Samsun
Dinçer OTLUÇİMEN
01/01/1976
Istanbul
Yılmaz YİĞİT
01/01/1976
Istanbul
Bülent YİĞİT
01/01/1977
Istanbul
Cem ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1976
Istanbul
Gülizar TUNCER
60943/11
14/09/2011
Nuran ÖZDEMİR
01/10/1961
Ankara
Ömer ÜNLÜ
60986/11
07/06/2011
Memnune KARAKULAK
04/01/1961
Istanbul
61290/11
11/08/2011
Ä°mam AYDIN
01/01/1977
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
62408/11
27/07/2011
İhsan KÖRPE
07/12/1986
Siirt
62442/11
24/08/2011
Özgür SAĞLAM
01/01/1981
Istanbul
Cengiz KARAKAÅž
17/04/1978
TekirdaÄŸ
Vedat ÇELİK
01/01/1981
Istanbul
Several BALLIKAYA
62655/11
20/09/2011
Atilla GÃœRDER
02/01/1947
Ankara
İlhan BİÇER
63115/11
21/09/2011
Babur Nuri KILIÇ
01/01/1960
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63129/11
21/09/2011
Yücel KÜRKLÜ
01/01/1945
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63135/11
21/09/2011
Didem ERGÄ°N
21/07/1975
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63138/11
21/09/2011
Gülgün TREN
14/06/1948
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63163/11
21/09/2011
Abdülkadir SAĞER
28/02/1958
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63167/11
21/09/2011
Nuriye ÖSER
03/02/1934
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63169/11
21/09/2011
Ayfer Ahu ÇAKIR
25/12/1954
Ankara
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63173/11
21/09/2011
SavaÅŸ Ahmet BUÄžRA
11/01/1965
Amasra
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63176/11
21/09/2011
Sevgi ILGAZ
27/12/1942
EskiÅŸehir
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63186/11
21/09/2011
Özcan EMEK
01/11/1944
Sakarya
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63190/11
29/08/2011
Bircan KAYSUN
20/12/1965
Ankara
Özcan GÜÇLÜ
24/05/1964
Ankara
Gürcan GÜÇLÜ
22/03/1970
Ankara
Nevin ÖZKAN
63191/11
21/09/2011
Timur Ahmet KILIÇ
01/01/1959
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63198/11
21/09/2011
Cengiz Mehmet KILIÇ
01/01/1957
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
63213/11
21/09/2011
Saliha Solmaz ÖĞET
06/10/1931
Istanbul
Ergin CÄ°NMEN
68064/11
26/09/2011
Bekir ARPA
10/03/1935
Diyarbakır
Fırat ÜGER
70415/11
04/10/2011
Hakkı AKBAŞ
29/06/1966
Ä°zmir
Yüksel KAVAK KILINÇ
72974/11
31/10/2011
Ahmet ÇELEBİ
01/01/1945
Istanbul
Cem ALPTEKÄ°N
74392/11
10/10/2011
Ersin ÖZŞEN
04/05/1973
Istanbul
Haluk PEKÅžEN
76763/11
23/11/2011
Süleyman SARIBOĞA
01/08/1951
Aydın
Gül SÖZEN
7527/12
29/11/2011
Nurettin BORAN
10/03/1962
Ankara
9725/12
25/01/2012
Ahmet BESER
12/05/1962
Istanbul
Ahmet Ersin BAZMANOÄžLU
17/08/1950
Istanbul
HÄ°DRO-MAK DAMPER VE HÄ°DROLÄ°K MAKÄ°NALARI SAN. TÄ°C. A.Åž.
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
10037/12
23/12/2011
Yıldız İMREK
15/11/1964
Istanbul
Semir KARADAÅž
10325/12
14/12/2011
Aziz ÖZDEMİR
01/01/1957
Adana
Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU
13479/12
06/01/2012
Melek ORHAN
15/06/1949
MuÄŸla
Åžuayip ORHAN
11/11/1967
MuÄŸla
Naciye CEYLAN
13714/12
13/02/2012
Ahmet KIZIL
01/07/1941
Adıyaman
Mustafa YAVUZ
13730/12
27/01/2012
Mustafa YILMAZ
30/03/1953
Sakarya
Nadir KURTDERE
14538/12
23/02/2012
Necati ÇALIŞKAN
29/08/1959
Ä°zmir
Barış KAŞKA
14539/12
23/02/2012
Halime DALMIÅž
09/11/1964
Ä°zmir
Barış KAŞKA
14540/12
23/02/2012
Birsen ÜLKÜ
20/10/1969
Ä°zmir
Barış KAŞKA
15079/12
24/01/2012
Mehmet Nuri KARAKAYA
10/02/1976
Kırklareli
16379/12
03/02/2012
Mithat CABA
19/07/1954
Amasya
Kasım ER
16385/12
20/02/2012
Süleyman ERDEM
01/01/1968
Istanbul
Baran DOÄžAN
16439/12
10/02/2012
Sabit DURMUÅž
10/07/1951
Ä°skenderun
16452/12
23/02/2012
Ali Sait BULUT
09/08/1966
Istanbul
Åžefik KARAKIÅž
16532/12
22/02/2012
Fuat ÇETİNKAYA
01/01/1964
Şanlıurfa
Fatma TAVAÅž
01/01/1966
Şanlıurfa
Ayşe ÇETİNTAŞ
03/03/1981
Şanlıurfa
Abdullah ÇETİNKAYA
02/04/1985
Şanlıurfa
Hasan ÇETİNKAYA
01/04/1980
Şanlıurfa
Osman ÇETİNKAYA
01/01/1959
Şanlıurfa
Hüseyin ÇETİNKAYA
01/01/1978
Aydın
Saliha ÇETİNKAYA
01/03/1940
Şanlıurfa
Muhammet ÇETİNKAYA
10/01/1977
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
16569/12
23/02/2012
Bedriye AZEMOÄžLU
22/02/1981
Şanlıurfa
Şükran YILMAZER
22/02/1974
Şanlıurfa
Hasan BALTACI
22/02/1979
Şanlıurfa
Cengiz BALTACI
22/04/1973
Şanlıurfa
Sedat BALTACI
22/02/1986
Şanlıurfa
Kadriye YILDIZ
22/02/1977
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
18143/12
16/02/2012
Asiye FARAÇ
01/01/1971
Şanlıurfa
Eyüp AVCI
01/07/1949
Şanlıurfa
Ziya AVCI
01/01/1969
Şanlıurfa
BinevÅŸ Ä°NCE
02/03/1946
Şanlıurfa
Mehmet AVCI
08/05/1947
Şanlıurfa
Fatma AVCI
01/01/1945
Şanlıurfa
Emine AKMAN
04/06/1953
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
19659/12
09/06/2011
Hikmet GAYIP
01/05/1965
Istanbul
19747/12
07/06/2011
Azmi GÜNGÖR
19/04/1960
Istanbul
21064/12
22/02/2012
Murtaza ANSEN
13/09/1951
Ä°zmir
Kubilay Ä°stemi ERGÃœN
26141/12
06/04/2012
Sebahattin YALÇIN
05/04/1967
EskiÅŸehir
27087/12
13/03/2012
Fikret ESMEROÄžLU
01/01/1948
Şanlıurfa
Lütfü POLAT
27348/12
30/03/2012
Tahir Nafiz ÖZKUL
01/08/1949
Denizli
27373/12
05/04/2012
Arif ÖTLEŞ
21/05/1983
Ankara
Nuran ÖZDEMİR
29252/12
02/04/2012
Bilal ÇETİNER
03/02/1974
Gümüşhane
48753/12
03/06/2012
Mehmet GÜNGÖR
01/01/1965
Şanlıurfa
Mehmet KIRBOÄžA
49490/12
04/06/2012
Sevil KARABURÇAK
10/03/1952
MuÄŸla
51150/12
14/06/2012
Filiz GÃœMELÄ°
06/06/1960
Ä°zmir
Sevim ÇAM (LAPÇİN)
04/07/1956
Ä°zmir
Günay TÜRK
15/03/1960
Ä°zmir
Turgay TÃœRK
24/09/1958
Ä°zmir
Güney DİNÇ
54588/12
18/06/2012
Hamdi GÜNGÖR
01/05/1976
Manisa
Mustafa ROLLAS
56073/12
25/06/2012
Hatice Semra BAÅžTÃœRK
03/08/1957
Ä°zmir
Havva Zülal KARATÜFEK
15/10/1955
Ä°zmir
Fatma Nihal ISPARTA
30/11/1964
Ä°zmir
Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK
56283/12
02/07/2012
Halil GEÇKİL
01/01/1961
Şanlıurfa
Ahmet GÜNGÖR
01/01/1962
Şanlıurfa
Deham GÜNGÖR
01/01/1957
Şanlıurfa
İsmail GEÇKİL
01/01/1962
Şanlıurfa
Mehmet KIRBOÄžA
56761/12
16/07/2012
Ziya KÖROĞLU
01/01/1967
Antalya
Bekir ASRÄ°
56922/12
11/06/2012
AyÅŸan DEMÄ°R
19/02/1962
Batman
Fahrettin DEMÄ°R
01/01/1978
Batman
Abdurrahim DEMÄ°R
01/10/1992
Batman
Sibetullah DEMÄ°R
01/01/1987
Batman
Alaattin DEMÄ°R
10/11/1979
Batman
Muhittin DEMÄ°R
25/09/1983
Batman
Seyhan GÃœZEL
01/01/1985
Batman
Ceyhan DEMÄ°R
01/01/1989
Batman
Naif DEMÄ°R
01/01/1960
Batman
Bayram DEMÄ°R
02/02/1962
Batman
Rıfat DEMİR
15/04/1958
Batman
Mehmet Masum ERKEN
62289/12
30/07/2012
Mustafa UÇAR
18/12/1950
Aydın
Adnan ÇUKUR
62535/12
18/11/2011
Güler SÖYLEMEZ (YILMAZ)
01/01/1982
Istanbul
Gülizar TUNCER
62612/12
11/09/2012
Osman GÖKDAL
01/01/1956
Mersin
ErdoÄŸan ATA
63107/12
11/09/2012
Fatma GÖREN
05/05/1927
Istanbul
İlhan GÖREN
01/05/1954
Istanbul
Zahide HASPOLAT
04/10/1949
Istanbul
Sedat HASPOLAT
65432/12
20/09/2012
Yavuz BÄ°LEN
01/06/1975
Istanbul
Osman SALMAN
66487/12
10/09/2012
Atilla GÃœRDER
02/01/1947
Ankara
İlhan BİÇER
66508/12
20/09/2012
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Naki DEMÄ°R
01/01/1981
Ankara
Sedat OT
01/01/1975
Ankara
YaÅŸar Ä°NCE
01/01/1972
Ankara
Deniz TEPELÄ°
01/01/1977
Ankara
Hakan KARAKUÅž
66603/12
01/09/2012
Sabri TOLUAY
05/04/1928
Bingöl
Türkan KIRMIZITAŞ
67044/12
21/09/2012
Hasan ÖZGE
10/11/1974
Aydın
Ece SOLMAZ
75633/12
21/09/2012
Bülent ÇAN
21/09/1980
Istanbul
Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ
75761/12
21/09/2012
Mehmet ReÅŸit AKAR
01/01/1975
Istanbul
Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ
77609/12
09/09/2012
Ahmet ERCÄ°YAÅž
01/01/1961
Diyarbakır
Gülcan KARTAL
32/13
09/11/2012
Yanık SATILMIŞ
08/04/1974
Zonguldak
21323/13
15/03/2013
Åžahin ÅžAMDAN
01/09/1975
Kocaeli
Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN