ALTAY AND OTHERS v. TURKEY
Doc ref: 9100/06, 11990/06, 50178/06, 7679/07, 15839/07, 17055/07, 19287/07, 20898/07, 32417/07, 33534/07, 36... • ECHR ID: 001-160043
Document date: December 8, 2015
- Inbound citations: 1
- •
- Cited paragraphs: 0
- •
- Outbound citations: 4
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no . 9100/06 Mehmet Aytunç ALTAY against Turkey and 155 other applications (see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 8 December 2015 as a Committee composed of:
Nebojša Vučinić , President, Valeriu Griţco , Stéphanie Mourou-Vikström , judges, and Abel Campos, Deputy Section Registrar ,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table ,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
1. A list of the applicants and their representatives is set out in the appendix. The Turkish Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent.
A. The circumstances of the case
2. The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.
3. The applicants were serving their prison sentences in various establishments at the time of lodging their applications. The educational committees of the respective prisons decided not to allow the applicants to receive certain editions of miscellaneous periodicals and/or other publications based on different grounds. In some applications, parts of periodicals were censored before they were handed over to the applicants.
4. The applicants ’ objections were rejected respectively by the enforcement judges and assize courts.
5. In application no. 13917/09, the applicant was also prevented by a decision of the prison ’ s disciplinary board from sending a letter which he had written in Kurdish. The applicant ’ s objections before the enforcement judge and the assize court were rejected respectively.
B. Relevant domestic law
1. Regarding the prisoners ’ right to receive periodicals
6. A full description of the domestic law and practice at the relevant time may be found in Mesut Yurtsever and Others v. Turkey (nos. 14946/08, 21030/08, 24309/08, 24505/08, 26964/08, 26966/08, 27088/08, 27090//08, 27092/08, 38752/08, 38778/08 and 38807/08 , § § 78-80, 20 January 2015).
2. Regarding the prisoners ’ right to correspondence
7. A full description of the domestic law and practice at the relevant time may be found in Mehmet Nuri Özen and Others v. Turkey (nos. 15672/08, 24462/08, 27559/08, 28302/08, 28312/08, 34823/08, 40738/08, 41124/08, 43197/08, 51938/08 and 58170/08 , § § 30-34, 11 January 2011).
3. Regarding the competency of the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384
8. A full description of domestic law may be found in Yıldız and Yanak v. Turkey (( dec. ), no. 44013/07, §§ 9-17, 2 7 May 2014) and Özbil v. Turkey (( dec. ), no. 45601/09, § 6 , 29 September 2015).
COMPLAINTS
9. The applicants complained of a breach of their right to receive information as periodicals, newspapers and books had not been handed over to them in prison. In application no. 13917/09 the applicant further alleged that his letter had not been posted by the prison administration as he had written it in Kurdish. Some of the applicants further claimed that they had been subjected to discrimination on account of their Kurdish origin. Finally some of the applicants alleged that the domestic courts delivered their decisions on the basis of the case files, without holding a hearing, that the courts that had examined their cases had not been impartial and that the decisions lacked adequate reasoning. In connection with their complaints, the applicants relied on Articles 3, 6, 8, 10, 13 and 14 of the Convention.
THE LAW
10. Having regard to the similarity of the main issues under the Convention in the present cases, the Court decides to join the applications and consider them in a single decision.
11. The Government noted that following the pilot judgment procedure applied in the case of Ãœmmühan Kaplan v. Turkey (no. 24240/07, 20 March 2012), on 9 January 2013 the Turkish National Assembly enacted Law no. 6384 on the resolution, by means of compensation, of applications lodged with the Court concerning length of judicial proceedings and non ‑ enforcement or delayed enforcement of judicial decisions. The competence of the Compensation Commission was subsequently enlarged by a decree adopted on 10 February 2014, and published in the Official Gazette on 16 March 2014 to examine complaints relating to, among other issues, complaints lodged by detainees/prisoners about the restriction of the right of detainees to correspondence/communicate in a language other than Turkish; and the refusal of the prison authorities to hand over periodicals based on different grounds. In the light of the foregoing, the Government asked the Court to reject the applications for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies, since the applicants had not applied to the Compensation Commission.
12. The Court observes that, as pointed out by the Government, a new domestic remedy has been established in Turkey. It further recalls that it has already examined similar applications and declared them inadmissible on the ground that the applicants had failed to exhaust domestic remedies, that is to say the new remedy (see Çelik v. Turkey ( dec. ), no. 23772/13, 16 June 2015 concerning restriction of detainees ’ correspondence in Kurdish, and Özbil v. Turkey ( dec. ), no. 45601/09, 29 September 2015, concerning refusal of prison authorities to provide periodicals ). In so doing, the Court considered in particular that this new remedy was a priori accessible and capable of offering a reasonable prospect of redress for similar complaints.
13. As a result, taking into account the Government ’ s preliminary objection with regard to the applicants ’ failure to make use of the new domestic remedy established by Law no. 6384, the Court reiterates its conclusion in the case of Turgut and Others v. Turkey (( dec. ), no. 4860/09, 26 March 2013). It therefore concludes that these complaints should be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Done in English and notified in writing on 14 January 2016 .
Abel Campos NebojÅ¡a Vučinić Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX
No.
Application No.
Lodged on
Applicant
Date of birth
Place of residence
Represented by
9100/06
17/02/2006
Mehmet Aytunç ALTAY
08/06/1956
Kocaeli
Gülizar TUNCER
11990/06
27/01/2006
Tahir CANAN
05/05/1953
Kocaeli
Sevil ARACI BEK
50178/06
29/11/2006
Zeki BAYHAN
08/12/1976
Bolu
Hamit GEYLANÄ°
7679/07
19/01/2007
Mehmet ReÅŸit ARSLAN
01/06/1966
Ankara
15839/07
24/03/2007
Kaan ÃœNSAL
14/11/1968
Ankara
Evrim Deniz KARATANA
17055/07
12/04/2007
Engin ARSLAN
24/01/1981
Bolu
19287/07
27/04/2007
Ali DALABA
01/09/1974
Bolu
Menal AYÇİÇEK
20898/07
26/04/2007
Mustafa GEYLAN
13/04/1969
Hakkari
32417/07
19/07/2007
Hacı DEMİR
01/03/1955
Edirne
Taylan TANAY
33534/07
30/03/2007
Orhan ÇAÇAN
03/06/1971
Ä°zmir
Niyazi BULGAN
36001/07
06/08/2007
Hüseyin DUMAN
01/01/1974
Diyarbakır
Servet ÖZEN
38793/07
07/08/2007
Ali Osman KÖSE
01/05/1957
Edirne
Bark ı n TİMTİK
41862/07
10/09/2007
Ercan KARTAL
25/06/1962
Edirne
Oya ASLAN
50808/07
07/11/2007
Ramazan VURAL
05/01/1975
Bolu
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
54420/07
04/12/2007
Rabbena HANEDAR
01/01/1965
Sincan
Kaan ÃœNSAL
01/01/1968
Ankara
Mustafa GÖK
01/01/1970
Ankara
Cem GÖÇER
01/01/1971
Ankara
Bülent BAĞCI
01/01/1964
Ankara
Ethem ZARIC
01/01/1972
Ankara
İhsan ÇİBELİK
01/07/1964
Ankara
Özgür YILMAZ
55216/07
18/06/2007
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
55221/07
18/06/2007
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
55227/07
04/12/2007
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
1328/08
19/12/2007
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
2360/08
24/12/2007
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
2481/08
26/12/2007
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
5599/08
16/12/2007
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Kemal ERTÃœRK
01/01/1975
Ankara
Mesut DENÄ°Z
01/01/1975
Ankara
Mustafa DEMÄ°RDAÄž
16/09/1972
Ankara
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Naki DEMÄ°R
01/01/1981
Ankara
Ali GÃœLMEZ
15/09/1955
Ankara
YaÅŸar Ä°NCE
01/01/1972
Ankara
Gül ALTAY
14006/08
04/03/2008
Habip ÇİFTÇİ
10/03/1973
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
14570/08
20/03/2008
Haydar SÖNMEZ
01/01/1970
Erzurum
Gül ALTAY
15886/08
03/03/2008
Abdullah RÃœZGAR
02/05/1969
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
17432/08
28/03/2008
Mustafa DEMÄ°RDAÄž
16/09/1972
Ankara
Kemal ERTÃœRK
01/01/1975
Ankara
Ali GÃœLMEZ
01/01/1965
Ankara
Mesut DENÄ°Z
01/01/1975
Ankara
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Kenan ÖZYÜREK
01/01/1981
Ankara
Hakan KARAKUÅž
18111/08
07/11/2005
Mehmet Zeki DOÄžAN
21/11/1978
Edirne
Meral HANBAYAT
19198/08
17/04/2008
Turan GÃœNANA
20/09/1981
TekirdaÄŸ
Ercan KANAR
19228/08
11/03/2008
Lütfü YOLDAŞ
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
19229/08
12/02/2008
Lütfü YOLDAŞ
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
20587/08
31/03/2008
Lütfü YOLDAŞ
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
24511/08
06/05/2008
Aydın ŞAKA
20/04/1980
Bolu
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
24516/08
14/05/2008
Ergün KARAMAN
30/08/1976
Bolu
Murat VARGÃœN
25700/08
12/05/2008
Zeki KAYAR
01/01/1973
Siirt
Abdulkerim GÄ°DER
26944/08
05/05/2008
Hacı CANPOLAT
01/05/1979
Şanlıurfa
26960/08
05/03/2008
Abdullah GÃœNAY
25/03/1979
Kırıkkale
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
26969/08
16/05/2008
Sami ÖZBİL
03/05/1977
Kocaeli
Özlem GÜMÜŞTAŞ
28982/08
11/06/2008
Nedim YILMAZ
10/12/1970
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
29667/08
11/06/2008
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Nedim YILMAZ
10/12/1970
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
29688/08
11/06/2008
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Nedim YILMAZ
10/12/1970
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
33409/08
24/06/2008
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Nedim YILMAZ
10/12/1970
Kocaeli
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
33410/08
16/06/2008
Abdullah GÃœNAY
25/03/1979
Kırıkkale
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
34667/08
02/07/2008
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Ahmet HÃœSEYÄ°N
10/03/197
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
34784/08
07/07/2008
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Nedim YILMAZ
10/12/1970
Kocaeli
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Ahmet HÃœSEYÄ°N
10/03/1971
Kocaeli
Hüseyin KOÇUK
01/01/1987
Kocaeli
Rıdvan ÇELİK
01/01/1973
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
34797/08
07/07/2008
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Nedim YILMAZ
10/12/1970
Kocaeli
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Ahmet HÃœSEYÄ°N
10/03/1971
Kocaeli
Hüseyin KOÇUK
01/01/1987
Kocaeli
Rıdvan ÇELİK
01/01/1973
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
34818/08
16/06/2008
Zafer BALCI
01/01/1977
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
36971/08
28/05/2008
Turan GÃœNANA
20/09/1981
TekirdaÄŸ
Ercan KANAR
36976/08
09/05/2008
Turan GÃœNANA
20/09/1981
TekirdaÄŸ
Ercan KANAR
37754/08
18/07/2008
Sami ÖZBİL
03/05/1977
Kocaeli
Özlem GÜMÜŞTAŞ
37771/08
23/07/2008
Murat CANÅžAD
20/04/1974
Edirne
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
38785/08
20/05/2008
Mahmut CENGÄ°Z
20/03/1983
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
39029/08
28/07/2008
Suat GÖKALP
21/03/1971
Bolu
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
41175/08
22/07/2008
Murat CANÅžAD
20/04/1974
Edirne
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
42161/08
16/06/2008
Habip ÇİFTÇİ
10/03/1973
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
42598/08
29/07/2008
Hüseyin KOÇUK
01/01/1987
Kocaeli
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Remazan KORTAK
01/01/1966
Kocaeli
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
42603/08
29/07/2008
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Remazan KORTAK
01/01/1966
Kocaeli
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Hüseyin KOÇUK
01/01/1987
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
47756/08
12/09/2008
Suat GÖKALP
21/03/1971
Bolu
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
48085/08
03/09/2008
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Remazan KORTAK
01/01/1966
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
49847/08
03/09/2008
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Remazan KORTAK
01/01/1966
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
49866/08
03/09/2008
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Remazan KORTAK
01/01/1966
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
49869/08
03/09/2008
Haydar ERGÃœL
03/02/1956
Kocaeli
Remazan KORTAK
01/01/1966
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
53248/08
16/10/2008
Sami ÖZBİL
03/05/1977
Kocaeli
Özlem GÜMÜŞTAŞ
53830/08
30/10/2008
Canar YURTSEVER
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Metin YAMALAK
10/06/1980
Bolu
Abdullah GÃœNAY
25/03/1979
Kırıkkale
Ergin ATABEY
01/01/1973
Bolu
Habip ÇİFTÇİ
10/03/1973
Kocaeli
Aydın ŞAKA
20/04/1980
Bolu
Fesih NARDAN
01/01/1964
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
53840/08
27/10/2008
Türkan İPEK
22/07/1966
UÅŸak
55902/08
08/10/2008
Serdal KARAÇELİK
01/01/1971
TekirdaÄŸ
Oya ASLAN
56148/08
22/10/2008
Medeni UÄžUR
14/12/1988
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
56244/08
17/10/2008
Cihan Deniz TARAK
15/08/1976
Samsun
Özlem GÜMÜŞTAŞ
58168/08
14/11/2008
Sami ÖZBİL
03/05/1977
Kocaeli
58179/08
30/10/2008
Canar YURTSEVER
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Metin YAMALAK
10/06/1980
Bolu
Abdullah GÃœNAY
25/03/1979
Kırıkkale
Ergin ATABEY
01/01/1973
Bolu
Habip ÇİFTÇİ
10/03/1973
Kocaeli
Aydın ŞAKA
20/04/1980
Bolu
Fesih NARDAN
01/01/1964
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
60485/08
24/11/2008
Murat YILMAZ
01/01/1970
Diyarbakır
Servet ÖZEN
4248/09
13/04/2009
Mazlum BATARAY
05/03/1982
Diyarbakır
RehÅŸan BATARAY SAMAN
5703/09
21/01/2009
Hamza AKKAÅž
01/01/1981
Ä°zmit
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
6167/09
20/01/2009
Ä°skender KARAMAN
01/01/1975
Van
Hamdi TURGUT
6763/09
15/01/2009
Lütfü YOLDAŞ
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
6769/09
15/01/2009
Lütfü YOLDAŞ
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
6816/09
15/01/2009
Enver ÖZKARTAL
25/02/1969
Kırıkkale
Mesut BEÅžTAÅž
8085/09
27/01/2009
Süleyman Yılmaz BULDURUÇ
21/04/1977
TekirdaÄŸ
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
10773/09
21/01/2009
RuÅŸen BAYAR
01/01/1972
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
10793/09
21/01/2009
Turan GÃœNANA
20/09/1981
TekirdaÄŸ
Ercan KANAR
10804/09
06/01/2009
Özkan KART
01/10/1983
Ankara
Murat VARGÃœN
11672/09
19/02/2009
Hasan GÃœLBAHAR
30/09/1961
Kocaeli
Hakan KARAKUÅž
13917/09
19/01/2009
Ayetullah AY
20/02/1980
Kırıkkale
Osman ÇELİK
17135/09
19/03/2009
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Kemal ERTÃœRK
01/01/1975
Ankara
Mustafa DEMÄ°RDAÄž
16/09/1972
Ankara
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Ali GÃœLMEZ
15/09/1955
Ankara
Hakan KARAKUÅž
17890/09
24/03/2009
Arif ÇELEBİ
03/05/1963
Tekirda ÄŸ
Filiz KILIÇGÜN YEŞİL
17934/09
19/03/2009
Mustafa DEMÄ°RDAÄž
16/09/1972
Ankara
Mesut DENÄ°Z
01/01/1975
Ankara
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Naki DEMÄ°R
01/01/1981
Ankara
Hakan KARAKUÅž
17935/09
19/03/2009
Tayyar EROÄžLU
20/09/1982
Ankara
Kemal ERTÃœRK
01/01/1975
Ankara
Ali GÃœLMEZ
01/01/1965
Ankara
Mesut DENÄ°Z
01/01/1975
Ankara
Mustafa DEMÄ°RDAÄž
16/09/1972
Ankara
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Hakan KARAKUÅž
18438/09
03/02/2009
Ercan BÄ°NAY
02/01/1971
Samsun
Meral HANBAYAT
23577/09
08/04/2009
Siraç ÇELİK
01/01/1981
TekirdaÄŸ
Murat Ä°PEK
19/04/1979
Ä°stanbul
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
23647/09
20/04/2009
Arif ÇELEBİ
03/05/1963
TekirdaÄŸ
Filiz KILIÇGÜN YEŞİL
24472/09
18/02/2009
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Hakan KARAKUÅž
24474/09
20/02/2009
Halil ÅžAHÄ°N
01/01/1968
Sincan
Ali GÃœLMEZ
01/01/1965
Ankara
Küçük Hasan ÇOBAN
01/03/1975
Ankara
Mesut DENÄ°Z
01/01/1975
Ankara
Mustafa DEMÄ°RDAÄž
16/09/1972
Ankara
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Naki DEMÄ°R
01/01/1981
Ankara
Tayyar EROÄžLU
20/09/1982
Ankara
YaÅŸar Ä°NCE
01/01/1972
Ankara
Hakan KARAKUÅž
25578/09
03/05/2009
Tahir LAÇİN
01/03/1961
Ankara
Yücel ONGUN
01/01/1979
Ankara
Hasan COÅžAR
20/11/1962
Ankara
Alihan ALHAN
01/01/1974
Ankara
Özlem GÜMÜŞTAŞ
26001/09
31/03/2009
Barış İNAN
05/02/1973
Kandıra
Keleş ÖZTÜRK
27289/09
27/04/2009
Hakkı ALPHAN
Ankara
Meral HANBAYAT
27442/09
11/05/2009
Turgut KAYA
20/02/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Nihat KONAK
10/05/1964
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°smail YILMAZ
01/01/1954
TekirdaÄŸ
Ulvi YALÇIN
20/03/1977
TekirdaÄŸ
Hakan KARAKUÅž
28108/09
14/05/2009
Ahmet DOÄžAN
03/03/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
28593/09
14/05/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
28602/09
27/04/2009
Murat KARAYEL
10/05/1971
Kırıkkale
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
28614/09
27/04/2009
Ali Murat ÇELİK
01/01/1968
Ankara
Murat VARGÃœN
28681/09
20/04/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
28687/09
10/04/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
28695/09
05/05/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
28707/09
27/04/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
28829/09
19/01/2009
Kemal YİĞİT
20/10/1982
Ä°zmir
Esin ASLAN
29048/09
11/05/2009
Turgut KAYA
20/02/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Muzaffer ÖZTÜRK
20/09/1957
TekirdaÄŸ
Nihat KONAK
10/05/1964
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°smail YILMAZ
01/01/1954
TekirdaÄŸ
Erol Volkan Ä°LDEM
28/09/1982
Ä°stanbul
Murat ÖZÇELİK
18/10/1984
Ankara
Ulvi YALÇIN
20/03/1977
TekirdaÄŸ
Hüseyin UZUNDAĞ
01/10/1984
TekirdaÄŸ
Fevzi OÄŸuz ARSLAN
23/11/1975
TekirdaÄŸ
CoÅŸkun AKDENÄ°Z
01/01/1984
TekirdaÄŸ
Erkan SALDUZ
TekirdaÄŸ
Hakan KARAKUÅž
29110/09
11/05/2009
Barış AÇIKEL
Kocaeli
Gül ALTAY
29181/09
11/05/2009
Tahir LAÇİN
01/03/1961
Ankara
Yücel ONGUN
01/01/1979
Ankara
Meriç SOLMAZ
01/01/1973
Ankara
Deniz BAKIR
01/01/1979
Ankara
Ä°smail KORKMAZ
Ankara
Ahmet YILDIRIM
01/01/1980
Ankara
Mesut ÇEKİ
01/01/1977
Ankara
Cihan KARAÇÖL
24/08/1977
Ankara
Özlem GÜMÜŞTAŞ
31853/09
27/05/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
31860/09
22/05/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
33081/09
22/05/2009
Adem Serkan GÃœNDOÄžDU
21/02/1977
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
33198/09
01/06/2009
Ahmet YILMAZ
16/09/1987
Ä°stanbul
Ä°nan POYRAZ
33731/09
09/06/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
35079/09
17/06/2009
Mehmet Faruk AYDIN
27/11/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
35087/09
01/06/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
36651/09
02/06/2009
Ahmet DOÄžAN
03/03/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
36675/09
24/06/2009
Mehmet Faruk AYDIN
27/11/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
38920/09
06/07/2009
Veysi EREN
07/09/1984
Ä°stanbul
Muhammed ÅžORLÄ°
01/01/1987
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
38962/09
18/06/2009
Sami ÖZBİL
03/05/1977
Kocaeli
40101/09
17/06/2009
Mehmet ALADAÄž
11/05/1974
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
40111/09
24/06/2009
Mehmet Faruk AYDIN
27/11/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
40167/09
06/07/2009
RuÅŸen BAYAR
01/01/1972
TekirdaÄŸ
Muhammed ÅžORLÄ°
01/01/1987
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
41097/09
02/07/2009
Muhammed ÅžORLÄ°
01/01/1987
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
41399/09
20/07/2009
Hasan YAVİÇ
23/10/1980
Ä°stanbul
Mesut BEDÄ°RHANOÄžLU
43507/09
03/06/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
44274/09
05/08/2009
Erkan ALTUN
15/05/1981
Ä°stanbul
Sevim AKAT EÅžKÄ°
44591/09
30/07/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
44599/09
27/07/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
Tekirdag
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
44608/09
16/07/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
44611/09
10/07/2009
Ziya ULUSOY
21/11/1953
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
44710/09
10/08/2009
Menderes LEYLA
03/05/1964
TekirdaÄŸ
Erman ÖZTÜRK
45771/09
17/08/2009
Mahmut YAMAN
04/04/1974
TekirdaÄŸ
Ercan KANAR
47794/09
21/07/2009
Ahmet DOÄžAN
03/03/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
49738/09
17/08/2009
Murat Ä°PEK
19/04/1979
Ä°stanbul
Ercan KANAR
50095/09
26/06/2009
Cihan Deniz TARAK
15/08/1976
Samsun
53175/09
09/07/2009
Mehmet NART
01/12/1977
TekirdaÄŸ
53412/09
02/09/2009
Mehmet SAYAT
10/12/1981
Ankara
Sinem COÅžKUN
54777/09
05/08/2009
Erkan ALTUN
15/05/1981
Ä°stanbul
Sevim AKAT EÅžKÄ°
54925/09
10/09/2009
Murat KARAYEL
10/05/1971
Kırıkkale
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
54943/09
10/09/2009
Murat KARAYEL
10/05/1971
Kırıkkale
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
55165/09
29/09/2009
Sinan Ä°YÄ°T
06/11/1973
Ankara
Murat VARGÃœN
55205/09
05/08/2009
Erkan ALTUN
15/05/1981
Ä°stanbul
Sevim AKAT EÅžKÄ°
55213/09
05/08/2009
Erkan ALTUN
15/05/1981
Ä°stanbul
Sevim AKAT EÅžKÄ°
56414/09
14/10/2009
Muhammed ÅžORLÄ°
01/01/1987
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
57661/09
15/10/2009
Sami ÖZBİL
03/05/1977
Kocaeli
58394/09
23/10/2009
Celal BEYAZKAYA
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°smail Cengiz OÄžURTAN
15/06/1974
TekirdaÄŸ
Murat Ä°PEK
19/04/1979
Ä°stanbul
Mehmet Fuat EROL
20/02/1984
MuÅŸ
Yusuf SALÄ°N
15/12/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
59194/09
23/10/2009
Fesih NARDAN
01/01/1964
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
59262/09
30/10/2009
Lütfü YOLDAŞ
01/01/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Ä°nan AKMEÅžE
60538/09
05/08/2009
Erkan ALTUN
15/05/1981
Ä°stanbul
Sevim AKAT EÅžKÄ°
61658/09
30/10/2009
Erdal ÅžAHÄ°N
01/02/1983
Ä°stanbul
Hüseyin BOĞATEKİN
64171/09
07/08/2009
Ahmet DOÄžAN
03/03/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKÄ°N
64190/09
17/07/2009
Murat Ä°PEK
19/04/1979
Ä°stanbul
Ercan KANAR
64201/09
18/11/2009
Murat Ä°PEK
19/04/1979
Ä°stanbul
Ercan KANAR
64251/09
30/10/2009
Fesih ERDEMÄ°RCÄ°
01/01/1962
Kocaeli
Tahir KIZILDEMÄ°R
01/01/1971
Kocaeli
Hüseyin KOÇUK
01/01/1987
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
64322/09
14/10/2009
Turan GÃœNANA
20/09/1981
TekirdaÄŸ
Ercan KANAR
66691/09
27/10/2009
Yusuf SALÄ°N
15/12/1982
TekirdaÄŸ
Mehmet ERBÄ°L
2918/10
11/11/2009
Turgut KAYA
20/02/1973
TekirdaÄŸ
Ulvi YALÇIN
20/03/1977
TekirdaÄŸ
Hüseyin UZUNDAĞ
01/10/1984
TekirdaÄŸ
CoÅŸkun AKDENÄ°Z
01/01/1984
TekirdaÄŸ
Erkan SALDUZ
TekirdaÄŸ
Sinan GÃœLÃœM
15/03/1983
TekirdaÄŸ
YaÅŸar ERÄ°Åž
30/05/1971
TekirdaÄŸ
Hakan KARAKUÅž