Lexploria

SECOND SECTION

DECISION

Application no . 40869/07 Yadin KARAGÖL against Turkey and 174 other applications (see list appended)

The European Court of Human Rights ( Second Section ), sitting on 5 November 2013 as a Committee composed of:

Dragoljub Popović , President, Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, Helen Keller, judges , and Seçkin Erel , Acting Deputy Section Registrar ,

Having regard to the 175 applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

THE FACTS

A. The circumstances of the case s

The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix, may be summarized as follows.

On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil, administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them. All proceedings lasted several years .

B. Relevant domestic law

A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and others v. Turkey (( dec. ), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013) .

COMPLAINTS

The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.

Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1.

These complaints are linked to the same proceedings which they complain about the excessive length .

THE LAW

I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS

The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal backgrounds .

II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION

All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides :

“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”

The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.

In that respect, the Court found in its decision M ü d ü r Turgut and o thers (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.

In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.

It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.

III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATION S OF THE CONVENTION

Relying on various a rticles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.

Having examined the applicants ’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matter s complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.

It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill ‑ founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.

For these reasons, the Court unanimously

Decides to join the applications;

Declares the applications inadmissible.

Seçkin Erel Dragoljub Popović Acting Deputy Registrar President

Appendix

No

Application No

Lodged on

Applicant

Date of birth

Place of residence

Represented by

40869/07

10/09/2007

Yadin KARAGÖL

02/03/1961

Kayseri

9976/08

27/02/2008

Sait TANGÖR

01/04/1950

Manisa

İbrahim Halil TANGÖR

23658/08

19/05/2008

Müzeyyen ONGAN

23/06/1945

I stanbul

Mehmet UÇUM

47713/08

26/09/2008

Hüseyin ERTUĞRUL

04/11/1940

Ankara

15833/09

20/02/2009

Kamil Engin ÖZTÜRK

01/01/1950

I stanbul

Gülsevim UZUNLAR

01/01/1941

I stanbul

Ümit ÖZTÜRK

01/01/1952

I stanbul

Eyüp Dursun AYTAÇ

01/01/1949

I stanbul

Åžerife KARA

I stanbul

Halil ÜÇLER

01/01/1935

I stanbul

Sinem ÜÇLER

01/01/1990

I stanbul

Hasene ÅžEN

01/01/1927

I stanbul

Emine Yüksel TAŞOVA

01/01/1947

I stanbul

Hatice Gülsüm KILIÇARSLAN

01/01/1956

I stanbul

Fatma Zehra ALTINEL

01/01/1949

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali BÄ°LGÄ°LÄ°

I stanbul

Halit SEZER

01/01/1943

I stanbul

Ömer Lütfi SEZER

01/01/1915

I stanbul

AyÅŸe KARASU

01/01/1949

I stanbul

Nalan ARAÇ

01/01/1970

I stanbul

Nazan TANK

01/01/1978

I stanbul

Elif KARASU

01/01/1983

I stanbul

Atiye ÃœLKÃœ

38314/09

01/07/2009

Kani FÄ°DAN

01/01/1962

Samsun

Rahime FÄ°DAN

14/02/1960

Samsun

Orhan FÄ°DAN

25/02/1981

Samsun

Hakan FÄ°DAN

08/01/1985

Samsun

Nurgül FİDAN

30/03/1989

Samsun

Hayrettin AYYILDIZ

05/10/1971

Samsun

Yılmaz ÖZTÜRK

01/12/1969

Samsun

Ali UZUN

22/03/1965

Samsun

57081/10

10/08/2010

Dilif KIRMIZITAÅž

01/07/1924

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

57091/10

10/08/2010

Leyla AKTAÅž

01/08/1948

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

57102/10

10/08/2010

Rıza BOZOOĞLU

01/04/1956

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

57212/10

10/08/2010

Dursun AÄžGÃœL

15/05/1973

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

57219/10

10/08/2010

Selvi AÄžGÃœL

06/04/1935

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

57226/10

10/08/2010

Yeter KARATAÅž

02/11/1964

I stanbul

Halil KARATAÅž

01/01/1957

I stanbul

Sabire İÇYER

17/05/1948

I stanbul

Aslı İÇYER

10/04/1973

I stanbul

Seda BOZOOÄžLU

10/03/1962

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

58251/10

01/09/2010

Murat PALANGO

01/01/1971

I stanbul

Celal ÖZGÜL

01/01/1961

Tunceli

PaÅŸa AÄžGÃœL

01/01/1939

Elif COÅžAN

01/01/1952

I stanbul

Aydın ÇILGIN

01/01/1966

I stanbul

Gülten ÖNDER

01/01/1960

I stanbul

Haydar TOPUZ

01/01/1951

I stanbul

Ä°bis TOPUZ

01/01/1935

I stanbul

Hıdır ENGİN

01/01/1934

Duisburg

Ani ÇILGIN

01/01/1936

Istanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

12885/11

31/08/2010

Teslim GÃœLOÄžLU

16/09/1965

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17040/11

10/08/2010

Turan AÄžGÃœL

01/03/1965

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17041/11

10/08/2010

Ali Ä°hsan AÄžGÃœL

01/01/1964

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17042/11

10/08/2010

Selvi TOPUZ

01/01/1946

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17043/11

10/08/2010

Celal KIRMIZITAÅž

01/01/1953

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17044/11

10/08/2010

Ä°brahim KARATAÅž

01/01/1939

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17045/11

10/08/2010

Cahit AKTAÅž

01/01/1954

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17046/11

10/08/2010

Cafer AÄžGÃœL

01/01/1935

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17047/11

10/08/2010

Alettin BOZTAÅž

01/01/1964

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17048/11

10/08/2010

AÄŸa LAZIM

01/01/1959

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17049/11

10/08/2010

Zabit KUL

01/01/1951

Istanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17050/11

10/08/2010

Müslüm KIRMIZITAŞ

01/01/1954

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17051/11

10/08/2010

Halit KIRMIZITAÅž

01/01/1947

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17052/11

10/08/2010

Ahmet LAZIM

01/01/1950

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17053/11

10/08/2010

Kenan AÄžGÃœL

01/01/1966

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17054/11

10/08/2010

Hamu ELMAS

01/01/1935

Tunceli

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17055/11

10/08/2010

Keziban BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1938

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17056/11

10/08/2010

Sait AKTAÅž

01/01/1954

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17057/11

10/08/2010

Teslim KIRMIZITAÅž

01/01/1960

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17058/11

10/08/2010

Cemal BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1956

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17059/11

10/08/2010

Hüseyin GÜNGÖR

01/01/1951

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17060/11

10/08/2010

Seydo BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1949

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17061/11

10/08/2010

Metin BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1952

Istanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17062/11

10/08/2010

Hüseyin BOZTAŞ

01/01/1950

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17063/11

10/08/2010

Özkan KIRMIZITAŞ

01/01/1964

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17064/11

10/08/2010

Kenan BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1952

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17065/11

10/08/2010

Hasan BOZTAÅž

01/01/1954

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17066/11

10/08/2010

Yakup BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1962

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17067/11

10/08/2010

Erdoğan GÜNGÖR

01/01/1961

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17068/11

10/08/2010

Ali BOZTAÅž

01/01/1933

Istanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17069/11

10/08/2010

Saher ELMAS

01/01/1938

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17070/11

10/08/2010

Mazlum BOZTAÅž

01/01/1961

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17071/11

10/08/2010

Ahmet ELMAS

01/01/1955

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17072/11

10/08/2010

Ä°brahim AÄžGÃœL

01/01/1968

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17073/11

10/08/2010

Zefi AÄžGÃœL

01/01/1926

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17074/11

10/08/2010

Kerem ELMAS

01/01/1964

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17075/11

10/08/2010

Haydar AKTAÅž

01/01/1932

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17076/11

10/08/2010

Aziz BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1956

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17077/11

10/08/2010

Aydın ELMAS

01/01/1965

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17078/11

10/08/2010

Abbas AÄžGÃœL

01/01/1970

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17079/11

10/08/2010

Nuray ELMAS

01/01/1973

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

17080/11

10/08/2010

Emirali BOZOOÄžLU

01/01/1958

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

20268/11

10/08/2010

Yusuf KUL

01/01/1958

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

20271/11

10/08/2010

Sabri KIRMIZITAÅž

20/03/1963

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

27320/11

01/03/2011

Rıza ARAT

02/06/1965

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

27321/11

01/03/2011

Süleyman YOM

01/01/1961

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

27322/11

01/03/2011

Rıza ÇUBUK

01/01/1952

Tunceli

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

33852/11

10/08/2010

Cemsi LAZIM

01/01/1962

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

38313/11

26/05/2011

Ä°dris Ä°LHANLI

01/01/1990

Selahattin KAYA

40819/11

22/03/2011

Demet AKKAYA

05/02/1971

Ankara

Bülent AKKAYA

30/08/1959

Ankara

Levent AKKAYA

30/09/1962

Ankara

Perihan AKKAYA

06/05/1942

Ankara

Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ

42508/11

15/02/2011

Fatma YILDIZ

01/01/1962

Aydın

Åžebnem TOKAT

48361/11

27/06/2011

Jale MUSLUOÄžLU

17/03/1929

Ankara

Hüseyin ÜÇPINAR

01/03/1931

MuÄŸla

Makbule TÄ°RELÄ°

12/03/1927

MuÄŸla

Hikmet Tülay ÜÇPINAR

04/06/1943

MuÄŸla

Mediha Ebru MERZÄ°FONLU

09/05/1972

MuÄŸla

Levent ÜÇPINAR

13/09/1969

Balıkesir

Ayşe ÜÇPINAR

30/06/1943

MuÄŸla

Ahmet ÜÇPINAR

01/01/1961

MuÄŸla

Aysu KINACI

26/04/1964

MuÄŸla

Şefika ÖZTÜRK

30/07/1940

MuÄŸla

Esat ÖZTÜRK

04/01/1971

MuÄŸla

Önder ÖZTÜRK

01/01/1962

Denizli

Hasan KOCAGÖZ

01/01/1941

Denizli

Bülent ÜÇPINAR

24/04/1963

MuÄŸla

Serkan CENGÄ°Z

48535/11

02/05/2011

Nesrin KEÇE (KARABULUT)

20/01/1957

Ankara

Çağan Mehmet DAYANIR

48578/11

04/05/2011

Sultan Melek TEKÄ°N

03/03/1959

Ankara

Ali Ä°hsan GÃœZEL

54840/11

14/07/2011

Fatma Şenay MERİÇ

27/07/1954

Ä°stanbul

59075/11

26/07/2011

2 C ENERJÄ° LT D . ÅžTÄ°

Ankara

Baran ÖZCAN

63010/11

29/08/2011

Ergül YENİCE

15/05/1959

Kırıkkale

Nizamettin ÖZAYDIN

65015/11

27/09/2011

Sabahattin Engin AKKAYA

20/08/1947

Bursa

Gülbahar KARADENİZ

28/09/1942

Zonguldak

Cemal ERTUÄž

01/01/1945

Zonguldak

Ergün BODUR

22/02/1944

Zonguldak

Ahmet BÃœK

08/06/1967

Zonguldak

Zeki YÃœKSEL

08/11/1948

Zonguldak

Mete ORHAN

07/11/1951

Bartın

66469/11

19/09/2011

Havva AK

31/12/1972

Malatya

Kadir AKGÃœNEÅž

66702/11

16/09/2011

Ali ÇAPAL

06/04/1960

I stanbul

69488/11

07/10/2011

Silva BENLÄ°

01/01/1955

I stanbul

Murat ÇELİK

69957/11

06/10/2011

Yılmaz DOĞAN

01/01/1950

I stanbul

Murat ÇELİK

70350/11

05/10/2011

Yunus KIBIK

05/06/1985

I stanbul

Mehmet AKBAÅž

72302/11

01/03/2011

Dursun EMRE

03/04/1936

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

72306/11

01/03/2011

Ali ÖZTAŞ

18/03/1956

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

72308/11

01/03/2011

Åžahsenem CÄ°HAN

01/01/1923

I stanbul

Ahmet CÄ°HAN

01/01/1954

Ä°stanbul

Hanım ŞAHİN

01/01/1957

Ä°stanbul

Sakine ÅžAHÄ°N

01/01/1944

Ä°stanbul

Songül EMRE

01/01/1962

Ä°stanbul

Cevahir YAÄžAN

01/01/1947

Ä°stanbul

Eylem ÖZTÜRK

01/01/1973

I stanbul

Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK

6950/12

17/01/2012

Mustafa TÃœRKOÄžLU

25/03/1975

Samsun

Havva TÃœRKOÄžLU

04/04/1944

Samsun

Mustafa AKTAÅž

12/01/1964

Samsun

Nuray AKTAÅž

15/09/1969

Samsun

Refiye KARABABA

19/11/1970

Samsun

Fevzi Cem ÅžENOCAK

7857/12

22/06/2011

Ali Rıza YILDIRIM

02/02/1966

I stanbul

10454/12

27/12/2011

Oya YILMAZ

12/06/1955

Ä°zmir

Naciye CEYLAN

11849/12

03/01/2012

Namık Kemal YILMAZ

16/08/1951

Mersin

Mustafa ERDOÄžDU

14591/12

17/02/2012

Ramazan TOPAL

13/09/1987

Şanlıurfa

Filiz TOPAL

25/09/1989

Şanlıurfa

Emine GÃœLER

05/10/1984

Şanlıurfa

Fatma GÃœLER

08/01/1984

Şanlıurfa

AÅŸhan DOKUMACI

01/01/1981

Şanlıurfa

Hanım GÖÇER

20/01/1966

Şanlıurfa

Mustafa YAVUZ

14627/12

20/01/2012

HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş.

05/06/1950

I stanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

14629/12

20/01/2012

HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş.

05/06/1950

I stanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

14633/12

23/01/2012

HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş.

05/06/1950

I stanbul

HÄ°DRO-MAK DAMPER VE HÄ°DROLÄ°K MAKÄ°NALARI SAN. TÄ°C. A.Åž.

I stanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

19595/12

04/01/2012

Ahmet BOZKIR

01/06/01975

Batman

Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ

20875/12

16/03/2012

Hacer ARIKAN

01/01/1966

Balıkesir

Hüseyin KARAKAŞ

21314/12

12/03/2012

YEŞİL ANTALYA MÜFTÜ ARAZİSİ HİSSEDARLARI YAPI KOOPERATİFİ

Antalya

Salih PINAR

24601/12

19/03/2012

Dilber ÖZTÜRK

20/02/1974

Ä°zmir

Nermin SELÇUK

24738/12

07/03/2012

Kazım ÇAYAN

01/04/1948

Samsun

Gülcan AYDIN

15/02/1981

Samsun

Musa ÇAYAN

15/03/1985

Samsun

Muammer ÇAYAN

02/04/1973

Samsun

Muhammet ÇAYAN

02/04/1977

Samsun

Rasime ÇAYAN

01/01/1949

Samsun

Nazmiye ÇAYAN

10/04/1988

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

26879/12

04/05/2012

Kadriye TURCAN

01/01/1946

Diyarbakır

Halit GÖZEN

23/02/1946

Diyarbakır

Fikri KASSAP

01/01/1965

Diyarbakır

Gülcan KARTAL

30698/12

06/04/2012

Senar CAMCI

06/02/1960

Mersin

Takyettin TAÅžKIN

15/09/1981

Aydın

Hamdi TURGUT

31711/12

10/04/2012

Süleyman Barış KÖROĞLU

07/09/1985

Ä°stanbul

Ali YILDIZ

31721/12

05/04/2012

Yusuf GÃœN

03/08/1943

Batman

Abdullah BAÅžARAN

12/09/1935

Batman

Mehmet BAÄžATIR

32062/12

21/03/2012

Rasul KOCATÃœRK

01/10/1965

Bolu

Mehmet Aytunç ALTAY

08/06/1956

Kocaeli

Mehmet Baha GÃœVELOÄžLU

01/01/1964

Kocaeli

Mehmet GÃœNEÅž

01/01/1951

Tekirda ÄŸ

Hüseyin ATICI

01/01/1970

Istanbul

Bülent BARMAKSIZ

06/01/1965

I stanbul

Hüseyin TUT

28/01/1972

Kocaeli

Bekir BALYEMEZ

01/01/1970

Ankara

Önder ÇARKÇI

01/01/1973

K ocaeli

Kamil YILDIZ

01/01/1965

Bülent GEDİK

01/01/1974

Kocaeli

Tamer TUNCER

25/10/1971

Kocaeli

Yüksel YİĞİTDOĞAN

22/07/1968

Kocaeli

Mustafa YAÅžAR

01/01/1959

Istanbul

Murat TARI

01/01/1975

Giresun

Mustafa DEMÄ°RER

01/01/1966

Ä°zmir

M. Tarık DİRİK

01/01/1965

Adana

SevdaÄŸ YILMAZ

01/01/1967

Edirne

Asude Åžafak DÄ°RÄ°K

01/01/1972

Adana

Hasan SEVÄ°M

05/09/1954

Tunceli

Hüsamettin ÖZDEM

01/01/1970

Ankara

Bağdegül KOCATÜRK

01/01/1969

Istanbul

Gülizar TUNCER

35296/12

11/04/2012

Erhan YETÄ°K

13/05/1964

I stanbul

37093/12

13/04/2012

Kemal ALKAN

10/04/1975

I stanbul

Ömer ÇELİK

01/01/1963

I stanbul

Seyit Nusret ÖZTÜRK

38780/12

01/05/2012

Mehmet DÄ°KER

13/09/1945

Diyarbakır

Nalan BENER

38888/12

02/04/2012

Ömer KURT

03/01/1979

Ankara

39154/12

29/05/2012

Ayten ÇELİK

11/05/1959

Ä°zmir

Berrin ALTIOK

39523/12

09/05/2012

Necmettin AYDINLI

06/04/1955

Diyarbakır

Ümüt MİKE

47741/12

28/06/2012

Fahrettin ESENDEMÄ°R

14/08/1968

I stanbul

47793/12

28/05/2012

Musa ÖZCAN

01/01/1981

I stanbul

Nurten KORKUSUZ

14/12/1967

I stanbul

OÄŸuzhan GÃœNER

01/01/1972

I stanbul

Hüseyin AKIN

05/02/1982

I stanbul

Umut BÄ°NBÄ°R

01/01/1979

I stanbul

Güler SALMAN

01/01/1979

I stanbul

Sultan YENÄ°GÃœL

01/01/1981

I stanbul

Seyhan KABADAYI

01/01/1979

I stanbul

Nuray GÃœNDÃœZ

01/01/1980

I stanbul

Aytaç DİNÇÇETİN

01/01/1975

I stanbul

Hikmet KORKUSUZ

13/03/1962

I stanbul

Özgür KABADAYI

04/09/1982

Ä°stanbul

Eray GERGÄ°N

01/01/1980

I stanbul

Mehmet YENÄ°GÃœL

01/01/1978

I stanbul

Mesut BAYRAKTAR

01/01/1986

I stanbul

Suat EREN

49095/12

06/06/2012

Ziya COÅžKUN

10/11/1964

Adana

BuÄŸra YEGÃœL

49357/12

25/05/2012

Nimet KÖŞE

01/01/1955

Diyarbakır

Mehmet Sıddık KÖŞE

01/01/1946

Diyarbakır

Mehmet Fesih KÖŞE

01/01/1970

Diyarbakır

Mehmet YUKUÅž

01/01/1946

Diyarbakır

Salih YUKUÅž

01/01/1950

Diyarbakır

Servet KÖSE

01/01/1961

Diyarbakır

Mehmet Şakir ORUÇLU

01/01/1951

Diyarbakır

Mehmet Selim ÇİÇEK

01/01/1943

Diyarbakır

Remzi YUKUÅž

01/01/1973

Diyarbakır

Yahya ÇİÇEK

01/01/1943

Diyarbakır

Abdurrahman YUKUÅž

01/01/1964

Diyarbakır

Mehmet Åžafii YUKUÅž

01/01/1966

Diyarbakır

Ahmet YUKUÅž

01/01/1954

Diyarbakır

Mehmet Rauf ÇİÇEK

49888/12

24/05/2012

Cuma PULGAT

01/01/1967

Diyarbakır

Zeki KARTAL

50102/12

03/05/2012

Åžeyhmus BAÅžTUÄž

04/01/1976

Mardin

Kemal BAÅžTUÄž

05/08/1989

Mardin

Åžeyhdavut BAÅžTUÄž

05/08/1989

Mardin

Nezihe BAÅžTUÄž

12/11/1973

Mardin

Sultan BAÅžTUÄž

01/01/1952

Mardin

Tenzile BABUR

12/11/1970

Mardin

Emine BAÅžTUÄž

31/07/1993

Mardin

Fatma BAÅžTUÄž

31/07/1993

Mardin

Halil BAÅžTUÄž

25/07/1995

Mardin

Sadiye BAÅžTUÄž

04/04/1986

Mardin

Yahya TURAN

50441/12

19/07/2012

Hatice DUMAN

05/04/1974

Gebze

Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N

53846/12

27/06/2012

Durdu Mehmet DALKANAT

01/01/1953

KahramanmaraÅŸ

Ramazan Selçuk EREN

53962/12

30/05/2012

Hasan TAPAN

01/03/1969

Şanlıurfa

54103/12

25/06/2012

Gürkan KULAKOĞLU

15/10/1962

Aydın

Faruk İŞÇEN

25/12/1957

Aydın

Serpil ÖZÇELİK

08/03/1963

Aydın

EÅŸref SARIBAÅž

01/04/1956

Aydın

Bekir TİMUÇİN

14/02/1961

Aydın

Halit MORALIOÄžLU

54386/12

24/07/2012

Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU

01/02/1947

I stanbul

Eyüp ERASLAN

54610/12

28/06/2012

Gaye ONAN

04/02/1976

Ä°zmir

54814/12

09/07/2012

Nurhan KILIÇ

14/04/1974

Batman

Nurhayat KILIÇ

05/01/1993

Batman

Mehmet Hakan TOY

54845/12

31/07/2012

Yıldız OTO AĞCA

06/08/1954

Antalya

55012/12

09/07/2012

Nüfer ŞEN

01/09/1963

Diyarbakı r

İhsan NARÇİÇEK

01/01/1963

Diyarbakı r

Mihdiye KOÇEROĞLU

01/01/1940

Diyarbakı r

Cemal KOÇEROĞLU

01/01/1963

Diyarbakı r

Keziban NARÇİÇEK

01/01/1963

Diyarbakı r

Şaban YEŞİL

01/01/1965

Diyarbakı r

İzzettin YEŞİL

01/01/1965

Diyarbakı r

Mehmet Şirin KOÇEROĞLU

01/01/1965

Diyarbakı r

Zeki ÇELİK

55679/12

10/05/2012

Songül ATLI

11/03/1966

I stanbul

55958/12

05/07/2012

Mehmet Nuri ACAR

01/07/1971

I stanbul

Mehmet ERBÄ°L

56503/12

28/06/2012

Gülseven TUNCER

25/01/1936

Ä°zmir

Türkan BUHARALI

05/06/1934

Ankara

Sevtap TUNCER

06/05/1966

Ä°zmir

Murat Hamdi TUNCER

26/02/1969

Ä°zmir

Mehtap KARAOSMANOÄžLU

26/02/1969

Ä°zmir

Ä°clal Ä°LÄ°MOÄžLU

56618/12

07/06/2011

Aysel GÖLLER

12/04/1952

I stanbul

Mustafa GÖLLER

28/03/1951

I stanbul

57231/12

08/08/2012

Mehmet GÃœL

20/04/1973

Diyarbakır

Ramazan DEMÄ°R

57578/12

20/07/2012

Filiz EYÃœBOÄžLU

01/01/1959

I stanbul

Boran ÇİÇEKLİ

58181/12

12/08/2012

Orhan ERSOY

01/01/1959

Löhne

58961/12

02/07/2012

Mustafa ÃœNLÃœSOY

01/02/1961

I stanbul

59753/12

23/07/2012

Tuncay EREN

05/11/1981

I stanbul

Yücel GÖKTAŞ

59791/12

16/07/2012

Mesher Ä°BÄ°Åž

11/11/1978

I stanbul

Yusuf Kenan ALTAN

59840/12

12/07/2012

GAZİPAŞA TURİZM VE İNŞAAT TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ

Konya

Güner KUTLUK

60213/12

18/06/2012

Mehmet Atilla ÖZMEN

01/01/1973

Samsun

Lütfi KESKİN

60218/12

18/06/2012

Haluk ERTÃœRK

13/10/1955

Aydın

Levent ERCAN

60583/12

20/07/2012

Aydın YILDIZ

01/01/1972

Bursa

Tekin ÖZTÜRK

60797/12

24/07/2012

Nedim ÇONKARA

20/03/1973

Ä°zmir

Serkan CENGÄ°Z

60803/12

24/07/2012

Fazıl Zafer AYDOĞAN

02/12/1961

Ä°zmir

Serkan CENGÄ°Z

60808/12

24/07/2012

Nuri TAÅžBAÅž

15/01/1961

Ä°zmir

Serkan CENGÄ°Z

62604/12

10/09/2012

Åžeyhmus TURAN

01/01/1958

Ankara

Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ

62650/12

17/09/2012

Selim KESGÄ°N

22/01/1972

Mersin

63018/12

13/08/2012

Rıza AYDIN

01/01/1956

Adana

Kemal DERÄ°N

63226/12

02/08/2012

Yılmaz Can ÖZALP

01/01/1988

I stanbul

Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ

63259/12

06/08/2012

Ali TÃœRKMEN

22/02/1946

Samsun

Tuba Rana TÃœRKMEN

63310/12

12/08/2012

Mehmet KORKMAZ

10/09/1959

Mersin

Mustafa ERDOÄžDU

63313/12

17/09/2012

Sevil UYSAL

06/02/1967

Ankara

Kamer BEYAZTAÅž

63366/12

11/09/2012

Mine ÖZGENLER YILMAZ

15/01/1969

I stanbul

Güneş TOSUN ÖZENSOY

63375/12

13/09/2012

Ersoy TOSUN

27/12/1945

Ä°zmir

Muharrem TOSUN

19/02/1940

Ä°zmir

Güneş TOSUN ÖZENSOY

63591/12

10/09/2012

Aziz BOZYEL

24/05/1952

Ankara

Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ

63595/12

10/09/2012

Aleattin KAVÄ°T

10/10/1977

I stanbul

Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ

64608/12

15/08/2012

Senem KANDÄ°L

01/01/1945

Istanbul

Ä°brahim KANDÄ°L

01/01/1965

Istanbul

Celal KANDÄ°L

01/01/1970

Istanbul

Ali Ä°hsan KANDÄ°L

01/01/1974

Istanbul

Nazlı AKBULUT

01/01/1977

Istanbul

Serdar KANDÄ°L

01/01/1981

Istanbul

Kamil Tekin SÃœREK

65028/12

23/09/2012

Zehra YILMAZ

01/01/1962

I stanbul

Fazıl Ahmet TAMER

65469/12

08/08/2012

Barış GEBOLOĞLU

02/02/1960

Ä°zmir

Müşerref DEMİR

01/02/1962

Ä°zmir

Layika EREN

02/02/1949

Ä°zmir

Hanım ATEŞ

02/03/1957

Ä°zmir

Fedile Hanım ATEŞ

26/01/1933

Ä°zmir

AyÅŸete KAYA

01/01/1950

Ä°zmir

65531/12

07/08/2012

Selim ÅžAHÄ°N

02/10/1950

Hakkari

Adnan DEMÄ°RKAN

65898/12

22/08/2012

Müjdat ŞENGÜLER

26/07/1952

I stanbul

Haluk PEKÅžEN

66069/12

21/09/2012

Ferhat ÖZDEMİR

01/01/1983

I stanbul

Gül ALTAY

66162/12

17/08/2012

Mesut GÃœL

20/06/1971

TekirdaÄŸ

Taliphan KIYMAZ

66169/12

17/08/2012

Elbey ERYILMAZ

23/08/1977

TekirdaÄŸ

Taliphan KIYMAZ

66173/12

17/08/2012

Cemal AKÇAY

12/01/1971

TekirdaÄŸ

Taliphan KIYMAZ

66176/12

17/08/2012

Ä°smail MACÄ°T

20/02/1973

TekirdaÄŸ

Taliphan KIYMAZ

66638/12

05/09/2012

Ünsal ÖMER

29/07/1972

NevÅŸehir

66662/12

31/08/2012

Ali ÇELEBİOĞLU

15/05/1942

I stanbul

66739/12

09/12/2011

Cevher ÃœREK

22/02/1952

Kocaeli

Elvan KARATAÅž

66822/12

24/08/2012

Suna SELÇUK

10/10/1958

Istanbul

Didem SELÇUK

15/09/1985

Istanbul

Iraz SELÇUK

16/04/2006

Istanbul

Filiz ERDEN (SELÇUK)

05/02/1988

Istanbul

Halit BOSTANCI

67609/12

28/08/2012

Ali ÇELEBİOĞLU

15/05/1942

I stanbul

67738/12

15/08/2012

Hasan TOR

01/01/1969

Aydın

Åžebnem TOKAT

67802/12

13/08/2012

Semire ERCAN

26/02/1980

Mardin

Sarı KAYA

01/04/1965

Mardin

Selima DEMÄ°R

23/03/1982

Mardin

Mehmet DEMÄ°R

01/02/1974

Mardin

Ali DEMÄ°R

12/03/1987

Mardin

Perihan DEMÄ°R

12/03/1987

Mardin

Halise AY

01/03/1981

Mardin

Emine DEMÄ°R

24/02/1955

Mardin

Halise ASLAN

10/01/1962

Mardin

Burca OÄžUR

01/01/1965

Mardin

Kifehi AKA

02/01/1977

Mardin

Faysal DEMÄ°R

25/02/1976

Mardin

Fesih DEMÄ°R

03/01/1979

Mardin

Muzaffer DEMÄ°R

01/02/1975

Mardin

Hasine DEMÄ°R

01/01/1941

Mardin

Yazgı ÇİMEN FİDAN

67904/12

07/09/2012

Sadullah ARIK

16/07/1971

Ä°zmir

Hanife YILDIRIM

68131/12

09/08/2012

Orhan KESKÄ°N

30/09/1974

Hakkari

Adnan DEMÄ°RKAN

68492/12

10/09/2012

Nilgün EKMEKÇİ

Ä°zmir

Ayşe ÖKSÜZ

01/01/1950

Ä°zmir

Özgür BİNGÖL

69514/12

25/07/2012

Fulya Saliha ÜLÇEK KESENCİ

11/10/1977

Batman

RahÅŸan Bengi GEZGÄ°N KAYAN

69540/12

23/03/2012

Tarık ERKAN

31/05/1985

Ä°zmir

Ahmet Sinan SÃœRÃœCÃœ

70693/12

20/09/2012

Bülent BARMAKSIZ

06/01/1965

I stanbul

Gülizar TUNCER

70768/12

20/09/2012

Ali İhsan İŞİTMEZ

10/05/1981

I stanbul

Orhan ÖZERLİ

01/01/1983

I stanbul

Gül ALTAY

70893/12

18/09/2012

Mustafa Asım ÖZTÜRK

01/01/1946

Bodrum

70931/12

21/09/2012

Perihan YÃœKSEL

01/01/1939

Ankara

Bülent UTKU

78959/12

10/08/2012

Mehmet Nafi AKGÃœL

01/01/1960

Diyarbakır

Hüseyin AKGÜL

05/04/1962

Diyarbakır

Mehmet Åžerif AKGÃœL

01/01/1958

Hatay

Mehmet Emin AKGÃœL

01/01/1969

I stanbul

Yılmaz AKGÜL

01/01/1980

Mardin

Devran AKGÃœL

24/01/1978

Mardin

Sakine GÃœNEÅž

01/07/1985

Mardin

Zeynep GÃœL

01/03/1982

Mardin

Akisa YILDIZ

06/04/1964

Mardin

Fati AKGÃœL

01/02/1938

Mardin

Yahya TURAN

81546/12

21/08/2009

Niyazi BULGAN

10/06/1963

Gaziantep

Ercan KANAR

39/13

19/09/2012

Ä°nayet AKSU

20/12/1977

I stanbul

Barış ÇİLİNGİR

Menu

KARAGÖL AND OTHERS v. TURKEY

KARAGÖL AND OTHERS v. TURKEY

LEXI