Lexploria - Legal research enhanced by smart algorithms
Lexploria beta Legal research enhanced by smart algorithms
Menu
Browsing history:

CASE OF ALBU AGAINST ROMANIA AND 171 OTHER CASES

Doc ref: 8508/03, 36992/03, 45924/06, 32494/03, 21305/05, 11601/03, 60489/00, 70639/01, 75261/01, 8266/05, 58... • ECHR ID: 001-186866

Document date: September 20, 2018

  • Inbound citations: 356
  • Cited paragraphs: 18
  • Outbound citations: 0

CASE OF ALBU AGAINST ROMANIA AND 171 OTHER CASES

Doc ref: 8508/03, 36992/03, 45924/06, 32494/03, 21305/05, 11601/03, 60489/00, 70639/01, 75261/01, 8266/05, 58... • ECHR ID: 001-186866

Document date: September 20, 2018

Cited paragraphs only

Resolution CM/ResDH(2018)354 Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights

172 cases against Romania

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 20 September 2018 at the 1324 th meeting of the Ministers ’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),

Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations of Article 6, paragraph 1, of the Convention and of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 due to the ineffectiveness of the mechanism set up to afford restitution of or compensation for the properties nationalised under the communist regime; having regard also to the violations of Article 6, paragraph 1, in some cases due to the excessive length of civil proceedings, the quashing of final court decisions following extraordinary appeals lodged by the General Prosecutor or the failure by the domestic courts to address decisive arguments raised by the applicants in proceedings brought to recover the nationalised properties;

Recalling the respondent State ’ s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:

- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum ; and

- of general measures preventing similar violations;

Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;

Having examined the information regularly provided by the government indicating the individual measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court;

Noting that the applicants have recovered the properties nationalised by the State, were offered equivalent properties or compensation at domestic level or received the just satisfaction awarded by the Court for pecuniary damage in the cases where restitution in kind of the original property was not possible; noting further that the proceedings found in breach of Article 6, paragraph 1, on account of their excessive length had ended by the time the Court gave the judgments;

Considering that the question of individual measures has therefore been resolved in all these cases;

Underlining that the closure of these cases in no way prejudges the Committee ’ s evaluation of the general measures in relation to the reform of the mechanism of reparation for properties nationalised under the Communist regime, to be pursued in the framework of the cases of Maria Atanasiu and Others and Străin and Others ;

Noting that the questions related to the excessive length of judicial proceedings, raised by the cases of Enyedi and Cherbeţiu and Pop , continue to be examined in the context of the supervision of the Vlad group of cases;

Noting that the questions related to the powers of the General Prosecutor to lodge extraordinary appeals in civil disputes, raised by the cases of Petrini and Simionescu-Râmniceanu (No. 2) , were examined in the context of the supervision of the Brumărescu group of cases (Final resolution CM/ResDH(2007)90 );

Noting that the questions related to the failure by the courts to address decisive arguments brought by the parties to civil proceedings, raised in the case of Karl Gottfried and Helmut Martin Schwarz, were examined in the context of the supervision of the case of Vlasia Grigore Vasilescu (Final resolution CM/ResDH(2011)19 );

DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases as regards the individual measures and

DECIDES to close the examination of these cases.

Appendix

Application

Case

Judgment of

Final on

8508/03

ALBU

17/06/2008

17/09/2008

36992/03

ALDEA

24/01/2008

24/04/2008

45924/06

ANEA AND NITESCU

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

32494/03

ASLAN

24/05/2007

24/09/2007

21305/05

ATHANASIU MARSHALL

23/06/2009

23/09/2009

11601/03

BABES

24/01/2008

24/04/2008

60489/00

BALANESCU

06/12/2007

06/03/2008

70639/01

BARBU

12/10/2006

12/01/2007

75261/01

BARCANESCU

12/10/2006

12/01/2007

8266/05

BECSKEI

07/07/2009

07/10/2009

5855/05

BISTRIÅ¢EANU AND POPOVICI

09/02/2010

09/05/2010

12776/06

BONE

04/11/2008

04/02/2009

75297/01

BRAZDA AND MALITA

31/05/2007

31/08/2007

24471/04

BRETCANU

20/12/2007

20/03/2008

20517/02

BUTTU AND BOBULESCU NO. 1

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

20532/02

BUTTU AND BOBULESCU NO. 2

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

8780/04

CALINESCU

8/01/2009

8/04/2009

10754/04

CAPETAN-BACSKAI

25/10/2007

25/01/2008

38742/04

CARAGHEORGHE AND OTHERS

19/01/2010

19/04/2010

32286/03

CERNAT

17/01/2008

17/04/2008

28607/04

CERNESCU AND MANOLACHE

08/01/2009

30/11/2010

08/04/2009

11/04/2011

11474/04

CERNITU

21/07/2009

21/10/2009

13248/05+

CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, INDUSTRY AND AGRICULTURE OF TIMIÅžOARA NO. 1

16/07/2009

16/10/2009

23520/05+

CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, INDUSTRY AND AGRICULTURE OF TIMIÅžOARA NO. 2

16/07/2009

16/10/2009

36476/03

CHEREBEÅ¢IU AND POP

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

20535/03

CHIOREAN

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

13067/03

CIOBANIUC

16/02/2010

16/05/2010

31603/03

CIOBOTEA

25/10/2007

25/01/2008

22281/05

CÃŽRSTOIU

04/03/2008

04/06/2008

38538/02

COHEN

06/12/2007

06/03/2008

28584/04

CONSTANTINESCU ELENA AND OTHERS

8/01/2009

8/04/2009

6946/03

COPACI

16/03/2010

16/06/2010

54400/00

CROITORIU

09/11/2004

30/03/2005

11388/06

CZARAN AND GROFCSIK

02/06/2009

02/09/2009

70890/01

DANULESCU

12/10/2006

12/01/2007

2252/02

DAVIDESCU

16/11/2006

16/02/2007

17754/06

DERMENDYIN

27/10/2009

27/01/2010

5629/03+

DIMITRESCU

03/06/2008

03/09/2008

35823/03

DIMITRU AND DUMITRACHE

20/01/2009

20/04/2009

35510/06

DIVER

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

3565/04

DOBRESCU

07/10/2008

07/01/2009

17268/03

DRAGALINA

14/10/2008

03/06/2014

06/04/2009

17/11/2014

78047/01

DRAGNE AND OTHERS

07/04/2005

16/11/2006

07/07/2005

16/02/2007

31181/03

DRAGOMIR

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

32743/05

DRAGOÅž

11/10/2007

11/01/2008

19835/03

DREPTU

13/11/2008

13/02/2009

17979/05

DUMITRAS

28/07/2009

28/10/2009

29231/06

DUMITRESCU CHRISTIAN AND MIHAIL

01/12/2009

10/05/2010

9292/05

ENCIU AND LEGA

08/02/2007

08/05/2007

4632/03

ENGBER

06/12/2007

06/03/2008

32211/02

ENYEDI

02/06/2009

02/09/2009

26879/02

EPISCOPIA ROMNĂ UNITĂ CU ROMA ORADEA

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

24959/02

ERBICEANU

26/04/2007

26/07/2007

2230/02

ERNEST

04/11/2008

04/02/2009

37522/05

EVOLCEANU

09/02/2010

18/03/2014

09/05/2010

18/06/2014

30142/03

FARA

14/02/2008

14/05/2008

34839/03

FILIPESCU

30/09/2008

30/12/2008

18108/03

FRIEDRICH

07/10/2008

07/01/2009

16891/02

FUNKE

26/04/2007

26/07/2007

35951/02

GABRIEL

08/03/2007

08/06/2007

16890/04

GHERASE

8/01/2009

8/04/2009

21227/03+

GHERGHICEANU AND OTHERS

08/12/2009

08/03/2010

35955/02

GINGIS

04/11/2008

04/02/2009

15269/03

GLATZ AND OTHERS

02/06/2009

02/09/2009

19188/03

GRIGORAÅž

07/10/2008

07/01/2009

2611/02

GROSU

28/06/2007

13/01/2009

28/09/2007

06/07/2009

10012/03

HALMAGIU AND BELLU

03/06/2008

03/09/2008

25230/04

HAÅ¢IEGAN

14/02/2008

14/05/2008

34011/02

HERTZOG AND OTHERS

26/07/2007

14/04/2009

26/10/2007

14/09/2009

24175/03

HOLLITZER

10/01/2008

10/04/2008

37296/04

HUBER JOHANNA

21/02/2008

21/05/2008

18898/02

ILUTIU

06/12/2007

03/02/2009

06/03/2008

03/05/2009

19436/04

ION

24/01/2008

24/04/2008

11116/02

IONESCU

31/05/2007

31/08/2007

10788/06

IONESCU AND ISTRATE

27/01/2009

27/04/2009

36128/04

IONESCU AND MAFTEI

27/01/2009

27/04/2009

25963/03

IONESCU ILIE

26/01/2010

26/04/2010

2608/02

IONESCU RUXANDA

12/10/2006

12/01/2007

34783/02

IRING

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

42212/04

ISAR

25/10/2007

31/03/2008

12728/03

JUJESCU

29/06/2006

29/09/2006

29739/03

KATZ

20/01/2009

20/04/2009

38023/02

KRAJCSOVICS AND OTHERS

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

10636/06

LÄ‚ZÄ‚RESCU MARIA VIOLETA

23/02/2010

23/05/2010

111/07

LOEWENTON

26/01/2010

26/04/2010

33768/04

MAN AND CUSA

23/02/2010

23/05/2010

35591/03

MÄ‚RÄ‚CINEANU

09/02/2010

09/05/2010

17955/05

MARINESCU

13/01/2009

13/04/2009

5381/04

MLÄ‚DIN

09/02/2010

09/05/2010

16304/04

MOROIANU

09/12/2008

06/04/2009

25008/05

MOROIANU AND OTHERS

13/11/2008

13/02/2009

10245/02

MOSOIU AND PÄ‚SÄ‚RIN

07/02/2008

28/06/2011

07/05/2008

28/09/2011

4867/04

MURÄ‚REÅ¢ ANDREESCU AND OTHERS

19/01/2010

28/06/2010

33353/03

MUSAT

11/10/2007

31/03/2008

9862/04

NEGOITA

25/01/2007

25/04/2007

2726/02

NERUMBERG

01/02/2007

09/07/2007

31153/03

NICOLESCU

20/01/2009

20/04/2009

10311/03

NICOLESCU TRAIAN-CONSTANTIN

23/02/2010

23/05/2010

15517/03

NISTORESCU

17/06/2008

17/09/2008

24202/07

NITA

26/01/2010

26/04/2010

63252/00

PÄ‚DURARU

01/12/2005

15/03/2006

01/03/2006

24/09/2007

4738/04

PAIS

21/12/2006

21/03/2007

25920/05

PAPPSZASZ

21/02/2008

21/05/2008

41819/05

PAÅžCANU

8/01/2009

8/04/2009

1597/02

PATRICHI

12/10/2006

12/01/2007

9405/02

PÄ‚UN

24/05/2007

24/08/2007

13075/03

PENESCU

05/10/2006

05/01/2007

73969/01

PETRESCU

15/03/2007

15/06/2007

23635/04

PETRESCU IOANA AND OTHERS

03/06/2008

03/09/2008

3320/05

PETRINI

24/02/2009

24/05/2009

30105/05

PETROIU AND OTHERS

24/11/2009

03/06/2014

14/06/2016 REV

24/02/2010

03/09/2014

14/09/2016

30307/02

PETRULIAN IOANOVICI

16/09/2008

16/12/2008

25434/05

PICÄ‚

16/02/2010

16/05/2010

30680/03

PINTILIE

09/12/2008

06/04/2009

13451/03

POPA LUCREÅ¢IA AND OTHERS

09/12/2008

05/06/2009

9684/04

POPESCU ALEXANDRA MARIA

12/01/2010

12/04/2010

24681/03

POPESCU AND DAÅžOVEANU

19/07/2007

19/10/2007

17799/03

POPESCU AND DIMECA

09/12/2008

09/03/2009

5571/04

POPESCU CONSTANTIN

30/09/2008

30/12/2008

21397/02

POPESCU DIMITRIE DAN

14/12/2006

14/03/2007

20589/04

POPESCU OCTAVIAN

30/06/2009

08/04/2014

30/09/2009

08/07/2014

4596/03

PORTEANU

16/02/2006

16/05/2006

9584/02+

PREDA AND OTHERS

29/04/2014

29/07/2014

21447/03

PREDESCU

02/12/2008

02/03/2009

38467/03

RABINOVICI

27/07/2006

27/10/2006

13309/03

RADU

20/07/2006

20/10/2006

14884/03

RÄ‚DULESCU MIHAI AND RÄ‚DULESCU RADU

20/10/2009

20/01/2010

39761/03

RASIDESCU

15/09/2009

07/04/2015

15/12/2009

07/07/2015

18729/05

RÄ‚Å¢EANU

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

6111/04

REICHARDT

13/11/2008

13/02/2009

35803/03

REUNIUNEA DE AJUTOR PENTRU ÃŽNMORMANTARE FRATELIA

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

29683/02

ROTARU AND CRISTIAN

30/11/2006

28/02/2007

4198/04

RUSU AND OTHERS

19/07/2007

19/10/2007

1696/03

SÄ‚VULESCU

12/07/2007

12/10/2007

36977/03+

SCHUSTER

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

39740/03

SCHWARZ KARL GOTTFRIED AND SCHWARZ HELMUT MARTIN

12/01/2010

12/04/2010

58612/00

SEBASTIAN TAUB

12/10/2006

12/01/2007

2915/02

SECELEANU AND OTHERS

12/01/2010

12/04/2010

19372/06

SILIMON AND GROSS

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

16272/03

SIMIONESCU-RMNICEANU

21/07/2009

21/10/2009

43953/02

SIMIONESCU-RMNICEANU NO. 2

22/07/2009

22/10/2009

3113/02

STAN AND ROSEMBERGER

17/07/2008

17/10/2008

3530/03

STANCIU

10/03/2009

10/06/2009

29755/06

STANCIU GETA AND OTHERS

23/03/2010

01/07/2014

23/06/2010

01/10/2014

35018/03

ÅžTEFÄ‚NESCU

12/01/2010

12/04/2010

34741/07

ÅžTEFÄ‚NESCU AND OTHERS

21/07/2009

21/10/2009

20334/03

STOICUTIA

03/06/2008

03/09/2008

26449/04

STROIA

08/02/2007

08/05/2007

25603/02

SUCIU ARAMA

09/11/2006

09/02/2007

26521/05

SUCIU WERLE

13/12/2007

13/03/2008

31177/02

SZEKELY

11/10/2007

11/01/2008

16947/03

TÄ‚CULESCU AND OTHERS

01/04/2008

01/07/2008

42194/05

TAMIR AND OTHERS

15/09/2009

15/12/2009

2122/04

TARBUC

14/12/2006

14/03/2007

43774/02

TEODORESCU OLIMPIA-MARIA

04/11/2008

04/02/2009

10108/02

Å¢EÅ¢U

07/02/2008

31/03/2009

07/05/2008

30/06/2009

18419/02

TODICESCU

24/05/2007

24/08/2007

5691/03

TOGANEL AND GRADINARU

29/06/2006

29/09/2006

36900/03

TOŞCUŢĂ AND OTHERS

25/11/2008

03/03/2015

25/02/2009

06/07/2015

77048/01

TOVARU

12/10/2006

12/01/2007

1193/08

TROFIM

30/03/2010

03/03/2015

30/06/2010

06/07/2015

29035/05

TUDOR

17/01/2008

17/04/2008

28282/04

TULEA

21/02/2008

21/05/2008

31566/03

TURUS

07/07/2009

06/11/2009

23354/02

UNGUREANU

09/11/2006

09/02/2007

8704/06

VARODI

19/01/2010

19/04/2010

19438/05

VENIAMIN

26/01/2010

26/04/2010

23576/04

VIDRASCU

14/12/2006

14/03/2007

11138/06

VIDRAÅžCU NO. 2

27/10/2009

27/01/2010

6350/02

VLÄ‚DUÅ¢

30/11/2006

28/02/2007

7976/02

VODÄ‚ AND BOB

07/02/2008

07/05/2008

35303/03

WEIGEL

08/03/2007

14/10/2008

08/06/2007

14/01/2009

© European Union, https://eur-lex.europa.eu, 1998 - 2024
Active Products: EUCJ + ECHR Data Package + Citation Analytics • Documents in DB: 398107 • Paragraphs parsed: 43931842 • Citations processed 3409255