TSKHOVREBOVA AND OTHERS v. GEORGIA
Doc ref: 43733/08, 43734/08, 44377/08, 44382/08, 44383/08, 45423/08, 45427/08, 45433/08, 45440/08, 45442/08, ... • ECHR ID: 001-216681
Document date: March 3, 2022
- Inbound citations: 778
- •
- Cited paragraphs: 142
- •
- Outbound citations: 2
FIFTH SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 43733/08 Dzerassa Feliksovna TSKHOVREBOVA against Georgia and 369 other applications (see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting on 3 March 2022 as a Committee composed of:
Stéphanie Mourou-Vikström, President, Lətif Hüseynov, Kateřina Šimáčková, judges,
and Martina Keller, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the applications against Georgia lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) on the dates and by the individuals, who are all Russian nationals, listed in the appended table;
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
SUBJECT-MATTER OF THE CASE
1. The applications listed in the appendix concern an international armed conflict (“the IAC”) that occurred between Georgia and the Russian Federation in August 2008, the chronology of which was described in the Court’s judgment in the inter-State case of Georgia v. Russia (II) ([GC] (merits), no. 38263/08, §§ 32-44, 21 January 2021). Relying on Articles 2, 3, 5, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, the applicants complained that the military actions undertaken by the Georgian armed forces in South Ossetia [1] in the period ranging from the night of 7 to 8 August until and including 12 August 2008, that is during the active phase of the IAC, had put their lives, as well as those of their family members, under real and immediate danger, obliged them to spend several days in anxiety and fear, restricted their physical liberty and damaged their properties.
THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT
2. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
Loading citations...3. The Court recalls that the legal issues raised under the Convention in the context of the above-mentioned IAC were comprehensively examined by the Court in the inter-State case of Georgia v. Russia (II) (cited above) as well as in the two leading individual applications of Bekoyeva and Others v. Georgia ((dec.), no. 43733/08, §§ 32-40, 5 October 2021) and Shavlokhova and Others v. Georgia ((dec.), no. 45431/08, §§ 27-35). In particular, as the Court ruled in the latter individual cases, the events that unfolded in South Ossetia and other areas of Georgia, where the massive fighting between the armed forces of the Russian Federation and the respondent State took place during the active phase of the IAC, were “acts of war”, in a context of chaos and confusion, effectively preventing Georgia from exercising its authority over the areas in question for the duration of the active phase of the hostilities. Since the inability to exercise State authority was only a temporal limitation of the normal exercise of the respondent State’s territorial jurisdiction over its war ‑ stricken territories, Georgia was, as a matter of principle, expected under the Convention to take diplomatic, economic, judicial or other positive measures. However, given the ongoing massive armed conflict, positive measures of a public order nature were, on the one hand, impossible to implement and, on the other, of no real value, as they could not have meaningfully contributed to the protection of the applicants’ rights in times of war. Consequently, the respondent State’s responsibility could not be engaged for the acts that took place in South Ossetia during the active phase of the relevant hostilities (see Bekoyeva and Others , §§ 36-39 and Shavlokhova and Others , §§ 31-34, both decisions cited above).
4. After a careful examination of all the applications listed in the appendix, the Court notes that they are identical to the above-mentioned leading cases of Bekoyeva and Others and Shavlokhova and Others , and that there are no reasons to depart from its previous findings on the matter. It follows that these applications, which stem from the “acts of war” that took place on the territory of Georgia during the active phase of the IAC, must be declared inadmissible in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Done in English and notified in writing on 24 March 2022.
Martina Keller Stéphanie Mourou-Vikström Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant
1.
43733/08
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Dzerassa TSKHOVREBOVA
2.
43734/08
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Elmira TSKHOVREBOVA
3.
44377/08
Alborova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Olga ALBOROVA
4.
44382/08
Khosroyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Fatima KHOSROYEVA
5.
44383/08
Koroyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Izolda KOROYEVA
6.
45423/08
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Luiza TSKHOVREBOVA
7.
45427/08
Khubulova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Fatima KHUBULOVA
8.
45433/08
Tokmayeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Rada TOKMAYEVA
9.
45440/08
Gobozova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Tina GOBOZOVA
10.
45442/08
Kokoyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Violetta KOKOYEVA
11.
45443/08
Tasoyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Inga TASOYEVA
12.
45444/08
Gigolayeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Zalina GIGOLAYEVA
13.
45448/08
Sanakoyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Alena SANAKOYEVA
14.
46282/08
Khabalova v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Ms Ella KHABALOVA
15.
46284/08
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Ms Madina DZHIOYEVA
16.
46287/08
Tadtayeva v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Ms Leyla TADTAYEVA
17.
46288/08
Bekoyeva v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Ms Zarina BEKOYEVA
18.
46296/08
Gagiyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Polina GAGIYEVA
19.
46298/08
Bikoyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Tamara BIKOYEVA
20.
46300/08
Tokmayeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Elvira TOKMAYEVA
21.
46636/08
Gergaulova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Tsiala GERGAULOVA
22.
46640/08
Khabalova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Emma KHABALOVA
23.
46642/08
Kachmazov v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Suliko KACHMAZOV
24.
46646/08
Dzhagayeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Svetlana DZHAGAYEVA
25.
46648/08
Kumaritova v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Eteri KUMARITOVA
26.
46650/08
Khudzhiyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Venera KHUDZHIYEVA
27.
46651/08
Bestayeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Ira BESTAYEVA
28.
46653/08
Gazayeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Fatima GAZAYEVA
29.
46654/08
Pukhayeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Kseniya PUKHAYEVA
30.
46655/08
Gagiyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Roza GAGIYEVA
31.
48372/08
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Larisa DZHIOYEVA
32.
50652/08
Kokayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Rusudan KOKAYEVA
33.
50653/08
Doguzova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Nina DOGUZOVA
34.
50660/08
Tasoyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Svetlana TASOYEVA
35.
50662/08
Taniya v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Dzhulyetta TANIYA
36.
50671/08
Bolotayev v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Mr Dmitriy BOLOTAYEV
37.
50679/08
Kulumbegov v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Mr Fedor KULUMBEGOV
38.
50681/08
Tadtayeva v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Ms Emma TADTAYEVA
39.
50683/08
Doguzova v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Ms Zema DOGUZOVA
40.
50711/08
Kasradze v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Mr Georgiy KASRADZE
41.
50721/08
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Ms Tsiala KOCHIYEVA
42.
52173/08
Byazrova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Klavdiya BYAZROVA
43.
52174/08
Gagloyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Sonya GAGLOYEVA
44.
52175/08
Smelova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Yekaterina SMELOVA
45.
52180/08
Dzagoyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Dzhulyetta DZAGOYEVA
46.
52184/08
Muzayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Zaminet MUZAYEVA
47.
52186/08
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Khadizat TEDEYEVA
48.
52189/08
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Alena TSKHOVREBOVA
49.
52258/08
Pliyeva v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Ms Lolita PLIYEVA
50.
52264/08
Bestayev v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Mr Kavkaz BESTAYEV
51.
53473/08
Kulumbegova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Zarina KULUMBEGOVA
52.
53510/08
Valiyeva v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Ms Alena VALIYEVA
53.
53513/08
Dochiyeva v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Ms Dzhulyeta DOCHIYEVA
54.
53855/08
Kokoyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Alla KOKOYEVA
55.
53857/08
Bestayev v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Mr Kazimir BESTAYEV
56.
53861/08
Bestayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Alla BESTAYEVA
57.
53869/08
Bestayev v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Mr Vasiliy BESTAYEV
58.
53898/08
Kokoyev v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Mr Aleksey KOKOYEV
59.
53906/08
Dzhioyev v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Mr Igor DZHIOYEV
60.
53910/08
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Fatima TEDEYEVA
61.
55263/08
Gabarayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Dzhulyetta GABARAYEVA
62.
55279/08
Bitiyeva v. Georgia
01/09/2008
Ms Yuza BITIYEVA
63.
55282/08
Arsoyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Alla ARSOYEVA
64.
55283/08
Khubayev v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Mr Vasiliy KHUBAYEV
65.
55287/08
Servetnik v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Valeriya SERVETNIK
66.
55289/08
Bitsoyeva v. Georgia
02/09/2008
Ms Maka BITSOYEVA
67.
56953/08
Bosikova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Kristina BOSIKOVA
68.
56956/08
Tomayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Nona TOMAYEVA
69.
56963/08
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Svetlana DZHIOYEVA
70.
57195/08
Kharebova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Aza KHAREBOVA
71.
57211/08
Alborova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Yelena ALBOROVA
72.
57247/08
Alborov v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Albert ALBOROV
73.
57260/08
Bestayeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Natalya BESTAYEVA
74.
58632/08
Dzhagayeva v. Georgia
17/09/2008
Ms Aleksandra DZHAGAYEVA
75.
58635/08
Dzagoyeva v. Georgia
17/09/2008
Ms Yuzya DZAGOYEVA
76.
58643/08
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
17/09/2008
Ms Larisa TSKHOVREBOVA
77.
58645/08
Pliyeva v. Georgia
17/09/2008
Ms Yelena PLIYEVA
78.
59655/08
Dyakonova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Fatima DYAKONOVA
79.
59661/08
Dzhigkayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Eleonora DZHIGKAYEVA
80.
59684/08
Khachirova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zhenya KHACHIROVA
81.
90/09
Dzhabiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Marina DZHABIYEVA
82.
93/09
Tasoyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Diana TASOYEVA
83.
94/09
Kotayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Svetlana KOTAYEVA
84.
97/09
Kabanova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zalina KABANOVA
85.
107/09
Bosikova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Fatima BOSIKOVA
86.
117/09
Loloyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Manana LOLOYEVA
87.
119/09
Gagiyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Zareta GAGIYEVA
88.
120/09
Dochiyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Asiat DOCHIYEVA
89.
121/09
Khabalov v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Vladimir KHABALOV
90.
123/09
Chekhoyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Lidiya CHEKHOYEVA
91.
125/09
Galavanova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Alma GALAVANOVA
92.
126/09
Dzhabiyev v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Khasan DZHABIYEV
93.
132/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Izolda VALIYEVA
94.
135/09
Kudukhova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Alla KUDUKHOVA
95.
139/09
Khubulova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Inga KHUBULOVA
96.
148/09
Gigolayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Larisa GIGOLAYEVA
97.
149/09
Guchmazova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Svetlana GUCHMAZOVA
98.
152/09
Dzhagayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Lyudmila DZHAGAYEVA
99.
154/09
Kelekhsayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Rimma KELEKHSAYEVA
100.
160/09
Tandelova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Rita TANDELOVA
101.
162/09
Chibirova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Svetlana CHIBIROVA
102.
163/09
Pliyeva v. Georgia
17/09/2008
Ms Mayya PLIYEVA
103.
165/09
Sanakoyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Marina SANAKOYEVA
104.
173/09
Bestayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Laura BESTAYEVA
105.
183/09
Gagloyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Revmira GAGLOYEVA
106.
186/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Lena TSKHOVREBOVA
107.
2177/09
Tadtayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Roza TADTAYEVA
108.
2189/09
Sinelnikov v. Georgia
18/09/2008
Mr Aleksandr SINELNIKOV
109.
2196/09
Namshuradze v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Genriyetta NAMSHURADZE
110.
2199/09
Kachmazova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Luiza KACHMAZOVA
111.
2202/09
Gatikoyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Madina GATIKOYEVA
112.
2206/09
Bestauty v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Shushana BESTAUTY
113.
2208/09
Doguzova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Giuli DOGUZOVA
114.
2211/09
Dzhigkayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Zemulya DZHIGKAYEVA
115.
2215/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Lyuba TSKHOVREBOVA
116.
2219/09
Khugayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Zhenya KHUGAYEVA
117.
2229/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Violetta TEDEYEVA
118.
2231/09
Kusrayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Galina KUSRAYEVA
119.
2234/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Galina TSKHOVREBOVA
120.
2237/09
Israelyan v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Mr Valiko ISRAELYAN
121.
2239/09
Avakyan v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Mr Frunzik AVAKYAN
122.
2240/09
Kudukhova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Nino KUDUKHOVA
123.
2242/09
Tuayev v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Mr Georgi TUAYEV
124.
2248/09
Muldarova v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Dzerassa MULDAROVA
125.
2250/09
Kozayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Arina KOZAYEVA
126.
2252/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Zamira TEDEYEVA
127.
2254/09
Tigiyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Aza TIGIYEVA
128.
2255/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Yelizaveta VALIYEVA
129.
2263/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Alena TEDEYEVA
130.
2264/09
Alborova v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Irma ALBOROVA
131.
2268/09
Oganov v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Mr Leri OGANOV
132.
2270/09
Gutsayeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Nelli GUTSAYEVA
133.
2271/09
Kachmazova v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Dzhulyetta KACHMAZOVA
134.
2274/09
Ostayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Fatima OSTAYEVA
135.
2276/09
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Zaira KOCHIYEVA
136.
5293/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Lali TEDEYEVA
137.
5294/09
Tadtayeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Svetlana TADTAYEVA
138.
5302/09
Dochiyeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Zalina DOCHIYEVA
139.
5313/09
Tokmayeva v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Ms Rita TOKMAYEVA
140.
5314/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Zaira TEDEYEVA
141.
5325/09
Gabaraty v. Georgia
08/09/2008
Mr Kadzakh GABARATY
142.
5329/09
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Liana KOCHIYEVA
143.
5331/09
Gigolayev v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Mr Georgiy GIGOLAYEV
144.
5335/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Marina TSKHOVREBOVA
145.
5341/09
Totoyeva v. Georgia
05/09/2008
Ms Bella TOTOYEVA
146.
5344/09
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
05/09/2008
Ms Madina KOCHIYEVA
147.
5349/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
05/09/2008
Ms Ira DZHIOYEVA
148.
5351/09
Tuayeva v. Georgia
05/09/2008
Ms Inga TUAYEVA
149.
5354/09
Galavanova v. Georgia
05/09/2008
Ms Fatima GALAVANOVA
150.
5356/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
05/09/2008
Ms Lena TSKHOVREBOVA
151.
5360/09
Bekoyeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Yuza BEKOYEVA
152.
5363/09
Satkoyeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Yelina SATKOYEVA
153.
5364/09
Tedeyev v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Mr Yuriy TEDEYEV
154.
5365/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Oksana TEDEYEVA
155.
5370/09
Gigolayeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Nelli GIGOLAYEVA
156.
5375/09
Kokoyeva v. Georgia
15/09/2008
Ms Aza KOKOYEVA
157.
5379/09
Vaneyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Ilona VANEYEVA
158.
5380/09
Byazrova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Alla BYAZROVA
159.
5381/09
Kokoyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Lyuda KOKOYEVA
160.
5382/09
Vaneyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Rita VANEYEVA
161.
5385/09
Parastayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Manana PARASTAYEVA
162.
5387/09
Dzhussoyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Dzerassa DZHUSSOYEVA
163.
6930/09
Khugayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zarina KHUGAYEVA
164.
6937/09
Galavanova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Aza GALAVANOVA
165.
6963/09
Bolatayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Mariya BOLATAYEVA
166.
6964/09
Bolatayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Fatima BOLATAYEVA
167.
6968/09
Bolatayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Fedosiya BOLATAYEVA
168.
6984/09
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
06/09/2008
Ms Fatima KOCHIYEVA
169.
6986/09
Tibilov v. Georgia
06/09/2008
Mr Vyacheslav TIBILOV
170.
6988/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
06/09/2008
Ms Zoya VALIYEVA
171.
6989/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
06/09/2008
Ms Tina VALIYEVA
172.
6991/09
Tasoyev v. Georgia
06/09/2008
Mr Ibragim TASOYEV
173.
6994/09
Doguzova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Dali DOGUZOVA
174.
7001/09
Doguzov v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Mr Vadim DOGUZOV
175.
7002/09
Margiyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Marina MARGIYEVA
176.
7008/09
Dudayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Madina DUDAYEVA
177.
7009/09
Dudayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Luiza DUDAYEVA
178.
7014/09
Smelov v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Ivan SMELOV
179.
7015/09
Dzebisashvili v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Khatuna DZEBISASHVILI
180.
7016/09
Smelova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Ella SMELOVA
181.
7020/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Zaida DZHIOYEVA
182.
7024/09
Kelekhsayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Dina KELEKHSAYEVA
183.
8295/09
Gubiyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Felina GUBIYEVA
184.
8296/09
Siukayev v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Soslan SIUKAYEV
185.
8303/09
Kumaritova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Anzhela KUMARITOVA
186.
8313/09
Tokmayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Nelli TOKMAYEVA
187.
8319/09
Laliyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Albina LALIYEVA
188.
8333/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Liana DZHIOYEVA
189.
8334/09
Sanakoyev v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Mr Guliyermo SANAKOYEV
190.
8335/09
Dzhabiyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Vera DZHABIYEVA
191.
8342/09
Mamiyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Larisa MAMIYEVA
192.
8343/09
Vasina v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Olga VASINA
193.
8345/09
Bestayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Marina BESTAYEVA
194.
8348/09
Lapachi v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Nona LAPACHI
195.
8349/09
Kotayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Irina KOTAYEVA
196.
8362/09
Kabisova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Roksana KABISOVA
197.
11344/09
Kotayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Mariya KOTAYEVA
198.
11345/09
Kotayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Anna KOTAYEVA
199.
11348/09
Ichkiti v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Mr Shalva ICHKITI
200.
11349/09
Bekoyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Rita BEKOYEVA
201.
11357/09
Zasseyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Irina ZASSEYEVA
202.
11358/09
Tadtayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Elvira TADTAYEVA
203.
11360/09
Gabarayeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Lyudmila GABARAYEVA
204.
11361/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Irina DZHIOYEVA
205.
11363/09
Dzhidchoyeva v. Georgia
09/09/2008
Ms Polina DZHIDCHOYEVA
206.
11371/09
Gabuyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Medeya GABUYEVA
207.
11376/09
Gazzayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Madina GAZZAYEVA
208.
11377/09
Galavanova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Tamara GALAVANOVA
209.
11378/09
Gigolayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Madina GIGOLAYEVA
210.
11392/09
Gabarayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Roza GABARAYEVA
211.
11396/09
Dzhagayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Aina DZHAGAYEVA
212.
11397/09
Dzhagayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Tasya DZHAGAYEVA
213.
11411/09
Dzukayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Inga DZUKAYEVA
214.
11413/09
Pukhayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Marusya PUKHAYEVA
215.
11420/09
Kozayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Dinara KOZAYEVA
216.
11423/09
Kokoyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Albina KOKOYEVA
217.
11428/09
Pukhayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Zarina PUKHAYEVA
218.
12318/09
Bagayev v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Valeriy BAGAYEV
219.
12326/09
Beteyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Valentina BETEYEVA
220.
12332/09
Bagiyayev v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Anatoliy BAGIYAYEV
221.
12350/09
Orlova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Lyudmila ORLOVA
222.
12352/09
Tekhova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Natela TEKHOVA
223.
12361/09
Tekhova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Zhanna TEKHOVA
224.
12373/09
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Izolda KOCHIYEVA
225.
12374/09
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Marina KOCHIYEVA
226.
12384/09
Dudayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Valya DUDAYEVA
227.
12388/09
Kozayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Evelina KOZAYEVA
228.
12390/09
Kudukhova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zalina KUDUKHOVA
229.
12393/09
Loloyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Rita LOLOYEVA
230.
12394/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Sofiya DZHIOYEVA
231.
12398/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Anzhela DZHIOYEVA
232.
12400/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zaira VALIYEVA
233.
12401/09
Bekoshvili v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Eteri BEKOSHVILI
234.
13471/09
Dzhioyev v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Mr Vadim DZHIOYEV
235.
13486/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Gulnara TSKHOVREBOVA
236.
13489/09
Tabatadze v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Daredzhan TABATADZE
237.
13491/09
Tekhova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Olga TEKHOVA
238.
13499/09
Kudukhova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Larisa KUDUKHOVA
239.
13505/09
Bestayeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Anzhela BESTAYEVA
240.
13521/09
Gagloyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Yeva GAGLOYEVA
241.
13527/09
Gagloyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Viktoriya GAGLOYEVA
242.
13531/09
Kabisova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Zalina KABISOVA
243.
13540/09
Beruashvili v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Fatima BERUASHVILI
244.
13541/09
Khetaturova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Irina KHETATUROVA
245.
13548/09
Parastayeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Yermoniya PARASTAYEVA
246.
13549/09
Koliyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Varya KOLIYEVA
247.
13550/09
Vaneyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Luiza VANEYEVA
248.
15200/09
Pliyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Lyudmila PLIYEVA
249.
15203/09
Makiyev v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Mr Sardion MAKIYEV
250.
15206/09
Khugayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Salimat KHUGAYEVA
251.
15220/09
Chekhoyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Aza CHEKHOYEVA
252.
15226/09
Tekhova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zhanna TEKHOVA
253.
15228/09
Ikoyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Indira IKOYEVA
254.
15230/09
Kisiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Dinara KISIYEVA
255.
15233/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Alla TEDEYEVA
256.
15240/09
Alborova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Galina ALBOROVA
257.
15250/09
Kasabiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Lyudmila KASABIYEVA
258.
15252/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Natela VALIYEVA
259.
15256/09
Laliyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Lali LALIYEVA
260.
15257/09
Guchmazova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Radmila GUCHMAZOVA
261.
15265/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zamira TEDEYEVA
262.
15267/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Maya VALIYEVA
263.
15268/09
Mamedov v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Mr Adyl MAMEDOV
264.
15269/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Ilona DZHIOYEVA
265.
15270/09
Kobesova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Valentina KOBESOVA
266.
15271/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Arina TEDEYEVA
267.
15274/09
Gubiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Marina GUBIYEVA
268.
15275/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Madina VALIYEVA
269.
15277/09
Chekhoyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Zalina CHEKHOYEVA
270.
15289/09
Gagloyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Yana GAGLOYEVA
271.
17594/09
Tibilova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Elvira TIBILOVA
272.
17609/09
Baratova v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Irina BARATOVA
273.
17613/09
Bagayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Zoya BAGAYEVA
274.
17625/09
Kokoyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Zalina KOKOYEVA
275.
17629/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Madina DZHIOYEVA
276.
17641/09
Gobozova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Tamila GOBOZOVA
277.
17649/09
Gagloyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Bella GAGLOYEVA
278.
17655/09
Kozayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Lyuba KOZAYEVA
279.
17657/09
Bolatayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Nusha BOLATAYEVA
280.
17658/09
Gigolayeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Alda GIGOLAYEVA
281.
17659/09
Mamiyeva v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Alesya MAMIYEVA
282.
17660/09
Dzudtsova v. Georgia
13/09/2008
Ms Galina DZUDTSOVA
283.
20470/09
Sanakoyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Liana SANAKOYEVA
284.
20477/09
Tasoyev v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Mr Georgiy TASOYEV
285.
20479/09
Gabarayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Elvira GABARAYEVA
286.
20480/09
Bigulayeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Tamara BIGULAYEVA
287.
20481/09
Asayev v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Mr Ivan ASAYEV
288.
20486/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
11/09/2008
Ms Angelina VALIYEVA
289.
20515/09
Guchmazova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Zhenya GUCHMAZOVA
290.
20518/09
Tasoyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Margo TASOYEVA
291.
20519/09
Gergaulova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Klavdiya GERGAULOVA
292.
20544/09
Kochiyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Manya KOCHIYEVA
293.
20546/09
Bazzayeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Aksana BAZZAYEVA
294.
20552/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Madina TSKHOVREBOVA
295.
22463/09
Guchmazova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Yelizaveta GUCHMAZOVA
296.
24877/09
Petrakov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Viktor PETRAKOV
297.
24878/09
Mustafin v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Farid MUSTAFIN
298.
24879/09
Nurgaliyev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Nail NURGALIYEV
299.
24880/09
Krupchatnikov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Aleksandr KRUPCHATNIKOV
300.
24881/09
Yunusov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Rustam YUNUSOV
301.
24882/09
Shents v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Sergey SHENTS
302.
24883/09
Suvorov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Dmitriy SUVOROV
303.
24884/09
Balkarov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Akhmed BALKAROV
304.
24885/09
Pavlov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Nikolay PAVLOV
305.
24886/09
Kelokhsayev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Atsamaz KELOKHSAYEV
306.
24887/09
Polushkin v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Sergey POLUSHKIN
307.
24888/09
Valiyev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Robert VALIYEV
308.
24889/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Ms Lyudmila VALIYEVA
309.
24890/09
Pliyev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Teymuraz PLIYEV
310.
24891/09
Kozayev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Aleksandr KOZAYEV
311.
24892/09
Kozayev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Dmitriy KOZAYEV
312.
24893/09
Dzhioyev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Yuriy DZHIOYEV
313.
24896/09
Korenev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Aleksey KORENEV
314.
24905/09
Kudukhova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Kristina KUDUKHOVA
315.
24909/09
Vaneyev v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Mr Andrey VANEYEV
316.
24916/09
Kudziyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Venera KUDZIYEVA
317.
24919/09
Sanakoyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Fatima SANAKOYEVA
318.
24928/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Khadizat TEDEYEVA
319.
24939/09
Gabarayeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Nelli GABARAYEVA
320.
24948/09
Gabarayev v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Mr Anatoliy GABARAYEV
321.
24954/09
Kulumbegova v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Manya KULUMBEGOVA
322.
24957/09
Tuayeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Albina TUAYEVA
323.
24958/09
Gigolayeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Mziya GIGOLAYEVA
324.
24967/09
Ostayeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Marina OSTAYEVA
325.
26502/09
Mamiyeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Inga MAMIYEVA
326.
27940/09
Konyukov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Aleksandr KONYUKOV
327.
27941/09
Guseynov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Tinamagomed GUSEYNOV
328.
27942/09
Zhivykh v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Igor ZHIVYKH
329.
27943/09
Gasanov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Rasul GASANOV
330.
31744/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Irma TSKHOVREBOVA
331.
31745/09
Tskhovrebova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Lyana TSKHOVREBOVA
332.
31749/09
Mgebrov v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Malkhaz MGEBROV
333.
31754/09
Kumaritova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Aida KUMARITOVA
334.
31757/09
Ostayeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Valentina OSTAYEVA
335.
31758/09
Naniyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Alla NANIYEVA
336.
31759/09
Muldarova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Zareta MULDAROVA
337.
31763/09
Mironov v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Mr Yuriy MIRONOV
338.
31769/09
Gagloyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Lidiya GAGLOYEVA
339.
31770/09
Gabarayeva v. Georgia
27/12/2008
Ms Vanda GABARAYEVA
340.
31771/09
Kozayeva v. Georgia
27/12/2008
Ms Marusya KOZAYEVA
341.
31776/09
Pliyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Minat PLIYEVA
342.
31780/09
Valiyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Liana VALIYEVA
343.
31783/09
Demeyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Tatyana DEMEYEVA
344.
31784/09
Kulumbekova v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Lyuba KULUMBEKOVA
345.
31787/09
Gobozova v. Georgia
18/09/2008
Ms Roza GOBOZOVA
346.
31789/09
Dudayeva v. Georgia
18/09/2008
Ms Ulyana DUDAYEVA
347.
33083/09
Kokoyeva v. Georgia
18/09/2008
Ms Gulnazi KOKOYEVA
348.
33085/09
Pliyeva v. Georgia
18/09/2008
Ms Inga PLIYEVA
349.
33086/09
Yelbakiyev v. Georgia
18/09/2008
Mr Vadik YELBAKIYEV
350.
33089/09
Kharebov v. Georgia
18/09/2008
Mr Gela KHAREBOV
351.
33091/09
Manasherov v. Georgia
27/11/2008
Mr Gertsen MANASHEROV
352.
34922/09
Bibilova v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Tanya BIBILOVA
353.
34923/09
Pliyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Landa PLIYEVA
354.
34924/09
Pliyeva v. Georgia
12/09/2008
Ms Aza PLIYEVA
355.
34934/09
Guchmazova v. Georgia
21/09/2008
Ms Tatyana GUCHMAZOVA
356.
34938/09
Marchenko v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Ms Marina MARCHENKO Mr Aleksandr MARCHENKO
357.
34940/09
Adushkin v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Sergey ADUSHKIN
358.
34941/09
Kononov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Vitaliy KONONOV
359.
34942/09
Shevelevy v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Yuriy SHEVELEV Ms Anna SHEVELEVA
360.
34944/09
Bobrov v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Aleksandr BOBROV
361.
34946/09
Kulushev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Eduard KULUSHEV
362.
34950/09
Tedeyeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Aida TEDEYEVA
363.
34952/09
Tekhova v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Evelina TEKHOVA
364.
34957/09
Dzhioyeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Diana DZHIOYEVA
365.
34958/09
Kudziyev v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Mr Aleksandr KUDZIYEV
366.
34962/09
Parastayeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Yekaterina PARASTAYEVA
367.
34963/09
Anayev v. Georgia
09/10/2008
Mr Eduard ANAYEV
368.
36100/09
Kelekhsayeva v. Georgia
22/09/2008
Ms Natela KELEKHSAYEVA
369.
36107/09
Arsoyeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Inga ARSOYEVA
370.
36109/09
Tarayeva v. Georgia
27/09/2008
Ms Lena TARAYEVA
[1] The term “South Ossetia” refers to a region of Georgia which is currently outside the de facto control of the Georgian Government.