Search
document

KAHRAMAN v. TURKEY and 14 other applications

Doc ref: 41053/17, 41336/17, 41392/17, 41417/17, 41424/17, 41427/17, 41634/17, 41695/17, 41701/17, 41712/17, ... • ECHR ID: 001-181013

Document date: January 23, 2018

Inbound citations: 0
•
Cited paragraphs: 0
•
Outbound citations: 2

KAHRAMAN v. TURKEY and 14 other applications

Doc ref: 41053/17, 41336/17, 41392/17, 41417/17, 41424/17, 41427/17, 41634/17, 41695/17, 41701/17, 41712/17, ... • ECHR ID: 001-181013

Document date: January 23, 2018

Cited paragraphs only

Communicated on 23 January 2018

SECOND SECTION

Application no. 41053/17 Hüseyin KAHRAMAN against Turkey and 14 other applications (see list appended)

SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE

The application concerns the judicial practice, in the context of expropriation proceedings, to order both parties to pay a lump sum to the opposing party in respect of lawyer fees.

The applicants complain that such an order decreased the expropriation indemnity awarded to them. They argue that they have no responsibility for the initiation of the proceedings, as the courts ruled in their favour and decided to increase the amounts initially proposed by the expropriating public authority.

Relying on Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention, the applicants allege that their right to peaceful enjoyment of their possessions was violated.

QUESTIONS tO THE PARTIES

Have there been an interference with the applicants’ right to peaceful enjoyment of their possessions ? In particular, did the fact that the applicants were ordered to pay attorney fees to the expropriating public authority constitute an excessive burden which upset the fair balance which must be struck between the general interest of the community and the fundamental rights of the individual ( see , mutatis mutandis , Perdigão v. Portugal [GC], no. 24768/06, §§ 67-78, 16 November 2010 ) ?

APPENDIX

No.

Application no.

Lodged on

Applicant

Date of birth

Place of residence

Represented by

41053/17

25/04/2017

Hüseyin KAHRAMAN

01/01/1948

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41336/17

25/04/2017

Abdullah SEVER

12/06/1932

Ä°stanbul

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41392/17

25/04/2017

Ahmet NASÄ°P

02/02/1956

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41417/17

25/04/2017

Ömer DENİZ

01/01/1950

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41424/17

25/04/2017

AyÅŸe EM Ä° R

07/04/1975

Samsun

Mehmet KESER

01/01/1953

Samsun

Himmet KESER

15/11/1959

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41427/17

25/04/2017

Aziz SEVER

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41634/17

25/04/2017

Miyase KAHRAMAN

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41695/17

25/04/2017

Ahmet KALKAR

01/01/1964

TekirdaÄŸ

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41701/17

25/04/2017

Mehmet DENÄ°Z

06/06/1972

Samsun

Ahmet DENÄ°Z

16/04/1974

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41712/17

25/04/2017

Emine KURUTAÅž

01/02/1954

Samsun

Himmet AKÇAY

01/05/1962

Samsun

Mehmet AKÇAY

01/02/1959

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41718/17

25/04/2017

Ahmet DENÄ°Z

28/03/1972

Samsun

Mustafa DENÄ°Z

28/03/1967

Samsun

Kadir DENÄ°Z

20/05/1965

Vezirköprü

Sultan DENÄ°Z

15/03/1949

Samsun

Hanife YILAR

28/03/1968

Ä°stanbul

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41771/17

25/04/2017

Hüseyin SEVER

01/06/1949

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41773/17

25/04/2017

Cemal YILAR

Ä°stanbul

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41774/17

25/04/2017

Yunis DEMÄ°RBÄ°LEK

Samsun

Mehmet DEMÄ°RBÄ°LEK

01/10/1957

Samsun

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

41776/17

25/04/2017

Zülfiye KALKAR

18/11/1937

Samsun

Kamil KALKAR

01/01/1972

Samsun

Melek IRMAK

01/10/1972

Ä°stanbul

Ayten KALKAR

TekirdaÄŸ

Sezai DEMÄ°RKAN

LEXI

Lexploria AI Legal Assistant