Lexploria

FIRST SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 3471 /04 Graziella BORDINI against Italy and 88 other applications (see appended table)

The European Court of Human Rights ( First Section ), sitting on 27 September 2018 as a Committee composed of:

Ksenija Turković , President, Pauliine Koskelo , Tim Eicke , judges,

and Liv Tigerstedt , Acting Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above application s lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,

Having regard to the formal declaration s accepting a friendly settlement of the cases,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

The list of applicant s is set out in the appended table.

The applicants ’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention concerning the excessive length of civil proceedings were communicated to the Italian Government (“the Government”) .

By letter of 7 January 2016, the representative of Mrs Maria Serafina Ascione , Mr Gerardo Caruso and Mrs Delia Ievolella (application no. 28985/04 ) informed the Court that the said applicants w ish ed to withdraw the ir application to the Court .

As for the remainder of the applications, t he Court received friendly ‑ settlement declarations under which the applicant s agreed to waive any further claims against Italy in respect of the facts giving rise to these applications, subject to an undertaking by the Government to pay them, the amounts detailed in the appended table. These amounts will be payable within three months from the date of notification of the Court ’ s decision. In the event of failure to pay these amounts within the above ‑ mentioned three ‑ month period, the Government undertake to pay simple interest on them, from the expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.

The payment will constitute the final resolution of the cases.

THE LAW

Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision .

In the light of the foregoing, and in the absence of any special circumstances regarding respect for the rights guaranteed by the Convention and the Protocols thereto, the Court, in accordance with Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention, considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the part of application no. 28985/04 lodged by Mrs Maria Serafina Ascione , Mr Gerardo Caruso and Mrs Delia Ievolella .

As for the remainder of the applications, t he Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the case s out of the list.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides to join the applications;

Decides to strike the part of application no. 28985/04 introduced by Mrs Maria Serafina Ascione , Mr Gerardo Caruso and Mrs Delia Ievolella out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention ;

Decides to strike the remainder of the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention .

Done in English and notified in writing on 18 October 2018 .

Liv Tigerstedt Ksenija Turković Acting Deputy Registrar President

APPENDIX

No.

Application no. Date of introduction

Applicant ’ s name

Date of birth /

demise

Representative ’ s name and location

Date of Government ’ s declaration

Date of Applicant ’ s declaration

Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage

per applicant unless indicated “jointly”

(in euros) [1]

Amount awarded for costs and expenses per application

(in euros) [2]

3471/04

18/12/2003

Graziella BORDINI

29/01/1943

12/07/2018

11/01/2018

1,500

250

6916/04

04/02/2004

Violante Amalia SMALDONE

29/03/1920

Di Gioia Ennio

Cusano Milanino

12/07/2018

05/03/2018

6 , 000

250

7296/04

13/02/2004

(3 applicants)

Biagio ORSILLO

25/08/1931

Domenico GALASSO

11/08/1960

Elvira GALASSO

22/11/1962

Pagnozzi Loredana

B enevento

12/07/2018

28/02/2018

3,300

250

7906/04

05/02/2004

Maria Antonietta LANTELLA

11/02/1968

Pagnozzi Loredana

B enevento

12/07/2018

16/02/2018

9,200

250

11401/04

10/03/2004

Paola RICCIARDI

26/10/1963

Ferrara Alessandro

B enevento

12/07/2018

03/01/2018

1,800

250

11496/04

10/03/2004

Carmelo FEBBRARO

16/07/1929

died on 29/11/2017

Heirs:

Luciano FEBBRARO

12/12/1964

Mercante FEBBRARO

30/04/1962

Sergio FEBBRARO

27/10/1968

Silvana FEBBRARO

20/10/1960

Iolanda ZEOLI

09/02/1931

Ferrara Alessandro

B enevento

12/07/2018

23/03/2018

5,100

jointly to the heirs

250

14569/04

08/01/2004

Rosario VITIELLO

09/09/1957

Pizzillo Domenico

B enevento

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

2,200

250

19219/04

12/04/2001

Istituto F ilippo S maldone

Viscardi Catello

Salern o

12/07/2018

09/04/2018

4,300

250

19240/04

20/07/1999

Mario CASCIANO

17/10/1967

Nardone Antonio

Benevento

12/07/2018

20/04/2018

1,300

250

19280/04

22/07/1999

Cambianica G ian P aolo & R iboli P aolo S . N . C .

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

29/03/2018

2,000

250

19693/04

18/01/2001

Carlo GRIECO

19/09/1960

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

27/03/2018

1,400

250

22174/04

16/06/2004

Gesualdi P ietro & C. S. a . s .

Romano Giovanni

Benevento

12/07/2018

02/01/2018

2,500

250

24062/04

29/03/1999

Domenico CALICCHIO

06/11/1947

Domenico RUGGIERO

24/04/1950

Ferrara Silvio

Benevento

12/07/2018

19/02/2018

1,300

250

24439/04

01/06/1999

Dora VESSICHELLI

30/01/1930

died on 31/12/2016

Heirs:

Concetta BRUGLIERE

14/07/1961

Maria Rosaria BRUGLIERE

07/01/1966

Ferrara Silvio

Benevento

12/07/2018

16/03/2018

6,200

jointly to the heirs

250

25793/04

24/02/2001

Domenico CALICCHIO

06/11/1947

Ferrara Silvio

Benevento

12/07/2018

19/02/2018

1,700

250

26016/04

25/06/2004

Gioacchino ZOLLI

11/05/1937

Pizzillo Domenico

Benevento

12/07/2018

03/01/2018

1,500

250

26470/04

23/06/2004

Azienda A gricola C aterina S guera S. r . l .

Pizzillo Domenico

Benevento

12/07/2018

18/03/2018

3,300

250

26741/04

21/07/2004

Maria Luisa GUERRA

25/01/1943

Ferrara Alessandro

Benevento

12/07/2018

03/01/2018

1,100

250

26760/04

21/07/2004

Mario RICCIARDI

04/10/1938

Ferrara Alessandro

Benevento

12/07/2018

03/01/2018

3,000

250

26876/04

12/04/2001

Leasing F inanziaria I mmobiliare S. p . a .

Viscardi Catello

Salern o

12/07/2018

03/04/2018

2,500

250

28985/04

09/07/2004

(6 1 applicants)

1. Amato AFFUSTO

29/08/1941

2. Mario BOFFA

17/02/1940

3. Anna BONTIEMPO

28/02/1938

4. Francesco BOVIO

29/06/1942

5. Giuseppe BOVIO

12/06/1947

6. Anna Teresa CAGGESE

18/03/1933

7. Pasquale CALANDRELLI

11/05/1937

died on 06/10/2015

Heirs :

Rosaria SACCOMANNO

13/03/1936

Elena CALANDRELLI

12/02/1966

Carmine CALANDRELLI

03/06/1962

8. Antonia CALANDRO

29/09/1952

9. Tommaso CANCELLIERI

28/01/1933

10. Rita CAPOZZI

29/09/1951

11. Ugo CARLETTI

24/07/1935

12. Luigi CAROPRESO

02/02/1944

13. Anna CARUSO

13/07/1939

14. Giuseppe CASSERO

25/04/1944

15. Rita CELATO

27/08/1957

16. Teresa CELATO

07/02/1956

17. Antonio CITRO

10/06/1947

18. Ernestina C ONTE

29/04/1937

died on 02/02/2013

Heirs :

Massimo RUSSO

21/08/1965

Angela RUSSO

03/02/1963

19. Antonio DE FEO

05/07/1947

died on 08/06/2010

Heirs :

Carmela Sabina GAITA

19/09/1953

Anna Rita DE FEO

22/03/1976

20. Benito DE SIMONE

26/03/1939

21. Umberto FALLARINO

22/02/1930

22. Giuliana FOLLO

16/01/1957

23. Ugo GALLIANO

20/02/1925

died on 08/12/2015

Heirs :

Anna SIMONE

09/06/1933

Giuseppe GALLIANO

10/02/1959

Luciana GALLIANO

07/08/1960

24. Cosimo IANNACE

05/10/1934

25. Iolanda IANNACE

21/11/1928

26. Luigi INFANTINO

20/08/1934

27. Felicia LEMBO

02/03/1948

28. Antonetta LEO

07/02/1934

29. Annamaria LEPORE

18/01/1953

30. Antonio MAIO

21/06/1937

31. Anna Maria MARCHIONE

28/08/1930

died on 31/01/2012

Heirs :

Antonio MARCHIONE

01/01/1946

Riccardo MARCHIONE

29/01/1949

Raffaele MARCHIONE

17/07/1958

Anna Maria Tiziana PALUMBO

11/11/1960

Cristiana Serenella PALUMBO

06/12/1963

Vincenzo PALUMBO

13/12/1969

Ilaria Barbara MARCHIONE

28/11/1976

Barbara Ilaria MARCHIONE

24/05/1968

32. Adriana MERCURIO

13/11/1947

33. Roberto MIELE

23/09/1935

34. Agostino PASTORE

21/11/1942

35. Antonio PASTORE

02/01/1939

36. Concetta PEPE

22/07/1930

37. Vincenzo PIETRONIGRO

21/04/1939

38. Giovanni PIZZO

25/07/1947

died on 24/05/2011

Heirs :

Anna PELLEGRINI

06/08/1956

Nicoletta PIZZO

29/07/1977

Antonio PIZZO

30/10/1975

39. Giuseppe RICCIARDI

11/03/1928

40. Cosimo SALERNO

28/09/1929

41. Felicia SANTAMARIA

10/04/1931

42. Lucia SARRACINO

21/06/1950

43. Vincenzo SOLLA

20/05/1943

44. Clotilde VARRICCHIO

22/09/1939

45. Angelina VERDINO

12/03/1950

46. Antonio VERDINO

10/06/1945

47. Mario VESSICHELLI

06/10/1931

48. Elisabetta ZAMPELLI

16/02/1933

49. Ida BORZILLO

21/02/1941

50. Alessandro CORONA

28/06/1965

51. Dario CORONA

22/04/1976

52. Massimo CORONA

12/12/1970

53. Walter CORONA

04/08/1967

54. Anna Maria D ’ ARGENIO

15/10/1950

55. Filomena Iolanda D ’ ARGENIO

15/10/1942

died on 17/10/2013

Heirs :

Vincenzo ZITANI

04/03/1970

Umberto ZITANI

04/03/1970

Arturo ZITANI

04/04/1967

56. Liliana D ’ ARGENIO

30/08/1948

57. Pasqualina D ’ ARGENIO

09/07/1956

58. Rita D ’ ARGENIO

29/09/1953

59. Assunta FORGIONE

14/08/1951

60. Nicoletta SANTAMARIA

17/12/1973

61. Virginia SANTAMARIA

14/08/1967

Romano Giovanni

Benevento

12/07/2018

05/02/2018

4,590

per applicant and jointly to the heirs of the following applicants:

Pasquale CALANDRELLI

died on 06/10/2015

( Heirs :

Rosaria SACCOMANNO

13/03/1936

Elena CALANDRELLI

12/02/1966

Carmine CALANDRELLI

03/06/1962 )

Ernestina CONTE

29/04/1937

died on 02/02/2013

( Heirs:

Massimo RUSSO

21/08/1965

Angela RUSSO 03/02/1963 )

Antonio DE FEO

05/07/1947

died on 08/06/2010

( Heirs :

Carmela Sabina GAITA

19/09/1953

Anna Rita DE FEO

22/03/1976 )

Ugo Galliano

died on 08/12/2015

(Heirs:

Anna SIMONE

09/06/1933

Giuseppe GALLIANO

10/02/1959

Luciana GALLIANO

07/08/1960 )

Anna Maria MARCHIONE

died on 31/01/2012

(Heirs:

Antonio MARCHIONE

01/01/1946

Riccardo MARCHIONE

29/01/1949

Raffaele MARCHIONE

17/07/1958

Anna Maria Tiziana PALUMBO

11/11/1960

Cristiana Serenella PALUMBO

06/12/1963

Vincenzo PALUMBO

13/12/1969

Ilaria Barbara MARCHIONE

28/11/1976

Barbara Ilaria MARCHIONE

24/05/1968 )

Giovanni PIZZO

died on 24/05/2011

( Heirs :

Anna PELLEGRINI

06/08/1956

Nicoletta PIZZO

29/07/1977

Antonio PIZZO

30/10/1975 )

Filomena Iolanda D ’ ARGENIO

died on 17/10/2013

( Heirs :

Vincenzo ZITANI

04/03/1970

Umberto ZITANI

04/03/1970

Arturo ZITANI

04/04/1967 )

250

30892/04

28/06/2000

Anna ROMANO

13/02/1955

Pizzillo Domenico

Benevento

12/07/2018

22/02/2018

2,300

250

32244/04

25/01/2000

(3 applicants)

Gaetano BRANCIFORTE

12/01/1939

Carmelo BRANCIFORTE

15/02/1941

Emanuele BRANCIFORTE

17/11/1948

Magro Francesco

Avola

12/07/2018

28/02/2018

4,600

250

32256/04

27/08/2004

(3 applicants)

Gioacchino GRASSI

11/09/1938

Martino COLONNA

02/03/1951

Carlo SCHIAVONE

09/08/1941

Ventura Costantino

Bari

12/07/2018

15/01/2018

7,000

250

34576/04

06/04/2001

Paolo REGAZZONI

14/11/1972

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

09/04/2018

800

250

36253/04

18/01/2001

Diego PEZZOLI

14/04/1970

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

09/04/2018

1,400

250

38909/04

21/10/2004

Domenico DI NAPOLI

28/02/1950

Romano Giovanni

Benevento

12/07/2018

02/01/2018

1,300

250

40761/04

25/02/1999

Franco UGGETTI

20/08/1958

12/07/2018

02/01/2018

3,500

250

40771/04

04/08/2000

Ilario GIASINI

10/05/1940

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

28/03/2018

3,500

250

40967/04

12/02/1998

Alfonso TERENZIANO

09/06/1946

Sparano Giuseppe

Rom e

12/07/2018

15/05/2018

4,400

250

41088/04

29/09/1998

Dora VESSICHELLI

30/01/1930

died on 31/12/2016

Heirs:

Concetta BRUGLIERE

14/07/1961

Maria Rosaria BRUGLIERE

07/01/1966

Ferrara Silvio

Benevento

12/07/2018

16/03/2018

2,500

jointly to the heirs

250

42194/04

03/07/1999

Zollo A ntonio S. a . a .

Ferrara Silvio

Benevento

12/07/2018

03/01/2018

5,500

250

43039/04

29/09/1999

Maria MAZZANTI

03/04/1943

Cargioli Paolo

La Spezia

12/07/2018

22/02/2018

1,500

250

44037/04

27/06/2001

Antonio ARESU

30/11/19 5 5

12/07/2018

03/01/2018

3,000

250

44243/04

29/09/1998

( 3 applicants)

Paola D ’ AMMANDO

01/04/1947

Marta GREGORI

03/10/1978

Patrizia GREGORI

31/01/1984

Vespaziani Giovanni

Rieti

12/07/2018

21/02/2018

3,100

250

44244/04

02/07/1998

Stefano MARGIOTTA

23/04/1931

Vespaziani Giovanni

Rieti

12/07/2018

21/02/2018

2,400

250

44247/04

30/07/1999

Brunello GUNNELLA

18/01/1936

Vespaziani Giovanni

Rieti

12/07/2018

21/02/2018

3,300

250

44316/04

06/03/2001

A fim S.N.C.

Verrilli Togo

Benevento

12/07/2018

11/01/2018

3,000

250

44627/04

20/11/2004

Gian Patrizio CIONI

24/01/1972

Zuccardi Merli Liliana

Rom e

12/07/2018

13/02/2018

400

250

44641/04

17/04/2001

Giovanni GRAMAZIO

23/06/1969

Nardone Antonio

Benevento

12/07/2018

20/04/2018

1,200

250

44656/04

19/10/2000

(14 applicants)

1. Ettore DE VITO

03/03/1955

2. Giancarlo ALLEGRUCCI

25/02/1945

3. Katia CANZONIERI

15/01/1970

4. Antonio CAROSI

25/03/1935

5. Micaela DI BERTO

17/05/1968

6. Aldo DI MARCO

23/10/1935

7. Giulio FABRIANESI

07/03/1938

8. Maurizio FLAMIGNI

09/02/1939

9. Maurizio MARCHINI

10/03/1953

10. Antonio MERRA

30/10/1943

11. Ruggiero RAPONI

09/10/1936

12. Stefano SCHIAVO

14/08/1955

13. Alberto TICCONI

16/08/1939

14. Vincenzo TRIFILIO

14/04/1964

Failla Gregoria Maria

Rom e

12/07/2018

05/04/2018

1. Ettore DE VITO : 250

2. Giancarlo ALLEGRUCCI : 1,200

3. Katia CANZONIERI : 900

4. Antonio CAROSI: 800

5. Micaela DI BERTO: 650

6. Aldo DI MARCO: 700

7. Giulio FABRIANESI: 1,300

8. Maurizio FLAMIGNI: 650

9. Maurizio MARCHINI: 650

10. Antonio MERRA: 650

11. Ruggiero RAPONI: 650

12. Stefano SCHIAVO: 650

13. Alberto TICCONI: 400

14. Vincenzo TRIFILIO: 850

250

45519/04

02/12/2004

Franco PAOLETTI

23/01/1951

Alfredo PALOMBA

18/10/1938

Zuccardi Merli Liliana

Rom e

12/07/2018

03/03/2018

2,000

250

7972/05

14/02/2005

Paolo CIAIOLA

27/05/1955

Zuccardi Merli Liliana

Rom e

12/07/2018

10/02/2018

1,600

250

4750/06

25/01/2006

Luciano CATENA

19/12/1958

Marzocchi Giorgio

Milan

12/07/2018

22/01/2018

900

250

18628/06

28/04/2006

Silvestro FORTUNA

28/01/1936

Marchetti Alessandro

Rom e

12/07/2018

28/12/2017

7,600

250

22731/06

27/05/2006

Marino MARONGIU

05/06/1952

Eugenio MARONGIU

15/07/1953

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

05/02/2018

2,700

jointly

250

27487/06

27/06/2006

Piero Antonio DE BELLIS

09/07/1953

Villa Paolo

Rom e

12/07/2018

23/03/2018

5,400

250

28942/06

18/07/2006

Tecno industriale S. r . l .

Defilippi ( pr ) Claudio

Parm a

12/07/2018

05/04/2018

6 , 600

250

1184/07

22/12/2006

Maria ABBATE

02/09/1934

Di Francesco Olindo

Agrigent o

12/07/2018

13/02/2018

1 , 800

250

6897/07

06/02/2007

Ezio LUCCHETTI

20/08/1921

died on 21/04/2016

Heir:

Gabriella FRANZELLITTI

30/11/1928

Lucchetti Dino

Latina

12/07/2018

04/01/2018

8,400

250

11797/07

21/02/2007

Enrico DE MARI

24/10/1939

Mocella Daniela

Nap les

12/07/2018

16/02/2018

1,400

250

12578/07

15/03/2007

Maria Concetta MIRRA

27/02/1949

Romano Giovanni

Rom e

12/07/2018

02/01/2018

1,300

250

32935/07

16/07/2007

Ludovico MAZZARELLA

15/08/1932

Villa Paolo

Rom e

12/07/2018

13/02/2018

5,200

250

47850/07

08/10/2007

Giulio PADOVANI

21/11/1918

Marchetti Alessandro

Rom e

12/07/2018

28/12/2017

6,600

250

7215/08

28/03/2003

Lorella BONASIA

08/10/1961

Massimo POZZI

22/10/1962

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

28/03/2018

700

250

7770/08

01/02/2008

Silvia TRAMONTELLI

15/03/1916

Marchetti Alessandro

Rom e

12/07/2018

28/12/2017

3,500

250

10263/08

08/02/2008

Cornicchia G rafiche di L eopoldo C ornicchia

Amici Michele Maria

Ponte S. Giovanni

12/07/2018

02/02/2018

2 , 500

250

18880/08

11/04/2008

Guglielma CESARE

15/08/1949

Romano Giovanni

Rom e

12/07/2018

02/01/2018

1,300

250

23083/08

02/05/2008

Olimpia DEL MASTRO

20/12/1933

Francesca DEL MASTRO

22/03/1923

Montinaro Luigi Paolo

Lecce

12/07/2018

20/03/2018

2,000

250

23455/08

14/05/2008

Iole BERTI

22/03/1956

Restuccia Patrizia

L a Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

2,800

250

23912/08

08/05/2008

(3 applicants)

Claudia FEDELI

07/02/1965

Loredana SARDU

12/01/1963

Emilio ARIAUDO

06/08/1951

Abbate Ferdinando Emilio

Orte

12/07/2018

30/03/2018

1,800

250

24024/08

06/05/2008

Carlo ROVANI

02/05/1957

Restuccia Patrizia

L a Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

2,800

250

26415/08

26/05/2008

Maria Piera EMANUELI

31/01/1941

Restuccia Patrizia

L a Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

2,800

250

26425/08

26/05/2008

Daniela RATTI

21/12/1963

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

2,800

250

26433/08

26/05/2008

Loredana BALDASSINI

02/04/1940

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

2,800

250

31007/08

12/06/2008

Cataldo MAINENTI

10/05/1947

Selezione P ac S .r.l .

Vico Renato

Bergam o

12/07/2018

09/04/2018

1,500

jointly

250

51984/08

29/09/2008

Emma BACINELLI

15/03/1933

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

1,100

250

51998/08

29/09/2008

Maria TONELLI

06/03/1941

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

1,100

250

52020/08

29/09/2008

Roberta MAZZI

18/07/1965

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

1,100

250

53551/08

29/09/2008

Carla VEZZI

27/04/1949

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

1,100

250

53659/08

29/09/2008

Sandra DI SPAGNA

17/09/1957

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

1,100

250

25702/09

12/05/2009

Remo FERRAGINA

15/06/1946

Vito FERRAGINA

01/02/1944

Defilippi ( sp ) Claudio

La Spezia

12/07/2018

05/04/2018

1,000

250

41712/10

20/04/2010

Giuseppina MORELLI

04/02/1952

Restuccia Patrizia

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

2,000

250

50737/10

02/08/2010

(3 applicants)

Massimo IACOMINI

18/11/1964

Franco BOGO

17/06/1968

Maria Angelica ZICARI

21/04/1963

Defilippi ( sp ) Claudio

La Spezia

12/07/2018

05/04/2018

4,500

250

61414/10

06/08/2010

Giorgio STAGNARI

16/07/1967

Defilippi ( sp ) Claudio

La Spezia

12/07/2018

08/01/2018

4,000

250

73329/10

12/11/2010

Mario SCRIVANTI

17/06/1948

Frisani Pietro L.

F lorence

12/07/2018

24/01/2018

2,500

250

23651/11

12/02/2011

(7 applicants)

Francesco BIFERO

18/06/1942

Filomena BATTIMELLI

03/10/1949

Antonio ARPINO

02/02/1951

Ida AMICARELLI

04/06/1948

Luca AMORESE

01/08/1951

Teresa BARBERIO

02/10/1951

Salvatore BARBATO

06/04/1952

Ferrara Alessandro

B enevento

12/07/2018

29/01/2018

6,000

250

43717/11

07/06/2011

Paolo FRATI

05/07/1961

Defilippi ( sp ) Claudio

La Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

4,500

250

46361/11

18/05/2011

Giuseppe SEMERARO

04/02/1949

Fiorillo Ernesto

Messin a

12/07/2018

16/01/2018

3,100

250

7422/12

13/01/2012

Antonio MARINO

30/09/1957

Restuccia Patrizia

L a Spezia

12/07/2018

12/01/2018

1,500

250

47721/12

16/06/2012

Rachele OLIVA

12/04/1948

Zicarelli Enedino

San Sosti

12/07/2018

05/04/2018

5,700

250

15654/13

04/01/2013

Michele DEL DUCA

18/03/1927

Fiorillo Ernesto

Messin a

12/07/2018

26/01/2018

6,600

250

8188/14

31/10/2013

Giuseppe LUBELLI

19/05/1949

Daniele Giandomenico

Lecce

12/07/2018

23/03/2018

3,800

250

42120/14

27/05/2014

Franco GIUNTA

15/08/1968

Branca Maria Gabriella

Savon a

12/07/2018

26/04/2018

1 , 800

250

55084/14

25/07/2014

Vincenzo VITAGLIANO MOCCIA

11/05/1933

Vitagliano Moccia Giovanna Antida

Nap les

12/07/2018

15/02/2018

1,000

250

57142/14

02/08/2014

Lorella PALOMBO

11/01/1974

Fabio SARDELLITTI

25/11/1973

Forte Bruno

Sora

12/07/2018

19/03/2018

1,300

250

21557/15

24/04/2015

Eleonora CASTELLANI

02/07/1981

Daniela Antonia CASTELLANI

06/07/1953

Meucci Francesca

Prato

12/07/2018

04/04/2018

2,100

250

46512/15

12/09/2015

Armando GIARDINA

15/01/1938

Giardina Amilcare

S yracuse

12/07/2018

05/04/2018

900

250

47929/15

18/09/2015

(16 applicants )

1. Rito AMBROSI

26/08/1947

2. Francesco BOSO

18/03/1944

3. Giovanni D ’ AVERSA

06/03/1941

4. Crocifisso DE GIOVANNI

16/04/1947

5. Manfredo DI GIULIO

17/12/1941

6. Giovanni FRANCESCA

25/09/1940

7. Antonio GRAZIANO

22/08/1952

8. Pasquale GRAZIANO

17/02/1937

9. Eugenio MEROLLA

05/03/1938

10. Andrea MORICONI

22/08/1934

11. Bruno NARDONE

10/03/1943

12. Giovanni PESCE

27/11/1936

13 . Nando PRATI

21/07/1935

14. Ciro RUOCCO

04/09/1953

15. Antonio SELVA

20/07/1936

16. Filippo TRITTO

13/09/1947

Lippi Andrea

Rom e

12/07/2018

19/02/2018

2,300

250[1] . Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.

[2] . Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.

Menu

BORDINI AND OTHERS v. ITALY

BORDINI AND OTHERS v. ITALY

LEXI