CASE OF LUKENDA AND 263 OTHER CASES AGAINST SLOVENIA
Doc ref: 23032/02, 28936/02, 27946/02, 22174/02, 26342/04, 26881/02, 32600/05, 75809/01, 75402/01, 24901/02, ... • ECHR ID: 001-170005
Document date: December 8, 2016
- Inbound citations: 700
- •
- Cited paragraphs: 17
- •
- Outbound citations: 0
Resolution CM/ResDH(2016) 35 4 Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights Two hundred and sixty-four cases against Slovenia (See Appendix for the list of cases)
Application No.
Case
Judgment of
Final on
23032/02
LUKENDA GROUP
06/10/2005
06/01/2006
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 8 December 2016 at the 1273 rd meeting of the Ministers ’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established;
Recalling that the violations of the Convention found by the Court in these cases concern the excessive length of domestic judicial proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy in this respect;
Recalling the respondent State ’ s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum ; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the action report provided by the government indicating the measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court (see document DH-DD(2016)1212 );
Having satisfied itself that all the measures required by Article 46, paragraph 1, have been adopted,
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases and
DECIDES to close the examination thereof.
Appendix : list of cases
Application
Case
Judgment of
Final on
23032/02
LUKENDA
06/10/2005
06/01/2006
28936/02
ACIKGÖZ
07/02/2008
07/05/2008
27946/02
ANTOLIČ
27/04/2006
Loading citations...27/07/2006
22174/02
ARSENIĆ
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
26342/04
ATELÅ EK
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
26881/02
AVDIČ
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
32600/05
BARIŠIČ
18/10/2012
18/01/2013
75809/01
BASTIČ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
75402/01
BAUER
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
24901/02
BEDI
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
25634/05
BEGUÅ
15/12/2011
04/06/2012
7877/02
BELOŠEVIĆ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
10017/10
BELTRAM AND BELTRAM CEROVÅ EK
10/10/2013
10/10/2013
77519/01
BENDIČ
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
39178/02
BENEDEJČIČ AND TRATNIK
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
1459/02
BERIÅ A
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
34747/06
BITENC
30/01/2014
30/01/2014
42274/02
BIZJAK JAGODIČ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
50719/06
BJELIČ
18/10/2012
18/03/2013
77809/01
BLAGOJEVIČ
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
23571/02
BLATEŠIČ
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
34386/10
BOKAL
03/04/2014
03/04/2014
5158/02
BOŠKIČ
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
21462/04
BOŠKOVIČ
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
72072/12
BUBNIK
16/10/2014
16/10/2014
42852/02
BUNČIČ
24/01/2008
24/04/2008
33024/02
ÄŒAKÅ
07/12/2006
07/03/2007
77796/01
CEKUTA
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
76430/01
CMOK
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
76525/01
COKAN
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
6539/02
ÄŒOP
07/12/2006
07/03/2007
38597/03
ÄŒUDEN AND OTHERS
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
57566/00
CUNDRIČ
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
75653/01
CVETREŽNIK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
49994/14
D.P.
23/07/2015
23/07/2015
32964/02
ÐAKOVIĆ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
44135/06
DANIJEL PEÄŒNIK
18/10/2012
18/03/2013
24376/08
DANILO KOVAČIČ
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
1438/02
DEŽELAK
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
70660/01
DIGITEL D.O.O.
15/06/2006
15/09/2006
38523/02
DIVKOVIČ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
66822/01
DOLHAR
18/03/2008
29/09/2008
38310/02
DRAGANOVIČ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
37289/02
DRAGOVAN
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
76212/01
DREU
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
5162/02
DROZG
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
49019/99
EUCONE D.O.O.
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
5110/02
FALNOGA
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
77818/01
FERLIČ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
75366/01
FETIÅ D.O.O.
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
39137/02
FONDA
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
42977/04
FORTUNAT
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
5059/02
GABER
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
32958/02
GAISCHEG
30/11/2006
28/02/2007
37057/02
GASHI
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
44581/98
GERDEN
18/03/2008
18/06/2008
35475/02
GERÅ AK
27/05/2008
27/08/2008
14852/03
GLUHAR
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
28275/06
GOBEC
26/04/2012
26/04/2012
76378/01
GOLENJA
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
77819/01
GORENJAK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
4507/02
GORIÄŒAN
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
75813/01
GORÅ EK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
9277/02
GRADIČ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
22174/06+
GREBENC
24/11/2011
24/11/2011
29891/02
GRENKO
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
31594/08
GREÅ OVNIK
18/07/2013
18/07/2013
33347/07
GROBIN
03/01/2013
03/01/2013
67793/10
GRUPA ZASTAVA VOZILA, A.D.
25/04/2013
25/04/2013
38333/02
GRUÅ OVNIK
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
26867/02
GRZINČIČ
03/05/2007
03/08/2007
14619/02
GUZEJ
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
23416/06
HABIČ
25/04/2013
25/04/2013
75695/01
HAFNER
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
69319/12
HAJRUDINOVIĆ
21/05/2015
21/08/2015
42236/05
HARTMAN
18/10/2012
18/01/2013
33595/02
HERIČ
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
33541/02
HRIBAR
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
10296/02
HRIBERÅ EK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
36054/02
HRIBERÅ EK MARJAN
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
75628/01
HRUSTELJ
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
75817/01
HUSEINOVIĆ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
41513/02
HUSEJINOVIČ
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
75790/01
IBRAHIMI
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
16484/02
IMŠIROVIČ
03/08/2006
03/11/2006
42857/02
IRGOLIČ
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
48163/08
JAMA
19/07/2012
19/10/2012
10761/09
JATAIRWAYS, A.D. BEOGRAD
03/07/2014
03/07/2014
31489/02
JAZBEC
14/12/2006
14/03/2007
5044/02
JELEN
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
37166/02
JELENC
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
4267/02
JENKO
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
38341/02
JEŠIČ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
32238/08
JEZNIK
20/06/2013
20/06/2013
52045/13
JOVIČIĆ
16/07/2015
16/07/2015
7883/02
JURKOÅ EK
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
20610/02
JURKOÅ EK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
75574/01
KERŽINA KUKOVEC
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
75798/01
KLANEÄŒEK
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
34544/02
KLINAR
08/04/2008
08/07/2008
66458/01
KLINAR
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
48782/99
KNEZ AND OTHERS
21/02/2008
21/05/2008
40128/02
KOÄŒEVAR
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
1363/07
KOLAR
05/06/2014
05/06/2014
25195/02
KORDA
30/11/2006
28/02/2007
28456/03
KORELC
12/05/2009
12/08/2009
77769/01
KOS
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
19894/02
KOTNIK
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
17330/02
KOTNIK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
75742/01
KOVAČIČ
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
24162/06
KOVINAR D.O.O.
03/01/2013
03/01/2013
18831/02
KRAÄŒUN
30/11/2006
28/02/2007
27694/02
KRAJNC
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
75616/01
KRAJNC
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
21313/06
KRALJ
12/04/2012
12/04/2012
75705/01
KRAMER
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
77541/01
KRAÅ OVEC
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
47825/99
KRISPER
23/03/2006
23/06/2006
77778/01
KRISTAN
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
75787/01
KRZNAR
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
76524/01
KUKAVICA
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
20300/02
KUKOVIČ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
77542/01
KUMER
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
28922/02
KUNSTIČ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
8756/02
KUZMIN
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
55062/00
KVEDER
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
33488/02
LAKOTA
07/12/2006
07/03/2007
42260/02
LAMPRET
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
37062/02
LEDNIK
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
66824/01
LESAR
30/11/2006
23/05/2007
33553/02
LESJAK
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
33946/03
LESJAK ROBERT
21/07/2009
21/10/2009
17321/02
LORBEK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
5186/02
LUŠNIČKIČ
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
38975/05
MADZAREVIC
15/05/2012
15/05/2012
28400/95
MAJARIČ
08/02/2000
08/02/2000
75773/01
MAJHEN
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
28662/05
MAKSIMOVIČ
22/06/2010
22/09/2010
31675/05
MAKSIMOVIC No. 2
01/02/2011
01/05/2011
75745/01
MAMIČ
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
75778/01
MAMIČ No. 2
27/07/2006
27/10/2006
40125/02
MANDIR
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
35489/02
MARIČ
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
1461/02
MARINOVIĆ
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
29119/06
MEGLIČ
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
75815/01
MEH
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
27102/02
MEŽAN
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
41416/06
MEŽNARIČ
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
43548/02
MIJATOVIČ
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
31391/05
MRAMOR
18/01/2011
18/04/2011
17360/02
MRKONJIČ
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
42252/02
MULEJ
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
77545/01
MULEJ – ZUPANEC AND OTHERS
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
6799/02
MURATOVIČ
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
37294/02
MUŠIČ
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
75777/01
NAHTIGAL
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
21675/02
NOSE
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
49016/99
NOVAK
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
75618/01
NOVAK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
5420/07
NOVAK
25/04/2013
25/04/2013
6855/02
NOVINA
26/10/2006
26/01/2007
75567/01
OBERWALDER
18/01/2007
18/04/2007
76438/01
OBROVNIK
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
4225/02
OLENIK
02/11/2006
12/02/2007
49323/06
OROŽIM
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
33561/02
OVNIÄŒEK
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
1423/02
OŽEK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
41060/07
PAŠIĆ
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
20543/02
PAVLOVIČ
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
37006/02
PAVLOVIČ
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
17337/02
PAŽON
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
76439/01
PEÄŒNIK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
66819/01
PETAN
09/11/2006
09/02/2007
25055/02
PFEIFFER
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
24141/06
PIPUÅ
16/10/2014
16/10/2014
77821/01
PLANKO
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
54503/00
PLANTARIČ
29/06/2006
11/12/2006
7709/06
PLUT AND BIČANIČ-PLUT
18/07/2013
18/10/2013
42224/04
PODBELŠEK BRAČIČ
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
5176/02
PODJAVERÅ EK
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
76515/01
PODKRIŽNIK
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
22266/02
POŽIN
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
75784/01
PREKORÅ EK
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
25046/02
PREVALNIK
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
22172/02
PRLJANOVIĆ
03/08/2006
03/11/2006
76199/01
PUŽ
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
20290/02
RADAKOVIČ
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
37296/02
RADANOVIĆ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
41511/02
RADIVOJEVIĆ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
4562/02
RADOJČIČ
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
42306/02
RAKANOVIČ
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
16263/02
RAMÅ AK
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
33584/02
RAMÅ AK
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
40445/06
RASIEWICZ
18/10/2012
11/02/2013
10288/02
REPAS
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
20965/03
RIBIČ
19/10/2010
19/01/2011
36349/05
RIJAVEC
15/05/2012
15/05/2012
7210/02
ROBER
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
38528/02
RODIČ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
21415/02
ROGELJ
03/03/2009
14/09/2009
75687/01
ROJC
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
75697/01
ROJNIK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
75779/01
ROŽIČ
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
20254/02
ROZMAN
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
24897/02
RUPNIK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
32989/02
ŠAKANOVIČ
13/12/2007
13/03/2008
1419/02
SCHÃœTZENHOFER
03/08/2006
03/11/2006
77522/01
SEDMAK
18/01/2006
23/05/2007
9842/07
SEDMINEK
24/10/2013
24/01/2014
42246/02
SEHUR
06/07/2006
06/10/2006
45936/99
Å ILC
29/06/2006
23/10/2006
38933/02
Å IMEK HUDOMALJ
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
7351/04
SIMONCIC
18/01/2011
18/04/2011
44580/98
SIRC
08/04/2008
29/09/2008
25053/02
Å KRABLIN
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
75810/01
SLEMENÅ EK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
77779/01
SLUGA
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
21464/02
SOLEÅ A
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
33538/02
Å OLINC
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
33333/11
SOTOÅ EK
07/11/2013
07/11/2013
22799/09
SOTOÅ EK
03/04/2014
03/04/2014
39154/02
Å RAMEL
13/12/2007
13/03/2008
77543/01
STAKNE
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
20526/02
Å TAVBE
30/11/2006
26/03/2007
41514/02
STEVANČEVIČ
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
1446/07+
STIBILJ
06/10/2015
06/01/2016
20159/06
STOJC
18/10/2012
18/03/2013
24784/02
STRADOVNIK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
34787/04
STREHAR
21/07/2011
21/07/2011
39160/02
STROPNIK
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
19611/04
Å UBINSKI
18/01/2007
18/04/2007
52886/08
Å VARA
10/10/2013
10/10/2013
10299/02
SVETLIN
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
38350/02
TOMAŽIČ
13/12/2007
02/06/2008
76141/01+
TRATAR
04/10/2007
04/01/2008
42863/02
TREBOVC
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
41391/06
TRUNK
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
35463/02
UMEK
08/01/2009
29/09/2008
6552/02
URBANIJA
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
9303/02
VARACHA
09/11/2006
09/02/2007
75701/01
VIDEMÅ EK
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
54836/00
VIDIC
03/08/2006
03/11/2006
77512/01
VIDOVIČ
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
6841/02
VIRJENT
07/12/2006
07/03/2007
36550/02
VIÅ NJAR
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
42281/02
VODEB
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
33549/02
VRBANEC
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
25616/02
VREÄŒKO
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
44100/09
VUKADINOVIČ
18/04/2013
18/07/2013
43365/02
VUKOVIČ
29/06/2006
29/09/2006
22235/02
WITMAJER
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
17596/06+
ZABOVNIK
18/10/2012
18/03/2013
24896/02
ZAKONJÅ EK
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
36261/08
ZAVODNIK
07/11/2013
07/11/2013
67447/01
ŽEHELJ
21/12/2006
23/05/2007
21308/06
ZELE
08/11/2012
08/11/2012
9301/02
ZEMLJIČ
13/04/2006
13/07/2006
35063/02
ZGONJANIN
27/04/2006
27/07/2006
27701/02
ŽIDOV
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
16281/02
ŽLENDER
06/04/2006
06/07/2006
76434/01
ŽNIDAR
09/03/2006
09/06/2006
75688/01
ŽOLGER
30/03/2006
30/06/2006
2792/02
ZORC
02/11/2006
26/03/2007
1411/02
ZUPANC
13/07/2006
13/10/2006