LEXI - AI Legal Assistant
Sorry, there was an error communicating with our API.
Try refreshing the page, and if the error persists, please try again in a few minutes.
ILIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA
Doc ref: 27622/12, 27626/12, 27633/12, 27637/12, 27643/12, 27647/12, 27659/12, 27663/12, 27665/12, 27666/12, ... • ECHR ID: 001-140352
Document date: December 17, 2013
- Inbound citations: 3
- •
- Cited paragraphs: 0
- •
- Outbound citations: 1
ILIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA
Doc ref: 27622/12, 27626/12, 27633/12, 27637/12, 27643/12, 27647/12, 27659/12, 27663/12, 27665/12, 27666/12, ... • ECHR ID: 001-140352
Document date: December 17, 2013
Cited paragraphs only
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no . 27622/12 Miroslav ILIĆ against Serbia and 99 other applications (see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights ( Second Section ), sitting on 17 December 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, President ,
Dragoljub Popović ,
Hel en Keller, judges ,
and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar .
Having regard to the above applications lodged on 12 September 2011 ,
Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the cases,
Having d eliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. They are all Serbian nationals and were represented by Mr M. Moskovljević , a lawyer practising in Kruševac .
The Serbian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr S. Carić .
All applicants are former employees of the same socially-owned company - Građevinsko preduzeće Jastrebac - from Kruševac (hereinafter: the debtor). In the course of insolvency proceedings against the debtor on 11 July 2003 the Kraljevo Commercial Court adopted decisions (domestic case no. S St.2505/02) according to which the debtor was ordered to pay the applicants certain sums. The applicants complained about the respondent State ’ s failure to enforce the said decision s rendered in their favour .
After unsuccessful friendly settlement negotiations, by letter dated 9 September 2013 the Government informed the Court that they proposed to make a declaration with a view to resolving the issues raised by the application.
The declaration provided as follows:
“I declare that the Government of the Republic of Serbia is ready to accept that there had been a violation of the applicant s ’ right under Article 6 paragraph 1 of the Convention a nd Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention .
I further declare that within three-month period the Government offer to pay to t he applicants listed below, the sums awarded in the domestic decision s under consideration in this case , less any amounts which may have already been paid on the basis of the said decision s .
Th ese sum s shall be payable within three months from the date of delivery of the decision of the Court.
Th is payment will constitute the final resolution of the case.
The Government regret the occurrence of the actions which have led to the bringing of the present application s. ”
On 15 October 2013, the Court received a letter from the applicants ’ representative informing the Court that they had agreed to the terms of the Government ’ s declaration.
THE LAW
The Court considers that, in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background.
The Court finds that following the applicants ’ express agreement to the terms of the declaration made by the Government the case should be treated as a friendly settlement between the parties.
The Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the case out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.
Stanley Naismith Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque Registrar President
Appendix
No
Application No
Applicant
Date of birth
Place of residence
Represented by
27622/12
Miroslav ILIĆ
20/11/1957
selo Đunis
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27626/12
Miroslav RADOVANOVIĆ
17/08/1951
selo Toljevac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27633/12
Boban JABLIĆ
31/08/1972
selo G. Koševi
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27637/12
Velimir KOVAČ
27/08/1956
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27643/12
Milija JAKOVLJEVIĆ
19/10/1950
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27647/12
Radmila STOJANOVIĆ
14/03/1955
selo Mudrakovac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27659/12
Vladislav JOVANOVIĆ
03/02/1940
selo Crkvina
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27663/12
Miroslava BRADAÅ
09/10/1947
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27665/12
Rade MILOŠEVIĆ
31/01/1967
selo Đunis
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27666/12
Zlata MILUNOVIĆ
07/01/1959
selo G. Stepoš
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27670/12
Mica MILENKOVIĆ
20/09/1957
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27685/12
Radomir MILENKOVIĆ
06/10/1950
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27690/12
Slavoljub MILENKOVIĆ
30/08/1946
selo Kobilje
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27692/12
Dobrica MILETIĆ
12/08/1958
selo Su Å¡ ica
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27695/12
Dragomir KOVAČEVIĆ
20/02/1942
selo Dedina
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27697/12
Borivoje JOVANOVIĆ
19/10/1941
selo Meševo
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27698/12
Vojkan KRSTIĆ
11/03/1972
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27701/12
Slavoljub TOMIĆ
14/06/1971
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27702/12
Radomir LAZAREVIĆ
05/12/1953
selo Dedina
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27705/12
Zoran TOŠIĆ
22/02/1966
selo Dedina
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27708/12
Božur MARKOVIĆ
13/09/1951
selo Å ogolj
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27712/12
Slobodan CVETKOVIĆ
10/10/1943
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27715/12
Milosija VELJKOVIĆ
22/09/1955
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27723/12
Vojislav STOJANOVIĆ
17/01/1937
selo Dedina
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27724/12
Nenad MARKOVIĆ
08/04/1973
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27728/12
Goran MATIĆ
11/01/1964
selo Vratare
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27729/12
Zoran CVETKOVIĆ
25/12/1972
selo Mačkovac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27731/12
Dragan CVETKOVIĆ
22/12/1948
selo Mačkovac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27733/12
Zoran MILENKOVIĆ
20/07/1956
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27741/12
Dragan STEPANOVIĆ
30/04/1943
selo V. Lomnica
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27742/12
Sladan STOJAKOVIĆ
03/02/1973
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27746/12
Nevenka STOJANOVIĆ
04/12/1946
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27748/12
Zoran MARIĆ
24/08/1954
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27751/12
Bogomir MILANOVIĆ
02/01/1955
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27753/12
Dušan RADOSAVLJEVIĆ
07/06/1946
selo V.kupci
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27755/12
Dejan KOSTIĆ
18/10/1967
selo Makresane
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27757/12
Milomir MIHAJLOVIĆ
02/01/1947
selo Lipovac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27769/12
Milorad RAKIĆ
16/10/1949
selo Bošnjane
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27777/12
Nebojša RAKIĆ
05/05/1958
selo Bošnjane
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27778/12
Dragica KOSTIĆ
28/06/1952
selo Dedina
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27783/12
Milorad MILENKOVIĆ
01/10/1949
selo Doljane
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27784/12
Slavica RAKIĆ
27/06/1963
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27786/12
Milorad MILENKOVIĆ
17/12/1946
selo V.lomnica
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27788/12
Milovan RADOVANOVIĆ
03/05/1953
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27791/12
Živorad KOSTIĆ
30/03/1947
selo G.stepos
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27796/12
Slobodanka MILETIĆ
18/04/1953
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27799/12
Mirjana MILETIĆ
25/04/1948
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27803/12
Zoran MILETIĆ
14/12/1955
selo Stalac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27809/12
Slavoljub MILADINOVIĆ
01/01/1955
selo Kukljin
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27829/12
Miodrag STOJMIROVIĆ
08/06/1943
Parunovac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27833/12
Dragoš ĆALOVIĆ
08/07/1950
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27837/12
Vujadin ŠĆEKIĆ
01/05/1965
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27845/12
Zoran GRÄŒAK
16/03/1971
selo Lipovac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27850/12
Branislav DIŠLJENKOVIĆ
04/10/1957
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27851/12
Jovan MILENKOVIĆ
12/04/1948
selo V.lomnica
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27853/12
Miroslav STOJANOVIĆ
03/05/1941
selo Grevci
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27857/12
Slavica ANTIĆ
10/09/1967
Grad Stalać
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27860/12
Strahinja STANOJEVIĆ
17/04/1965
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27862/12
Olgica STEVANOVIĆ
10/03/1974
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27947/12
Peka ĐOKIĆ
20/08/1966
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
27992/12
Dragan PRŠIĆ
10/02/1952
selo Trbotin
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28029/12
Rade TOMIĆ
27/09/1958
selo Zlatari
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28045/12
Vojislav STOJANOVIĆ
21/08/1948
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28050/12
Saša STOJANOVIĆ
22/01/1974
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28056/12
Zorica STANIĆ
29/04/1951
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28079/12
Slavica STANKOVIĆ
15/11/1950
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28099/12
Zoran RAKIĆ
15/03/1967
selo Bošnjane
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28104/12
Branislav BATOÄŒANIN
19/07/1955
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28112/12
Zagorka VALJAREVIĆ
04/10/1946
selo Kobilje
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28119/12
Ljubodrag DAVIDOVIĆ
04/09/1952
selo Å anac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28125/12
Dragica ĐUKIĆ
19/07/1964
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28133/12
Đorđe MILIĆ
19/01/1946
selo Pepeljevac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28139/12
Radojica RADOJKOVIĆ
03/04/1948
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28171/12
Stojanka NIKOLIĆ
23/02/1963
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28200/12
Milija PAVLOVIĆ
05/04/1955
selo Dvorane
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28208/12
Milovanka MILUNOVIĆ
05/01/1956
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28215/12
Milan PAVLOVIĆ
30/06/1949
selo Žiljci
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28218/12
Živomir PAVLOVIĆ
22/04/1951
selo V.kruševica
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28223/12
Milosav PAVLIČEVIĆ
07/07/1953
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28227/12
Grujica CVETKOVIĆ
11/05/1959
selo Mačkovac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28251/12
Saša RADMANOVAC
10/06/1974
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28271/12
Zoran NIKOLIĆ
14/03/1977
selo G.stepoš
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28275/12
Slađana RADIVOJEVIĆ
28/08/1961
Prizren
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28282/12
Radoslavka MILANOVIĆ
15/11/1952
selo Gari
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28298/12
Radoslav STOJADINOVIĆ
22/12/1948
selo Zdravinje
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28325/12
Ivan LUKIĆ
16/10/1977
selo M.Vrbnica
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28348/12
Živojin RADOJEVIĆ
09/10/1943
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28356/12
Radiša SAVIĆ
01/03/1954
selo Majdevo
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28357/12
Dimitrije LUKIĆ
08/11/1947
selo Doljane
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28360/12
Radule SAULOVIĆ
03/03/1940
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28363/12
Živko KOSTIĆ
11/06/1944
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28366/12
Vujadin SPASOJEVIĆ
07/08/1957
selo Å titare
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28371/12
Života STAMENKOVIĆ
25/06/1956
selo Vukanja
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28375/12
Radica RADOJKOVIĆ
04/01/1956
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28377/12
Živorad ANĐELKOVIĆ
14/08/1947
selo Gaglovo
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28382/12
Slađan STANOJLOVIĆ
03/12/1948
selo Boljevac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28425/12
Goce STANOJEVIĆ
09/01/1959
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28429/12
Dragiša STEVIĆ
18/03/1940
Grad Stalac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28434/12
Aleksandar SIJIĆ
22/04/1969
selo G.Zleginje
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
28438/12
Anica RATKOVIĆ
11/07/1944
Kruševac
Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
© European Union,
https://eur-lex.europa.eu, 1998 - 2025
